Loading...
Office of the City Assessor_Property Assessment Appealst~ OFFICE OF THE CITY ASSESSOR COURTHOUSE 720 CENTRAL AVENUE DUBUQUE, IOWA 52001-7051 Richard A. Engelken, City Assessor Telephone: 563-589-4416 Mayor & Chairperson of the Conference Board City Hall 50 West 13th Street Dubuque, Iowa 52001 July 24, 2009 To Whom It May Concern: Kim Reittinger, Deputy Assessor Fax: 563-589-7807 Enclosed are copies of four Notice of Appeal & Petition forms filed with the Property Assessment Appeal Board. The four properties being protested are: 1) A vacant lot on Cedar Lake Drive, east of Cedar Cross Road 2) Hy-Vee ~on the Northwest Arterial Road 3) Holiday Inn on Main Street 4) K-Mart of Dodge Street This notification is required under 441.37A (1) d of the Code of Iowa. The appeals are for 2009 assessments of value and would affect taxes payable in the fall of 2010 and the spring of 2011. We will keep you informed of any settlements, actions, or dismissals on these properties. Please feel free to contact me at the telephone number listed above. Sincerely, ~~ Richard A. Engel e~ Dubuque City Assessor JUiv ~ v ;_~~.:1 Property Assessment App®al Board NOTICE OF APPEAL & PETITION PROPERTY ASSESSMENT APPEAL BOARD 401 S. W. 7`a Street, Suite D Des Moines, IA 50309-4634 ~~~ JUN 15 ZUO~ PROPERTYASSESSMENT APPEAL BOARD IN THE MATTER OF: Richard V. & Charlene L. Hansel Living Trusts At~eJJaut(s) Name (Plcasc taint) - ' 439 Tamarack Court Maiht~ Address Dubuque IA 52003 can state !ip 563-599-9433 Parcel Identification #: ~ 0-34-101-019 Dubuque - -_----•--~-. County Property Address: Lot 2-2 Cedar Lake Plaza 3rd Add(Vacant Lot) Dubuque lA 52003 Street Address Ciq~ State "Lip Please enter a short and plain statement of the claim for this appeal, -, Property is being over assessed when considering solid fill conditions, useable property acreage calculations ,necessary improvements required in relation to adjacent properties, property comparables calculations to adjacent properties,and current market conditions. Please enter a brief statement of the relief sought for this appeal. We desire the lowering of this proposed assessed value increase. Current assessed value: {from local board of review letter) Total $522,700 Land $522,700 Buildings $ The value you contend is the correct assessed value (if applicable): Total $287,250 Land $287,250 Buildings $ (if applicable) (if applicable) Grounds on appeal. These grounds must be the same ounds that were protested to the local board of review. Check all grounds that apnfv: l~j The assessment is not equitable as compared with assessments of other like property in the taxing district. ^ The property is assessed for more than the value authorized bylaw. ^ The property is not assessable, is exempt from taxes, or is tttisclassified. ® There is an error in the assessment. ^ There is fraud in the assessment. ® That there has been a cllange downward in the value since the last assessment. Please check the a ro riate box: Q I want a hearing ~ t do not want a hearing. Ag Buildings $. Ag Buildings $ If you would like to request to participate in yow hearing by telephone, please fill alt dte 1teQtJrs°r Fox TctEpxoNS HEAxIJ~iG form. The form is available at http:/hvwtv.oaab_iowa.~ov or may be requested from the Secaetarv of the Property Assessment Apveal Board. If you are going to have someone represent you at the hearing, please list your tegai representative's or attorney's information in the space provided below. Please note that all future correspondence from the Property Assessment Appeal Board will be seat to your designated representative or attorney and not to you personally per customary practice in a case proceeding where parties are represented. Q Legal Representative - other than an attarney (may include tax rep.; fancily member; or ocher person) © Attorney Jeffrey S. Hansel-Trustee Name Firm (if applicable) 439 Tamarack Court, Dubuque,lA, 52003 563-583-6422 ivcamng t~oaress Phone If you are going to have a Legal Representative appear for you at the hearing please 611 out a PowErt oF' A7°rortNEy form. The form is available at htt~ i/~~ ~~,1~~ naab.io~a~a.~o~lf'ormsrintiex.htrnl or may be requested from the Secretary of the Property Assessment Appeal Board. An attorney shall file an appearance. The following documents should be attached to this NOTICE OF APPEAL & PETITION: One (1) Copy: 1. The postmarked envelope of the letter of disposition by the toes! Board of Review; 2. The letter of disposition by the local Board of Review, 3. The Petition to local Board of Review, 4. All records, reports, and documents provided to the local Board of Review in support of tlce Petition to the local Board of Review; and Optional Attachment: Three (3) Copies: S. Any new information including records, reports, appraisals, and documents that you want to subtctit to support your claim. You may send these documents at a later date. The Property Assessment Appeal Board will send a copy of this NOTICE or APPEAL & PETITION form to the local board and other parties. It is your responsibility to send the copies of documents listed in items 1-5 above to the local board of review and any ocher pArties. The local board will also provide you with copses ofany information it submits to the Property Assessment Appeal Board. All of the above information is correct and true to the best oFmy belief and knowledge. Name; Jeffrey S. Hansel (Please print) Name: Charlene t_. Haase! Date: 6' j ~ -2009 (Please print) - Signature: ~' ~ Signature: ~~~i1~-y(,~? ~~~ y The Property Assessment Appeal Board is an independent State Agency and hears appeals from all 99 counties and 8 cities across the State of Iowa. The Appea[ Board has no afPdiation with your local Board of Review, assessor's office or county attorney's office. Tttis form must mailed in or delivered in-person to the Secretary of the Property Assessment Appeal Board Postmarked to: NOTICE. OF APPEAL & PETITLON JUN 1 2 ~Oi?~ PI20PERT'Y ASSESS141EN'I• APPEAL I30ATi1) Property Assessment 401 S.~i'. 7`r' Sheet, Suite ll Appeal Board Des 1l4oines, IA 50309-4634 ~~~~~~ JUN ~ 5 ZOQS PROPERTYASSESSMENT APPEAL BOARD IN 'fHE M.q"ITGR OF: 4800 Asburv Road Dubuaue-IA LLC Appellant(s) Name (Please print) 5820 Westown Pkv Mailing Address West Des Moines IA 50266 Qt}' State zip 913-239-0990 Daytime Telephone Number (Include Area Code) hfOTIGE OF APPEAL & PETITION Docket No. ~~ .... /~ ~•--~ ~~~ ~1 {To be/assigned) Parcel identification ~: 10-17-476-005 _ _ _ county City of Dubuque ___ PropertyAddress: 2395 NW Arterial Dubuque IA 52002 Street Address Ciq~ state ztp Plcasc enter a short and plain statement of the claim for this appeal. The county value estimate is above the actual value of the subject property. ~ Please enter a brief statement of the relief sought for this appeal. ~! We request the 2009 county value be reduced to the actual fair market value of the subject property. Current assessed value: (from local board of review letter) 'T'otal $ $5,061,500 Land $ $1,161,700 Buildings $ $3,899,800 _ ,A~ Fuildings $ ____ (ifapphcable) The value ou contend is the correct assessed value (if applicable): Total $~_~_QO~c~ _ Land $ c Buildings $ Z7 0o Ot3p Ag Buildings $ (ifapplicablc) Grounds on appeal. These grounds must be the same grounds that were protested to the local board of review. Check all g~•ounds that apply: ^ The assessment is not equitable as compared with assessments of other like property in the taxing district. The property is assessed for more than the value authorized by law. ^ ~'he property is not assessable, is exempt S•om taxes, or is misclassified. ^ There is an error in the assessment. ^ There is fraud in the assessment. ^ That there has been a change dowrnvard in the value since the last assessment. Please check the appropriate box: I want a hearing. © I do not want a hearing. If you would like to request to participate in your hearing by telephone, please fill out the R>rQuES'r t~otz TELEPHONfi NEAKING form. T'he form is available at http://www.paab.iowa.g_ov or may be requested from the Secretary of the Property Assessment Appea] Board. (osroos> if you arc going to have someone represent you at the hearing, please list your legal representative's or attorney's information in the space provided below. Please note that all future correspondence from the Property Assessment Appeal 13onrd will be sent to your designated representative or attorney and not to you personalty per customary practice in a case proceeding where parties are represented. Q Legal Representative - other than an attorney (may include tax rep.; family member; or other person) ^ Atta~ney Jerry W Chatam Name J. W. Chatam & Associates Firm (if applicable) 7301 W 129th Street, Suite 150, Overland Park, KS, 66213 913-239-0990 Fax: 913-239-0993 Mailing Address Phone If you are going to have a Legal Representative appear for you at the hearing, please fill out a POWER ot~ AT rottN>iv form. The forrn is available at httR:/lwww.naab,iow~.~y/forms/index.hUnl or may be requested from the Secretary of the Property Assessment Appeal Board. An attorney shall file an appearance. The following documents should be attached to this NOTICE OF APPEAL & PETITION: One (1}Copy: I . The postmarked em~elope of the letter of disposition by the local Board of Review; ''. The letter of disposition by the local Board oI'Review; 3. The Petition to local Board of Review; 4 All records, reports, and documents provided to the local Board of Review in support of the Petition to the local Board of Review; and Optional Attachment: Three (3) Copies: 5. Any new information including records, reports, appraisals, and documents that you want to submit to support your claim. You may send these documents at a later date. The Property Assessment Appeal Board will send a copy of this NOTIC6Or= APPEAL & PETITION form to the local board and other parties. It is your responsibility to send the copies of documents listed in items 1-5 above to the local board of review and any other parties. The local board will also provide you with copies of any information it submits to the Property Assessment Appeal Board. All of the above information is correct and h•ue to the best of my belief and knowledge. Nang: Jerry W. Chatam (Please print) Name: Date: 6/12/09 (Please pant) Signature: _~_ _ Signature: •The Property Assessment Appeal Board is an independent State Agency and hears appeals from all 99 counties and 8 cities across the State of Iowa. The Appeal Board has no affiliation with yom• local Board of Review, assessor's offce or county attorney's office. This form must mailed in or delivered in-person to the Secretary of the Property Assessment Appeal Board within hventy (20) days of the postmarked date of the local board of review decision. (0~l2009) postmarked tp; NOTICE OF APPEAL & PETITION i ~~ ,,. ~ ~ 2009 1'KOYERTI' ASSESSMENT APPEAL BOARD 4roperty /1SSe55rr1@nt 401 S.V4'. 7`h Street, Suite D Des 117oiaes, IA 50309-4634 Appeal Board to ~rl-~~ MATTER or: Blue Moon Development Company Appellant(s) iVame (Nlease prinQ c1o Deborah M. Tharnish, 215 10th St., Ste. 1300 i~htiline Address Des Moines IA 50309 Cil~ State zip 515-288-2500 -- Da~ume'Celephune rJumber(Inclt,de.UeaCodej -- JUN 1 5 200 PRO APPEAL BOARD ENT Parcel Identification #: 10-7.5-236-001 County Dubuque Properp~ Address: 450 Main Street _ Dubuque IA 52001 Street Address City State Zip Please enter a short and plain statement of the claim for this appeal. The property is assessed for more than the value authorized by law. The actual value of the property under the market approach and the income approach is $4,000,000. Please enter a brief statement of the relief sought for this appeal. Appellant requests that the value be reduced to $4,000,000. Current assessed value: (from local board of review letter} Total $.5,700,000- ---- Land 9.___-,__-- __._-- Buildings $- -___--- Ag Buildings jil appliwblel "fhe value y~ui contend is the correct assessed value (if applicable}: I'utol $ 4,000,000 Laud b Buildings $..---___-- Ag Buildings $ --- --- tirapplicablel I - -- -- --' Grounds on appeal. These grounds must be the same ,rounds that were protested to the local board of review. Check all ,rounds that apply: ^ 'fhe assessment is not equitable as compared with assessments of other like property in the taxing district. The property is assessed for more than the value authorized by law. ^ The property is not assessable, is exempt from taxes, or is misclassified. ^ There is an errat in the assessment. ^ There is fraud in the assessment. l'hat there has been a change downward in the value since the last assessment. Please check the appropriate box: __ __ Q 1 want a hearing. 0 1 do not want a hearing. If you would like to request to participate in your hearing by telephone, please fill out the REQUEST FOR TELEYt10NF.•, HEiAKING form. The form is available at httfr/%www.paab.iawa.gov or may be requested from the Secretary of the Property Assessment Appeal Board. (osizoo9) If you are going to have someone represent you at the hearing, please list ,your legal representative's or attorney's information in the space provided below. Please note that all future correspondence from the Property Assessment Appeal Board will be sent to your designated representative or attorney and not to you personally per customary practice in a case proccedinb where parties are represented. ^ Legal Representative - other than an attorney {may include tax rep.; family member; or other person) Q Attorney Deborah M. Tharnish Davis Brown Law Firm Name Finn (if applicable) 215 10th Street, Suite 1300, Des Moines, IA 50309 515-288-2500 tulailing Address Phone If you are going to have a Legal Representative appear for you at the hearing, please fill out a PUwfrR or ,1TTORNt:v form. 'I'lie furor is available at htip_';+v+++a.paab.io~ti~a.~ovifbrms;indt:x.html or may be requested from the Secretary of the Property Assessment Appeal Board. An attorney shall file an appearance. The following documents should be attached to this NOTICE Ufr APPEAL & PETI"PION: Unc (1) Copy: t. The postmarked envelope of the letter of disposition by the local Board of Review; 2. The letter of disposition by the local Board of Review; ~. The Petition to local Board of Review; 4. All records, reports, and documents provided to the local Board of Review in support of the Petition to the local E3oard of Review; and Optional attachment: Three (3) Copies: S. 1ny new information including records, reports, appraisals, and documents that you want to submit to support your claim. ~'ou may send these documents at a later date. The Property Assessment Appeal Board will send a copy' of this NCrCICE OF APPGAI_ & PETITION form to the Local board and other parties. It is yow• responsibility to send the copies of documents listed in items 1-5 above to the local board of review and any other parties. The local board will also provide you with copies ofany information it submits to the Property Assessment Appeal Board All of the above informatiat is correct and U ue to the best of my belief and la~ow(edg'e. Name -~t~4/!~?~-- ----- Signattue: 1Y~-tDO'ro~~ ~. 1 ~-~ Y\,~ (Please print) - -~- --- Name: Signature: -.. __. `` (Please pant) --- Date: ~o l l Z~O `~ __--- "The Yrnperty Assessment Appeal Board is an independent State Agency and ]tears appeals from all 99 counties and 8 cities across the State of Iowa. The Appeal Board has no affiliation with your local Board of Review, assessor's office or county attorttcy's office. 'This form must mailed iv or delivered io-person to the Sccretaty of the Property Assessment Appeal Board within t+venty (20) days of the postmarked date of the local bou•d of review decisiatt. (OS120o9) Postmarked to: ~~~~~~ JUN 16 2009 NOTICE OF APPEAL & PETITION JUN ~ 7 200 Property Assessment PROPERTY ASSESSMENT APPEAL BOARD PROPERTY ASSESSMENT Appeal Board 401 S.W. 7`" Street, Suite D APPEAL BOARD Des Moines, IA 50309-4634 IN THE MATTER OF: > ~ '" ~ - ; Sears Holding Corp., Dept 768 Tax Appellant(s) Natiie (Please print) ~ z ~€~(j • O~ ~RPEA~. & PET~'IC1N ~, 3333 Beverly Road ~ = -~ ::~ -- Mailing Address 4 s ~ ~ E ~ /~~~ ~{ Hoffman Estates I L 60179 ~~~~ ~ ~ .~. * To biass~i,ntxi) ~ ~ _ ~ ~,F ~ , ~ f;,;; ~,~, .,~,~~ city state zip ~,'' '~ 314-692-5841 . ~~~ ~ ~. _ . , Daytime Telephone Number (Utclude Area Code) ~ ~ "~ ~ ` .. .. , Parcel Identification 1/: 1027476015 F- ~1~~T --_ County City of Dubuque, Dubuque County Property Address: 2550 Dodge Dubuque lows Street Address City Swte Zip ', Please enter a short and plain statement of the claim for this appeal. Market rents and market transactions do not support current value. Declining retail sales for this location. Please enter a brief statement of die relief sought for this appeal. I respectfully request the value to be reduced from $4,955,000 to $3,465,000 based on supplied information and the current state of the economy. Current assessed value: (from local board of review letter) Total $ 4,955,000 Land $1,282,900 Buildings $ 3,972,100 The value ~ contend is the correct assessed value (if applicable): Total $ 3,465,000 Land $1,282,900 Ag Buildings $ Buildings $ 2,182,100 Ag Buildings $ (if applicable) (if applicable) Grounds on appeal. These grounds must be the same rg ounds that were protested to the local board of review. Check all grounds that apply: ^ T'he assessment is not equitable as compared with assessments of other like property in the taxing district. The property is assessed for more than the value authorized by law. ^ The property is not assessable, is exempt from taxes, or is misclassified. ^ There is an error in the assessment. ^ There is fraud in the assessment. That there has been a change downward in the value since the last assessment. Please check the appropriate box: Q I want a hearing. ~ I do not want a hearing. If you would like to request to participate in your hearing by telephone, please fill out the REQUEST FOR TELEPHONE HEARING form. The form is available at http://www.paab.iowa.gov or may be requested from the Secretary of the Property Assessment Appeal Board. tosnoo9) If you are going to have someone represent you at the hearing, please list your legal representative's or attorney's information in the space provided below. Please note that al! future correspondence from the Property Assessment Appeal Board will be sent to your designated representative or attorney and not to you personally per customary practice in a case proceeding where parties are represented. Q Legal Representative - other than an attorney (may include tax rep.; family member; or other person) ^ Attorney Richard Hermes CBIZ - St Louis Name Firm (if applicable) One City Place Dr., Ste 570, St Louis, MO 63141 314-692-5841 Mailing Address Phone If you are going to have a Legal Representative appear for you at the hearing, please fill out a POWER of ATTORNEY form. The form is available at http:!/www.paab.iowa.>;ov/fornis/index.html or maybe requested from the Secretary of the Property Assessment Appeal Board. An attorney shall file an appearance. The following documents should be attached to this NOTICE OF APPEAL & PETITION: One (1) Copy: 1. Tire postmarked envelope of the letter of disposition by the local Board of Review; 2. The letter of disposition by the local Board of Review; 3. The Petition to local Board of Review; 4. All records, reports, and documents provided to the local Board of Review in support of the Petition to the local Board of Review; and Optional Attachment: Three (3) Copies: 5. Any new information including records, reports, appraisals, and documents that you want to submit to support your claim. You may send these documents at a later date. The Property Assessment Appeal Board will send a copy of this NOTICE oi~ APPEAL & PETtT1oN form to the local board and other parties. It is your responsibility to send the copies of documents listed in items 1-5 above to the local board of review and any other parties. The local board will also provide you with copies of any information it submits to the Property Assessment Appeal Board. All of the above information is correct and true to the best of my belief and knowledge. Name: Richard W. Hermes (Please print) Name: Date: 06/15/2009 (Please print) Signature: ~~t~`~~<.~L1~1~-cam/ Signature: The Property Assessment Appeal Board is an independent State Agency and hears appeals from a1199 counties and 8 cities across the State of Iowa. The Appeal Board bas no affiliation with your local Board of Review, assessor's ofrce or county attorney's office. This form must mailed in or delivered in-person to the Secretary of the Property Assessment Appeal Board within twenty (20) days of the postmarked date of the local board of review decision. (osrzoo9)