Mintues Human Rights Commission 4 14 08CITY OF DUBUQUE
HUMAN R/GHTS COMM/SSION
MEETING MINUTES OF
April 14, 2008
Commissioner Oswald called the meeting of the Dubuque Human Rights Commission to order at
4:18 p.m. on Monday, April 14, 2008, in Conference Room 2 at the City Hall Annex.
Roll Call:
Present: Dan Chatfield
Shane Oswald, Chair
Marco Rubinstein
Colin Scott
Vince Vanden Heuvel
Katrina Wilberding
Gretel Winterwood
Absent: Anthony Allen
Staff: Kelly Larson
Carol Spinoso
Molly Menster
Approval of Minutes
Upon a motion by Commissioner Wilberding and second by Commissioner Vanden Heuvel, the
minutes of March 10, 2008 were approved as submitted.
Caseload Report
Carol summarized the March Caseload Report. There were fifty-six intakes, four new cases filed,
eight cases under active investigation, two cases in mediation, one case in ALJ review, four cases
remained in backlog, and four cases were closed. The case summary details a claim of disability
discrimination in the area of employment.
Chairperson's Report
Commissioner Oswald explained the DCSD's Discrimination, Bullying and Harassment Policy
documents that Commissioner Winterwood received from Kris Hall at a recent PFLAG meeting.
Either students or staff can complete a form if they believe they have been discriminated against.
Administrators will determine whether the complaint moves forward.
Director's Report
Kelly reported that she, along with Molly and Anthony, traveled to Atlanta last week to attend the
HUD National Fair Housing Policy Conference. HUD's is currently focusing on the mortgage
lending crisis and their ongoing efforts to get low income families into permanent housing using
FHA loans.
Kelly is on a committee that is reviewing proposals for the Washington Neighborhood to hire a
consultant to work on a comprehensive plan for that neighborhood using current programs that
have been established.
The Iowa Civil Rights Commission has funding to support a Vista position in Dubuque for one year.
The Vista will be working on poverty issues.
Staff will be presenting some legal training with the Sheriff's Department as part of the small
business/nonprofit training. They will be six 2-hour sessions presented.
Kelly reported that the city is completing its contract with One Ummah Consulting, and that they will
be issuing an annual report to show what they have accomplished through the process.
Additionally, she stated that the City will now be offering domestic partner benefits.
Kelly is working with Project Hope on community poverty issues. They will be gathering information
from across the community on different community assets to try to determine who needs to be
involved in the planning session. They will be contacting several organizations to bring people
together in May or June.
Commissioner Rubinstein stated that the Cedar Rapids Civil Rights Commission had conducted
some fair housing enforcement testing which found 90 % of those tested to be in violation of the
Fair Housing Act. He asked if Dubuque should be doing these types of pro-active activities. Kelly
stated that it's a policy question for the City Council. Currently the Department may only conduct
testing if a complaint is filed. Commissioner Oswald suggested that instead of enforcement
testing, that they possibly do a study. Commissioner Rubinstein would like further discussion on
this issue at next month's meeting.
Subcommittee Reports
Education and Outreach
National Origin: Commissioner Vanden Heuvel reported that the committee sent out more
solicitation and grant applications. They expect to receive grants from the school system,
Loras College, NICC, and Dupaco. They were informed that the video is currently being
filmed and that it should be completed in late June or early July. The next meeting is
scheduled for May 14th at 3:30.
Race: Molly reported that she and Anthony are ready to proceed with training speakers.
Disabilit :Molly stated that she hopes to have this group of speakers trained by mid-May.
Housing: No report given.
Sexual Orientation: Molly reported that locally outreach efforts are being made in the gay
and lesbian community. She stated that if they know of anyone in the community that
would like to be a part of these efforts, to provide her with contact information.
Accessibility
Commissioner Wilberding stated that there was a very good accessibility article in Business
Times. PAD is working with a social research class at the UD with the students conducting
quantitative and qualitative research for them. They will be contacting people who are
affected by disability issues asking in-depth questions. She will share that report with the
commission. They will contact Chamber member restaurants to encourage them to take
the PAD survey to become members of the program. The PAD Board has been holding
planning sessions to fine tune some things. They also prepared a mission statement. They
are continuing to work on developing a hotel survey as a follow-up to the Easy Access
Chicago piece that she mentioned last month.
Commissioner Rubinstein reported that he had attended three DCAP meetings over the last
couple of months. Two meetings were dealing with complaints related to disability, and the
other was a regular meeting. At the next meeting this summer, the group will discuss being
more proactive.
Election of Officers
Commissioner Oswald opened the floor for nominations of Commission Chair. Commissioner
Wilberding nominated Commissioner Oswald. Commissioner Rubinstein moved and
Commissioner Wilberding seconded to close nominations. All in favor. By consensus
Commissioner Oswald will remain chairperson.
Commissioner Oswald opened the floor for nominations of Vice-Chair. Commissioner Wilberding
nominated Commissioner Vanden Heuvel. Commissioner Rubinstein moved and Commissioner
Chatfield seconded to close nominations. All in favor. By consensus Commissioner Vanden
Heuvel will remain vice-chairperson.
Discuss the Change in the Statute of Limitations to 300 Days
Kelly stated that the Iowa legislature has amended the state law changing the statute of limitations
from 180 to 300 days for filing state civil rights claims. Commissioner Rubinstein moved and
Commissioner Wilberding seconded to request the City Council to extend the statute of limitations
from 180 days to 300 days to be consistent with State legislation. All in favor. Kelly will be in
contact with Crenna to get this accomplished.
Appoint Commission Rearesentative to DDRC Advisory Board
Kelly stated that they needed to replace Mary Coan as the Commission's representative to the
Dubuque Dispute Resolution Center Advisory Board. Commissioner Rubinstein moved and
Commissioner Wilberding seconded to appoint Commissioner Vanden Heuvel as the
Commission's representative to the DDRC Advisory Board. All in favor.
New Business
Commissioners Wilberding and Oswald will be meeting April 15th at 1:00 p.m. at Hempstead to
work on the Human Rights Commission brochure. Commissioner Oswald extended an invitation to
anyone interested in attending. Commissioner Wilberding asked that they forward any comments
or recommendations via email.
Adjournment
There being no further business to come before the Commission, Commissioner Vanden Heuvel
moved to adjourn the meeting. Commissioner Winterwood seconded. Motion passed by
consensus. Meeting was adjourned at 5:25 p.m.
The next regular meeting is May 12, 2008.
Minutes approved as submitted:
Minutes approved as corrected: