Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Notice of Appeal of Claim by Clayton and Nicole Ketchum
Copyrighted October 16, 2023 City of Dubuque Consent Items # 04. City Council Meeting ITEM TITLE: Notice ofAppeal of Claim SUMMARY: Jim Hauberfor property damage, Clayton and Nicole Ketchum for property damage SUGGESTED Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Referto CityAttorney DISPOSITION: ATTACHMENTS: Description Type Appeal of Claim by Jim Hauber Supporting Documentation Appeal of Claim by Clayton and Nicole Ketchum Supporting Documentation September 1 l, 2023 To: Dubttque City Council Members iF�' Fr.om: Clayto� & Nicole I�.etchum ' : � Re: Praper�� Damage at 177b Custer 5treet, Dubuque, IA 52001 =� ; �, . Dea� Council I11letnber_s, , �n Au�ust 11, 2023, a shoot off a tree located in the allcy�ray behind our property fell oi�to our home cau5ing damage to oz�r property: There �uere not an�T significant weather ev�nts ca�sing the damage as �ell as the t�ree appeared to still be a�i-ve. We immediatel�T submitted a claim ta ou� insurance cornpan�� as the tree v�Tas on top of ou1- hame and Ue�an calling contractors listed on your wehsite in the area to eorrie to iemove t�ze t-xee. `F'he following morning, one o�the con�rac�ors c�une to our pzopert�T and quoted the cost t� re�nove but c�ue to the tree being c�n electr�cal �ower lines, the contractor stated he could ��ot safely ren�ove the tree off our home until the utilit�r company came. We contacted 1�1liant Energy who then came to c�ur home within a few hours. Allianr removed parts o#�the tree that were ir� the wire and stated the rest wau�d have to be done l�y the contractor. We then contacted rhe contraeto� and he schcd�.�led to remove the tree on Monda�; Au�ust 14, 2023. On Monday, Au�ust 14, 2023, we called the city and spol�e with Rob, in the tree service division �,s the tree i� located on city prc�perty u� ��e alley �uay. Within a few hours, he and a co-�uo�ke� a��ived ta look at the damage at the same time as the contractor had arrived to re�r�ove the tree f�c�m our raaf and property. Rab statec� th�.t he �vould have to go back to the engineer. to determine if both the tree and our. rctainir�g wall were ir� fact on city �ro�e�ty and if so, they tivould be back later in week �o do additzanal t�-immin� He advised us to f�le a clai��n against the city as �hat uras neecleci for them ta open the case and determine if city property. C}n Tuesc��y, Aug�st 15, 2023, we completed the rec�uired claii�-� form and lzand delivered to �he C�ty Clerk that afternaon along with several photos of the damage { 5ee pa�ges 1-18 att�.ek�ed). We also con�acted Giese Roofing to have someone come ta assess the damage and provide a quote. ��n Wednesday, August 16, 2U23, �he city warke�� came back to the praperty and tr�mmed additional b�anches hanging ir� our yard a�ong with brush on top af the �eta.inir�g w�ll (See page 19 �tta.ehed). On Thursday, August 17, 2023, �re rece�ved the quote froan GieSe Roflfing for damages ta our roof ( see attached pages 20-Z3). On r`r�day, llug�.ist 18, 2023, vve paid �2,000 in fi�11 to the tree removal contractor. (See attached page 24). On Satu�day, August 19, 2023, we received a letter f�om the Cit�= along with copies of correspandence tio your insurance cc�mpany IC�1P and City Council members. { see pages 25-27 a��ached). i On Mt�nday, August 21, 2023, we spol�e with T'o�ia Shermai-�, Claims with ICAP. llfte� reviewing what h�.d c�ccurred, she statcd that she wauld need to call �.nd speal� with the cit�T enginee� to determii7e if it was the city's property. Ho`vever, she aIh2ded during this fz�st canvers�tion that she u�ould be det�yin� tl�e claim regardless. Later that afternoon she called Uacl� to state that she spal�e with the cit�T ar�d even though it is the ci�y's tree that caL�sed the da��nage, the city is not liable due to the �act that the ci�y does nat employ a tree 5urvey team. Since the ca.ty c�oes not keep up on the maintenance of t��cix trees on �I�e�r property encro�ching ather. ��ndowners prnpert-�; rhere ��ras no way £c�r the cit�r to know �he tree was detetiozating therefore she was den�ring the claim. We tllen asl�ed her�Then the tree �vas schcduled to be reinoved since both the insurance cc�iripany and the cit�r agree�i �che tree was rotten. She stated rhat we tvould ha�Te to contact the cit�7 to ac�dress any filrther c�uestic�ns regarcling the tu�l remaval of the t�ee a�d thc �-et�.inin�wall. We then called and l�ft a mess�ge �oi Steve Fehsal, Parks Divisic�n Manage.r and asked that he coiltact tne regarding the adc�itional quest�o�s tive had. C�n Tuesda�; August 22, 2Q23, `�Ie �eceivec� a call from Tarua Sherman statin� that the cit�T sent her an em�il and that we necd to speak onJy to her reg�rcling the claim. We info�med her that the voicemail to Steve was not in regards to the c�aim but u7 fact when the re�nai��ng t�ee was to lie removed to not cause addition�l dama�e to our property and surrounding neighbars as now they a�e aware it is encroaching c�n our pro�ert�T On Monc�ay, Au�ust 28, 2023, we received the denial Ietter fr�m YC11P. (see attached page 28). There was no�l-iir�g o� the notice �regarding how to appeal this decision. Un Tuesday, August 29, 2023, ��e contacted the City C�erk's office wl�o t�ld me �ve would ha�e to call tihe ci�� �.ttorney's oEf ce �ar assistance_ When we spoke with that office, the emplo�Tee sta�ed she woL�d hav� to ca11 us back anc� she wasn't ativare of hc3tiv ta assisE. She called back late� that day, to tell us that we needed to sL�Uintt this letter along with doc�.unen�ation for the Cit�= C�erk's offtce to �-e�riew and decide if/when we could be placed on the next Cit�T Cou��cil's meeting to appea,l this decision made liy yc�ui insur�nce coinpany. As of toda�; 30 days after the damage occurred, we have suffered a tr.cme�.dous loss; pa�Ting out of pocket the �2,OOp.OL� fo� the removai oE th� tzee, tl�.e upcom�ng expense af raof repair { $1,894.00 witha��t t�x }, tl�c irrimincnt increase c��homeowners insurance and possibility o.f being dropped �t ouz renewal, time spen� on claim forms, phone calls, meeting of contra.ctors, vendors, insurance ad'justers and city workers. Further, we have yet tc� receive � call back from Steve Fehsal on when the remaining rotting tree w:ill lae r�mov�d as it is still stancling (see attached page 29). I�is our ho�,e that the City Council v�rill cor�sider compensation to us in the a3nount of�5,000.00 for �lze damabes a.nd oux time inv-ested in this that occurred from wha�bo�l� Ci�y O�'icials and ICAP have confiitned �s u� f�.ct the city's p�operty, Sincerely, Cl.ayto� and Nico�e I�etchu�z� i CLAfM /AGAINST TI�E CITY OF DUBIJQUE, iO1NA � This wri�sr� report cor�stitutes your claim against the City of ❑ubuque, kowa. You should comple�e this form in f�l� and a�tach any additionai in�ormation that supports your claim. The Claim must be filed with the City Clerk at City Hall, 50 W. 13x�' St., �ubuque, IA 52001. It will then be referred by the City Cour�cil to the apprapriat� department for in��stigation. Once tha�t investigation is completed, a report �nd recommendatian will be submitted to the City Council. You witl be provided with a capy of that repor� and recommendation. THE FINAL DECISION ON ALL CLAiMS IS MADE BY THE CITY COUNGIL. NO EMPLOYEE QF THE CITY OF DUBUQUE HAS THE AUTHORITI( TO MAKE ANY REPRESENTATION TO YOU AS TO V4IHETHER YQUR CLAIM WILL OR WiLL f��T BE PAID. 'i. Name o# Claimant: � �l ` i��� 2. Address: ���� ��.� � � City: �'� � Sta��: Zip:��.�� , . 3. Telephone Number: �,���` �� ~��� ��„ 4. Dat� of Incident; - ����i����-� � , ,,,,,,, ,,, ,,,...._ , 5. Time of Incident: _��. _�i� , -- 6. Location of Incident {Be specific�: ������"1�{�"'� _�L�._`���.. ���...,.,. . �r��� a�.. ��- 7, DESCR{BE ACCIQENT OR dCCURRENCE THAT CAUSED lNJURI� OR DAMAGE. (Give full details upo� whi�h you base your cla�m. If a City employee was invol�ed, gi�e �he employee's name.� g ��. Y � ^ � l �� �� +� 1l `. � � oti '��- �i ' , � - � '� � ' � - � � �� � ��'�.y � - - .� 8. What were weather conditions lik�� . _ ` �� '� ���4 ,�l � 9. Give name and address of any witnesses: 10. Did police ir��es�iga�e? {if so, give names of ofFcers.) ��� � 11. Was anyone injured? (!€ so, give n�mes, addr�sses, �nd exfient a# injuries). � � 12. Was any damag� done fio praperty? (if so, d�s�ribe property and the extent of damag�s. Attach estimates of damages or �describe basis far ascer�aining ex#en# ofi damag�.) � � � ��-,, � �: � � �� °I3. What ather damages do yvu claim, if any? 1�y� C�� � 1� .��;,_�� `�`;`t"��.. T '- � .. '� 4 � . `��� �� � � R . 14. Harre yc�u b��n compensated for any part or all of your �laim by any ir�surance compar�y? (Ifi so, give name and address o�€ insuranGe campany and amount paid.� ��� 5. Vllhat amount do you cla�m fram the Ci y af Dub que? � [ '16, Why do yau claim the �i of Dub�q�� is respor�sible? � 17. Hav� yau made any ciaim against any�ne else for d�mages as a resui� �f�his in�ident? (If yes, gi�e name �nd adda-ess.1� 1 S. If the answer ta Question 17 is yes, ha�e yo�a received any payment from fihat source, ar�d if so, in what�mount? Da�ed at Dubuque, lowa this �� day of - , 20�. � ��:�.a � ,� ,� %� �� "�`-�-s�` __ - ��� (Signature) � v��_ � '� � � � ` � 1��.- �e °� (Prin� Nart�e) {Rev. 5118} .�. . •�"�. '.w .�'�,r'� �,,�L �.' ..,' - •� +�♦ •yo-�������"t,���4 ' �� ��' � H�.'�"? 'y'iX �r ?,�; ,.ti'.�.i�(+t•4?s a���"��'•R'i s�i •• s,•4 ;�,!�: �". � ,s�,' �Y:^ • � s�•..i'� , 4• � ,�y` , �.. � .y. '�N�� �� `'r•� `��a" '•�` � . � r�• . �r � ,��. ' •�•� •�4, ��►� 'T•�s� i�� i•�+ ,,�-��� :. 4s.{»����� •`C:'�."a •.is:; ����.ti �`e�'�� �,� t f ��i' !r �. a+� �e. �ti� 4, �4' '�r,' 'R'!R4 $� �.,f� .�°.'•�� � s .'-V �+w^�tH ''��4� �` � ' " jl� .,, ` `4, .��. . t: .� ra � � �1K: • r ' ?w -1 '� .1„y . rf' 4e+� �� � -" • �^•�• �,•' , ��� p''- � � .� ��Y '�,i.i' • �i� ��'':, `�• �. � t �� 1f�. '�• �F'" -ti,�' .+��- �b• i - � �,�' •�j t� '�.. .S '�.t���'•; w� � ��� +. �f� +"�. r, 'r,l �� '�1 •��� •4�' �' '.'3r,� ,S�- - • •n �i- �T'IT, 'rZ� �w � ��r. � - +J� _`t , � - �` •: '*• y� q;�� ' '�r"r� • ;. .. 1 .� .. ,�. f� ,�-�•�r�, Y� k ���"�',• ' e-' _ 'i��rt�Ar�'S� d S� 1f� F � x�� . �� .�' S * e'•' 3'��� ��•�v�a' * ..w .'�'�r�'•.o , �y �� �,r .�.•..�� i �. ' ' • ' " � - . �ii��,, ` . � v ,i �. `w"- �rt. a- . . ��p�" Y � � �11�� • =� .i�' •... � y - '1�Y��- '��� �j • •:� e4,�+��:Y�����. • ,� .�� .��•'� j�, �•J ' �'� �P" � „4`. {� �'M'F �� Ja� ' y � � .• d '�: - • 4�N . 1:�- ,� � �,r t�.. ,ra. , 7b•. �� . Y'S.�'1��` . �� �1 � �'��'.• ��'x �►�.,a 7 t • x{ •� ���,••�F,;� •,.��;' .r�:a/r f��r 1�qF+R�'�'� .�����'�r.�. - ,'r a a• r _ .y�+�'} �`.y• ,`., y � ',�iy��. ��L� !'., . . _.b..:.i��3 N��� '�y � � ���; � � �r ��. - �' ` � * ; . ' ' ' : -e.<<.�•y�7��.+_.'!•� . i�i' . +. � ��s 1�'�'�h�.� Y �y';ti.Ni .Y'� 4 .t��i�, *� .� " ' ' J. y" R� +y'� • '�-*' ' '� _ �'�• '�.��',.'���,�✓"' +r11��'"`�.' '�, ' � "': � ':'� .�1 � �r • 'r " � '�, .9 ^.'' ♦ .� .. r' .bi. tfr ;f�• , ��. Y •�'� E �� � y♦ f �s•i• n• �!,a 'i p � ,�' y �� . _ •t' � . s ��.'E_, . ��'. ,�3;k����Lly� , `••��c + ' S.�VP. ., . �.��e i' �:,.t Y I ' M'' . - .i� �.������ Y�" .�y.,, �•_yi �� P * ! '�. ' _, � j � il !�� `• •�-'- . �'��Y , i � . .s ♦ . . y . �H�' �i ' ,7�� �"' . • 4 w� � � � �4 .�a. .�. . � S' ,S�' • ' ' r+ ��� � '� ''�� ` •' • ,�rr � h.� . . , .. �, � 4� r r" � � �y r •� w p[ �.. . � � . `it �. �+ •�'�•�,� ��'� � � ���� x n . _ � .. � , "�,Ji• ,r..�'•,• ��� � 7� . • _ • �+ +'S. 'r� , ��.•�:` "' `, '`v' -: ' � •' 1� .� � � '�� . 4' � !F ♦ . •� �.is^�l ��- •�.. .i . 'l��S` !� '� �• ' t, • . • • �� ;v � �• ♦.� '- .f .� ? ��•�\�� ... �. 4y•� �r� • . :�' x �r a,a� r�I �' �f �� +�.� . - ��"�' .1l�• �� t��� � �. a �Vi.�� »S{ � � � *. �1, •��t+�, :i��� '� 7 j ,�a �'��':'.c�J.s...�w-.`.��'<-� � ='o��1 e ;� - .. .. .. C, . ' r '��.�.k`":'a'.�..3�:;:�:'`k''.�"-°`� ,r., � .. . _. _ 'rfi ,�,.�yy�..,.,,._,, - � • --.�., � ' . .' . - � .,s �,K �`�.._ .'� s� � � � � � � � _ . -•- . .`,�"�,} �'' . �}�`�. .'�`� �91e r.:v,� . .`..�=� . .-a:j -- w�!M�� ,,.,� . �,�;1. 1 vs� , •6• �� -�.' � —' .. - 1 ! � + � 'R'1 �z; � �i . y .*rt�r•s q: 'a � �� ..���. � � � �i.r_�.- �.. • »s q ,t �,µ,rl� +Y-ti. 1 r-Y`_i J,°:3;y.. _ . .- '.a . ' �'1�` '4.'�-h ' �� " ��'4; 3�3� . a 4+� ti ytiY ' � � � �e�r��' �� .'y 4�t�- , • '� 'I�' 3 .i.r`F i� '� '� ��y�'1J'�v.�•. � r � .� .� �t�",�� � i� �1 l '�_ � �: � n r., � r .,����i � u } y�e � ,{"�+�� �F'• a ..n�' �L:�1. ` a x��.y.��� d�� � �ti:r�+*��;,A J, � -1N.'�.���'� �. `� ~-�.� �`3. `�~ ,k,��`� * �K � �� ti3,�t 'L�� . � � ± j� } -_.x<<<��,�' _ �y��.'� � � � �`L '<,t- •x' � ��>. ti^*� 4 �•�� ' •��� t } � +n" i� ,��r1?�'�`rl.S��. �i': _ '`�' ' - ' �� - � ,;�. �!.�,'� '� �i. 4, � , 1 a , ��� k �Y ��' ��3 `.y , �, . . , _ r" -. ,.. � ; ` ; ���.,y •L�-+!'�� �':� 7 �.�� ��' . 1.. - ==!.� I �,�,,��r��+f. . S •,{ I�:� �' 1 � ,t: e `!° #. '�: ��+ "4 ,+, a,t Y! ��1 •`A �� f � � �� r� i t��I� �. �' - 3 - .'� _': ��� 7• } ,�3+�,Y a � , II ; � �.�_: t _ .� �= . .3 - '; !. •�; � , �. r 9� , � �.��3' �R y r'y�ty r. v �( Y r �� �'. ` . �, 1� � � .+.i-'S r��y � ..i�. � '�,"'�Jly. .'� .y`'� ` --"�, '"� �! � �, �0..: .� • _�a�' � �,� �! ,��.�, ' .�� , �' ��,�1�. ��- '� ,.�r__« �_ ` 1 '�: _ F a h ',�. �� i � i r��r c �,Yti. ,'•, �� j /�', ,� •� . .�.� � • �'..•. +e� •,� _. , „r: . . �^ _i '" ",�' ' `- � 7'� �j y .—� i ,r r ,hrw •�' ���:�y �, • � x j �•tl • t••*` � a'�� ,°�y� ^ 1�tl.� '� �!`.� •�� , f� ��i � ��f��� �' E�� `c,�� }�' , i�, ^�-{, �4• �. p � �y��- �'.� ��t,.. t.� .- rP w; ` M a,Y. �. i'�' '+ + ... ys�+t!. � �a� 4.�+' e�� 7� :+ � �:''-�-.h'n?'. .w..r. +!:• � r .•,�mt� ¢-Y �f�k ti�' ��! . . i , ••� r- ht� 'r - h. ?/r ,"�� s` tr � .'--� ..� . •f4• .}a,.� e� � .f!%�: r �ti } r �+� �r�.�s�.• - �.� • ' . . fi�' _�'�!d "� •., �'�r�,� x ti , ,; ar. � �� � K�. 1. • �s'_ { ' S 1�� ;ty 1 �, R�• M�jF�.,,. �r �^,, ,.. . .. -. . �• _ !� � • �. �. � '!�. '� • ��'F;* '.''�'�'W.�►�'�'��;. t!� �-�;+.��, r,yr ' �� 3i� S ��.�'. :� � ��"9 1!F• . ' 1". ti':�; ,, .�; . a. •.c . ,S ..: :_�i wf '� • � -. d� , - ., . y� . � /� ' ''� . � e�' "1�� '� i •-�' A~ ����' �,�. � A/ s �F . i ; t " a / .e� + ►�'.• s� . �� �" . ' '~~ ',��� �' y sI ' r f ` • t� ' � . .�= �_tR �' r � y _ •�•' .r. _ , ...�, ' �'" '��iy t. •' y r y.i a_� � F�`�'3. ^ �'0. .�� � . ; • . �� , , rP r '� t ��� �y�� . d �� � �e� ''� 4 '. •c� 'A . . .r�- , _ s�• ;•#;a � y.•. s' '�rlc �� � _. `.a15r� - �:� 'i . . � � YY , � l � � + � �L'��'��' • � � .K� ♦ ����' �7+1� �� ,� '� l�. srt . � ,*t y , �'� • :Y�'r ' ` + "�'` ���. .�: s i r ' r,s� .; e': �' '! �y�;';a� e.� '�'�"' �+� • � c�• �"�!� tt ' ' �� �.�'#s't� �r'+.' �u • � _;zi _�'� ���r.'i, • y ��- � �� ��` ''�F� ' Y` ''K. .�f `� r,� �1"��..�"+�,� 'p�• r:�f- .�� ^ _ �. w � , ,,�,,,� y-� 'd� rk����,.'��� �'�w ,,; •�,. � .�- �t. - *�`• 1. �' , :,�. ••y �� '� r���y.T� �.�s''1� -.r r . � `( � � r . � '` .ti!L wT '-�,a� y,S��ti�' • _ �' ���^'�'^_�". � r �t ��, � �r�T.i � ♦•�.�^i�T'' j'S,'�4�§�, 4^ �J � 1 � ' . ..�^ ���. i. _ .• _ 4 1 �� *�'�. . .� .o`kJ 4 � n� ,��Y•v 4^ µ1 ��`��1-. �:. • . �� f -fF- } �1~1 ��� �'a �f ��,- �. "��� r��_'d4. w � . ]]�" � .r`• ��• �,�� ,, � ����'"ry r'� � .!1 � . r� r ��'� •,� ,• - t.^ . .�� ' fl` .,. �;' �'�e 4, a �' �}'i` V -—,-y�r. � �y �. . } � • .. . .�; �� � •� FT �'� ' �� r i .t �• .• 4� � . ►�.. •��': � Y�+�-. � r - `:� • _ - - �' M1 � � •fSy:; �` ..1 a �'t� �. .'1 1r �� �. _ A'� �` � �:� ' � � �_ � ` ' • � ,�''� :`..'if°tt; '.�1rSt_''s- '. . •�'�, • • a - - � •_.'�. `:?� ' s-- � _ � - ' .�-e t"./;_ +�A�� � -ti� �;.�;�'.+� iF �7 '�- !s, �{e r �w. �� r�i � �-x f� P'j �' .1Y��. ��, . Y f '�h".; , - _ � � �� � _ . �r . - , +� � �, � � � 1� -r="c� � . _ - '* ' . ' , e = ,�; z - � . � ' �, ..,, - ���r `~� r I� � � .�!�"�y� �f� "��' ,', r� . �', �e q• �'d� �;•r �' �`' a=-i� �, .:a� � ,- � - �� .k�. �� ' ~— + 'r�. '•�. �. '�n- . 64 � ' , � �ti +71 ..f,' 'r ��1 ^!3 � } ' `�`�\ k ��. _� 1 ..�, � ,�� �" '.4 �.! - _ �� �' t' •• i t - r� t r � i�` � e�' �'..� r i. 1 I � .r, �� f�_^ # .K�`_ � �"tY. i ' � x �. � - d}. . . � � - 'rt , .,�r~ ,�. � '.�� �� e,�� .n � .Z. �� t,x� y. � .��,� � �r f ,'Y.� jf. � � r �� +' � q��t' i..a .* , �: _ �l4'� - �-� �!. ' �' ��•,�' a 'I'(' � �„`f . � 't f�5 � � � �= �{�`y � _ i� � _� ..-�� �. �� ` �., _ � Y '� ' f� � � ��- ' � ``�'1; � +�; �# '��'� # � ��!` � t' � �, .,.. i/ � - � �lif• .�'.. � . �.. v�STY ��• .� .. �. �.� �- � � � � • ��-, �; � � ,. � '��`� �,��• �:, � ,�' ��' .. � �. . . ,¢ ty�. ' ` ,� �"}r_.� `1�w-`'' p�,-� t�� �� �. .4 } `.�IP e,rri �� � �`�.r.+T�^f r�.i,-�"/�'�':` af`�'._ /.. :� � -, . �y�!'� ;��: .'7f �� � ,,s 'R-� " `.r i� . 1.. - � f, .; '�:y-. �� Jt� � Y �: . �� . , ' ..� � f.`L. .-,�_ " �'�" ':'i ��. ✓ ; w �4:+t.w. �. :�R � ��a��'�e 4j ��� '.r�' . . '. .�_ k .� ` tg�7l.'. ',.�'3`y'�� � ,*(� �- ;. :� �i '-� �� _ � �� ,� _ .� _ �� ,,�;, , 1 � ,�,�t - .,�� �;.q � t��. r� a�.;, E.,; a �r �:;� 1 ��� �, � ;;' � � � � � 4` �I + � � � '+�'� '� �;� �t;-.! �^7 � '��- _ i r � � d fs ♦ Jh �y - ,7"� Y V ...�., , .p. .�. i .1. � . i , �. �i. s1F �' �„�-- '.r_ ��ti �� �� � � y� r _ y'I CF, � �, ,%; � '��°„ '�� � 6 - . . ._�. '� ��� �s <"�t��: " 5 c � �' ;�'.#, �. �. � ���_ �• , -� ���v .. � � �'�`-�r ��.5� � '4�'�`�� .� - }: 4 ,y��.� .✓�. _ ,z�� � �:,, E�.� t4 . �� ._„k . ' t� .'_� * � � r�� .�� �_.,� °k ���! �f i`��� ' �'� ,,- �' ,,� � �.' '��� i�^"�jr��i, "��7 ..,� 1 . .,Y-Jr �. ` 7 , � '' .....x+ -�1�. �rT �i. - 'q!- �,�� � � -�t;.y �� ` 1d � � + �.n .l�,'� �ne , 1 y ';;;b , u � ,. ' �, { j 4 ��' _� � ��'` ,�i�i:, ��. '���`4 ,, �,� �7�"`.•.r � ���`� �` �,. � t �' i� �,^'� -. _�' w '_ `J'1 " �� , � t� � �� V ^� '.�:.. - R- - �i� �A 4 f � � ._�� .tHl '}�.� .C R ��M1 , . _ s =� .. .�, d� i���. >'� �} ��--`�� � r�1. ��,�.�.. �'� f„�,-' ���� �. � 'tfi� � -�,�, ` �. - 's- F".`._•r, � ; , �.�.-�. �' '�� ,h, �,. ,�., �" � � h 5��� y �'. _ . � . - �� - r" f i � fi xm J ' :,� ����., ����� ,` � �' -: • �e.: L � � YR. ��3 Y ��` �. t t `"Y �.� , _ F' " _ .�ti' � � t F ' ' . '. 4+� t .�' . �i. FM i , ,. �� a . ' -, _ .l°' ,_ ° �v� � r ��-' . � r �,r... .c�'�� +��' + T A!�'r��F: -� - _ � -. �� �i r 2c. ' �a� �. �� L. � �`y,�•. y' -�'f� .�� �_ �a` - _. ' - T�� �;�G�.,, i'���� �,''��,.+�,�1.e ' r ��• � � ���' � .3� � •�'r� * � ��� �r-I. ���� i �':� .j �Aa�'� l' � �- �yb _ ,��.y�` - �'� �, �.- _ _ t µ�.' `- '�4[s ��� ,y . �1 �„�J �q 4tti, y� �C' --- � � t l iu'_ E :-�;:� �,,� ' ,�� ;� ,� ���4 ,Iw.-..��� �- � � �'`�'� -.�` F ti' y, n : ' � � '� '� `� � '�• � 1��� ���.} t _ ��, a��:+` � 'f � •� ��� � f/' �.. aa�� �!� ' 6 ,� �'_ �. J� �,� \I ? �:!� �f• 2't'.. �f' �#f �� L Y . +.2 � � � T�� �`�� t } . ! •��'y r� r ,'�'�',�— "�� �+ �. ��,,�r � ��,v� .� _ - . '�,�'�� s�OAf� .��.i ..,., "�'"3 � �� �3`.,� f - �� Af�'* �. ��t�i{� �+,. �'�'T� r t a ����f� Fti �ti' t 4 '�v .,,.- ..`.��' � �}� ., �� �s �` � ��� � ,�.� .k �t � ���`- � 4 t� 1�1�! '� � r �r_ �d� \ aL��� j r ,l �; � __ `:4 yi.,���,�! .n av i �� �#.� � r���-.. �' � �"• Y i T .� ����,� ` �x �.�> �n � � �r . �, ea � a-a �:5� �+ F-k' x - �L. � �:A���i{ � a y�r- �m 't' � yr4_�`�y. �l .F. �� \ - fF �". �� y+ td�i, �'�1,�L�.'M,h ,1. ' Y ♦ � � '� i ��+e �,��.,1.�� 7�'� f�;� tl.', s_. � p�r�i `� ' `d� � i#� r �- ��� �' r �� n - " � r� � �F� �� .-. ve.., �y�"5 '+ '� �" r'+� d'� '�:i.�-N.. , � se ,a: ;:�ej . r 4��,. ,�,i' w,F s�� � '�.��P �: . ��id�"',.n.s /��.a � i -. t� _. t�,ah. ,y� � � .<M. � 4 ►' sY - 1,�� _ ��.�`'Sy .`( L 1� -. y� f 3 1' � � � �''-_ ,. "�' ;,� - ` � � . ������ . s '° ;- - r. 'R,�-�+,°�r .�' v ' * t :�'� �� `� �; �;.�iC`' �r:.., i �.� � 'v,,,''s� '�, L+� �` �_:'� -. , � Q1 � �� t�►, `\ �(a �-' ,r�. :F-� -�1 ',,e" \.: ���� '. ,:� ��'. !i'_ �." ."�. . a���t- � �_.\- . F � � ti'�- , �� _ �,� r.�;��: , . � "�i+�'�.a�..,a . �t , . �t;! � �a '� ' � i '� '')� . S 1 L r�.� ��, f � . -1� �� � �{'��1 � '�V�I ' R ,r y � fJ,�� �iE, 1 `' " �: �t� .� k ' r� ,$ � �'`� �� `s�K" � f�' �',��+`'1','��•� `' ,���� r � `�'f,' i �i Y' ;'�� r �.� �.� � '`i �.;. �w.'�}�� �i -r" �r �{� '� � r3;.: r �"�,,�.:.�i 'r�f �' � �� ,r 'Y������� � ~ "w'� � �5- , u � n ! i 'k ✓ �5 4 �i�� _ ! �(..LJ � � ��. :P� f � ��+II( � ���1. t � �f�� �I T..�. 'S� ; V � �1�,�.�,��+'S� ���� �`' {l� �` ��� �y' 3 `i' !� ���i a� +� +.�'� '. � f1_i�� `f ' � ��i� / �� 'd: .�r',vl� J {��(�� � .,y. k�F i �11[d !.� �f�}" ,b,�,��pt). -y�" �.�.� i ��t s� ,�, � l �. } r.�/ I '.:��l+' r �f ��i}} ,� ,�a,� �F F ..0 ' ,�' 7R' .j �� *` ` � ..y�^�, ' '� .¢� . S. ��'11 4� { K- . �•;�C b S;i � i � ,'��1 � �/�� � � -1t s'+' y fi ��- � . �t.- J h`"-, t� "�S4vj Ki .6. � � �'�ti�'. .,��, '� N'� ���ti . .,._, �;�'dt��� y'�`��� :R�, ,r F� i t� .�.����.,Y^'� '� 1�°'��r�� � �,, . .�... ���.:���� j�l s���,flc. . a�'A,3 ` � . ' ��- '1 N s a -f3`��� � \',�t' �� �i ri� L �� � -4 .�y si.�. �,�}j,�ipi�.;� 'y''"�.�_F"F i.l'� � r ,� y°�sh��.�t v 1� . �r� 43r` 4��'. .'�,•� � �t,� �r-.. /�� � y� 3 � • #- ff,�� ti'� 4: ��I'�k 6 ?k��fi ��� �,��' 1-�y .- ?:� y� � •'s;�'� +�s�� .�'��T J' ��M� .�.�� , M �p.. #� _; "'� r . � »��.�p e , . '�� �� � �'tk'� 3 f !- . .,:' '�°t�, � A' ,,f; +�_*i�3.r, :i I`� s, ..i i, �- .'�{ f t � , �� �. i. - ��. - $' �� �,yr,�,� F' - - '� a. - 5�� � � �'� 4!?" t . •° t, PI` _ n ,�.I�`'� �� - � M� S`�'� � � � ��1 � �.�. .�:� f�" -. ����-r � �3��v f,t' 1Y,��!'�' 1 �Cr,. �r ! r �' �* �J*u ,✓��iYr ,�" ��`f `d �t ��N�,�� :�� �� a -x r � - t y.� � � . pf,�� "�'��4 j� ,, . :�.. � �,a}"F ir �� �,� �z�-����{ � ��}_�,.. �w 9.-�:� A�A+. �{�� :y.'�� '� � ' r, 4�' ' - rj �#� ..L ����. r a�'�} .w'1 'r;,:_� � ./ ��' -'�a- K� K��+r+ �� ��,t��1 4�@ ��._�s µif��''�; �+,..r�.,!/ • � i��--,:� _i�„ ,��°�y `�T�' �'� ; ;� .,�' �S�1G� y'�j'���r y��.,. ' ��. , � . �5` ��p��'�ij�E,��__ '�♦ , �;. � �?p" }� T - � � t °"±+� '���i���°`�? � ` � ' '�.'J�l ..Y 'P�.�u.r- r� � sr a �r 'r" �' -` „�-?i� :,+,�' 1'''p N k- �, �����1�. ':z y -,. �''ir- dF �"� 3'f tl} 3 !s .�. .�,� a S �.t,��l� �� . {{``� �T` -'a�� �'���`� «��''r�Y�Y: .-i� '�� � �,+s4. a. �{�ilY �.q{T�`� ,} 1 ryy � ► *����: '���r�, � � y� Y=J�Ir���s5'!F�"�'s�"��if'1 hyF! ,'a1 ` ��,�. '� .a , _, +�'�� ,*...d:, J .�� �' �! 1 , r 3?s�','-'�� i .f:_, - t� � t. i., 9p �� � ':p= �, � �.if�y k%� ��,t ' `` �� �j c. a= �� `� ,s''� ti�'y s ,_ `• p ia,t 4.y,`'' J ` A,.� �iS..,l. S,J� 4. A� �'�ii .S �'� {,i��r4fi''��i ���;���,'�� �` � �,�c � �r 1 '3F`� �� '�,-.� ,-�. y �A. .M-,� ,� 'f„ a � �� vf �.+ r ` t j�'t�., -.- T � '°��� .��f � +. r"` P' ���y�� �d ��. . . ��. .,vt�' � �l�h �-t" '1 h' 't +��-3� ` � ^9�f, �Y , n_ r 5 1 X ` . • ... � I ' ;�' � { ,ef � '+�, �y�� �'.� �'�.a� f,r� �; /� -11 - � ... ��# � �.��•� 1 �" �^ t � ' . ,�µ� K�n Y� -� , �� r 1 g ,b .4 � =¢ -t" - ''� ''� '"`§f�`�� C,� s+"^ . . ��� �� } .3s' � •a, � �� _� � - � � '� �. � � :'�P� ' /' r � . _.. . ' } v ►y. �_ ' t� . .} v.y .. _ �.. - ��e',� s � �.�IR ., � �r f -.r.-.. �"3� rTt�'�'��� _.-. s� -�"r��!' �� a��'��.« ��..� � . 3 ��� �V 4.���'!' "}J� a -,�, �, �. ;�at ' � :�' �`r` �"� �yIC�,�'S'� � k�.�. �' . ,��,,, n's � � � y,�r � t . � s z'� ' �� .� � �i�. �,.,,� , �'� r 1 A�P �+�' K - +a. �� ��.. ��,q� v, �'.o-�a '" f'' .9� p '��,u,• �,w�'�'F' i � r �F . �� .i._� .�$ �,..�, 1� �� '��yi � y�� � '�'�. , �� �t ' -i �,�� I[.�' �� -L �w�'-� T��'&�-•7" - � .,r� ^Y�r• q , � . r !.-� . ,{`�. � � T; �% ' . � ��v' ' -t}� � 9,,' ��" {f ,.� +l, i I;� � � y�' � .�� '�j'1�\ . t ,1��� .� i�"�, y. � T �� Sr��. ��� '_�� _ ��f c�— . ; : - �.. ^` ' -//�.:((�� . ' � I �� (S .� �...- '� ��` � � �• <ti r.r � y ', .... a�;' e ' � '` � L� 'l r �,�( IL � r -s<�,�i- +.� +�i' s �8�k � SaA,'�. � -'t�` [ �x!�, �r- �"�i� ;` � .�".- -� _ � . s !�'� �' -�f� S ,� '' ��y � �[� Y��' . . a ,� � _ _ ' ._ r� _�4 �' �5�...�I t���, r � ., 7:. �-.�'L`. �.`f-�.. ��� , . . �����r� l _ � �� �'._ '�i� �1�� � b � _ � � ��- � _ ��' �4 4 �{�' _ - ��� ��r� � ..� �.`f 1,�.. e,e � -�yf F` '1� l- �:_ °r� _ r pa qt_ � - � -;� �r ... i t ._� �F��. '�� `i� �`�5'� ,fl f q� � �..]� "- aI� � ��1Lx _,+f�r 3 ye , ..,�lL +�}L. +��r fl ' 1� ��_s�- �,.�s _ e� � -`� � ... . _ ��, �.� '��tk " ''4' �� r.3�� 0 �, ,� '�� i h � � � � � � ��� ��� �; �; �_ �;`�°,b ��i �3 �,�� � � ,'V �� '�' �e � f .�&^ '�� � �, ��.��: i!.r � _ '� �i - .;�.���-+-'.� 1. -t V� � ,k. ;�� ;.,. �- . - .i 4.. , r °:�, � h ° � [dai � �,'� ��.�"` il�' ��F f � `4.�k5;�� �� eJ.�'�.:.t� � _.a �. ��t, `�� .�a� f! � �.�, � ;�, :,� ��.�_�, -�: �� �e � � . � � , �.` � �_ y�,�� � �` ::� .3'�e�„ � � ��\ , � - -� .�- � '� "� � R` �� � - � -, �, � ';� � _�., . ' , '� , � , �' , .� s�. �y�._��� p�...�.liti��'� �. . � � � . � .. . i � �g. �a � r ,; i.�- � ��,, r,—. �`��� '� � kr .�`,�,�,��,� � i :� _�_= �� ' h 'r w � � �= r �� �.. K ��� `�-" ;..�� �;�'�° `� .4 � - � . ,�y.� `� 5, .ry -. , 7 _,if_ - . _ �� p��A� T�P ��k� } � ^����` � ' �- ,, 7 , 1,� �,�.i s# �;4 ;..���`���� � , °_�__ �� - T i��� 4:��,����4_�F�'� ti_d:��v�" - ` ;� - . _ , ��_' ,�,�'# . ,yri �,kc 1 1�, ■ ' �� -_ - I _.._._ . ' y���� i -_�� ��� :. _ - - - . -- � ' �+��4 ' . �.�'t * � ��' - �� -'' - �i; ti i"' f�'� _.. _k� _ ��., , :- � - .�ty .`��� ` ` _ ry - r'�� .��� ~;'��I -�k— �1,���- - �,� }, - - _w �, , _ �� ,k �.`� '� ��, �: ,1�� . . � .� '� 1,` �•:� ��. � .��~� 1. �-Y- { '?� , �y ,'4 ..R Af - � �', ,-� ,� �! <;� ; �� _ � �,� � a�_ � • [ �;�r ��rr � a�: ,� �r . t �;° r � . � ,; � + •��, �1''� .,i _ � � � �K` �' �, �'��"`� � ��A � i ;{;;��4 .. ���¢ �Y* �.�:�i� ' ..�_A�� , - iF, � �'� �R���, �_ y � � ��� k . ' ! � {,� i' �J,� �� .��r� VI ,� � ��y� .� _ � i�� 1+} ��•f•� � ` ��� ` Y'�,�,1 I � ''l j�� �� �' ` '�' *. y,a { _ ' h �'1 i:' {' r f�.. ��� �� d � ��:�7' { _ €�� # Y'\r ' r � r ,� -� .ti ��,��F`'"� �. 4�� ��x'_?-' ��¢ '� y'4� a.f�• ,� ''��`�,.�n `i�� S / ��, :k::.� ����� _ �` �- ��� r�. _ � � �",.�.� '��i ; ��l„•� -� - -��..4. ��s"rs� .�� fs � :�-� � �� �� `��- °'} - � 4 � , � 5 � f . - .� , ��- I � >"4 � ;� .i �;�' .i m , _� , l ' � �3 i- - , � ;91 tv! `Fry ��q� . . / � l�j ��f� �� ,r r�, :}"y_ ��k�. ���f� �_ `��i �r`AS�`.t '.; - , � , � �-�� ���, °.- � - ." i. � "'." - 1. .k c i� �s_ .�'.. .,„y��"{'_ _ � '�. . . �e. . .- l ,�� # '`�+� ..�� F � � r. '� - � ,� t �ti, ��. : �. �r ��� } �� �`� '". ' '��,� � � ��. �, �+ >� `,: rt, ; ` i ' � , �,.° '�- �__ �~� 5 - �_� - - � t* � �`, � � N ' `is�,X;�- )w'^�� r � '�." P+� �_- . � � y. . �.k�- _� �,, � � � � �h�.�� �� }s -� _S A h r` 3� 'e.�.A.. _ ,�a_� ��� P.w�MM""".. ' - � r�'1����f Y.:. � 1.. r . ' ��y. y - �;,`.+..� , :,, ... . , :._ �, _ �1.V �' -- �-, ' �" i / — � _ .... � � ! f''�' � _z �, - ^� ��,' ' � .� _�"" ��`r- �' �' � `�..--� � �,.,,�' ' _.,,4 �-' �s -•-�_ �� .. �N -„ — ,. ___ � _,�- � � � f -� , :` �r+......',. �,,,.,„,� . _ ` f i � . �.e��t . -,�,�`,x.�,=�• �� y_' . ..;; ,... - _. \ _,�.,,,r.�tiyf . Y� � 1 �, , -. �� �� � -.. :� ^.. �� � � . yM'"'. ...,��•---� s.�.� -�"��—�°¢ �- � i �f� �1"" ✓ .`.. � . ry,r�y:-Ls+ - . ' t . . � � s,r•.;a..i4.� � �. . •. �.��^ '+w'='�"�}�2�''�«-�'�� ..K,. � � f �`.¢LY �y'i. h! _"i �Pl.#.- a"�'�� ' ! -�-1,.,_ ,`!^^'-�'���m.�._ - . . �_��,..a.��'Ns.+":^ I .,:��_ j.".��-nxH�'N'#`s�R:?�'�. -�.� � �..t:J$1`Sa�'C�,���-`- � .. . � �y. .4 � � ,...,.' � .� .. . �--�F�r .. "»�-� . . ' -- � .� - 1X.3Fh , _.�.1� y - �-. � . � 1��}��*� f, � - � ' � . - . f ' I . . _ , _ { . l� . �a� . , ,..n�R' . . i �l '��4A�e�b�`.J-+���, ' ��l - `\ ��� . . . .. s . . .. . .a�5.:. �� . .. ' _ ' - � 5 , "�"!t .l. - .� . . ��_ . . � � - � . ' � �. �,_# � -� �; �� � i_ �.� � . - . _ . - T,, _ � .:� _ � . .s, T '� . ' . � .. �.�. ' . -' , . . . -1 �'-� . :Y _ r- - � �'tit , - � . ��^':F4` _" - { .. . _ Y�, ' ,� . ' .� 1 , ti �. � . ._,t � -� -r `., 1� ' � .�4. � - � 1:� � i " � � r � r. �" s ✓t5.. .. _ f,� `,' y ' i t � { ' - .: 1y!Fi. r . � r,� �;?Y. . / •r }_ �f�. .,��. ,S, ' , ,l .. . � 1 •�Y ;4�_ �- . .. .. - ' '�� - `_ � ' � `5`` .[ � +Iy - :7. .-. . � - _ _ }._ - . . � �.,[� � � � - -` 1��'� ��' - s � r .-, � ._ �� .; es��`\ , � 1 f �f.-, _ _ LY � y,'?�. .Lr'R Z ,. r - � x � ` � a� � �-�. ��h iY .t . .i �s�� t Y � .4 .i � ��Y .�� �r � �.�� .4 1���_�� ���_ k �-`�7Ty�11;. �! S�i• F _ _ 'd . � . �Y � , . . _ . .�w3+'r�'�Y �. '� �. . '�.; " � �,ra,4, ,^'`�.� �c - , l� � �. t 1 4} � L p .'p v w r F l ��F'.. hs �� , 4� t 7�+ f� { 1: 4 � . � �'� �t -.i:�' -1 y � '�� � 3. '��1� L 4 v w . �� i t �.. t 1�' � �4 ys:H . � � ti ",+F � �s - .i: ` . . ,� x.L ti� r s �,. ,. o t�y.. <' 'r'� ��' �'� {' u ?r f -+ �'F i y�`� � �^� �y 'f� �` �•} � yi� � n'�' � i � r�� f.1yt��. aj�1. �} � � , ' r�I � - �s• T '�4� -{ � j��'�. � �i s �.+'�''+i�y- r � i �+i � � - t ���: �, � y � • �, - , s x. t,.,f` ��r�3 { - �ti� � �{., :�'!t�>.� � ��.1 � � ...�' , � .'��� d`,i1' 6 ��wi �.+ - '; �.� �C � s �k.� ���'• � ,r - y - . �,. � .:'1 ., , r i .�^,'��n�7��y.�--�'��y� :: . •;7�"�' �. .. , ,. '� b �. e .}` S t ti y t .R� -r. . .. �.._.:'.�l,�� ,,,_. .. . . t?. . i� ���F . .. � .•a;- -�,�y„a q ;�.�.,�y,: �•i„ .j. ���,. � �� -�,i �. �' ; -y b�.� 'x �_ i�4)' - ��" ��j ` 4�, h a,� ` fj"�.�F� �r - '�1 � 7 �'�..'�. � r- � 4 ,��� �,4, .,tu ,;t 1 ,� �,y�.� � R„�'�'._;" �� ♦� �l��tP � �F'�� ����.� � �� � �,���� �.� f �� � �� y �� Ly � � ." �''�' � -�y � ��' .� `lM�. � 5 + 'y'�,��� �����' :���.�. �'1:�� �`:.i�,g.�. ; �4�� �,. �VM.I r, J �y � � t _ i y 7 �,w vi. � b' i� f' 'F '°�l� ;,7 �y� •�L1.'� f ,a j• II `�i,_s..4 � !i. K ..T 1s�-TM-�i �u ,§, � - �� _ #' ���.� �� . �� =2. p�- 5 - .� .f �4�� ' �� `� ,� #`�� f I .���� '3� • #.�' ' ��'' ` � r �;�- ', ''� �..., � �. -. �. 3 � , k � � r � � �:� ,•� � !� , . � � � , , � � � i � �'�� i r f 4� 'i��� ' _ z �� ' , ,t� � �,:� �1 - , ! i, '� " ��. .�,�� `. ��. � � r' i� 1 � +� ,i .' . _'�'i`^.. ' • � � �{ �,. s r � 4. { 1 4 • �?'�R a + ' PJIS R: 'T�i ..�;; . .,..�. ._4 . , 3 � � �r . ' �� �s }, �,� ; ,r��,� _���� � ' .v� �� +t� �t! .�' Yd s,, _ '�z -, � � �' l�� "� .. x!°, �%-_y � r v �.Z �,� - � � > �'��y (.�/�_,�"�"�'" �"'4�,y`rl�c"�t'r' a �a... ���a�a�` g"� _ �� �9 ` ��+ ,, 'f: ���: ^ � _��+.,_, :��!'! � �Y, �;r# �'� � ',,:"�."''�'^ �.� >."�+,`;�..�..rt :�---• �-y � ��g�C �r����. �� a _ � �'-i � �1F . i.: .;�r.--:il'. 'f A�►� �V_ • .^�, �n �.':�"� a.�.,� �. ' . -a��. • 8 _ ' + �i V�y���-.,,r. �� � ��..."L. 'sr . .Ak '� /_ i�F1.jLy-,�_ `a�' ��.,��, ��T `14 tti` _ �'u�� iy►:� f - ... ��`_ .� 4' �� C�' a�;►�� � '�' J �' . __ ^.. ' \ �`) ^ �.�.��iz,.i.�.'�.�c�� .. - -�R. i. � ~� � �� . . JI x , �4 ` .i�"�j` __ � - h�.'S' ��{\'��.�<� F1r��1C>�Ia - �� i� L 4-f��. � . F "�F/','� '7 �,,� �'�' --�' f �P*. '�yy� �, ,4� �q� .�.,����_- �t..Y�t*'�.4y,e`�^i"k .�� , '1 +.-:�� .� t •' fy�,1� �� �13YF�1`.�.�y..'_� ��l K �'_.. f�:� `f" :^�` MI �� � A Y' '4� ..di�: „r� �f� ��3��� : �y . �' ' � j� � � � �� �.,�,'�� �� .� �, �r' +- - . .. _ � ��� ' l . F r. � •' ` � : rl " f� ��1 ''trl (- _ ti '�,.�''�^ r:�f��d ..,1 '"r n f � . _ ��1�e--�,"-- �'.., _ _ , "��Y, �4 �� 7f -.� - .��. �'� .� , -�'�s� �� K .}� �. r ; _ . ! ' a Y a r� . :' r �: 3���� � �• ��w ����� '; `� .. � r ,��� ti + �� ; ' i � 4 �.�,����1 ! � �� _ '4 }. _ . {{ � '"Y i� � Y \ '� � � 1 � � r „� p f t � � +` ' f t k�il����� r � � '' l � >+ � 5 c _�# 1. .�' ,. :�r' tf� 3 j� Y� yK � . !' y _. � fr1';A { ' { � � : - r ' {'a�"' 9 r� '1 ` ��� r �. ..fY 1� -�y j' • � ` - i�� ' } '+. �tiV _ � -? �� !(4 `i`�+£ �� .,L �- y ' ,y xT } }.Li -..,� L t. ' ,� � -. > � ��` 1 � � .1 Si -r• rS,�%,`Kt �� a �: :+C 'd , . - .- - . 'S . ' .. J . '. v � ��I�',5;}It �k ''.� - 4- �y f h L � - �� f,_ � � i� 1 � .. r � f`��Y'Jr" l�... �Z�a dJ t,}I� ',. �S . �`, Z �1�� Y .� �� � �� � �, .r ' .. - r�, i � ; !,� F L r -� 6 ��}� ,. � 5. ..�* ^ � ..4 �,'� 1 .-. �� ,f �?: a, s ' � -'��ai r z a n ' f y � r y�, , �-T ��� �r� ,�rrk�, ����y�r"r ��Y 4�-, ' r L:�� 'k`e � ��.� 1`-t��,. --���.�Y lc �" �: h. 1�� �.0 � ' .:�y ��,r . 1 , l��Y � , �, Zh -{ '?l r . Y I * ,� "'- -, -Y�r:� .y � _ •i f�� rf K �, � � � ' �-� k �{��v�{ �,'�.tr �x-.. . , � ~ - ,�'�� �-���..�`� � t r � o� k - ��r r S, } ' � y� � '�'� � �'�� ,. '`f1 � r- � `'. a'= ' �.ir .� -,.-5�7����._ fi��. _t ` "�"` -r,! � :c Y p . t � a i, �> � ` � . , . ` � � � � `: t - ' 4 �� { 4�# + � � _?'{ F_y..A�` �F . -,y; y� r k 4`�- Y- 7 i t S}' ��.� }� T Y y��" � i f�t � r � Y. 1 *� � .. S�'� ,�x 'j ,��' r �.!�,� �� r ' "'��,�- ^T" �a^�^ t� ��i�' �i, , 4� ? t c - M a^^CY `� 7 �x���h�i� �C`�Z � �ti'. � �t� ` ... �� . ' ' �.c�µl �?'��y�*�� .�i ' r J.� t3 �r.�.- F. . �,� . t �r r ', i � �V s�MJ'--' Gati 7 � ., `, F f�� T � j � � � > i , _�S� `i.L:s�,• S r '.h�'��° ,4�ti .�i .�€.�A�������� � �� J�, ��� o . r ;' 'i 4 ., �,.. -�,-z � '� , }_ 5'` },� v X" � �"' t r , ` $ -� `? �t � ' � �i z s r i� `��'(i` 3a;�; r ir `�'. ..f � u�5.�.ti � ::{r w . __r ..c �i� - ��', r�vJ.wc ra r�h y � : r� -,}.. �i� �� '�r. '�� }�� �fy r T��'�-r� s -.�f f� �P°'� 's��.{ '�r " ; i�� ' '(� � ;- �,,1" 7.�r�`" � r yp , r�y�. �r ..�,.� . ' t -. . � . � i�ae.�a � �r h"-���� � �,� e -.�i � . �F�� -,�,r;t��t�� 1tLy.��T `1' -��,t ••e .,.�� r i !7 �� T;i-."fP,y,�.�.� i �v. �,lu .� . '� 7' -��-� fP�K�� .. - tif^i .�.�}� .f �� � -� . '�4s�s� ��) . X � . J�� �r` 'hL . . 7S � .lb-, ,��` ! �.,a } x.�r '� � .�� r..r : 7�y- e'� �. ��y -k� s �+�y �: { nf • ' � {tYl.-. ���f ,tit...". . n F^t a t�y i{ .. ✓ u -r .ri'4�,_x+rJ" y yj]r({�yp� a'i a�,,�y1 `�1�i":- .c Yd ..'r i_5�,• J�+,�x �'4 � � �. .� �"J � S i .' f•CtiT�S�� � ._ .'tF�Y- b �C �.`i'. {. � �y� 'ynF 1 4',Af�.r µ p� � k �� � �.., -'tx � -�i }a-� t k1�.�r� al��� y.y a bi , Sra�:�� �t(? � ���.�+�,.t ; � t i ��1f; l,i .r! �i , c � f`- . � ; r, ;� ti �rf� ,a � ` � f� . .��'S L �u�Ai� ,�^A,�,;,� Z 5 S tr i.' �"�s z � �/ '� ! �, � I ,� ;.�� s �� � � +'.: •rt � '�,aa �1r} E � .s � ��l.e L�� '�� . .s��' '� ♦ �', y � '��., �,y � ' l°P, '��„� r����� .. i .. . �� ._c7 J C.i>._ ;�. ..�.'.�a.,,ws �.r��i_.r.N•i... �. .��.,. �� .� ..�:� ., . h5 ��'�. ..t'?h.��i� ..'�.� � x . .. - i..'r,.1.. �,�.,... �. � �k �t#•.�- �.. ;i_ti?'� �,5', �`�_ - r i � /k �`����� ��' �R�ti' - /� ^� � �T�lb�� M �. Y .� .1�,� Y � � '- � ��` .F � � '��'�r � '- �!Nl � `.� ���:� � .��� 1�� �} - � i ; �'� � E'd`P� .r. 4�:�� '" -' ?�t�� r' ,yJ�T � u9' - ' _ A� ,.+���� , . �! v , ' # y.:.,+� V s� - k+�� , f�. �,r+14�a � ;���;. . ; - . ,.+ ,, � . # : :r: �� -� . ����•...� ��� ; - ,;i = � 1 ,r. ! �. ,{5 Y '�� ��� *�- • -�l � f� 1 �� ,� � f� � Y�,r� � ���i�s J �fi � I f r - f I .Ti .j!. �` -�` _ .-:'r,. . � + �,�.II `Y�r•- � y` �����4 �'`�+}�����' ' � '_ :s � '�`'�► ��` �<� � �.y' �"'tt"� �:;.' ���� �,,� , � . _. t� �,, �, j,,� ,�� �5 �^ ::� , • �,,�;� ,�; � � ;'�' '�y �� ��* ,•P � -�� I����.�, r .— "� � � �. ��� � A� �A .. Y�� ' F . 4 Y �,� �` .. ; '� � � /, �. l � !�v� �"�,,,,,.� �� ,i. . ' . i _ . y ,.� � .� « .� ,� �'�.,! � `F. �� _ � � - �� .. _( ��-.�-�� }�. . _ i .l�,-F 1 3- � t�� : ' - . �B ��� �.�� � � i:�s '1 ti�, '��,'S\ � �I _ ��. " -�,,�, � ,�N�s1 � {', '� � i ���yi 6.�A _ �a 1z } +� ��r r 5,.S .S - � 3 +�y� ��� �` � i, : 3'- . . '`A .ir.'�y�y,,.�.'� �� T , J � ; i . "�"." , .1'.1� '{�., �� ^y . I S�,M�- s �:�� , � 1. . jl . . h�,�' � � � ���i ti� � � � �� � .`_ �;� -� � � , �-,r ��< , a �.� .� �,, .� � ; a., � t ��� ��" I t� � + � ;�'} I�� ,, � f 1 �" � �•-. , 'F � � �; ':!�• .r. _ ! ��� . _ . / � - � 4�� / ' � ��_� � �1� , �� �� �,,�� ' �� � . ..� . . r,�. �. , y �// � ,� t R '', � '%""�w%''"':7'-'"Y`� ._'7 TT"'�.. � � c ' . . � k _ -�'�! . . �,�. w� `} . �-'����. � � i � ��9 ���� .. 1 _,j' . _ �����a�,_'•,y`'. , �'. �. � � F �I� . ., ` �i � � '�� �' '�.{' _ 54 -.:.}�iY�Y�������� � 5 �:� _ -�. '- �r y��!RS�..}'t°'.y,r .� � r�}r,._ k_ -�.�j_ ,-c�"E�. -.��,"..,s ''�� '-���_ - 4 � S �'�'�i.� .f�; �� � .; - ��. ;��F'� ,r� . "�'� �`$i `C .�s� .� 4 y1� .0 �� ' , � , \`P . y �r.�. _ ;� �� � '`4�1 Li `y �.3.� T: F a T �'�� '� � 1� � , � ' �,�`��'�`� �"•�r',� ;1 1�,� ,i, "� � `.F - `' .y .'� , r , �� '� � / ( : :j �,�K � � � tp a f f ;�I �`+, i ' � 1 � 1 � �' � f �.,� �-� � r :J �-s tf �j' . � r � .i i" �, � �`§' - � � � � � ,� ,� -_ �: �,;�� � .�' ���.I 'S � y� j' If' � � ��l��T � �. . i4 �.��� �A} _ ,,� �i 1 •J �. 1 .�„�Y�' ,:� }_ ;� ° t. `�.� _ �! i ' :..��ea '... r-�. �. Y r �' . t 1 ��5' � ti'_ '%` � � � �,i ` ?� � _JJ � � J1 � - ��`" � � ,� ... k �� �R �� 'a � .�r�i !t! _ �h��3 . _ . ���'s'_. ��_,t.. , , } :�b7 , �14,� ,.. a � �. '�� � 9 � ry � K � I.�i '�.'�l - ,i�_}� y� j3/�r ` � � �'1'�� - " . i. l '`� 1�` �� -_ �t � l _ � fi �� � '1� �� `Y. nt � ..-. � �c� -�'� - -��� �. + _ f 4.x' . ,.<< ' ' _ . .--. . . .�'� � ,����� •-�` � ��' '�- __ . � '��Y�k4�i� � ��. �'f'' t..4 - .+'. _-_ __ -..� �.ti ' 3 s �'iy� 9i - � �t x�`` q"� , -. ._. . . L / i�`} � t)i' ��" ��tl _..� = �.-�-. _ ��. � t p a �i. -�� -- '� _ ti`', 1 -�l�. 1�, :$' .F f� t . _ - �� __ ,� �,� 4 . � A ���'', � =...__ ; . t n� 'w� .. . �9*1_:�k , �..��'. .. 4�;. - _ i �q -- � ; � ,;'� j;' -���El?'. ' ���� ��,�ilr! � - _ `( �t _ `:� � � �< -__ �` ' �� , j '�t�{' r��� , 1` y' ., � '•�' � �� '� {�� .�. } ,.� k:. "'� ,,1 -_- - - ��_- . :� '�T ' � dit*4 1 r x � � �- � :�.i ��� V _ _ �__— -- .-- - Tf '�4 t-�. ' � � i �' -. �''+�; �,y� �'► ,. t�� t �,, �:?? ��, y� � ` '� , ��—�— - t ,a� ��`� � • �t ��1i! hl „ `�*� ,� r f' ;r'4' E 1"`s—�—�`"` —- � , '�. ;��,� �,. �r,, y,. . t y �1 � �. �_ -r �f- � � v��; --� . Y� { `4_` .t� �� , ;.� ; � Y��,�. � . �,.,�:� .r�.� .��6.��_ S �.. 12"Y��} �-� v h'I � �.�� . '� �'' ��: �_t �.��`'."�a -, +�" ��, �:� `� f , � ,�' �_ �� :,�.����� --c- . .; �. Y _�, _ a. ` i . � Y, , ' � -�^- - �_'��A� + � � �� � � �. / � � S � ,i' �- -.�` ,y�, � � " , h�l';�;Q �.► ¢'� �, ,� � . �_c.�' �� �s'�-; � ' - :,�, .� `�, ��� �r ��'w ' � .,�iP" _� � ., �'� l� ;� ' ' �-'r3 ��f�p �'' _ � �� � � -E.- ,:� `C��`�aF'` � Y .'.�-��. � t � ���`N. "T i�� . a�� �4 �ry� ��� '�` ,'_ a � � :� � ,� _ .�.� �'�'w, , '��, s : : � � P"`� ,� ��,� ,�,.��� �y . ,� ,!�,E ���*-a�-�. �-� ;,,�"--� 1 a� y + �. '{•'� � �.y� , �. #r�� ,�,�p �/��_ �� �`. .�`_ � � �+<,�����`� '�''.- � .�• '� ; � � � � l '~ -���1`-��'� .� e � t�� ,.'��1 S. : °ti � � �1 '� ��, _ �1 Y 'y5: �F . S',�/l _ _ t .,� �j, � S.- ..-'� ,3 `;� ��L� � � ; ','��4�I.�-� .i �4' � -�� ���' . .�' .d- �� r X -��k. - :� t�. �� rr ` 1 i�j �� � .�� '' �"�� 'yt �� j 't �', ; t_ � �� .4 5 �� �jj��� 3-- ��' � � �I, .�`"� �' �f�5�: A, �� �+�-- - ` �.+� � �' _`. ti.� > y ,�� 1�w��� �.._ �`'�'� �' . _�� f '� . ��i '"��;' � '`dT: � � �k � � t��� - .{�,.�-�yn _ �1 � � � �i�. ';� �-Y ' ,� � � ���C�` �� R �;. 4 � `+�`� : �' '� ;,�„ ' � '` �� -��� -.�'•.� � ~ �� ���_ ` .��'�C } f e� t -.� �� .�,. ', ' •� p •�a--� � ��( . ��\ . . � � . 5'��'Y�S� `... � �,�'; �_ � �`� ,� ' ��d �s �! f'. '� �- y 7.. �1� �.�'. �r'W s_ • �� �:�a• ��'�-~—� �; � „�,.� ��.� .� .� r,. :�:'`. s � � '� 4 j� '■�~� ,� , ti - ,� �.� �r.� •.,p� �`` tr-' �,. �#r �'�-�-`- '�;: '`�,`__ �� �s :�;, �, _ ' ` �; , � ,. t �� �. � �` � �,,. —�-�, x- �� > � . ; �'` r �r'r ' ' r` � � �. `��.�`�'�i . , :� " �K 1, .� _ '7� '��'r �f: F �.. i s. . f. � . 4 l '.�`" .� i�/ � �r a, _ r f�� Fh � \ .�'k r � ��� -.. t �, � . l, �.��'� ,� L . y �,. £ � f :� � � �µ\* 9 'I .. ( � ��� . � �._ � �l ,. {�h , . ' . fy �- �4�_."-. : , �.`'" �:' ;;� ti n�j � �. � , 1 � 4 . . �,y t rt . ,:t- -F 'r - �.; ' w s .S;���, ��. , � - K�� $ r..rs',t ��]Z ,.i� .,.-_ .� . �� � � � �.� .1� r - SU�; � 3 riSrt .e,. { .e.t,,.,�� � � ..� . � . ��-. -, -. . .. . .E '� � '.ry�-, {��'� .�T S �� : l�':r J� � 4: F� �,�C� F _ .11�. , T - 5 '�� Y..-�� !' ..'� � � �F ��' ;''Z y , �. '�T f - � t .' i r....11. A� { - y -A ' ._'t y �`r'-�_�'• .,-s f 1 �' k .a 9�'. � . ,,, -s��� t I l f s -'J}i� -ys iv -�. zky{ '.;`3 k .; ���'rt� *)� -, ���.' ��� �i - ' i[ ✓'t: / r r 7 � � " �a��- i � y�. '�t,.` c _. s �� F � '�ry � ' - - . � .�'._. �i ' '` � . f _y. r s 1'F� �s i ; � _ � K- ��� pc� h ` '.tY -��� "4 Y��� ,} . . 1 f �5 _ }� t _-1 l - G� _�1� .; ��_? � 'tt /� , y,�`�,. =.r- .'ys l�, Y '��t - � '_. .� . _ ��;,,... .. �G�1 r � ` ��, �,t. P R .� Y � '' yF ✓ ., < , _. r.;�ti. '4. _ ✓ ,: i•� ,- s4.. � ��'�� - 'Y'- � . ,. `[� ..-j� �./. '_5 ':- S _ _ -, � ^F: ra ,�-t y � '� � 'i .h�� --�� . �.�� f -�i.�" �f. � ,1�n l� • � { 1 V 3 K 1 �` �' } � .h . ,y . � ,. � I L'` T �, t � � �. ^� `�4l1. 1 \,.t, ��,' l J � f�+1 . ti!1 ` S� 1 � � F � - - � Z�i � }� y,�'f+ i . ti �� '� �'._:r�r'_:. .i;, -d,,� *'y� _ �; -�'i a t_�5� -°�, , 7+r?`�. �Y�` � f�.{,� y: _ w . �r -r r ��' - � �`�.y�� . .;d-i �� � .. �� r '„ti�v Z; Y v� ..., �f N� ' '� fy+ a � � r - �y � � z. ,k-.. �� � � ?.-,.� r� � " � �: 7 q h�u F.4_sl r��a ` -� � �s,f-,*+ fs�^fTy i?�' i �..� ," ��� •f., r.��M-4- . �.'� �4 a� ��4}, . ;y r. v r`' r�3'�; 4 L y t45.� .4+ y . 1 � J a! �tii �' - � _: ::y,�`,�_r ,.s�� ��� �sy,'„�' �-� s�:"+r . l e i �4���'n� 1� ... r S 4, y- �. ' ' �� �,���. -F:3�":� - . T ' :, ���r?.� �d �7 �� �hl 'S.�L`� +- -c � ':`c,S "�� � � �_ ' t ��. .•�.� r$fe r . •�� f.• �rf ��.,.r''. �.y � � ,- R�� ��: ... �. .. '�i .� � , ��g �F� \�', .� . . .'� ,- , ���. . .. r:: a� :� ,e .�� .�..�. tia tN ��� ��F,�r ���— � �'� �'� '�, �-"4�,�.}�1 �F� � r�y� - -�1" R� �Fjl� �+�` ��'. - �:• � � � �� �� } � '. .. � ' � _ � 'i� � ,+ , �� Y/�' � J�.�T � ! �� -!.�. y, ;�-�� � �i�'.{r . _ � i�� 7� ;k` ��1� t ��� � i s � ��, 's�+� f `� ��;� ;�w ��� r ��� • �' ���� �`.�� �'� + _ �� � .t. �.� . � iy.� �T: Y � �r"a' _ {� �f, Y ��� y 3 �1� �� g� � F ��`r 1 � . : i �..� F� , _ � y t 1�t. � � �`� .,� .� � ::� �"F �1 �' �1 � . ' � �� A+��, �� I.�.' � \ .. \'•�' ,Q_ �i� � • . t �; .�,� -* y - ,�:.� . _. � �_ . q 7 _=` V .��,��x`� r f� i �� f. :a :1 / �'-1 •*� �. � w 1 i! ���� r, � �� 1� .�'' � �.� '�T. , ' � � .:�. 'y �1 . . �� ' �� '� � ,�F �i � � ,i �: - � � ��5 3 * � f �4 ;I' t; �5! - ,��� } 'E J ''' . ' .� .$. � .. ._ --i t .`�`. � . n .�1`�E 'S�_� �fi .j„�• .+' �;' !a. � �`, ` 7' W� 9'''1 1 ��f� � �Y •`� �� �� j�, , ' J h1 -�A.- �� , �' �Yl.. ']. . �' '�' w��'i.' ��� �L �� -��� " � __ �'- ,1.1'� �'i�Tl�. F�� � ..SF� . a7' l � . � }h � � rf `-� �5,��y; �•4� •� iil. � . 1` � .. � �,� ; _ . i !1 .�[._ � � " �: F '!. � { ��` 1�" t ���• . � . �` i i l y 'Y.n 4 %� S �'; �F A +� m . A � . t;�1.- j � �'• 1 �, ft ~i' � I i � t �r+�s�1 h .� h nr'"„ f'�; � '�` *+ � ' �! a . ii .* - � G?��`�• Y _� F � � � `�i ��i� �:"f{ k � ��i' � p } �� i '�<t. tl i-���y ' ;� 4 ' ' a �� t i ` i � � -1, r�` �j t.�� ��. V ' ,ti��` # � - p ��� t� j ` i = ,�'��.. ��• �;f.% � - �� � ..._ *i p.T-r� ,, f � � �� ,��� � ,.�, � i�p 1 �: f : f .:�.� ,i`y� �r L� '� P'� }� SF�� � •� .� ` �� �'�� ��_ � � �: � � �i �R '�!tr � � � { � 1 ���-T,'� . t�� 1 ��k 'n �-FY.�y� .. ,2 4 s�. .� ' . _ � � � ,.,i' � � k � ?_ , ,�� ,� `.� �.r .4;- . r � /� < � ,. .�� � ; -.. � �j$ , �� - , r.'� ,. '1 J ' - 4 J Y��. _ f,, ,T�_ � .r t; ��,t3 I � ;� ��..I '`F�I / .:T � �� r . i � - ',•, �f �dk�: � ,���.. e-�, r�� � r. -x � �: fi r n ,. 4 �V..i(•. t . . N. .�� 4;L.� _ }� t'. a t* .'i`' �' � x k ' y ,� � ��� �r n� , � ' � '1. � F` � .. � �5 1 4 � _ � '� � , .., �y�y� id k :�f I I Sr..rry''' � ��� -�¢ . .:j� ��� . l�� { �+ ^ ti � .r�� ;�� _ i" �„'.t: �� � �; �� ` �, _ t r? >' 3 i `4 � �� N � . - �1,� ,�'y . . _ i. '.� �.�� � ',.t ,.� y'Q'1/§ � �.�F �•' ��v ��. �. •� S^ t�� �j'f� . �j �*t 1- �- 1 ul� S�F �. . �. 1� };s� r ��� ��T ' ( e � � * , _ �° -'�; �� , �� A' �zr. �" �r _ � ` s , L `� l #�' .�� ti t-, K ' a: '4r �'r z � �t -kY e �' -�1 �st�c� '���. . ��; 13�� J' _ � . . r-T'�1+�_ . F..fi.. '. ti _ '�'_` .� .Y:"�,k{. ` � T�,• � �� - K+. . � .�, � 4 .' ��� �r ! i f' ,�t , � � �:�x' �.,� � t: �ti �.� ri' �fr��:� a. -t�� � r�E Y'if 9 L Z J�� ',.` .� a. S.� �a .[ y � i :y. $ . y1ti - i �r �Y \ � ��,�� _ .,h �yal. ��t�'`�*� ', � *`- -�r �'. �jy-��'r ri ,.3� . . 4 ` y ',-F� ' ` ,� y\ - r W.��,c- Sd< �. �� * v a ; ti .; ' 4�� .�!'{�'� z�'. 1 � 1 _ t„- ' .,� . �/�, � � i i � y�, � .T "`-+s "�s � ^ � �� � .- '�'� ..,�..�� f: r �.p.�f -,. { S^� _L . �_�'. . }, �ti�: � �S . k _ _ , a`�` � .��. t �.,..j/. f � i�4 3 � ' "�.l e'�T�.y . r. ro�r��� �„�S "_.• .r ,' �}.,�h l ,.e ,. ' Y� , ,. �' r M � �F. � � z � ` . �r- 1 vs-Y'ki' �y.' � . 'a- ? .y--A,:..:r t 4 , . . k s: '` s�,k'f 7�_ ]���yh .�'��'�i 1 i�.`^'�S"',.;,�,�' t Y��' i _� r� 4�4 iY�w Z • i . i.�.y �- r: % �* �,y � �� ��-r"-� �r.`�'ars���"1�'tia.Y.?^ ti� �;��-?a,r�.���r ..,r r a_ �►#.-7-�'.-��r•, . N ���.`��{,�e^.'�e �' T . >,�, � �^,.� x .. T }}, �i"rt �,. �*� �r ��..� � ��.� .r �;,�` ,�,::r z �� r �.,:;t���. .��,� ;y , ` y� �C � ` 'k�� ,��`r� #kti"t �� - _ - � , -. A �.h, c. '�L 'fic �.t k...:f 'h*s.,� e ' r� ,n, x��t - F� -: ., � i . -j t� � � - �r . y��t�x � .. ,� . tr •i�� � �t^M� y�, J,.+�s•�y��'-rr�7�it w ;�� tr �'% , r , .~x T`� . �f'•'.�ti . �}1 � .h : � .s �'Ky ,�,4,+�. .�,, 7i�{�+y"� t i r. ; �K k ? "^v t` T �`v �,,4 '� ` ♦ �I y�3 ��� +� , •-i, -Y r�� �!`4,'L r � i �, . �. �,` c.. x.0 x � .�i f ,� -�P-/ �'l�, j � ' •c `' •c�,7 +.. ""`,�"�y t rt r. � s+ ��'z��r � � i/ w ��. � r� --�.t z;� � � zs a �„r �..� ,� t � � �c �tY �� �-� - . 3r r,}�, 6L �"n.s' '� � �} �.7 ..`f ��r 'lv� `'t � ,t �� 1 �,� +�1 y,. ��' K ,�.�.�c,sa `_'. �,�,-.`�v; �yk � �.z�; � r�.. .� . -s' ay„ . � . F� .y. rx� �v.� .��.k � .,� .. 'Ii�TK, h.. .Z �Jf - : K1 i.�_-�J t � r- ` '! } , •� r , r E L f� , �� 4^ � �- . [`�;3- ' � ' f�. � 1 - - 'v f 1. � S � .11 ���.�! r.. , ,1 �: a SeY7� .t �'� �` � ve« �.�, . - � `,t ti a �-� '� ♦ � .. ,-��x .� -,k ♦,�`_f � ..y� ...r . � �Y'� ✓� 9,r'S �ii� �.� ��.r 5 r"P 4y.`� �w � h _ �.'` _ ^ k }y '; ° �:}.`w.Y...`. ` ��y*}r�*i �4�A .�: 7�-„r'�s;"4.f�'�y�� ��#,�� ^s w F�;kZi� 4" i C �t�Y-�. 4 4�'.'ti a Y._ '-:` ° ��� ��,�.`� .,a��'� ' -l' _.:n�` }. . 7.� . "� (h �} 'ti r -�1.. �'' j .,r � + . �ti�Y .♦ x -�i -. >'iY .}.. �4l - J .S+�a � 'y � !�' -.�x?, t ` } e� 1 �f ` Y._ 1r L,1!;.1� m'' S� ,� l}i..��`� 1 � � 4 . . � U : � . 't. _ 1{']i? ..73': � �������ic,.��r?..i spr ; r. �t � f , _ i���'t. �,r w� � Ti`�. �. �� : �` .�"� ''41 ��;r} .L, -4�.h � r ` �. � , � � � �``t� t'� y.� , . r fY^� �.'F.r Y` :trt y[ty r�`' t�y.'� � � �y} � � ` ii�: tk'Yt ti. �� �' ^� -.}. �j�r;'.� rn r�r.�Tr i.t �:- 1� i�v �. , • ,�. �,,;_ �' � y�'-�'� '�� ' F f` .�� �_.'i�,a �,�.. ,?3 `�► . - ,. .�; +� �t.. t � � t� x-- � � -y; �`�y♦i , ' � '� r t a ? � 2 .�'f �� kl �� � -�,�r i 1� ua � � � � , � � �s �; �q � , '7, ,t~`� s�'�t� w k ..t� �. �%'t� �i::� , , t �'t'fbx i � � 7�;r , x`�.� �F�:� .is i y� F.;`.q��:-d:, ' '.�'�" ���� . �r�,�e.at� �ry�r,�� .rr� t i-�?T-�Lc��"C�*���1tRS f�~�� -r r �� '-'��' � !r Et.�. h'1 �;'.4 r ��: +{..` `��`+r, ,,.�Y rt�s.K tff.:- �'h�,? `� � � � h• F}� L +r�, i y�i4�^ �'. �5. . �, � . i'�,� F. �r- � �� ��`.�yr p�-�•'F'' +t ,relk'�''�""y ..,i. ^'�.�i-rt i�,�'C���� -ti���; P ..* '^*y y`s*r'�h. �,rM �.-. i� { ?4��+� �� �-�����T� i' �.��" : �. - ��} � 4�,r Sfr-r` �r-.'t • '►-�� �..c,,,'�w ♦v y,,,� r'��!1;��{,�\ tiV• . � � t�. :.i� .;,i�� '�r:�� >. � �t.�1 �ir r Y �� Z�4� ;,':� .�� � t-a -:r� -,w...r 'S'�i3C'�"�e"�15. �f' a � �_\��. �'•��� .���:w - .4ti Y WL'-�� .L.,,��-� �.._4, �..���-�'�*� �y?.1a�'� "{�'►'� -,y� �.Y` ;�Y'�:�t. - ' .�r�- '��� �' i. F r , -� �'C����n>�t �. �`_ . , r .,i*��j��rt��.. �• rt '�ii�i+i1"`.�.�q'r�` -'za�'e"`µnt '� -'• r-�,} �,J� ^+ �- °�,:"�'�J�. 3� !'u`•�k 1� �:"�'�`��„' s 1- � .-. ��� 'r�.i� ��.al""' i ,r" :�., -�! �,� ',r*� y �5��'.�i+�,�,.'i�����r K��r� �...{. ,�� �'-'k�`*yi`,�*',����{' *-�t.: �;, �.i-��• � r��s � .,r .� . ' .. ��.- �t a�1'' � r�ec�.t "� .'y� a. k s� �';r {�'�+ 'i' 4: ,�- r w �,y � �• r . L . � •- �. c �� �s t L.�'P-�G.f •F' '" � ,�' t p �,,,�s`��l�i�'i x a.�`'`e'j�`� ��ri'r - �.-r�,h ��,'� ��- .:�t�=.rf'- �.. •, 'C . }y,�,.4.��y..�,����,� "F � -�7,�,�k�,lrt t '�i�� ytl. Y �'F.4���a. ,i � ,a -._e -" +�� �y."et�� �� � -�:L�� .�y r . �` 'j#i�'�� = r -�d�"at�-�'k-:�' �e�,����'ct^�. -� 'l .� a, � l ; � y� �'7 � `xt« ti. �y'�` i. . � �n ,� � n L' "Z' } S 3� > - . ��}- ' ���y, Sflr � }I� �y •wT " '�4�1jy y l�.�T+ '.}� .1�F 1yh l� . ��i ��k'+..�,j'Fr �l�ti�K1 �. . wY � '. ! ��-r '�u'i��-�' �.'��i�7� � }-�4'.'-' �7�� 4'�-�%.r k ati'�k#1 ���.�,��. yf,J+�;��*�� k.� �'�' i+ �.: � �.1� Y•'M��.��..k �. r . '�;. .L 4 yR'.�-��-y`rw.�. 4�'Y1�} F. 1' 1�1 # k��� �� .���` r�?r��A F�v .- �' �'•L f� f.. M ��i i4 ���i-4 ti K .' �,�4�' � h,�� � `� .�. �r r� c ti: ^^ h��%t � �.jy �$��� �°" '� . , = s� a"� +�. r,.� , � `'� "_� '^. i - + + �t r :nk\ "� �S ��� '�l � + t . Rk ti'�`�r•`'#`,�,��'� �ye� �/� ! +�i iY� t �r �-��T`�, ` �fi' '�� ���� f . - � 4 �•�• ► ti s.r i F� if�.� '. e �x '�� ,f � 1 Y�� L� �.l�ai � "' ' �'t ,.w_ �f f _ � � 'tf_`� t ,. 'j`r ° k.�t ,r �+tt'��t y,�j�+�T;� (`S,xiy�R �d `,+�4. �j f-' � j '� � :7 .r� ��.-L�,<�'�`�"1' �`�� 1 `�`R.. t ,� .;• ,••. "• �" -.�.t� "'r�� R' � y, t �t��'.�-��, r. +�, ti"r tiat � y��� � �:��,. �`� 't,E ��rtr�� .�iFt. s _{`,i L .-ks:� '+�+...�k ,��.1:..;�y,� . ,�. � ,_�:} .:;:�i►titi Yti` :.al�i.,,� :'���.. _'�e;x+1'i�'�a�E,`�`,:� Y�;4� t.. ����f �, �,� +� � - - ,. - Z �� ry r�4 _f ��-A i�^��� s ��'� r���`-;� ���� ���'�s., s �, �� � ��� 4'� r'.. - t Y �. � . i.� - .f, ��T'�� yf'.� � �xv� `lF,�, t - �!*� ����} x� j�� �:tr� ,r,��C a�� • ;'.,� � �F�i� � - .r��� �; �s �t�a �� �:¢ � .�" 1' a'• S � � ` �"y� � �I'_,.� yr�} � ` S �-I�', �- .. :;� �r � �. :a. �i � � • y -r'74m��-i��lk4f'!�- . , �s-:�I,�' � 'F, � n+,� �./ --'t`r p y'�'� ,�. � ' ..L'-r"F �e �1'� �*�,�.�F�{�,_�� � ��+ .t � .�� � ., � o' � ������� "�� . , '���� ��a'-�'�;"rdCk°�i.'� ,�i �� : !1,' i��:* � "�a1;•I' "� /,. ��' n � - . , �r.i,w ,,��, . tSR -- _:iv t ��_�- � l�'". � �4 : �' � �7 �.��yP��r �'�.t'� �','s ` �"e�: �e _ � - ,.'t r .,��r _ � v��, �/`"y�'�.w 1� � �C�: �r'�. •A ��-���"�1 ��+-yi+..1N� . � IY ?' �,?M1f'" y � -- r.c�-_ �,�2 -° � -�`.^� ti� ��;r ' .+�,t�.. F'� Y���w �1i �� � � .� Y� � ��'�� .������ �.�� �,..,� •� r �, 1•'. -�' " � � t "� � �R `A � M. .kr: - �'�r r{ '"� "��„' ..�? �Rd'a., .,.r�'� � !.� �`�w ��� �� � �' ,����� � � �a �'. +w � -� .: J� ' -�� t�#�l "".. � '�'' ''. � aY,g' . -�l �'�'qr. � ���] , .` r�. ,�t. " �! x :y�{, `���'g�,&� :�c ,� �-. .'.�, rv�!"sr����y�y.„ - �r,. �� �� " -Q��' �. .'��]/ �1� . 1!• � ' �}C �M f .- � . .:,.7 i t`�'�'!` �� �;�'� �' �� -�'.�' \. �a. �f e �•? ip �„ -:�� �,. : �.. ,i. �� �f M.,. �� � '�3r `�v=-- ''� �y±'15 9�,�r� a�ri ��a � E:: J'r" _YI" Y�� �f`,'c' ' � ''�'�'� �S' Y �"�+ r-` �� .�rr.�+ �T �c.,. y � ..�� � , �: f��� � ,� � _.t'�,. �,.,-� . � ,. i ar.. � p� �,�'; `y���„r � ;� `�''� 1 �- _ ."` ,,�;1� � � _ •� '"'�;.'�; e: �' rx� e;r �.. ;, !. � �,� �' „ �`� l�������J �.�` _ } , � .�� x' ��`y ...�, '�`� � � � *��^�:y� 1 �# .�f ��, � �+ '�� f`• :,�'rr ..��� i y��''� ili .� � ���� +��r �f�r_,.� '��� ��}"f r 'IF 1 `'^.���� ;� `���� �_� �r A ^�� y� t � �� r Y� � � � �j� C�-"� ii� J �n �y' F,ty1�p s3�.�� � 'r�Yw f Fr ��F �f�{ Yfi++ � � , rr "'�� ��>.� :� ,� '�*'��T+j., . f ..d ��f�,r`si'/..�.a� �.s'�',� �.� r ry fi � �� �: f ��� � -- �:�+ '�•� ��{� r .��`Y � T �` - " .�d ��. .L �,�a �.i' �,..ff ,� �h t• .!'�,' 9 �r . �l� � �� x . �f '� � ..Lti �,� y .� i � �l ��,�. �r.��Y �J� '' , ° �... I�� �f� ' ,�����..�. �+"ae� �s ��,r•� T}1 " _�� r�-� �'• �,r� �i�" �`�•li �,�!f =•+��y�._ ,��,�; ,�i' �-��{�� rT,�f 17CY* �y� }4id�.sp .�,��j. , �.. y . wr� 5 � �� �,1l.Y�� L:; ���s�� (�'wf�Pr r� °„'_ .a �`+�� �..� •' �1���.. _ ����- +; z� ' ,� �� w o Y �,� .! � * � I j( ? ' � �".`��. j F �� � � i�� rI�`�' �� �� i.. ��•R`r •2,�1'1*' _:�Vr. =f." �� .#,': ,' �'� ...�i. G F . . n. y 4 _ 4P`✓�•r�y. v f�' ^ �r� �; �• �;': .f� r'�`".� ��'f. � � - � s .f x +e i .�,�. }..�, f. � r � +rf � 'IL� ., F ��� f h �e���! ��� '�G ��. r, ;��° � � r ,� + _!�y i '� �� y�F'-� � � _ �� !�!� -�� � � r � �,�.-' e ��%v}-.• 6 �, C�"�,.! �.� �, r � �� � � ,�r/ . I .'� i- .��J aA�r�„' ./ ,h�;� '�. -,�� r �,. ��.y�7..4 y � �'ti�'� �.,yC_` �„r p .. . �7' �!`U 'IF 4 „� /. . ,�. > .. , �� . �� � � � _�hF .�� �` ..� �` . ��� �.. C�, � '"T� 'R r � .�` �� � A�� f I ��x L{{, '! ✓r,� � .t'�f=�- ���- , ,'� '� '14 o�i �'�- �°��.�.�'{ � �'[�''"�� � .- � � �. �� �s �(�M� ���_ �., �j�� ��y�'7r . �"? �°+,� � �--. '�: . i .�F:�� .f- ,y pL���r���' "L � + �� .,R� ..1 '*�.. - ��4t� `k���� .�����; �/r��f���f w���� �r� �� .i-� '. '� ��� +'� ` ��. � �s � ��` 'K, �-F r�'k �^,�"�'� � ' �r � � ,�,�4%r 4.. �Y, r � A� �i�J � r _�A .� . i, ����^F� A �"� ��j� I. .w��i�� * '„�k:� tr `-� `P'!� �'�'�,f..� .y�''�'} ,,�'�4. as�. �,� ��F � :1�� ' �:: r� q?h—_.�� �I/a� ���i s, �T�p w s�.�'�„+ � �.. ��lfi,#, � �Tc� R; _� ""s- � �' ._ �t.� ���f'�ih 31V� Y ats�,`S.�'�.a}•: a"-.. �un ,. � " ry;r- q �. r� a.� #, ��^' r " ; ��,� � i '� � a 'r .r •;,?r«a °i t � �"� + � t' ' k_ � ,� ° �' -�w�' _�`R ' �,�,,;,� i ����''.��.�'�;� ���. , �. ". g:-- � �y �� S �,,-,��,�r �- � 1 � � q; � ^ � �! , '1� ,ai.- �,s �,� ��.+--��'��� _ . � .�, 3r � .+j �'r�-�''� ^c' ,' r} T��� T� � y�-f�i¢ .��_���:� � ''�r.-�k.�� t .'.�.. ��y ' ��r . ,�,'/ii'y„�!i!t� �� � , �"�� � _ .� � " z"�� �� .�'�� � F� �� ' ���< ; ����r��� .�, - 1 � ' .C' P•� - � .�� � � `i �� 9 � � �`���` �R�` � �. � ��+,'' ��yl �� ,�� - �R: (��1� C/� �j�p,� �F+�� T� �'�����+�+ `.�� � r .�`y�: ;r�y�7�q 's�, ��; � }i�'�. �K�x,� . t +��p,;' , l.r+;_Y'�� ,�1�- .? �,,�' Y'� ,� � ib�,fai � 3, :�f� �;`w �a,�,a>� 1���'�ai` �'F'a�� � ��:'93�cl����r� �#��'�'= -W `w �Y - �s.�� '. d�'.11�h w. �L..._ ,a�'.�{�� ��'�F� ��f'��.y'��. .1`���• � '�"�`+� � (J ,� � }��htl �.' "� '1�V� lY�!/[4'l ` 'TTA � �YL/Y�� �i. 1 �. � 'i�Rl_;y;�:Y �r1, i.�"Y��l. Y,� y'�JY}r`.y� j�f� a. ��"� t r � i�� , � .r � N,r��:ts '� -*r n ��� �. �� �,� F{ '� � �,� . �{� y�-,..�,�� ,��+y ,�:r�'��� �{ f � '` r��. R� � �rl' 1!'� YK ,`ks#j�p �` j�fF A � .�""� �.i � � �' ''',��.a ���� -�yj i,'�t 4�` '�r •l 7 �.t �2`. _�'t .f -��. u � �4 e � ��,� ���'^ ����� � .���` � ' -'�� t . + h���.° ` :�''� �e� v��a�'i j� � ':= 'f ��`'�I .,6 , , �,�,1 'Y rs-�Y�54� �� � ��fyi^�� . �J ���`� 5 t.r:M � ��� f�r �!' �l ri�r�!._ �1 4� �F .r ti y{' .�. ''��'=t�`�� n � _ � #':� •,,�y �C+ir'+�'�1 W�,.�� .�' "± ''� ,z�w �ry�t.. k i.: ''`"'�.a� ,.•; . '� � ���.�� �- r„�F;: , � . ` � „�' � ��' .,�� '�'�'�''j+ �; z 4 r�4;r� ,�. �_ , ����, � �► � --- �- � , .. ,� �` •��;iF` t . '�'.^�...� '. �. � .� .a���._�+s::�,.�-; .� •r��: 1er.�.` ' � - .� � , :�`�l���� 'N��� t- y��,.q`9iQ.r uw'^7F ""F x �L�,.�. ,. _ �� ,,+, � � � . y y l' �S 9� RKT .' f ��'4 F'T }L , �� F f�;� � � �,�'4' '��� � � :�� �� '�s ,�ty �, �? �+, w �y-��� { g ,y„.�� : � \ �.x � <. "S♦♦ „ -. �'4y� �� � . itc w� !� �'�•�:� ,'�k�, - � '{y� S l. * y_�.j,� i '�. . T �R� „v" w� . '- _�` 1X� , i^ .� � i. , i'S� ;� ..`"� �t �, h �� - "i_ � � t � �,�� R�\ � s,. "���u a �'� �_ : i 4' i �. '1 , ����� �N�� - . s,.:.-', ;t'�., r f� 'd',�`� a v� � ��� :'�c.'w � �� .1 • �,.,.� ';•�r?' -�, ` �. „� ,� �, . ..1�' iti _ -: �r� j _" S�'' �p., " •i R `'� +a� G f .� ; � �� _ �,�,y. � � � . , . `� s ''' r ,..� � � '' �� . � ������- 4 �� 4�� 's 4�5 fis' � . `���� , � �� �i���� �... -a ,.. ��r, �C _ {�� '� y s s �� i,r� - .-. .�. •+��.�F� ' l �'�tt��, �� 'F` 6� �y,� Y ��.^ .��' ���`:. '1 � �y �. ` ���i�' _��x. ,�.W ..t , S�.. '� . .Y�. `' ~�ti a '� � � �4 17��� '3 � �d�..--����� ,(�� �. ��'_�� �. �����'_��?^FY�T-- ��' ?'3. ' .t. +�� . ;�1+ 4��p ri � � � - —+. _ �`'�, i:-'� �" . I�� �. I / � � ��'�, /�' 3 . •� ���'�,��.��,�,�� � �i ��,�"`Z � E �l V'���= t fi '�" -' �i f;'�'� ,,'�t'�r�:��'��s� y � ��F� �l • �` _ ��!-'�,, � �ry w� �.; +f����� �. �T2' `��y 4�� �.4"a r�a - .,�7. � � - � "�',, +H *r ., . I.,fkai�fS� h:,' . , rTZ . •�F+r �1 �*t�f ` '.L ';ah . �'C.:r��!'''� {'ydw�#�� f � a �.' '� '� y. ,u: ;� . . . * +.tY�'��, fi'�� h_r �_ .��� �� u �_� �� �'. � � ��tt� x � F_�� �� Y�� j ��'. AJ� ��� K�' .�,'=._ 1� .� : 't ��q�`_'�" i� , � � }'�! ��� 2 r ��r � �i � � '�' , : �� �.4 4 ' � ��:�. x �� .�f�'` , � . y, - �.��y,jy fi�y; 1� p�, _ � '�k.� � --��' �� r �, it4 ���`'�� ".y �T �r : ".r4 ' ��3 r _ 1 .�" �� �� i�,�k `i���� � '� � ~�� � ��.�. . _ j ,� �+ i,.� ^� 4� �`. �, 1151�' � �. � � "� y ��� ,,�� 'p r �,�G� ,��"`,4 J fi � �.Y �, ' r��,�'�A t���.�#� ' _ � _ - � �. -+,' c.. _l� L' �f � ' '�` . - ,F(�•� . '� �`'s—��} �, �'. -� �. �S. I t,'.Ju � � ` , . .{.'- �' ; e . �i ' � � * Y'� -� �', �_.,'_ 5.='v,t s' ��� . s �� f ,' 'F�� & � 'f ` J � ,�yy�� _ ���'. § � I . 'Z^ I� '✓ "�r� -= s - 'J'T�". �. � ����R .. � e ...... r �� -S� .f+' - � 4 � \'�6� - - � � �{^�, �! +�,y�� °'; r•��`�..�iy'r*a4 �4�!y�p �,: �'.f�R ��' �4 •,} ��, . Y1} ` � .� y �Yro. h. f, y� 1� � +. ��, � _t^ � . .. � �,�� , ,P� � ,s 1y. .n���`�,��s f,t ;*� ¢ ,�� � ! � ��� � " i � ��,�k�`'��; � � 4 �� "� � ' �� i � r_ � � ,}� �: �' � a �,' � .'K', � ,.. _ -, :-r1�� ,�� �i - �' ��. L _ _ �'�., ' �q �y��q,;,��+� k_��,�_ '-f.1, -� _�- - _'` ,�s. .� .;�� `�f ' ` t �1,��, �.� �4 ." - . ';.�, . �;� .'� .s- ;f'�.� - i�F ,._.. '., � tL'� �s�, �x[�-� �{�� � �r .q .rl-►,� �,�� .� � '-� �► :.:• ,� �s- ,,. � � -., �t.�a�+?�'�`{a� a�_:._1� _ ���q . �. �r`�` �'. e �`�.��� �y-�.`:�.t"R'�.��r �+r�'x. '' . �'^ ���Y"'Y .1C - Y �-'�+. t *� `�' 1�,��.�G a-�-'!Y `'TO'.��� �,r'� '#,. '� �'� ``��f�" J�. '����" �`�. �_ �„�..,y.. . : p a''z� 'F� !,- tt' '�+� , � ��•�R � . - 1! {{: . � ..�t l c"L 1' `,� -.� 'p.�7'�t �i" .K•. .,a t �� - :i, fi� .'�s,Y{�� _,�i. � ,. �� ,_ � > � � . � - '� �'� �*' - � _:�• ` , a � .—�,.- `-�� ;" t - �i;`�.�- �� .� ��:� �"�''��'a±� �'�kq(� �` i �,��:"� �":�:, r y� • � � I � �`+� �-��� i1T'¢r°��,{ " ;���"��t'`,y,�f�`'� . ^����rc�'''��"�`� }���•.W .`� `.:++y�-y,, a ��; t� � :����; ti_Lb+, �,�^�, �� � ��. €a,� y w, ��. -u -�.: � ` � � r � -...- �.�r. �- . �... � ��i-+__ -�ks'�,�:` A,K �',..'�. ''��'y .�a,. Y+��,, � ��. S�?��y 'i"� a` .y"�`'� '� 3ty �'�„�„�y�.y R� 1..�' � '�� �,'� WL"��[` R i�'+.�K �'�'k1 ���'��.� , ,'�-.+!#?'��, ��[✓ ��° �u� ��s �+'`' S � w � � , ��:. � "{••�.4—'.`7. •r-•'' _(�� ��t, � �y' _ � � ♦-. ��tt -�s ' y� ,�r {���� � � e' _��' . r y 1- r �^r ✓'l ' t y A L 't4 .��y'� - .,,� - '-i�r 4+5`"tY''r� )� "> �' .� - ..;',:' _4'RF� . k�7n' . .�'��_,C� �i. . ' -� . � r � . , �,Y �..y\�,�� � . . _ X.>.�,�... . a+�een b � �`' .�_��. . :`� . �'�'� "� . *�.r- ,..� " —��:.�„4, -� � '`�' a!,� ' ... - �` ��'k�: _ _ _ :�.T �' S �, �'.. . � !� '�� �'. �^��� f s+� 3F •• �.- .. -� . :caf. -_ �_�' ' ��' ��..y vi� ..� '-_ 4 ' '� - , . . � ''��•- .�k�'._' y,4w'��,� �.t+ _ M1•� ,, ' .'�� ,y . ' ��.�2 � �.�i ,�_��. 1�� �E},: ��� . _ .��`'�� - .,5• � 't.� ,. '�� l'. - �'n` . �� , � 1 �`"t-' �-� .L; t r 4 f��: • � P` �f . r w�... ,s'�K . .a '�- `'� trl- ���� � Y"M:!� :�.� .__ _,��cr.�'... E.t.:' .- . .�.L.d�� .7._,'3. ,�... ._ , . .. , t ..�� • � ``� i � ,' L �`- FT'�!, .�j,�. �A �,�=1 T T. / � , `�� '� '` , ��� Y� � -� �'r f ��` *i +;.y���'',y,� wti��r '� �� ~ �_- \.-� •�r 4 � ��� - � aLStiS`ti .�I(� � �[�+4 � �� �5• .��M �' Y s , �' , - � �- t .�,• ` �� i i . j { i ;� � 4� � �i ff,, 3 y',j�i}i ��.�.. � � �fg S�. �..� �-l"� . , � i. , �� �s'�'� �� rw� ¢��.' '� - �y •� �l���5� � `� �� k ' � -� ��' ��•�'ia�� ,�,�( �J , t� . , YI. �- :.j��;y-� Y�.� �. �" j , . ." .r. - �' i�i r�, " ' � - ��� - -� �- ,'� �C•��.� ^�, Y �■• �'f�y.'s �. ..'. ;� ��1��'.�� ,�'�_.��. ` t� � ' ! ,-r "� 1 � - �'�ti ''•. � . a • � 3�'t Y . � ��• +�r �� ...�rr, ., t` -,_ �r, ' ` `�.�,. �.,;� ��y ;.a��.�,�'�.� �� if � �� �i�T ,����, �' �. � ,f + .�n�__ � �}� ���� ����,.� ��� �. , ..,� � i � �.�� .. � • , �� .�� 4 � �� y 1_� i� �i��, �� N . . ti� . ,�.�. .���' f}� ,�-� :�S ' ;� {� ',� � . i� rs,.: '•1� f,�;"�: ,� � •� � ���r �.'. - +1 4 " *'�.+�°,_ -� 's. �." • � t �����'� . �N �^ t �� ' a`� � `q �: �h - S�� . .�• . 7 r . .rtr' • _ {'X� ,y� • .. 1 l � � •� }Sr " �i ' y L . '�t,. ;� • ` ` ` . .. '�� � j;h . q 1�� � _ _ �1' � �:1 �,,�� '-.,„}�; � :� � _ ' �j ,'�' . _ +r� � �x. �:.� 1� * .� i � � k � r - ,,.- ' �,� �, ' �r ' �;�� L . �' l .'�� yT ��[ {}�, '4 . - - � . y • i 1 .i • • �, l[" A � ;`E �� ' j 'S. , '* ,.F '�- +e.1 t i� � • . f. ., . � /�' �'r/� �J' ._ '�� �g r.� Y'. � f��!! ��, � .y' 3� ����� ' � �►h'�i{ t , �:s �I�F. '4r � ��,� `~ . �� � +'e� � e•t � 'e t x� , � . . S {�` •` �T ti- Y {4i �� � R: � 1:4 -f� '1�`' ) � - g; !F ti+ � -�'�`'_� � ,�#t � � � 1 �. ,r. +f� � ,���� � �' �t`, � .�. il� � .,,� •,' r� � �� �� � - i.� ..'��.. .� �^ci . r -� .,_, � �' �. � � � � i y ' Y .t�_ ��-.,� ;•�` _ �. ,,.?�,,. �. �� =tt . ` ,�. �.� �y� ,, ^+�.- a.:� ��. , � -,w� a�► �w�T� !�� ��',�.�, ';� � , -a . 'r �� ', .I� � `y `- �.� �� ' + 't Ty. ► � " ��1 , ; ����l►_ # ,�. �r t yt� . � . �.� .�� :� 1ft Y/ �'�'1' .�• F•���ti� ��� � ' - �.' i� F t 1 • `�. � � � �.� „0 {.r �� �.�� � ' ` ,�i� ��r ^ � �_• '': ..�+.,� A . .- � yr�r;5 a� ,, ��. . � ' i� �� � A , � • +� , *� ` �� ' 1 +�' /! .� K � � . yt � •t - .+ �l.r 4 1 �. ._ 4 . 4 � +. ,�_ :��' � i. !Z f � � ra �. ���'•� ' �. •: � � �� � + • ' �' �t:�' _eF .s� . � Y `�, � .y,.�• ,.. .i�,- •y L'+� � .� � " .�v1e ��I� 1 � .f •- ;� �� � ��.. a '+� .4, dr• _� ''�.� � .. . �, "+ 4 '�i'f., , �.�✓ • �E ; W K:- � a����+, ' '4:., f�~�•J �• � :�d � _ '. d� ', ' ;�� � .4 i - � `�u` -� ' ' r • •��� � ;Rf'r� '�- ^� � pp �,, ' ,+.�� * `• r'I' . + ,�� � M . . ��.' ` .�-�.._ �,�_,.�. .�`', -.� , .� _� ,� -�f� � . �.� �.. `�? �� _ .{ �� ' y'�" _ , `� - ,.� - � _ , �% ��_ -` Y .. ' . ,:r�' -t�_ , .,'• - ' ' w- �. ' � �� ;�:•'.�,. '�,� �'.` r.. . y;,• , �. :�: k!^, �r,� «� � •� -f � T� �e , ..`t,'� x'' 11� Ir . • � � �k �. ..�- -1 I ��(.�. `-,E� � �+3 ` � �4 • . •� ,.r—�.' %�f� ��'; � ✓� ': � r ,r�., „� �.�%� ��� � , � � � , �� � � !�• �'; ���TF' . •.yf� 1� �• �� �� •�L` � ••'�-y�•:' . �• � :'�+ . . +�. a •^ �yt r•�4�+Y•f ' _ '-� }'- �� '•t � �' �`{'` �. 4� } I�t�;k�'��� 't i�-,'�i„; �_s s rt2s�_� - _��"�-��- ;� S � ',I � i i_ y�w r �t• ' ��-T � r �,.:�. �; ���!� ,,t,�� �,, ,�� � .�. �� ��� � , �k "�'"�I ` ti _ � . ,y �. . 1 � � �'��"_,1'�i ��1wI '"S.�SI• , �i ,��,i n,� f ' t `�'7 r���w'��' -�� ' `{ ,�� ' � `� f �_ � •,•f ), I� { � . . . . . - , . �i� �' ' I � � �!. � _ . , . . ... ,.i-�. _ 1 } [ � � . � 1 4� � .`1 �'� ' . . . Il i. ;,P. 1�� ����.�� �� .#�� k, V X � . , . .' ' T� `��i���� .��¢ '� . �� �. ��'. .,.�. '�s. --� ���� }��'� t ������ �r '� i,,4 � , _ ..y �� I � •I�'�} „� � ` ' .�:���,fll:� 1� 1� '� i �' ` 1i � � yjt � �11'1 �4t11����;.1i 'rl� •.w .� k,�t ��,,j� 4�� , �- �y ,�j'�� ,` 1 .;;� 1 - ,���!�y 1,���I'��l 4�: � � . ,�I� � �- � , � ,,�,� �: ��, � ,.,�, t � _ �qqi� s14�� t�� �� .�t �ly��. f �4.i ,��t` 1 } ` � � y I'� !F� i � � � ...`� 1 ;I` ��- �� I` � `; i � l l' �. 1�4� ���''� �3't-y�''.. ,.��.II � .`� �' . � ' � �� .'��- � .� � s� 1 ��� ,� - .�-�ir � � � � I� � ,� r}. �'�'� t'';}, '� } ��i s , . , 1 � 41 �� � �,�, l '. � � ` I ; �° l _ ��", '.. `'��', 1 : , � � , � - k '��', �4 '� �. �,� ' �i 11 � � � � ,I r ,� '�i , . t ,r ; , 1' � . ! i �+ i � � ` 4 1 �, 4 i � �. - ,', . . _- ` . ., ..k . _ �. s, i f .' � ° `�.� 5 I' �' `�� -: � �� ���1� _�� , . � � % 1 �%;"�� `,.1,. � � � !•', .. �r',:. �'` • � f ! • L7:'s� � �� } �� ' t S �,�', t ,{.�� � � S ��'�� ' � ,�� ^�' k � �� i r. �t �'.��•��; �` �:� � . � . ��ta - � � � � + . .fo �9 �` � ^f.��ye • 1 � � , � '' , _ .���`T; r' �r«� ,,,, E , '��:,.,��,-�� �1�� ..� .�- ? �l h � �` '�''���•- � ..� ' ; , s ' �� �� �' ;� ��.y� -.I�!l�r F a t _'+-.� "'��r � ' .�,y�.ry�� .�`�j*'µ . M � i t��.!'���. �;Y��- i • .� }, � _.�� ;��A•t�- , .� ���.�� : �� - � .. � . : . - . - . *_ I : . . ' . -��- � f.k: + ' ,"�. #'�-. .�' ,,`. _ � � ��'' ����, �FV — � `,+�s .. _� . I , ,�i _ Y ; '. • •f ;s i �����t` '.� ���^ � �'.,'�+• � -* •� �.-- _ r.:;� ; � �t. �,�' � - , : ���#,� , :�� a- - ' � '� `� . ' - , =_a. , , �i ,.�` �;�q.w1�:�i� ,:, '� � � - ',��'�'�'1�'�: i �} ; :;, � . i � , �_ � � ` r _ � - ~- ,� �*� _�. . � � ;� � ' �- _ � �i. ,;_ ' � � K �' # '.�°+:i r - � a3-� ``� = �iy P,��� a.- ,�i� ":1 r ' : yrs_: ,a' � `�' .,� .a +�;..� p r Y i� �j 1 . 4 �e �_ ! � y�"•,� a . �� � �r y L. � �� } � '� � -.���y;. :� :� �� . ` �.. r' �",� �+�;� ��� _�7: �� �f �� \� �ri ey � � S' 1■ .� t � • ' ' �� n,,:L,�r z,�C �L1 L—���QtIE � A�le,l,�rr�i iri„ifl.•i41e. : ...,i / . • � ' i_ I: p � � � � �� i r � � � � s �. � � . � - � s w' ' S� � >G;'� �', �1'� =}x,�'. � . , � � y � . # � r �s. rr 4 ..1� J .� - �k � � . 9, 1 ♦� Y• � .I � ... # �T . � ��" -(! � . �* � � � � � � ~ � �� . - f_ ���;{��T 'r� � a-. -� �-.� {�_._�- .�e�R � � .e •4 �-:i:•.� �. Y- , 'ti �� -,t ��� ���. . � ,�'� � ` �- .�. , �� �'M�� _ �o. � ' _���;�,�# 1 �� � i i-' • � j � Y { �: - '� � - �' _ � �� �� _' � ;� r f a�� _'�,:f_.. ���� r � ' � _ ' r���,,'...:-, ` .. ' �`� � � 'r; �,.'.y,�"" w.. . �� - ��;pl+IIYL '��- ,� �""- . � �-. ' � �� �< � � - +��(f � � � . � ��� � :.r►F' ;�,"t f'`a: � _ ,,_�_x= -. - _ � ��Layers o� Basemap gallery 8 Details �' Share � Print .-�-�-�"�w��� �� �- _ ... � _ , � _ , �'�~Q ��-:t� ' � • .a � / � ` - jl `i . ,R � . - .�. i � �.,` . - ,. :-� e .. a-� 5' .'�" . .,.k'� $ ' � •��• . �w . }� . � . . �4.:•L • ' ' ` � �/ r ' .� r �Jk���� . �i' � ,� 3�.--Y . ��:, �. � y � y��l.�'J�i w !'.` . + �i'+ �,� 1 5 . t � �Z+',,��3i. �`�- �'S - r � *•'�' . a., b- ';k s �.,a.' � ��' !y : . ' , �� � y" �. �'�,. :r.- a,, a � �� . � . _ �« � , ,� � , �y�,s,l� � , � � ��.� . i !� .r � V _� # .- �, �� � � � � ���,. `�-x +-�� , - , i *� � ;�" . � -r�( . ^F' . - • � \ _ ♦ . i� . '� �.�. - !. ` `,. � , ��.a. _ - a I � w � � � �� •. #� ' . `�, ��� � � ,� �,�r�• " _ w� � � . ' . • � �i� � -� � �� �►��. _ '�� ~ `�' ^ - . i � � � ,���rf"� '' ' '' �F � `�k .. . • 4 � J � ya � � .� .p � .*' ,�Y, — - � -� - - - - � � (1 of 2) ► " . � r : ! r ' 1 � � i11 � � • w � �3.. �., Z r � . �,�� ,t.. '^i � y� jr� � a � �. �< '�F�' :►9{,' � �� v��''y� �, ` �' � 7 ` � �� ?� j'�f 3��'���r�' a� . �' .�� f-, � \;�. .:.�' �.:�� < .��r.� ,I. ,,��•. `,. �'. �r��' � Jl��► ` j, �'�y/. � � "� � `�y,,, _ ' .Y`sx' � • . ,�. � '�� � ��� , . ��Ci- Y��,�' � �' . 'yyc.c. ��„ "'=.� '��'"" �.t� t�}��. . ', , '� ~��������[ ^� � �, � � . ..��,•. .. a• �,� . . •r �,� t�,a+";. i ��" 1. . � �� �* ' v w , .k, y `,.�.. ,� �''`►' t" �°�;"_ , � "'�';�#' d. �, �`"�r'�. i•=,. .�4� . 'r L;1'�1 .1 :�1 .�.� '� �,� `\�� II : ,. � ;' � �` •a.F�;' .. M'- a S# � •..-'• ' `'�. � � � s. w � '��:- � � ; • �� � ' . 'n�, -� -� - �'�"� •�1 , �p�. i> .;:� ,y�:J^ +� t i'•h �t'�A l `' � a. , `.�'� i zL."► r, �t 1� � • .f'r ��„�� a�t4��'w� �r. �'�.� �' � �.- r �` _ s.. i�:�,�� .' '. `�Y' �`� '� r � � .,r� �F� .� ��n�,' � s �'� , w� ,YY ��' ' �`y +��� �, •� �����+ ��� ���^,sl�y �,�' -� _ �.��•_ *'' _ ,� i� • -_��.�•.::r�_�`. . . . �� ,_ a.,� � • ,�r�"� i �s.� ' x s 4�;`, : �' �.� '�� -s `�: . �y ����'� �- � '� �'��� � 1i _t�p � .,,�!.F� ���''� �_ ,�'1��.. '_�, �'; : -� �. . .'' �1 r ' . �7 :_n ;; fS' •.`°9F Rr, S;. a.:���� �• 1F�'i e:�: ~y4 ��;�•h, :�•. y� +p r�,�. � � ���� � ' - N /� '1.3 �iF .3' � c, .� . , V '�� , !�-.a�� {pW-, �'�' t y � �' � +!': .i'��►��,�� r' �-� �^� s� °#�� 14i� y: ,- •'v. ''+7S` '�y.� 1 �' _ -4 :Y� :� �`s •r � .�` �, �y�. -� 1 :� )i , .�j.�. ` ':3'e•:� a J - +� - .���•�4 � y�, � ?� �:���� � �V .yi � ./+i *�.� .� ^A 'C} �r,�.,f ,�•� ,.� � -r �`,'� �r�-- " + � k � -� s+e' '.t�'�. .� � . — '•� : .,� . Y'''1 �'`A:_. - S„_ ,e fr,.... �. py.� . ' i�,� � ��.• ' .. � ..... _ _ � .� ;� .•r _ i' ,I� �, r s_ ... 'Y' - �- 1 • L� �i .. ��� ��,e r; •� - �w ..� ` . _ . ' ' ,� �`'' � . � - � .��� � '� � . _ �'�':��. � , � _ . �, . '; � '�, .'��� '�: ,, _ _: v .,�. R t �� « - Fk.� �i• -- "' d, '= � ��".� "{ ti- �..;y► .-q���� r - -a� f' � J yy .i:i� j� -;t� � �i' 4'-� : . � � � ��i.�,: ry'I���L7' � �i -,I.lf� � ' � 'w''S;yS �w)'. i� �� . '�.• ., ! �� e q 'Sr� f � ��� I� •�r - ` '. _ T � w� � a y• _ ,_,},' • .a.- ' ' � `A'�� `�f.: - � �• i ��'�• ,� . . r.��.'- d ,� . - �f #Ir . � '.�'. � � . . .. - .�� �> � . -- • � . � - ' ~ � '� � ��4 � r *�` � . . r'` ♦ �_p� r , , _ .a 'v. . . • . �� :�� '; . ' �! -�' - t � ,? .. �����`�"'; -t . ' , ,f�+� � � � .� TF ..� �f ��' .; ' _'" .. � ... . . . .�� . ' . � . ' . . - �� � .��- .� , "�,�I�: �-. ' � , . . - . . ,.. . . , . . ,. . . - .«; " ,'-. � � - - .r��; � .1' .�x,� �'�sr�. `�r s'�4 �* - � _ .� �4E.fJ��. � •\ -- .' „' }� _ � .4 k " .�,� ,�yy. M�, tr��w ".' .. .� � ' . . 4 j , %• `n , *�` # ° r._ . _- . �p � !/ '� � � ,• . K y� � .�1'�„Y �F,��i M' . _ H ' uY1.3 , Nr , - "#At^d?dY �.. �-. A.�* ��= ,� , . � 3► r" !�; n'� .r _. �' s � ���a �%� �� :� --X. � .T� � � • .6�' 1 . � � �� '@ - _ 4. 1 F S i"4'.y�}��i'. .r�� �i�a�, �4-��� � :f� .'� 5 � �y . ' � �' - �, *�s.. �, ^�� .� . 4. � ; 'l �a _ ��- .S^sL, } V.�.�,�Y'r 3e'j, �.E - '•. _�.l �.�.11'.' _C w -,.�-�'S�w. "x-I._ _ .�Y, r,x,ys. - i -_ - "i:. � •� - ; ._.�'�., _.'j lzs�-": F !% F�—_ � ���=�������1��(�,,�- i i l�LI�TLIS� 17� Z�2� f `J � � �Nilcici & Clay KeCc17ti��11 177b C�is�cr Street Dubuque, IA 52001 -� RE: �iainglc roof t-epairs Dear Nilcici 8. Cl�.y; As per your s'equest� lor a roof inspectioa� due to t�ie daitlage caused by a tit'ee falliiZg on your 1ioi�e ocl 8/1 1/23. We ha�e the s€�ingle rooCal�c� gi�Cters l��ve sustained damaged. Str�lictu��ally the t�oof`��nc� [r��nlir�g we��e �-�c�C c{a�liaged, Please sec the attached ��icttires. We ��ropose to fiu•�Zisl� a«c� inst�ll new inatecials �s follaws: 1. Renloval �nd c�isposal c�I'3U lii�eaf� 1'eet of c�am�ged g�Fltei•. 2. D'asconnect tl�e oz�igiz�al dow�ls�out. 3. Re�nove a 4 sc�h scctioti af damaged i�oo1'sl�ingles. �, Ii1st�11 ne��icehv�tet• sl�ielc[ �r� are�t. 5. Install c�ew architeciural shillgles tli�t n�atch as close as possib�e to �l�e original. b. Iz�st�t.11 3U linear feet of tiew alu�l-�i«t»�1 5" I� s�yle v��hite g�t�:ez� a��d tie ii�to ori�ii��l gu�ter. 7. RecotulecE e�cisling dow�ls��out. 8. l'klis ��epazr woLild talce a two (2} pers�t� c��e�� less tlian �� ciay a con���lete. Total cost O��e Thousa�id �igt�t Hi��aclz�ecl Ni�ieiy Dolla�•s, !�1,$94.40, pl�.�s a��plicabie sa1c5 tax. I�OT�S: �. T�Ze ahove ��ro�osal cloes t�ot iYrclarde i�lterinr repaies. 2. "1']Zc al�ove proposal i� only v�lici {'oi' tl�irty (3p} d�ys. 3. A 3% sLircliarge will be ADDI?D to the billec( �innunt i�paid �vitll �i c.cedit card. 'I'hanlc yo� ['or thc ap�ortunity i�c� bid on t��is ��roject. Tf yoL� 11ave �ny questinils, please iee;l fi•ee ta cal1. Sincei•elY; �����. � ` 'ilRJ'/���-�. � D�nny Spr�►iIc � Cel�; (563) 590-1228 Pr«jcct Mai�a�er/Estiin��or Ei�lail: c��i_at�lc cr �ieseco.cail� Gi�se F�oofing Company 2II20 Elm St�•eet, pubuque, IA�520�1 {5B3) 5a�3-2dGU Phone•(5G3) 5a8-206II Fax , . i , Y.� � � � � IMG953419.jpg .1- � � ' 38K - -- � �� �� t _�� '� j � f � � � r� � � �� Y __ �� `� IfVIG953420.jpg , � 42#� �� �� : �.- .: ., �'' , .�� �,� � � IMG953421.jpg s�� 46 K _.y �. sy�''. .��. � �� y�. ��� . . � I!, ��' . � �``': � �. � : ._ ^ � ' 1MG953422. .'t�?:` J P5 � ' � �• :x� ,_,�i 41 K i � � � ,a.�� `` � r � _ .�� � `'� , .' � .-.i t � �� ��"''��►1�1 �° �°�"� ' IMG953423.jpg �� f 45K A ,.j �, ,� , , �.��"' � • �� �'�""�'.�.�'',.�� �,�,. - � , . F- � ° �° IMG953424.jpg �, � �`,� ` � 44K � f�i ��. . y ` ►�I` A � f � � ` � � .. �4r� ��.+� 1 F � i. J �� .�,._ ;� . J!� / �'�.- � ' . j � t 1 �• \ jS �' IMG953425.jpg ,� 41 K ,�` . .� � � ` ' ��1 1 '_, . . . e�, `� � � �ti'- -- - . . ---- �.._..� .---�---•.....���� '-- - .� �-.�,-.. � ..:-..-:�..�_.�="'-�:.�. —_..--_._.-.. IMG95342fi.jpg 27K r � � " : a .� — -�e� ��A��_�T .'T�� � IMG953427.j�g ;.'r 45K � �- v�. '*'�'�� ?: ''.�'�—'—�-"�.� ;�! IMG95342$.jpg 51K ' �.. . ��. :.---. � e ., � �� Y� � _�:�- . ��.�--�_. � _..�=, _ ---- - -�-__.,_ --�- — . �.,.� -. - -- -_�__. _ .� -_. _ IMG953429.jpg 44 K i � ----:� . ���' �=� �� ,. IMG953430.j pg �,�.. �� 53K �, � Giese Roofing Company -Ketchum - 1776 Cus�er St, DBQ, fA -8.17.23.pdf 337K - ---- - -- -- -- , i� � 1 � �� ----- - ---� -- ------ --------� � Ce11:563_$42-7505 7ree g�s•.815- ��d Lands�aprn�5�rvrce �47-3866 Ea518470 Krarner Rd. Cus a er: f Dubuque, ll 61�ZS � 1 � r ������ ���Q��� Descrip��n � ��'J� �rice � � � �r � � ���v� � �� ��� � ����� /� �r� �� �� � � � ��V �� 13 s�o � ... \. - f v ' r�Tq� J�� Si�natu�•e: � r�'w�C�is_ D���� � AlTY Q[1@5 ' �..�..__ '�� t,ons a��ut yQur t Tarr,Moatz ��°ic�Pte ���5)747-3866 ase Cal1 rh�rrk Yac� far yo�r gusin�ss f Joni 1Vledinger Du�7{X l(e rr-�F C[TY oF Lega] Admiiiistrative Assistant � Suitc 330, [-Ierbor View Place �-�- 7� � 30U Main 5h�eet AI!-Ame�€caClty U Dubu�ue, [owa SZDOI-b944 (5G3)583-41 l3 offoe �,� �l7t�sEer�7iet'e ot1 tJ�te Mississx���i (SG3)583-1040 fax jmedinge@cityofdubuque.org ��iu;•�Q7z•xa�3 i' r' � . � August 17, 2023 Amy Miner, Claims Manager Public Entify Ris�C Services 12951 University Ave Sufte 120 Cli�e, lowa 50325 RE: Clairri Against the City of D�buque by Clayton and Nicole Ketchum Dear Amy: Enclosed is a claim filed on August 15, 2023 against the City ofi Dubuque by Clayton anc� Nicole Ketchum, Claimant alleges Clairrjant's home was damaged when a tree on City property fell onto it. If you have any questions regardir�g this claim, please call Steve Fehsal, Park Di�ision Manager at (5�3} 589-42fi0. Very sincerely, C ���,� .� � Joni Medinger �egal Administrative Assistant Enclos�re cc: Stev� Fehsal, Park Division Manager Clayton and Nicole Ketchum Tim English, O'Connor & English Ir�surance Agency .�oni Medinger DA�3Ul u� -�xti,ct-��Y oF L.egal Admiiiistratit�e Assistant � 5uite 330, t-[arbor View Place ��� � 300 Main Sh•eet AN•Ametic3Clry Dubuque, lowa 52001-6944 (563)ss�-4 t l3 ofFce I r Mast�j-�iece at� Elie 1VIis�issr����i (563)5$3-1040 fax jmcdinge@cityofdubi�que.arg znn;•znsz•zai3 August 17, 2023 ' � �P Clayton and Nicof� Ketchum � �7� �:.l���r .Ctl"E.'�f Dubuque, [A 52001 RE: Claim Against fhe Ci#y of Dubuque Dear Mr. and Mrs. Ketchum: TI�� claim that you fi[ed against t�e City of Dubuque on A�gust 15, 2023, alleging that your hame was damaged when a tree on City property fell onto it, has been referred to Public Entity Risk Ser�ices of lowa, #he agent for the lowa Communi#ies Assurance Pool. If you should have any q�estians regarding this matter, you may cal1 them at (888) 520- 4074 (tol!-f�ee), or you may wri#e to them at: Claims Public Entity Risk Services of lawa 12951 University Ave Suit� 120 Cfi�e, lowa 50325 V�ry sincerely, �. �� d � Joni Medinger Legal Administrative Assistant Enclasure cc: Steve Fehsal, Park D�visian Manager Amy Miner, Claims Manager, Public Entity R�sk Sea-vices Tim English, O'Connor & English Insurar�ce Agency i � Tl-IE CITY OF DUB E MEMORANDUM Mnste�2•�iece otc tl-te Mrssissippi � ,10�11 M � DIHGER � �' LEGAL ADMINIS7RATIVE ASSiSTANT � To: Mayor Brad M. Cavanagh and Members of the City Council DarE: 811712C23 RE: Ckafm Against the City of D��uque by Claytar� and Nicvle Ketchum Cfaimant Date of Claim Da�e of incident Na�ure of Claim Glayton & Nicole 8/15/2023 8/11/2023 Property Damage Ketchum This is a claim in which claimant alleges Claimanf's home was damaged when a tree on City property fell anto it. This claim has bee� referred to Public Entity Risk Services of lowa, the agen# for#he lowa Cammunities Assurance Pool. cc: Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager Steve Fehsai, Park Divisiar� Manager Clayton and Nicole Ke#chum OFFICE OF�HE CITY ATTORNEY DUBUQUE, iOWA SuiTE 330, Ha�gaR ViEw PuacE, 30Q Maw STa�Er DuBUQUE, IA 52001-6944 T��EP�oN� (563) 589-4113 I FAx (563) 583-104p I EMAI�. jm�dinge@cityofdubuque.org 1 � 12951 EJniversity A�enue,Suite 170 f Clive,IA 50325 Underwriting/Local Administratlon:[Spfl}383-011G Claims:(888}57_p 4074 AugUSt 22, 2023 � , �. � • Clayton And Nicole Ketchum �. 1776 Custer 5treet ; � �ubuque, IA 52001 ' /� ' �r.� Re: Our Member: City af�ubuque � Claim No: 4AZ308NVJ[3Z-Q001 Claiman�: Clayton and Nicole I<etchum Date of Loss: Aug�st 11, 2023 We have completed our investigation of the claim that was submitted on August 21, 2023. We beiieve that we ha�e obtained all the facts concerning this claim and are able to advise you af our d�cision. As part of our analysis, we consider whether our Member is legally liable for your loss. If the fVlember is not fegally lia�le, then there is no legal obligation to pay your claim. Foilowing analysis of the rele�arrt facts, please be advised that our Member is r�ot at fault for yaur loss and therefore, we must deny this claim. Sh�uld +in�.t ha»a aririitional nPrtinont i�form�tinn regarding the facts nf thic rlaim; nlpasP ��nf��� me at the nurnber below. 5incerely, Tonia 5herman Senior Claims Adjuster 515-z51-1726 l�ni� �-}ic�piot:va.co;ra cc: City of Dubuque O'Connor& English �nsurance Agency 't T�' .,���: ������������I������������������������������������������ 8/22/2023 4A23fl8NVJBZ00D1 562a2348220$057 � L ,�,. •�,� '�. =� i# M! ,;� �" . .s. ••r ,�_ �l¢ ,��ti� , A�� i�,, l`� _ , . x- + ,, , �,ti. f�� , A�..t,, .�� r` ��}y � � � ' h'�s � l.. �• �'' � �4 .• �����.+ `� ..� i�� , 4 , r �. � ���� i '�" r '� � ,, k ��} ��f��V�� .,F���' �,f � ,�c - A+ r�' 'i :.y f ;� ,r� t- i 1�; , ��• _ ,�;� "a • 4' � �:,� � .�-F �',�y �`�� J•tY M�� ,1 � ;,�•� }L,� ;�M.Z hs� {e.�" ;•""�'��:.•'��:._ ' .,� �'fl. � . � ' � �! R ,� �: . , y��' e: tq., '�.�. � a F�.�a., s ,�i�� .+`J� ry ir.,-' �, 7 y � �� �_ �i4 �' �'+� ti :� . +�c�< _� L � :i�-�: '�4 �r ,�ya � „4�~• �� �f, ��•� -'Y� ' ♦ � .. � . � �-,f � ��� ,e �{• _`. �Fr.� ,_- '�r.�-� 1 4�� � � �. 'S`�i * � � . . �. • � � •1' Z a �*� '��� ,}. .� J�r�A� '�•�C�64 •�t�J .�. "t �yrx- � �� ��...t. . t� � � �� ;.. � � - y , •4 f . . p` ��yy � - � : � .. .' .• � +�v�41� r�i�' =t�� :� 1� �», � . • .*• , .�_� rT L ,bc. *,� `�� -" '• * �' *ry,. '• ��, r .'�;:e�' ta` ' � - "li`'��t: �4�'�s'�' a s•� :r +, �~� „ .._ v , �'�' �� t #'.�. � �,�� s,� � ,s� s�� '� «' ..- � .- ...• , ; ( . �,__r. , , -- � ,�� ►� . • , .i •�"�� ;;�� , 1',• �A � •�'- yi�' ..�•� ~, 4t .�. 'CS?-� �i,,.1� �`'�i �r ., ;� .'�.'�•n•. �,.r•�� i . ' ., c �Y R � .��I � .� Y i.�� , `,� 'X, Y`.��.�.� �� �,!!- .l��.f,i: �•� � � _�'' .. � y .��,Yf ���� r '� y�. ' •�� �; y � � �= r �. � - N , `.r��� :�'( •, ,� _ , 4�r '1� . �� ��� . :i.i � '"..yi�y ,3.. •`,i. '-`.�, � _°'. '��� .�;�., ... , � . •;-� *�I' . Y ti' ..s.... J'�`�.} y� %�'� '�_ #�,� ' K�, .t ' . _ �,.'�,� �.' Y{ �i�y�'. .�, � ��.: �j t �• {���,,,' „ '��� ��.�•'.'€•�I i . -_: - .. - _ `. ' �� �� . �•� • • , Y"'�.�� • � Y• �� y��f .� �� ' . ��� •: ��"i` ,�� .� i,. . ',�. �:�r` �h��` u A -.. , . ` 'j�.• l�V� x`�"�`:�';'� �t�,.� - t',� �y . ti• � .� '�-^ • ,� 1 �- F '•,�1,. ' . - . � 1. • �i _ - � ^ s S . ;��� 't 1 :� �r r ^°� )Yr. � � •�i, _ •Li4` .�e � _ f_�r ..� �„�, �'a ry y ' � sa Y�c� i��� } ' , u',�,f. w��,,,.) W , �r' .� + . ';_ .� '.�.. -` ��-' �` ��"ai'"� ; -� - y Vr r} . r-,c � � � - .:�w .x .:� .r'!�`,�-�•._ .f_s,r, .�¢ �. t'� : '9N • - ;r.� ""'�.r iV+.... �� w� �y'�v`�Y; •-�� ,� r �� �` � .�. .�A.r� a.. - V� �,Y _4-� �'r .-n ���•� r .� � .�t �.. � ' �A� 1"I'�� E_ ' I •� ' �� .a � `" '�. � .!. ; � �I �~S ;� 4 r *' �; .,I _�. � .r � 4 . s:• }�, � ' :�'. i �� .dr �• , , •' a �.a. - y� ' 7 +wr `� ;��� '� � cf �.���.�� � � ���' r �� �; �t r• � �_ `� - /�� M `� e �F j � ��'f # � ♦'11 r'MY '� '�t A� �� - C'' Y✓ • .� � M.. �i� .ri' '� .S.��: � ',• s r�- �.r. z ��� �� _.. , �� [}._ �� ` �, 1., � ''�� .+,�.� _ ,:. .'7.: �^- . k�� ���y °tl��� � k _ ,'�{�, �V` a` � �4 �., -M ��. t �{'-C -3.. -.�1�� � si�, , ••A����� .�.,. ��� rYi��cH ', *�t .hp '4. - ���' f,.# �; I �! • � , � <,� 4 •i�