05th Street West 0442-0444
DIVISION OF HISTORIC PRESERVATION
DUsvaUE,IOWA./..{{/ 1918 ~
ArchItectural Survey 1919
Inventory Photograph Roll 4 Frame:L
STREET ADDRESS ~~4t~, 4"~4 t)j 1{:\~'~1l+
BUILDING NAME
PRESENT OWNER
Address
=~:~ Facade N/s/EI'W By
CONDITION MODiFICATIONS/ADDITIONS:
1 ZQ)4
1~3 4
13 4
i~ ~ t S(1M~
1(2)3 4
lQ.')34
1 Z 3 4
1 Z 3 4
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
DATE OF CONSTRUCTION
Source
ARCHITECT/BUILDER
Source
PRESENT USE
DESIGNED USE
Source
ACCESSIBILITY
STATUS
BUILDING MATERIALS
Foundation 'D~ S~JL
Walls 13fiJ.c.;(_. ,
Trim. ~rGtAl!" ( I h.\U~~4) )
Porch/Storefront L)J~Of.;:;
Eavesl Cornice ()JOOf.)
Roof ASP~JAtlf
Chimney ( s ) P.;fUc,J(';'
C.!t) G,O
"""ll""l~ \,
! "'" ,J'" '.,1 "(i,^",)t,.
r~,,1 .f:I\ rI!i'. ~ '
,,,q\#IY\..J1':: ~
DESIGN FEATURES
Style
Details of Note:
I t,lW1ecL~; p~ /
l hT
Interior Features:
Site Features:
Evaluation
I QUALITY Aesthetic
lIistorical
Rarity
II ENVIRONMENTAL STATURE
III CONTEXT Immediate
,Broad
IV INTEGRITY ,OF FABRIC
1(2)3 4
l(I)34
1 Z(~. 4
lZ~4
~z 3 4
Z 3 4
L2 3 4
ArchitecturalSi9nific~nce
PROBABLE ADDITIONAL AREAS OF SIGNIFICANCE
REPRESENTATION IN EXISTING SURVEYS
Date
COMMENT:
COMMEN't:
!.::JI:J
~2~~@
SURVEY CONSULTANT: Bruce M. Kriviskey, AICP
HABs/NlUIP
Date '-'2- M/.l"1' 11
~
e
CJ:l
H
1-3
t:r.l
~
t:r.l
iAJ
CJ:l
1-3
iAJ
t:r.l
t:r.l
1-3
~
t:I
t:I
iAJ
t:r.l
CJ:l
CJ:l
t:I
H
en
1-3
iAJ
H
n
1-3
HISTORIC SITES FIELD SURVEY
DUBUQUE, IOWA
Year Built
use~
~L.~
-+
"'
Common Name
Adq.ress
tiLl 1. -Lt L/ 4
~-q'ir
Hap Key
Present
Present Owner
Present Occupant
Zoning
fJ.F
NATURE OF SITE
Building
. Area
Site
Other
SOURCE OF INTEREST
Historical _______
Archi tectural ..4-
Other
ARCHITECTURAL QUALI'ry
w. .5~
Material
~:Jz
Exceptional _
Excellent '\
Good Significant features
Fair
Poor
URBAN DESIGN VALUE
Great
Moderate
Minor
STRUCTURAL CONDITION
)(
Foundation
~^lalls
Roof
Wi.ndows
Comments
MAINTENANCE
Structure
Site
Adj. Bldgs.
Adj. Prop.
Vicinity
Comments
Is site threatened?
Sound
Minor
Repair
Major
Repair
Critical
A
t
4-
Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor
~
.A-
x..
i:
)(
,
Additional information -5~ ~ leti.3
~~
\
Site Inventory Form
State Historical Society of Iowa
(December 1, 1999)
State Inventory No. 31-00478 D New rgJ Supplemental
rgJ Part of a district with known boundaries (enter inventory no.) _
Relationship: rgJ Contributing D Noncontributing
D Contributes to a potential district with yet unknown boundaries
National Register Status:(any that apply) D Listed D De-listed D NHL D DOE
9-Digit SHPO Review & Compliance Number _
D Non-Extant (enter year) _
1. Name of Property
historic name
other names/site number
2. Location
street & number 442-444 West 5th
city or town Dubuque
Legal Description: (If Rural) Township Name
D vicinity, county Dubuque
Township No. Range No. Section Quarter of Quarter
(If Urban) Subdivision_
3. State/Federal Agency Certification [Skip this Section]
4. National Park Service Certification [Skip this Section]
5. Classification
Category of Property (Check only one box)
IZI building(s)
D district
D site
D structure
D object
Block(s) _
Lot(s) see below
Number of Resources within Pro ert
If Non-Eligible Property If Eligible Property, enter number of:
Enter number of: Contributin Noncontributin
Q buildings 1 Q buildings
sites sites
structures structures
o~ects o~ects
Total 1 Q Total
Q
Name of related project report or multiple property study (Enter "N/A" if the property is not part of a multiple property examination),
Title Historical Architectural Data Base Number
The Architectural and Historical Resources of Dubuque. 1833-1955 fiffi
6. Function or Use
Historic Functions (Enter categories from instructions) Current Functions (Enter categories from instructions)
01 B-multiple Dwellinq
01 B-multipleDwellinq
7. Description
Architectural Classification (Enter categories from instructions)
Materials (Enter categories from instructions)
OS-Late Victorian/05B-ltalianate
foundation Stone
walls brick
roof Asphalt
other
Narrative Description (IZI SEE CONTINUATION SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED)
8. Statement of Significance
Applicable National Register Criteria (Mark "x" representing your opinion of eligibility after applying relevant National Register criteria)
DYes D No IZI More Research Recommended A Property is associated with significant events,
DYes D No IZI More Research Recommended B Property is associated with the lives of significant persons,
IZI Yes D No D More Research Recommended C Property has distinctive architectural characteristics,
DYes D No IZI More Research Recommended D Property yields significant information in archaeology or history,
County Dubuque
City Dubuque
Criteria Considerations
D A Owned by a religious institution or used
for religious purposes,
D B Removed from its original location,
DCA birthplace or grave,
D D A cemetery
Address 442-444 West 5th
Site Number 31-00478
District Number
D E A reconstructed building, object, or structure,
D F A commemorative property,
D G Less than 50 years of age or achieved significance within the past
50 years,
Areas of Significance (Enter categories from instructions)
Significant Dates
Construction date
1885-88 D check if circa or estimated date
Other dates
Arch itectu re
Significant Person
(Complete if National Register Criterion B is marked above)
N/A
Architect/Builder
Architect
Unknown
Builder
Unknown
Narrative Statement of Significance (IZI SEE CONTINUATION SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED)
9. Major Bibliographical References
Bibliography IZI See continuation sheet for citations of the books, articles, and other sources used in preparing this form
10. Data
or
11. Form Prepared By
name/title James E. Jacobsen
organization History Pays! Historic Preservation Consultinq Firm
street & number 4411 Inqersoll Avenue
city or town Des Moines
state IA
date June 15. 2004
telephone 515-274-3625
zip code 50312
ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION (Submit the following items with the completed form)
FOR ALL PROPERTIES
1, Map: showing the property's location in a town/city or township,
2, Site plan: showing position of buildings and structures on the site in relation to public road(s),
3, Photographs: representative black and white photos, If the photos are taken as part of a survey for which the Society is to be
curator of the negatives or color slides, a photo/catalog sheet needs to be included with the negatives/slides and the following
needs to be provided below on this particular inventory site:
Roll/slide sheet # 7471 Frame/slot # ~ Date Taken Sept 2003
Roll/slide sheet # Frame/slot # Date Taken
Roll/slide sheet # Frame/slot # Date Taken
D See continuation sheet or attached photo & slide catalog sheet for list of photo roll or slide entries,
D Photos/illustrations without negatives are also in this site inventory file,
FOR CERTAIN KINDS OF PROPERTIES, INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING AS WELL
1, Farmstead & District: (List of structures and buildings, known or estimated year built, and contributing or non-contributing status)
2, Barn:
a, A sketch of the frame/truss configuration in the form of drawing a typical middle bent of the barn.
b, A photograph of the loft showing the frame configuration along one side,
c, A sketch floor plan of the interior space arrangements along with the barn's exterior dimensions in feet
State Historic Preservation Office Use Below This Line
Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs
State Historical Society of Iowa
Iowa Site Inventory Form
Continuation Sheet
Site Number 31-00478
Related District Number
Paqe 1
Name of Property
442-444 West 5th
Address
Dubuque
County
Dubuque
City
7. Narrative Description:
This property is located in the Cathedral Historic District. StyleNear: 1885-1888, Italianate style two-
story brick side gable duplex. This is an exact match in terms of lintels, etc. with 414-16 Loras, pre-
1889.
Physical Description: paired brackets beneath eaves, eaves extend beyond end walls, chimneys in end
walls, basement windows have stone lintels and are aligned with upper fayade openings, latter have
very ornate inscribed stone lintels with raised ends, pediments and attached spring stones. Paired and
centered entries with original doors and hip roof porch (original posts and decorative elements). Raised
stone foundation and water table. T-plan (front core 30x39, centered rear wing29x28, side porches
5'6x29, two-story rear porch 6x28, front porch 4'6"x13).
Alterations: very well preserved as of 1986. Permits note re-roofing in 1988, remodeled in 1990.
Landscaping/Setting: property level drops to the east and south, driveway to west of house, fronts north
8. Narrative Statement of Significance:
Building History: not present on 1884 Sanborn, is present on 1889 birds eye view.
Samuel Martin built a double brick dwelling for $5,000 in 1878. He was a grain dealer and lived at 28
West 5th as of 1880 (Times, December 11, 1878). This appears to be too early for this duplex.
The John D. Sullivan Estate owned this property when it was sewered (no date).
9. Major Bibliographical References:
Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, 1884, 1891, 1909/36
Dubuque City Directories, 1902, 1915, 1925, 1934
Bruce Kriviskey, Dubuque, lowa--Architectural Survey 1978/1979, Atlas of City Wide and District
Survey Maps, Dubuque; n.p., c.1979
Dubuque County Assessor's Data
Newspapers and other primary sources as noted in the text above.
Historical photographs, Center For Dubuque History, Loras College
Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs
State Historical Society of Iowa
Iowa Site Inventory Form
Continuation Sheet
Site Number 31-00478
Related District Number
Paqe 2
Name of Property
442-444 West 5th
Address
Dubuque
County
Dubuque
City
10. Additional Documentation:
Legal Description: City Lot west 107.5' of west 170' Lot 614.
Map:
4
J1/. 51-4. IT. -.'-'F ';V~.~~~P.)l:
4+ 7'- 44-4 $-/,2 -/,2-/2- ' ',,~ :".
- ~- <,: ~,:: '", R" ...,.,,:.
.. ....,). ' ',~~P1f~
f
R E'M A R KS ASSESSMENT SUMMARY
/'O-d~-6o #/0 LAND '. .f
.~ 8'1 tlJtl/ BLOIS. ...'
I ~ 1-6/1 C8
1f 1/77~ .. . "
J ~+~I ....... . TOTAL ..' ~,~
...... ' ,,""'" ~,!
....., J A ~ ES ~ ~~ ';'rI:I - ~ _--:....
SULLIVAN. LAND
.. 'fI'r: tTI~sr_~ 0,
':' <()"". ?JI/) ~ C8 BLoe.. - ",~
(~IfIu.db .. l
TOTAL ,',
..... ,. , :~;fj;~.~~~~
", C.IT,y,;"LOT 1107.5' 1170' 614 LA.D
, ;";'<
, ! ILDU.
" ~
: "" TotAL
o . ~ LAND l:
0) ILD...
..
~ TOTAL .'
, ,-.
LAND
BLM'- f'
CD
7 ~-~ AF ;.::~/. ..
us"qe, c. - TOTAL
~~ c... < ~ I--~/, ~tI~L SJ~..L $(,.. P LAND
1.)~'/1;, . I'd nce.- i"j ~CL I , -:
'" .s;~c. Q BLDe..
\ .. ,\~
LAND RECORD LAND VALUE COMPUTATIONS TOTAL
~5 UTILITIE8 LOW FRONTAGE AVERAGE UNIT UNIT trRONT PT. COR.INtrL. TOTAL ~EPR. VALOt LAND
FIGURED DEPT": PRICE PERCENT PRICE \
NO SEWER HIGH ..307-
NO WATER ROUOH /tJt s ~'f ~I!? 1'7 R' .:s~;2.t:J .3.. 3'S-~ ~.l3~? BLDG'.
CJ)
NO GAS ROCKY r k .. ,.,.
NO ELECTRICITY SWAMPY TOTAL
HILLSIDE ;i'!j!
NO STREIT WOODED ~ LA tf D
DIRT STREET 8RU8HLAND ILDe.. '::\:':\,~f'
8EMI-IMPR.' ST. TILLABLE 0)
... <;~"'~:' ~VO'~~ i
NO SIDEWALK TOTAi.
, .
" ,,.. ,PORM NO JMC 101 · THIE J. M. CLEMINaHAW CO.. APPIlAI.... . .2,r[~~~
.1. ,
,- '" ,:,.';-~,
"~.~.,-.. .'-'"
CLavIELAND. OHIO
/
( OCCUPANCY
J)WPLC--Y
, I
''''. " . 5:t 2L ~'J J3~~ ~'
"
ORADi- AGE IIMODLeO I CON o. '....;~'~I'~ rUICT e' DIP. REPL. VALUII' ..~
4"94~ ~ .~ ~-&J /~X' ~1. -7;J. ~
.~..
rf-t;JfirJ~ ;~.~ ,~.-t"::Yt~ 'l~\~;';",,:~:,:,~
PHYSICAL YAlu.'; . Atn'UAL VALUC':!~~
/~i'~:~~- y~,'y.2-r~-;
, ',' ; ':;'~~~';i
:.~
CON8TRUCTION
81% II
,-2..s ~ -" B 8A'K
FOUNDATION
ATTIC 8t SSMT. FIN. ~
Anle FL.a STAIRS , ' 00 F I
FIN. Arne AREA b._> I...... ..~ ~,? ~ (.
FlN.BSMT. ARIA e:;~ (~
l/RICREAnOIl RM.BSMT. I ~"_l'
v' OARA.I'" BIMT. 1f.J ,.d- ' ~
TOTAL
J;/P 11!/4....!!'
....-.:-~ ~ /. ~'
".,~<!._ . /Yo w- 1C'~oP,
If<- cL. - c:.. ,
nLI WALU
tt C'..NT ILK..WALU
~'lco"CIITI WALLS
r IRICI WALLS
STOIII WALL'
~i!~, .
u!b
.-. ------
:>S'
~/.
BUILDING COMPUTATION '~~~;(;'
.;, f F~ 10:
';;1 ~~
. J/ 81J;'
.. ' I / ~41.~
i 7.3 t. ,~~:
~ . ,':~ .a'7~ i~
" ~,:,e ;~
':,:,~%:~, :;;
";.:
/9r;;l s. F.
J 'I, '/ 1
~b(J
~b~
"'.AA
~.4~
, ':/.~ ~
~ I. F.
/ " () I. F.
~~ s. F.
/~" s. F.
/"" ..s~
I BA!tI!MENT AREA
\t P~'~'" ,,, rr::J
EXT.RIOR WAL1.8
"liD'''. (J1f SHEATHING i.
SI...LI SlO1N.
WOOD SRIIIOLII
CO.PO. SRlie.Lis
. aTOCCO .01(. 'RAM' ..,... .
8tuCCO 0If,;:Tn.1 OR';ci,'~ (,
'AC. IRICK. YIIIEIR
" 'Ae. 1..0" tiLl OR C. I.
CO.. IRICI YIIIIER
. eo.. 'I.ON TILl OR C....
SOLID CO.. BRICK
STONI 'IIIIIR
f'
'II-
..3~
ROOMS i
BSIIT I 'IT X ./
IND V I liD ".
INTERIOR FINISH
'IT 11111 31D
-1.1
~
l~
/,
,/ 3i
(j3
PIN.
.NAMELID
CHESTIIUT.
HARDW90D
/'
V''/ '" J1#'~
...~AeI1fl'C
+..tIIf'S. ~()
:z A/'cL- I
,', .
'.hL.2.. .'~:~~;.r
,.' """'.i'{
,. , ;).;~.(.)
/~.#/7 ,
WAll BOARD
_ATCH IIAD ./
oAf HFIN. lifT. ;J:N'f, PI?" C/o -I
"I ." ~
'"T.CONO. '. Yv J:I!'E I ,
LAYOUT V . t/ ~:. , _ ,
STRUCTURE I........ "".. > . ~ ILL' . ~
HEATING. . --~ A:-E - I 3 ;q .
JfOT AIR 'u. J:aJ ,;I '. - J J #;, .
~ STEAM :no ~ J '" :S~OH S" ~~~ . Jc>"f"~ ~..~
HOT WAfER LIGHTiNG ..... " "rILING . ^~IJ
VAPOR NO ELECTRIC LTG. BATH FLOOR a WAI"SCOT
,jIR CONDo CAS LIGHTING BATH FLOOR. WALLS
~ 'l. OR WAll FURNAC! PLUMBING BATH FLOOR ONLY
PIPILISS 'URNACI BATH ROOMS ~ ~ .-fOILET RM. FL.a WAINS.
NO HIATlNG SYSTE" ST. SHOWER BATH ROOM TOILET RM. FL.I WALLS
OIL BURNER STALl.SHOWER EXTRA TOILET RM. FL. ONLY
COAL STOkER TOILET ROOMS V
GAS BOILER WATER CLOSET EXTRA II'" KITCHEN WAIN,SCOT
LAVATORY EXTRA LOCATION
SINK UJAI\ "'- ~ ""6'OOD /FAIR POOR EARTH FLOOR
BASE PRICE
3/J
,135 J,.f, PLN ,
PdlJ I(
B8MT. AREA
WALLS
C>~ PL.~X
o::,:.:tr.'V:;' ~.~ '.;..... .,~
:i,',., ;,3,.';:0::'
,'.': .~Li
, ,...... 3l!J~.' ~. :.~~t:"
~~1,~ ,~t .,' .,,:;:.,z.'
.J..) /)
+- 1.1
ROO'"
ILANKIT INsULAlM'J';~
;...ROO, IHSULATIO,,"" J
ROOF TypT
., O'ABLI! ,...
FLAT
FLOORS
P'LC:;>>ORS
ATTIC
BSMt. JrIN'SH
INT. FiNISH
HEATING SYSTEM
AUTO 'HTO. UNIT
..;F /r- .:j~-
HIP
MAIISARD
GAMBREL
ROOFING
ASPHALT SHINGLE
, WOOD SHINGLE
ASBESTOS SHINGLE
S lA TI
OUT BLOOS.
I 2 ME~SURED BY
',.
WALL FOUNDATION
PIER FOUNDAnON
SINGLE WALL SDG.
DOUBLE WALL SDG.
4-
LISTED BY
4
'10':'.
,i .,1-'/ L.
'+/.<()1i~'~ )~
,;;:',' ~.""
SMINGLE WALLS -.
STUcto ON (AV~
CEM ENf BLOCk ^"-I--'"
BRICK
CONC- FLOOR
ARIA COMPo BY
'!
..
FIREPLAqE8.
PLUM BINO
TILlNO
TOTAL BASE PRICE'
'.,.
(,
, ~',A c."O';"'>'.:~
r-7~ I';.'~_,. 't~
. FLOORS
B .l,'T 2ND 3RD
#I'
PRICED BY
fJ--
,..i'
,S;
,;>/.'7 .2"~~
.~ . ,. ;;~;.~l:~~~,~
, ,.,~{;t;f~
I~' If?
! CEMENT
. IARTH
PI HI'
~ HARDWOOD
.'NGLE Fl.
FIREPLACE9
1/' jlREPLACE STACK~:~
~ V" FIREPLACES 1(' ~
v' 1/ ~nFlCIAL FIREPLACES
V" ~ 1/ .INCINERATOR
TO~AL
COSI FACTOR
REPLACEMENT VALUE
SEPnc TANK OR CEISPL.
WATIR ONLY' .
NO PlUM81NG
INCOME
'2'~"'~OJkD
~A ~" /h "
SHINGLE ROOF
ROLL ROO'IH;
ELECTRIC LIGHTS
". '-,;, ....
,. ~.;;..~ i,;~~~""
..__l_w._n___ .4.._____-.........