Claim by Loras BogeBARRY A. LINDAHL, ESQ. ~I~' I~
CITY ATTORNEY
MEMO
To:
DATE:
RE:
Claimant
Mayor Roy D. Buol and
Members of the City Council
April 9, 2007
Claim against the City of Dubuque by Loras G. Boge
Date of Claim
Loras G. Boge
04/06/07
Date of Loss
03/18/07
C7 0
-.,1
~~ ~
~ ~ ~ f'I')
s ~- I~'1
~' p' ~
tV
Nature of Claim
Property Damage
This is a claim in which the claimant alleges that City of Dubuque police officers
damaged the door to his rental property after using forced entry to gain entrance into
1961 Rockdale Road, where an alleged domestic assault was in progress.
This claim has been referred to Public Entity Risk Services of Iowa, the agent for the Iowa
Communities Assurance Pool.
BAL:tIs
cc: Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager
Jeanne Schneider, City Clerk
Kim Wadding, Chief of Police
Loras G. Boge
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY DUBUQUE, IOWA
SUITE 330, HARBOR VIEW PLACE, 300 MAIN STREET DUBUQUE, IA 52001-6944
TELEPHONE (563) 583-4113 / FAx (563) 583-1040 / EMAIL balesq@cityofdubuque.org
PPR-02-2007 MON 11~~6 AM DBQ, CITY CLERK
FAX N0. 563 589 0890
CLAIM AGAINST 7'IiL CITY OF DUBUQUE, YOWA
This written report constitutes your claim against the City of Dubuque, Iowa. You
should complete this form in full and attach any additional information that
supports your claim.
The claim must be fled with the City Clerk at City Hall, 50 West 13~h St.,
Dubuque, IA 52001. It will then be referred to the appropriate department for
investigation and to the City Attorney's Office. Once that investigation is
completed, a report and recommendation will be submitted to the City Council.
You will be provided with a copy of that report and recommendation.
The final decision on all claims is made by the City Council. No employee of the
City of Dubuque has the authority to make any representation to you as to
whether your claim wild or will not be paid.
P, 01v ~/'
~~
~~~
~~~ ~~~
1. Name of Claimant: ~c o r A s G ~8d~c~
~! ~ ~ GLe ~', ~,~ e C~ u ~ ~ - ~eD s~7~1- 1~ .~ ao ~ s'
2. Address: % D 7i
3. Telephone Number ~.~ _ J`_~`/ 7f 3s
4. Date of Incident: 3"' ~~ ' D ~
5. Time of Incident: ~ ~•3'~
6. Location of Incident (Be specific):
l4~/ ~~ c k d~.e
~a ~s ~
7. Describe the accident or occurrence that caused injury or damage. (Give full
details upon which you base your claim. If a City employee was involved, give
tha Rmn{nvee"s name.l
9. Give name and address of any witnesses:
,rt~_
Od G~'~
10. Did police investigate? (1f so, give names of off ers.)
~R.~ Ua r ~~ n r eGD s~J~9-n/ ~0 ~ ~ a
8. What were weather conditions like?
D~
•APR-O2-2007 MON I1~~6 AM DBQ, CITY CLERK
FAX N0. 563 589 0890 P. 0~
17. Was anyone injured? (If so, give names, addresses, and extent of injuries}.
r~ ti'fs~o u~i~/
12. Was any damage done to property? (If so, describe property and the extent
of damages. Attach estimates of damages or describe basis for ascertaining
extenfi of damage,)
e/~'pufz-L
Y i yr D ~c~ /,~i~~ +®o E~r-
13. What other damages do you claim, if any?
N'o W`~.
14. Have you been compensated for any part or all of your claim by any
insurance company? {If so, give name and address of insurance company and
amount paid.)
it/D
~, 15. What amount da you claim from the City of Dubuque?
a~,~i
16. Why do you claim the City of Dubuque is responsible?
~ e y /~,~,~~ ,Ov.-v ,~ ~ ~av.-- -~ 6~`.,1 L-'~ry -~ /gyp L i ~
-~
17. Nave you made any claim against anyone else for damages as a result of
this incident? (!f yes, give name and address.)
~~
18. If the answer to Question 17 is yes, have you received any payment from that
source, and if so, in what amount?
~~
Dated his 7~h day of ___ 1~~/~~ , 2t7 0 ~' . ~,
C7 -~
(Signature) a~
~ C=~ ~
~'
~~~''~9s G, ~Og~ ,~
~ ~ _
~
!
(Print Name)
~ ~ -
x"71
~ N
Renaissance Construction Corp.
2909 Kaufman Avenue
Dubuque, Iowa 52001-1656
o ~i~ ~~~ ~ ~~~
pad s~. 1~ Sa o~~
12 Ala 1P fi ~' /P-e~o Lac e
3/~~a 7
i~ ~ ~~ .
3 0~ sv°~'~~ ~
i _ ~.-~, ~~,-t-,~~,~ ~ ,gym, ?'~c-, jar , ,C~~:,~s.~~
~ S- 6~ ,t7 i~ fI a s +~-~-
~ ~ ~~ r ~ ~~~~~
ff~ ~ 3S a ..s
~/fit ~ 36.0 °
~ f sue- T~
~~- ~-
fop. vv
~s. ~ ~
3 S, ~
l~• ° ~
%'~~{ J ~
~~~ a ~
~_
~~~' ~ J
~~, i ~
1~~9. ~~
Phone (563) 588-1689 a-mail: Rencorpl l@hotmail.com Fax: (563) 589-0022
04/06/2007 FRI 09:20 FAX 5635873849
DUBUQUE SOPD RECORDS
/
DPD. i -o,-elDUBUQUE POLICE DEPARTMENT QFFEIJSEREPORT Page 1 a ,
• J . -77 -a-1
Fi°
Ca1r1b
!
- kkit
o ,
lend P
tut_ I . 1 ST WX i N i Y
emaline*-7
7i .2R -2h 13a
fpe:u a
0•1.b
N°.
Car,R=
p AA*
fl le
Manse 0 M empt
I,-
rose Cad. (JCR Cody
Reposed
No
Cases
, CAdall
offense ❑ Pawl
es Code Omits
Pram n..e
03 di30-7
Frtm Fbw
Dt-1O0
Ye Owe
03 1(60:7
To Hour
0434
Evidence
ti33,3 Q(
Trios=
1XR.LYER 8cA
I gob- ALL
-�
_
b ENInStolen t �m
sbf°n v.hsde
Amount
(Amount Property
I Amount
"45" Of:
°Denies 1
Warts
1
menders
I
b 1
v.nk e� Vehicle:
vst.,6 tQj RaCovw.d „ �,
Prernaee
Btn.d
Yod
I Y' r�
`li ) D I Type
I �A.ss riomic4as
Y Typc CaouRrar..nr.w
Favid Entry?
Location
—� 'jam'
0
0!lo lJnMnwrl�CI
Drug ReIsa.d?
Yee 0 lkiotisrrn
,rr�
Q
'T
fatted C
Occupancy
rgiiry �
Type
'J
Arlivhy
1
weather
1
U9x
Ctddren
Soo
Crftne7 ! 1 Type of 1—
Target of
Yoe
0 lb
Sisiesebe py:
IN 1
_Peva Forms
El Gmeohna 0 Bribery
01
n u
n jAi
�1 �Nt
�
moo§ Mamma,
[I Inskox
1 COMPLAINANT -= VICTIM
CcaPtar""
Nome (t. CFFrsi Weds!),Did
Ui VrnE,
Rs
V L
(I1 L
wet
?
ADi3UN
Addr.w
•
Hones Phone
Worfi Phone'
1
Number
D Type
8
6
Fillgiwi
ODrr,d.r°
S�VLU
T�L Pi
Ci) LE- L
Pau N
1L
°„9,�
.�•
"Ma 1 K DP
213
?
6,DO
rw
a O JL
p
n T
_sir
Wing
Lm� ,
o
m
`.5` s zv W2?
95eCOfl
h57,y.0 ADefmort?
Mediea!���(��k�ee111.........aaa���111
Tr�anted
By, To. Trsm.d
By I
Cl Yes No
O
Yes Na
- I
1
0666arkif
duetws
7
6FX
Pvepsely Type
Na
Met.
I {
1
fsr.nrl
Modal
CObn
six.
9er rsl Number
a+.w i0
U vdu.
❑ Rsp.ir Cos
[image" der ^ Victim
PIC Numbs
—1= gN
Ls ` Loddn
1 I Type
Cod.
Cade
Nuabor
Ca
Cast OwnK !b?
a Y.. ❑ Ns
Addaor.l
De.trlptlen
ia+s Rea+ser.d booe Yrlae
`
t
Typs
°oar
su.
f
Saet.r Number
cN
l7 V�ue
Plepsir c
Lcc.b°r
(� Typ.
Owmepe j) 1 g• ue
4 1 V,[Lm
C`.fiiR I J Cede i f &znber
P1C Number
11G1C
gM
Cen Orxrer ID?
Addhio * Dwaiption
__ p �
ii.cvs.r.d V.1uo
r»essanve
<<�r1nn .b... . 1T" �' STD i
ij ec.r1=) B.dvels)
- %b�ONf'.- .1 ` 5
Cyls�h��panl FiMd
W I 0
Sun rvisor
!L
B.opa
,
04/06/2007 FRI 09:20 FAX 5635873849
DUBUQUE SOPD RECORDS
002
pep pot-0t•B1
DUBUQUE POLICE DEPARTMENT
0- L 01
OFFENSE
REPO
Page a of
t l Ntrdel (� rGi 1R Zr
prc enr% NWne (Laskt,Farst Middle)
BUH
Yet: rrbi ST-- I } t'-f /U A 2 n c vz
nneirm.?w�,wL4tC, b4
1a Ca j ck DAUL. , -.f� cx.;
Hair Eyes Hair Type! Fidel Hair Speech Gerdes
r
A Complexion Tapxrs Demeanorrkljrued7 Wooer at � r Comments - Additional AascnObon
0 '7 Merles �: Yell�l�. Sr)'U3�
nCValtang rn
'� °° �l Type l 5 `9 °d° ==i V.chr„
0 No Numbers
Handedness
v
m
53
FX
Solloect
Humber
Doe al Biff(AQe f4amgo)
Row
Brink
Origin
.•n
Reisiorohip Present? Name (IL Fret Middle)
P Vdim O yes O
Boole Smartly Number
Addles
i••
Cannes
Ihdlealor
flab
fi b l l .. 7l Demeanor. O� hW� worth.eact WO,aI lier der - c«,,,..m,� - Additions! Desorption
L— k, f Yea CI
Weapon Tea or
Type f Entry Medr,d u Typed I I Type E Tye peu� Kb
op - • . • Veer M.Ire
(C Na Velidc ld.>DFicaBon Number
5 Location
Type
Healy
--r-7 Hwy i ram.+
I I I Numbers
AddtionetDescription
ype
BICYCLE
Wheel Sae
WIC
Damage1Same vim
CCsle f Code ! J Numibr
P)C Hamper
El Value
Rex* Cost
0 0
Frame Color
Na. Loarbon
Type
Fenders (Cola or None)
Boys Make
o Gitts
Brakes ❑ Fear
d band 0 avCi
PI* Rercoreavd
Mtrenm7
ADBUN
Nondaleuiy
hooey No.
GIN
Lacaion
Type
Had. Bias Color/Style
❑ Generator
o Fleaactor
Value
CI Raper
Callers Race/Sea/Age Speech Detect or Adoens
Serial Number
Lecalio" of Bomb
Bare
Liousre Humber
Lit Vey
E ClahraOshr
NumberCode Code
Vor. Recognized? Bedsemind Nase?
y:ma Mares, Parts Taken
reamemerseseimmminmummiliminmommigummiimimmmilinr
o Claw Yrarkaud%
D Trauma be Yraeaaed?
0 Properly! Ve * e Resort Fired
0 Cmmnued ore SF 0 O ' Ccee Currant Status
Clearance FY.d by:
U4/ Uti/GUU7 r'!Zl Utz: GU FAA 5U35873S49
CtPO 01417 -08
Cateleo.
DUBUQUE SOPD RECORDS
4003
07-- J0-27 2
Pwve.lG/hF 3 44 .; Chepter/Sectran
w�. .77v.1)-7,t/z '
Charge
DUBUQUE POLICE DEPARTMENT - ARREST REPORT - ag
t
Dree a iTine or Ann%
A
m
r)
r
146 l
f/�
LoCsHon
No
. DJ ,4? ih(U /CZ
�6 0G /2
Loral Aggreart(tf DAterrA Then Permanent)
E3 t16
❑ *awed
Ethnic*
C 4✓Ji„'c th-
S`,ro
GEM
ass
WeePon
Type
' m A Vryuy P. ,
Eioe`t L�V1 Type Cicumstarms
Incrosreted Fre Memtrtrmcrney Noune l (Reietionterep)
• Nokias* To
Monde Warning Given By. rgrzw,47, , S�
tee' 051'7
Lots im or Arrest
J i6 / �� T/C /67
Relationship Preeeff? Armies's Nome (Lee. FIrg Middk)
10 Victim Az Yes 0 No
Pennenere Mime
ROC CJ Certenued
C Y
O State
Yes
Ow,u
n Operates
Diepasition
RepKlered Owner
Jail reemian
I fomnatlon j7Yeu
Nanette -
1i11 4 4,6 /3 nc 5
Color Top Calor Bettor,Year LS.im Carr�npn
proper-, CL.ulpd)7 P/C Menhir r ,reeeeer,,
❑Y�1j No
/11 7372o_ 141/4
i 711
J Cle.thing a Cbtflhg Cwauno
IiiiIMPOrwil By, TTo, Treated By
OPD Nuaher COCA)
H
L_.. 1 f
WIN
vbttnt ya�nurK,m�
vobws 8 U
E«S A®PST'
LKL3 0 ON
of139oking TITOofBoalting
Medioelion
T+r,• NaTs.d
eo CJ
Model
Dais
$y
Lloenee
/
5tatetYR
UN Personal "Mors, Famlty, Manama, end VehirlM on Reserve
ARRESTING OFFJCER(S)
fizz s ci)
8.4oOE(6) � pit �
o3 / 7
Ri ilt Thumb Print
,ri
04/06/2007 FRI 09:22 FAX 5635873849 DUBtigUE SOPD RECORDS I~1001
o~ .~,-$, DUBUQUE ~'aL1CE DEPARTMEN'Y' r c~
REP~C~RTE ~ ~,
~ ~ ~~~a ~~ ! ~ ~ i Gr ~t~- ~ - ,
monad b Flo. r ~~ I ~ ~ ~ 4 ~ ~ ca4- ~p t'~ad~
Twee R~porled nn Carta ~ /ldtdl ppsrae '
y ~ ~, ~ Q i ~. Code
Plan Dra From Fkrur 70 ~ To Fkxr - t
03 r O~ ~O~la~ d3 lao7 I ~~3 ~~ Q~
~ . 13.3 ~`
NUY9ER OF: ~ ~t~ Q V1een~ ` I I o~y'4,~r~ ®91 ~ R~iOO~i~ered I~ ~roQ ~ U T~~ ~ TYPO
~..7
u{~nGY Lul=1 YYPS ~ IrC~'i11' YYarahsr ~layfr~l RraMNd4 DM1g Rel~d7
F ~ ~ V ~ A4d~ad ®ooe
~ ~ ~
-
d I~b ^ Unlaown p Yts ^ L4tlsrown
k~~eti: ^ ~ppipg G Oompr~rThetl Abtfe7 CNdre~h pe~~~d BYE Forma Bre CrYne4 T d 7
o o ~ o ,~ o~ ~RefertsFs ~ . o~ -,,,~,~ o~. ~ ~ a ~ °~
aY~"" .~ ^ ~ ~ ~. ~ T ~ a ~ ~
~ a..~.
a
, ,
[~
~~~ }
~ ~ ~~ o..a
Ak*Mnos7
~~ Flwrra Pharw
Wp4 pMgN
~ a ~ ~ ~nsf~i~~dle,
a ~.
~
'
Z .
Yp~
1(,i~ L oe u ~
- T
-
~
a o ~..
~ ~ ~° oC.€c.,pP~t-~.
t ~~~~ ~ ~ _
we a ~ (¢.DO '~..OQ ~ ~,. ~ Tye ! nl ~~ t'{~t7. ~~
~ ~fVfN~,1~ S d~ '~q5 Cc~c7`-74
Iitlerrtlorr? ~Aedid Trrtr~oHed By, To. Twelsd By
O M.c I~b ^ ltw 1b ~~
{~T-~ OfwM
~
#k
+een
L' _1__l-J I I I _1 ~,a`~°r
6F7C PrOp*y 7ypf 1~ l,wn
m
I I I ~ Ilk+dtrl
CoIQ slzs 9errai Nunber OtMtar ~ ~ V~us
^ fair GvN
_
Ty~n ~ O ~^ Gods ~ Yj~rrrpa PIC Nvn6r fIQIC ~
~
~ ~r Parr. lD7 ,rr~orrl Deearplion
^ Yas fl lib Dro Reowarad VaMu
fi
Tye ~ ~ Type
Brvrd ~bdal
Cebr Slse 9w+et Nrunber P~ 10 A ~- -
^ Reprar Coat
mTa~ a~ a~ er P~ ~ ~Y
Cen bwnsr ID? .iddEOrrd be.cripOpn
o~ ~ ~
Osle Recovered mad Vale lI~ Lordion
1...+.,-1 Type
. U1 GT 1 Yvl I~-~- fib ~`r~ ~n~ ,F S~' t Cr j4 S~-a, .t t ~~" (~ `i' S?'~.
S 1,.~~ ~c..-7-. _.__ . -~.,...____~.~_ .~ ~.
al ~`(=I
f~DDfiE ~~ o..~ Filed
~ +~ ~ St4erveor BeeOe
~, .
p4/06/2007 FRI 09:23 F~,X 5635873849 DUBU4UE SOPD RECORDS
f~002
~ooeta,-a, DUBUQUE PQLiCE DEPARTMENT AEPO~ar~ Page Q1 of ~ - ,
w 0'7 l.07 ~ a, i --
~s ~P°aly!'~7~,.'1 ~ ~stWP We~^ wi,d l~y~ch.{sT Middk) ~ ~ ~j --~''~'
LJ ~-5`2,! Yes .... NDl ~~/C_-i ~ . 1/ 4~ ~••~ IV ~ fl ~{
'
~ l 1 ~
B U N
~ Oro d
~05 3c a 5 ~
~ ~
l/U
_ ~
~ 1_~~ C~ ~~.0c.1~ Dl~~~~.. -~ .~w~ ~ ; ~
alo~n ,-~„
_ ~ Frey
Hnk r Facial N.y Speech
G~;,,,
Hardedrry
1~.. ~~ ~ Tmoa f1 . Da~nseno~T Inju~d7 ~ ~ words d OOerder - Ga~n~ , p~jyq~ p~~m ~---
W~ertpon
~
Tml « ^
~
~
/ ~
L1LJ ~ L1.J Er~y WRnd
m
pe~ ~ Type ~ ~ T An~1ed7~ J
'
~j ~
~
j~ Ty
~
b
I
~
-~ J
~
A
er4
r.~7 ~I m Rrsorehb Pnrarn? ' ~ I~LF.at Mlidar)
folrrCbrn ^YesONo
~ ~r/~r
Yilusnrr7
ApBUN
O! of 9iAK~ gw.ge) 8odd Se~nrrr Number _ _
Address ~"~'
Aaz RruO Na4a ~s Brild H
i
~ e
r lyas HairT Frii0lHair$prfi ~p
- ~ ~k
CohrpFirrsion j
{ Trleus ~
1
i d Olfeeaer - cana.~ . p,~p~ p,~ry~e
Darneanwi
-_
~Iv1~ D Yee G No
~
~
~r ~^
~ ~
~~
. ~ TY
jle
T- - ! I ~~ ~ rB ~ I y~~,~,~8 AReelsd7
L.. I ~! YV~ ~J ' f~19 ^ Yi ~ ND _ + VicNn
~ 1~11tibe19 '~I` `~}J Mme
~-~J~J `~
_ ~ lib. Vaiio4~ IderrY6erlan NuMfer "~" ~ ~ ----~-- .- ~~`
~1
m T`m " ^ ~ ^ ~ ~ PlG Number ~ ~ Cost ~d
~~r p.wrioean ~ Ltite ~awno
Ra~vwra0 Yrua lAw
m TYPr
~,~~ N0' ~ r~ ^ ~ Nda Alodsl +lyds ~ Colag9lyle $~i Cbldry9yrle
~ ~ ~ Q G~
Wlrel S~ Frame ciWar Fandws (Cabr dr Nona) 6r~, O Fact ^ C~nsralor SrW Nrxnber Lorek -~~~r Lic Y~r
/7TC1 c~ r~„e a aoat n
IdGC SIN O Valor Ooh kYt~q ibis, Phrh T~ifrn
Q ~pvr ~ O ~ ~ 4bm ~ Nun~er
! Oriprd Call Time Phone+iR f C~trYan Tlsaat Hermwtl !Heron d Bomb WtynNlil Bomb 6gNeda9 YYIr IGrrt d bomb? Lack LiMs7
~ ~ Giler's HaeeJ9ax/Ap6 Sp~dr pelecl w Acetinl
~°° ? Badgmutd Noss? Q t~1ar YNmacabd~
,___ _ ^ TrawbbaYMa,MQ/
G Ftiopwty/ VahieM Repoli Filed ^ Cdti1tlW on SR l D ~,~. Carrwt ~~ Creslarros face py:
04/06/2007 FRI 09:23 FAX 5635873849 DUBUQUE SOPD RECORDS f~003