Loading...
7 20 09 Clerk's Skeleton Notes and Meeting CallCITY C®UNCIL REGULARS SSIN, JULY 0, 2009 C®UNCIL M T IN R GULAR SESSIN AT 6:30 P.M. I THE HISTRIC FEERAL OILING fr PR S NT: MAY®R, UL, C®UNCIL ME RS ,'RAID, -NRS, J® S, LIVCH, RESNICK, !/®ETERD CI°fY MANAGER VAN,ILLIGEN; CITY ATT®RNEYfLIN®AHL ASSENT: Mayor Buol read the call and stated this is a regular session of the City Council to act upon such business that may properly come before the City Council. INVCATI®N: Pastor Jennifer Meyer, Rockdale-Center Grove Methodist Church 2 cNSENTITEMS Ayesy~; Nays `~'`~Voetberg raig `~ Buol Connors ~ >-, Jones ~~ ~' Lynch ' ;`F, ~`"`Resnick Minutes and Repo Submitted Cable TV Teleprogramming Commission of 6/2; City Council of 7/6 and 7/9; Civil Service Commission of 6/10; Historic Preservation Commission of 6/18 (Regular Meeting and Worksession); Investment Oversight Advisory Commission of 4/22; Zoning Advisory Commission of 7/1; Zoning Board of Adjustment of 6/25 Investment Oversight Commission's 64t" Quarterly Report Proofs of publication of City Council Proceedings of June 15, 23, and 30, 2009 Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File 2. Notice of Claims/Suits Camille Blackburn for vehicle damage; Paula Hammerand for personal injury; Marjorie Meyer for property damage Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Refer to City Attorney City Attorney advising that the following claims have been referred to Public Entity Risk Services of Iowa, the agent for the Iowa Communities Assurance Pool: Katherine Dietzel for vehicle damage; Marjorie Meyer for property damage; Camille Blackbourn for vehicle damage; Paula Hammerand for personal injury Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Concur 3 3. Agreement with Hillcrest Family ervices City Manager recommending approval of an agreement with Hillcrest Family Services for the use of Murphy Park for a holiday light display. Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Approve 4. Purchase of Property - 502 / 504 Rhomberg Avenue City Manager recommending approval to purchase a residential dwelling located at 502/ 504 Rhomberg Avenue as part of the acquisition program associated with the Bee Branch Creek Restoration Project. RES®LU°fl®N ~~~°.a Approving the acquisition of real estate located at 502 / 504 Rhomberg Avenue in the City of Dubuque Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution 5. Citizen Communication Communication from Patricia Haas urging the City to adopt the Proposed Ordinance Section 5-2.1 regarding conditional uses for R-1 Dwellings, in particular Accessory Dwelling Units. Suggested Disposition: Receive and File 6. U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Communication from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development advising that the Homelessness Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing Program Substantial Amendment to the City's Consolidated Plan 2008 Action Plan has been approved for funding. Suggested Disposition: Receive and File Ayes Nays Voetberg Braig uol Connors Jones Lynch Resnick 4 7. Iowa Great Places Grant City Manager recommending approval of the submittal of the Iowa Great Places grant application for the following projects: Streetscape and Public Space Improvements in the Historic Millworking District; National Mississippi River Museum and Aquarium Great River Center Phase II; and Installation of Windows in the Carnegie-Stout Library Renovation Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Approve ~. PEG Capital Grant Expenditure Request City Manager recommending approval of the Cable TV Tele-Programming Commission recommendation for funding from the Public, Educational, and Government (PEG) Capital Grant for Access Equipment and Facilities for up to $4,200 for a portable digital recorder for recording of School Board meetings and other events. Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Approve 9. Eagle Point Water Plant West Clear Well Phase II Pipe Coating Project City Manager recommending that the that the original contract offer awarded to K & W Coating, LLC of Elkader, Iowa in the amount of $35,000 for the Eagle Point Water Plant West Clear Well Phase II Pipe Coating Project be rescinded and a new contract be awarded to the second low bidder, Superior Painting & Epoxy Coating, LLC of Urbandale, Iowa in the amount of $36,256. RESOLUI"I®N P~=='~ ~'~ Rescinding Resolution No. 142-09 Awarding the Public Improvement Contract for the Eagle Point Water Plant Clear Well Reservoir Phase II Rehabilitation (Pipe Coating) Project to I< & W Coating, LLC RES®LUTI®N ' `~ ;3~-? Awarding the public improvement contract for the Eagle Point Water Plant Clear Well Reservoir Phase II Rehabilitation (Pipe Coating) Project to Superior Painting & Epoxy Coating, LLC Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolutions Lynch Resnick 5 10. Pennsylvania Avenue from 132 to Vizaleea Drive Safety Improvements Protect, Phase II City Manager recommending award of the public improvement contract for the Pennsylvania Avenue from IA 32 to Vizaleea Drive Safety Improvements Project to McDermott Excavating in the amount of X310,221.51. RES®LUTI®N ~'°;~;~``~ Awarding public improvement contract for the Pennsylvania Avenue from IA 32 to Vizaleea Drive Safety Improvements Project Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution 11. Final Plat -Graf Farm City Manager recommending approval of the final plat of Graf Farm Subdivision in Dubuque County, Iowa. '' ~~~~~ Rescinding Resolution No. 362-08 and approving the RES®LUTI®N p.-~~ ` ~ «~ final plat of Graf Farms in Dubuque County, Iowa Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution 12. Civil Service Commission Civil Service Commission submitting the certified list for the position of Fire Equipment Operator. Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Make a Fatter of Record Ayes plays Voetberg raig uol Connors Jones Lynch Resnick 6 13. Community ®evelopment lock Grant (C® G) Fiscal Year 2010 Annual Action Plan Amendment #1 City Manager recommending approval of the first amendment to the Fiscal Year 2010 Annual Action Plan. R SLl1Tl®fV ~-;~ ' ~~~~, Approving Amendment 1 to the Fiscal Year 2010 (Program Year 2009) Annual Action Plan for Community Development Block Grant Funds Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution 14. 2009 Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) City Manager recommending acceptance of the 2009 Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) in the amount of $360,320. Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Approve 15. Alcohol Compliance -Civil Penalty for Alcohol License Holders City Manager recommending approval of the Acknowledgement/Settlement Agreement for a first offense alcohol compliance violation for Lot One. Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Approve 16. ®elinquent Water, Sewer, Refuse and Storm Vl/ater Collection Accounts City Manager recommending approval of the submission of delinquent water, sewer, refuse and storm water collection accounts to the Dubuque County Treasurer. RES®LIJTI®N ~~r~''~ Adopting the Schedule of Assessments for delinquent water, refuse, sewer and storm water collection accounts and directing the Clerk to certify the schedule of assessments to the County Treasurer and to publish notice thereof Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution Lynch Resnick 7 17. Port of ®ubuue iverfront Marina Project Communication from Brian J. Kane, representing Port of Dubuque Brewery Development, LLC, advising that his client strongly prefers that the docks be constructed in front of (or to the east of) the brewery building. City Manager's response to Brian J. Kane. Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File 18. Midwest High Speed Rail Association City Manager recommending that the City join the Midwest High Speed Rail Association (MHSRA), amembership-based, non-profit organization advocating the development of fast, frequent and dependable passenger trains, at the $500 patron level. Suggested disposition: Receive and File; Approve 19. Liquor License Transfer Request of the Rotary Club to transfer their liquor license to the Alliant Energy Outdoor Amphitheater on August 29, 2009 for the Irish Hooley event. Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Approve 20. Liquor /Tobacco Applications City Manager recommending approval of annual liquor license renewals as submitted. RES®LUTI®N .-~'~' Granting the issuance of one new license to sell cigarettes to C ~ M Chains and Things RES®LUTI®N ~~r~..~~ Granting the issuance of five renewal licenses to sell cigarettes to Awn Stop Mart, Dubuque Mining Company, Hammerheads Bar, Oky-Doky 14 and Pioneer's Rest Area RES®LUTI®N r~'°`.`~X ~;°`~~ Granting the issuance of a Class B Beer Permit to Monkey Business Family Fun; and a Class "C" Beer Permit to Road Ranger #161, Road Ranger #160, Road Ranger #159, Oky Doky #6, Kwik Stop Food Mart, Oky Doky #14 and Kwik Star #495 R S®LUTI®N ~~ ~~'.~~.~ f Granting the issuance of a Class "C" Beer/Liquor License to Walnut Tap; Special Class "C" Liquor License to Bell Tower Productions; and a Class "B" Wine Permit to Basket Expressions and Oky Doky 6; and a Class "WBN" Native Wine Permit to Kwik Star #495 Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolutions 8 ITEMS T® E SET F®R PU LIC HEA ING These agenda items are being scheduled for a future public hearing on the date indicated. 1. Slattery Center Lease - ubuque I~lontessori School City Manager recommending that a public hearing be set for August 3, 2009 to consider leasing the Slattery Center in Flora Park to Montessori School. RES®LUTI®N r-~` ~°'~ of Intent to dispose of real property by lease agreement with Dubuque Montessori School Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution 2. Fire Station No. 4 - ®oor Replacement Project City Manager recommending initiation of the public bidding process for the Fire Station No. 4 -Door Replacement Project and that a public hearing be set for August 3, 2009. RES®LUTI®N ~ ~`~ ~ Preliminary approval of plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cost; setting date of public hearing on plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cost; and ordering the advertisement for bids for the Fire Station No. 4 -Door Replacement Project Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution; Public blearing 9/3/09 3. Garfield Retaining Nall Repair Project City Manager recommending initiation of the public bidding process for the Garfield Retaining Wall Repair Project and that a public hearing be set for August 3, 2009. RESOLUTI®N ~::~~-'.~:~~=~- Preliminary approval of plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cost; setting date of public hearing on plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cost; and ordering the advertisement for bids for the Garfield Retaining Wall Repair Project Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution; Public Hearing 9/3/09 Ayes gays i/oetberg raig uol Connors Jones Lynch Resnic4c 10 Historic Shot Tower Rehabili tion Project City Manager recommending initiation of the public bidding process for the Historic Shot Tower Rehabilitation Project and that a public hearing be set for August 3, 2009. RES®LU1°I®N ~'~.=-'~~ Preliminary approval of plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cost; setting date of public hearing on plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cost; and ordering the advertisement for bids for the Historic Shot Tower Rehabilitation Project Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution; Public Hearing 8/3/09 5. Storm Vi/ater Utility Revenue Capital Loan Notes City Manager recommending that a public hearing be set for September 8, 2009 to consider the issuance of not to exceed $1,000,000 Storm Water Utility Revenue Capital Loan Notes. RES®LUTI®N ,:t Fixing date for a meeting on the authorization of a Loan and Disbursement Agreement and the issuance of not to exceed $1,000,000 Storm Water Utility Revenue Capital Loan Notes of Dubuque, Iowa and directing publication of notice thereof Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution; Public Hearing 9/8/09 Ayes Nays y,-;Voetberg ,~`~_~~~raig ~/ f G"r llO~ C®nn®rs Jones fF,,t•~ Lynch ~r' '° Resnick f 11 ARS/CMMIS IBS Applicants are invited to address the City Council regarding their desire to serve on the following Boards/Commissions; applicant appointments will be made at the next City Council meeting. Civil Service Connrnission - Mayor Appointr~nent One 4-year term through April 6, 2012 (Term of Krueger) Applicants: Tom Rawson, 2310 Knob Hill Drive °. °'~ John Stevens, 2215 Graham Circle Elizabeth Takes, 1245 Dunleith Court --Y f ~,:.. Transit Board of Trustees One 3-year term through July 30, 2012 (Term of Stedman) Applicants: Thomas Croissant, 444 Angella Street, #8 Matthew Esser, 90 Main Street, #201 Appointments to the following Boards/Commissions: uilding Code Board of Appeals Two 3-year terms through August 1, 2012 (Terms of Carr and Luchsinger) At-large and General Contractor requirements Applicants: Richard Luchsinger, 2875 Brueck Road (At-Large Reappointment) Chuck Carr, 1705 Kathy Drive (General Contracto,~`reappointment) F. 12 Library oard of °frustes ® ayor Appointment Three 4-year terms referenced with expiration dates contingent upon proposed ordinance which will re-stagger terms: 2 terms through July 1, 2010; and 1 term through July 1, 2013 (Terms of Guns, Kolz, and Willis) Applicants: `' Mann Guns, 1715 Diane Court (Seeking reappointment through July 1, 2010) 'Beverly Kolz, 2206 Simpson Street (Seeking reappointment through July 1, 2010) Gail Murphy, 3096 Oak View Court (First-time applicant) Lorri Regan, 2659 Queen Street (First-time applicant) =ffCllike Willis, 1365 West 5t" Street (Seeking reappointment through July 1, 2013) ,~-, Ayes 4~_ R , ~., ~ ,. ,_: s~,. t' jF Voetberg Craig uol Connors Jones Lynch Resnick tu~ys 13 PUBLIC HEARINGS Citizens are invited to address the City Council regarding the following agenda items. Please corns to the podium and state your Warne and address when the item you wish to speak to is being considered. SUSPEN TH RULES Ayes Nays %, Voetberg ,,~ r )13raig `~ uol ~, ~~FA~Connors ~ ;~' 'Jones '~ Lynch ~r ResnlCk 1. Request to Rezone -University Avenue between Ethel and Prysi Streets Proof of publication on notice of public hearing to consider a request from Tom Kluck to rezone property located north of the University Avenue and Ethel Street intersection from OR Office Residential District to PUD Planned Unit Development District with a PR Planned Residential District designation and adopting a conceptual development plan and Zoning Advisory Omission recommending approval. OR®INANCE Amending Appendix A (The Zoning Ordinance) of the City of Dubuque Code of Ordinances by reclassifying hereinafter described property located north of the University Avenue and Ethel Street intersection from OR Office Residential District to PUD Planned Unit Development District with a PR Planned Residential District designation and adopting a conceptual development plan ' ``' Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; motion E; Motion A ° ~° `% ,. Suspend the Readings Final Reading and Adopt Ayes Nays Ades Nayes ~:'~ Voetberg f .Voetberg raig -`~ ,',raig ;~' Euol '` ' uol `'~ Connors '~ .,,Connors _` Jones ~°" ,, -~~ Jones ;Lynch f Lynch Resnick ;' Resnick 14 2. Water Revenue Capital Loan Notes Proof of publication on notice of public hearing to consider the issuance of not to exceed $8,000,000 Water Revenue Capital Loan Notes and City Manager recommending approval. RESOLUTION ~~ ~~~ Instituting proceedings to take additional action for the authorization of a loan and disbursement agreement and the issuance of not to exceed $8,000,000 Water Revenue Capital Loan Notes Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution Ayes Nays Voetberg `~_ Eraig ~` uol .~ -' F=, Connors ;~` Jones ~~` ~ ':Lynch ,~ Resnick 3. Iowa 32 Hike / dike Trail Phase 2 Project Proof of publication on notice of public hearing to consider the plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cost for the Iowa 32 Hike /Bike Trail Phase 2 Project and City Manager recommending approval. RESOLUTION r ~~~'~~=~:~ ~ Approving plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cost for the Iowa 32 Hike /Bike Trail Phase 2 Project Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution Ay,~s Nays Voetberg -' Craig ?,~ uol Connors ~"~ .Jones ~~~Lynch Resnick 15 4. Trail Project at erfeld Recreation Area Proof of publication on notice of public hearing to consider the plans, specifications, form of contract and estimated cost for the Trail Project at Bergfeld Recreation Area and City Manager recommending approval. ~-~ t, _- RESOLUTION <~.~~~~-F Approving plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cost for the Trail Project at Bergfeld Recreation Area Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution ayes Nays k ~°' Voetberg Braig .. Buol ~` E: Connors ,y Jones . ~ a, Lynch Resnick 5. E.B. Lyons Nature Center Addition Project Proof of publication on notice of public hearing to consider the plans, specifications, form of contract and estimated cost for the E.B. Lyons Nature Center Addition Project and City Manager recommending approval. RESOLUTION s`` Approving plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cost for the E.B. Lyons Nature Center Addition Project Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution Ayes-~ Nays 't'' `i/oetberg ~_ ~, ~; _` Braig Buol ~` _ Connors f *~~A~' Jones `~ Lynch ,~ Resnick 16 6. Locust Street Resurfacing ®9t" to 17t" Stree Project Proof of publication on notice of public hearing to consider the plans, specifications, form of contract and estimated cost for the Locust Street Resurfacing - 9t" to 17tH Streets Project and City Manager recommending approval. R SOLUTION ~~~~ °~~ Approving plans, specifications, form of contract, and estimated cos ~, for the E.B. Lyons Nature Center Addition Project Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution ~-yes Nays ,~° Voetberg ~'~,*~'Braig Buol ~ Connors d,. ``~ _ ~,~,Jones ~`~{ ~ ~° ~ Lynch ~`~ ~ ~ Resnick REINSTATE THE RULES This action limits discussion to the City Council. Ayes Nays Voetberg " ~ ~'~ Eraig '"'~ - Buol '~,, Connors Kf Jones ~° ,; r,;. ,Lynch ~`~~~ Resnick 17 ~~f ACTI®N IT MS These are items where discussion is held by the City Council ®ulic cornrnents are not allowed except as authorized by the Mayor. 1. equest to Address the City Council ®®pen Meetings Request of June E. Strueber to address the City Council regarding the open meetings law. t ~;~..~ Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Council 1,~ (, }~;. ~, Ayes gays ! t;' `~ `4, fv. f j~: ,~~ Voetberg '4 ~~ l ~ ~ , ~ r ,~raig ~~%~ ~~ ~ , r ~~ x ~uol ~ 4r~, ;~ .`~ ~~~r'Connors `~1 ~ ~ v Jones Lynch ~ ~ ~ ~~ °'` Resnick ~~~ ~ ~i ~~` ~, ~ ,r 2. Request to Address the City Council ®Dog Park ~" Request of Toni Kretschmer to address the City Council regarding the dbg park. Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; C-e~~il I e A~ `' f Ayes ^®ay~ F 6 ~ ,~ E F . Voetber `° t ,, d ' 4j, I .f x Craig ~~` ~'~' ~ t~ ,~ k''. :,Connors ~ ~ ~ Jones ; f ~ i ,. Lynch i ` ~,~~ k' fi s ~ Resnick ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~`~ ~' ~ r jr ~~'~ , {}'' °` P is {~..~ ~~~~ !' ,Fk r ~t: ~ ~ ''~ {, E F yyy f. /~: t ' ~E A. it { (~_ !e t t 18 r' ~~~ ~f 3. ®uuque County Historical ociety Request of Jerry Enzler, National Mississippi River Museum and Aquarium, to address the City Council regarding a Resolution of Supporf for the Historical Society's application to the Vision Iowa's River Enhancement Community Attraction and Tourism Program (RECAT). City Manager recommending approval of the Resolution of Support for the Historical Society's application to the Vision Iowa's River Enhancement Community Attraction and Tourism Program (RECAT). ...~ RESOLIJTI®N ~~- .~.- ,~ pf Support ,,~ Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Adopt Resolution Ayes ~~ys '~ Voetberg r' Craig uol f-~ ~~~~fConnors ,~ ~~''~ Jones %` ,-, Lynch ,Resnick s M1 f' {~ f ~ ` i_x ~ tkk., i ~ ,~ I~' ~,d ~,' ,: ~~~ ,_- ; 19 4. 5. Fiscal Year 200 ®ubuque County REAP Plan ,' .i ~`: t` City Manager recommending approval of the City of Dubuque's update of the Fiscal Year 2010 Dubuque County REAP Plan, submittal of the Fiscal Year 2010 REAP grant application for installation of the Iowa 32 Bike /Hike Trail -Phase 3 Project and appointment of a City Council representative (currently Council Member Joyce Connors) to the REAP Committee. Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Approve; Council Appointrnent Ayes, , gays .%~, -'Voetberg Braig ,.~'r Buol °` .Connors E ~",'Jones ~`~~ ~_Lynch 1`Y Resnick Restriction of All®Terrain Vehicles (A1°V) Use City Manager recommending that the use of ATVs be restricted to private property of not less than one acre in size, and only between sunrise and sunset, and only with the written permission of the property owner if the property owner is not the owner of the ATV. A F ~~ ®R®INANCE ~` ` _ Amending Chapter 32 (Motor Vehicles and Traffic) of the City of Dubuque Code of Ordinances by amending Section 32.4 All-Terrain Vehicles to prohibit use of all-terrain vehicles on property less than one acre Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Motion B; Motion A f, Suspend the Readings Ayes Voetberg Braig uol Connors Jones Lynch Resnick gays Final Reading and Adopt Ayes Nayes Voetberg Braig Buol Connors Jones Lynch Resnick 20 _ f I<<.f 6. ubuque Sister City Relationship ~`~ . `F! City Manager recommending that the City Council solicit two City Council Member volunteers to recruit members for apublic/private partnership Sister City Committee and then agree to serve on that committee. Suggested ®isposition: Receive and File; Approve Aye fr_ Nays ~' ~;%~Voetberg ,~~ ` `t Craig A, 13uo1 `~ ~~~Connors f Jones .~`~ ; Lynch ~' Resnick COUNCIL MEII~~ER REP®RTS PUBLIC INPUT At this time, anyone in the Council Chambers may address the Council on matters which are of concern to that person and which are not an agenda item. Please take your place at the microphone and state your name and address clearly. Proceed with your comments; however, no formal action may be taken at this time on your comments because of the notice requirements of the Iowa Open Meetings Law. CL®SE® SESSI®N Pending Litigation and Property Acquisition -Chapter 21.5(1)(c)Q) 2007 Code of Iowa ,:~ ,t Motion to go into Closed Session at = , ,% Ayes Nays ,. Voetberg ~~` Craig ~'~ ~~~_~ ~ ~uol ~' : Connors ~s. ~~ ~ ~ ~~Jones ~, ~,, r"" < Lynch f Resnick Motion to adjourn at b =~ ~'` ```~ 22 . ir' ~ ,~ } _ v ... d ~ .. ' ~ ~ s _,a .- " .. ~ i,. r; ' / r - '~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f` ~ . ~ ,_ .w.- ,~ -- . ~' ~ f %! -- a - ~, ., r ~~ ,~ , , f -. 4..~ . ,-, r / . y .' e,a.,y u._~ a,. ~ ~ A i -'' r,r .> ~`f +" f ~ we e _, ,^ .. e .. ~ . r _ ~ ~ , .; ..., i ~..r ~ ,. - ~ . t ~ ,^ ~ .~e'f - ~ ~.- F~ e _ _,. r. f . r ~f _ . f.:~ 3 ,% ~ . : ~ r Y m'"r ' - ' . .. gy , f, P " . 4 i ~ r'` _~ jj ... - {`f' ,; _.<~ fi ~'" ~ f r r r" r -i l r, f / ~~' ~;+ j' ~ ~ _t f " _ ~ . it .: , .. ~ ... t ~ ,. ~~ b ~~ ~, ~~ t ~ ~. t' fL , ~~` f , ~ ;. a 5 , ~ r {, 1, '; ~: l 'V 'c I+i} 4 . . ~~~