05th Street West 0426-0428
OF HISTORIC PRESERVATION
DU~UE, IOVVA..'iY ~
Architectural.Survey 1919
Photograph Roll 4 F.rame
'~"
Inventory
4'Z,~"'4.,~ U",J, +:lFfi+"
STREET ADDRESS
BUILDING NAME
PRESENT OWNER
Address
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
DATE OF CONSTRUCTION
Source
ARCHITECT/BUILDER
Source
PRESENT USE
DESIGNED USE
Source
ACCESSIBILITY
STATUS
BUILDING MATERIALS
Founda tion Ct~ S"'CQW\!:',
Walls r:, eL~ ( P~HJ!eD)
Trim ~Jt,l't::. (FL.JJ=( l)iU.l\'E~ )
Porch/Storefront l~jC~
Eaves/ Cornice W (JOt')
Roof ~$P\..l.Cl\,.rr
Chimney (s) F3I'(,A.~
c \e~O
DUfJ t.;~ '(
'PL)J? t,!))(
RES /UNR/afa>
<<C)UNOlwp
CONDITION
1(j 3 4
12 d) 4
1034
lcz,3 4
1 2U) 4
1(2) 3 4
1 2 3@)
1 2 3 4
123 4
DESIGN FEATURES
Style P~Q VICl2:1JtWW':)/t..
Details of Note:
,
DVP"'~~~
Interior Features:
Site Features:
Evaluation
I QUALITY Aesthetic
Historical
Rarity
II ENVIRONMENTAL STATURE
III CONTEXT Immediate
Broad
IV INTEGRITY OF FABRIC
1 2 3(4),.
1 2 3(!5
1 2Q) 4
1 2 Q)4
(J;)2 3 4
(D2 3 4
1 2(])4
ArchitecturalSigni.ficance
PROBABLE ADDITIONAL AREAS OF SIGNIFICANCE
REPRESENTATION IN EXISTING SURVEYS
Facade N/S/E/W By
Date
MODIFICATIONS/ADDITIONS:
I T"ll"\ ff1 ,91 l
r\J'if~A.,.,l""'"
COMMENT:
COMMENT:
~~~.I~
HABsINRHP
SURVEY CONSULTANT: Bruce M. Kriv'iskey, AICP
Date
~
~
~
C/)
H
H
j::I:j
Z
~
j::I:j
~
C/)
H
~
j::I:j
j::I:j
H
:>
t::l
t::l
~
j::I:j
C/)
C/)
t::l
H
C/)
~
H
D
H
Site Inventory Form
State Historical Society of Iowa
(December 1, 1999)
State Inventory No. 31-00477 D New rgJ Supplemental
rgJ Part of a district with known boundaries (enter inventory no.) _
Relationship: rgJ Contributing D Noncontributing
D Contributes to a potential district with yet unknown boundaries
National Register Status:(any that apply) D Listed D De-listed D NHL D DOE
9-Digit SHPO Review & Compliance Number _
D Non-Extant (enter year) _
1. Name of Property
historic name
other names/site number
2. Location
street & number 426-428 West 5th
city or town Dubuque
Legal Description: (If Rural) Township Name
D vicinity, county Dubuque
Township No. Range No. Section Quarter of Quarter
(If Urban) Subdivision_
3. State/Federal Agency Certification [Skip this Section]
4. National Park Service Certification [Skip this Section]
5. Classification
Category of Property (Check only one box)
IZI building(s)
D district
D site
D structure
D object
Block(s) _
Lot(s) see below
Number of Resources within Pro ert
If Non-Eligible Property If Eligible Property, enter number of:
Enter number of: Contributin Noncontributin
Q buildings 1 Q buildings
sites sites
structures structures
o~ects o~ects
Total 1 Q Total
Q
Name of related project report or multiple property study (Enter "N/A" if the property is not part of a multiple property examination).
Title Historical Architectural Data Base Number
The Architectural and Historical Resources of Dubuque. 1833-1955 fiffi
6. Function or Use
Historic Functions (Enter categories from instructions) Current Functions (Enter categories from instructions)
01 B-multiple Dwellinq
01 B-multipleDwellinq
7. Description
Architectural Classification (Enter categories from instructions)
Materials (Enter categories from instructions)
foundation Stone
09A04-side qable two stOry
walls
brick
roof Asphalt
other
Narrative Description (IZI SEE CONTINUATION SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED)
8. Statement of Significance
Applicable National Register Criteria (Mark "x" representing your opinion of eligibility after applying relevant National Register criteria)
DYes D No IZI More Research Recommended A Property is associated with significant events.
DYes D No IZI More Research Recommended B Property is associated with the lives of significant persons.
IZI Yes D No D More Research Recommended C Property has distinctive architectural characteristics.
DYes D No IZI More Research Recommended D Property yields significant information in archaeology or history.
County Dubuque
City Dubuque
Criteria Considerations
D A Owned by a religious institution or used
for religious purposes.
D B Removed from its original location.
DCA birthplace or grave.
D D A cemetery
Address 426-428 West 5th
Site Number 31-00477
District Number
D E A reconstructed building, object, or structure.
D F A commemorative property.
D G Less than 50 years of age or achieved significance within the past
50 years.
Areas of Significance (Enter categories from instructions)
Significant Dates
Construction date
1856-517 IZI check if circa or estimated date
Other dates
pre-1872
Arch itectu re
Significant Person
(Complete if National Register Criterion B is marked above)
N/A
Architect/Builder
Architect
Unknown
Builder
Unknown
Narrative Statement of Significance (IZI SEE CONTINUATION SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED)
9. Major Bibliographical References
Bibliography IZI See continuation sheet for citations of the books, articles, and other sources used in preparing this form
10. Data
or
11. Form Prepared By
name/title James E. Jacobsen
organization History Pays! Historic Preservation Consultinq Firm
street & number 4411 Inqersoll Avenue
city or town Des Moines
state IA
date June 15. 2004
telephone 515-274-3625
zip code 50312
ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION (Submit the following items with the completed form)
FOR ALL PROPERTIES
1. Map: showing the property's location in a town/city or township.
2. Site plan: showing position of buildings and structures on the site in relation to public road(s).
3. Photographs: representative black and white photos. If the photos are taken as part of a survey for which the Society is to be
curator of the negatives or color slides, a photo/catalog sheet needs to be included with the negatives/slides and the following
needs to be provided below on this particular inventory site:
Roll/slide sheet # 7471 Frame/slot # Z Date Taken Sept 2003
Roll/slide sheet # Frame/slot # Date Taken
Roll/slide sheet # Frame/slot # Date Taken
D See continuation sheet or attached photo & slide catalog sheet for list of photo roll or slide entries.
D Photos/illustrations without negatives are also in this site inventory file.
FOR CERTAIN KINDS OF PROPERTIES, INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING AS WELL
1. Farmstead & District: (List of structures and buildings, known or estimated year built, and contributing or non-contributing status)
2. Barn:
a. A sketch of the frame/truss configuration in the form of drawing a typical middle bent of the barn.
b. A photograph of the loft showing the frame configuration along one side.
c. A sketch floor plan of the interior space arrangements along with the barn's exterior dimensions in feet
State Historic Preservation Office Use Below This Line
Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs
State Historical Society of Iowa
Iowa Site Inventory Form
Continuation Sheet
Site Number 31-00477
Related District Number
Paqe 1
Name of Property
426-428 West 5th
Address
Dubuque
County
Dubuque
City
7. Narrative Description:
This property is located in the Cathedral Historic District. StyleNear: 1856-57? pre-1872,
Vernacular/ltalianate style two-story brick side gable duplex altered into Classical Revival style c.1900-
1910 (Palladian window in added shingled dormer, porch pillars).
Physical Description: rectangular plan (Assessor's drawing divides plan into two sections, front 32x42,
rear 24x42) with rear wing, raised stone foundation, paired brackets beneath eaves, end chimneys,
eaves extend beyond end walls, paired centered entries, stone lintels and sills, broad narrow hip roof
porch (5'6"x26) with square pillars on brick piers, glassed in. Broad gable roof front cormer contains
Palladian window set. Twin separate rear porches, 6x15'6" left, 6x14 right.
Alterations: windows replaced, porch replaced c.1900-10, concrete stoop. Permits note re-roofings in
1968, 1993, missing cove moulding replaced 1993.
Landscaping/Setting: parcel declines to the east and south, building fronts north.
8. Narrative Statement of Significance:
Building History: appears on 1872 birds eye view and 1884 Sanborn Map.
There are two candidate builders:
1. W. C. Mace/Mase, built a two-story brick residence, 22x30 with 16x16 rear wing for $1,800 in 1869,
apparently half of a duplex. He was deputy sheriff and as of 1870 was listed as living on 5th between
Bluff and Summit.
2. James Sullivan built a double brick dwelling, two stories plus basement, for $3,500 in 1856-57 "near
the Bluff on 5th." (Herald, March 8, 1857). This is the more probable builder.
3. he built a $20,000 residence on the corner of Bluff and 5th in 1894 (Herald, January 1, 1895).
4. He built three new residences on the same corner, for $6,500 in 1986 (contract letting) (Herald, May
24, 1896).
The John D. Sullivan Estate owned this property when it was sewered (no date).
Isabelle and Marion Ryder own pre -1955, Marion Ryder owns post-1959. Converted to apartments
c.1930.
9. Major Bibliographical References:
Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, 1884, 1891, 1909/36
Dubuque City Directories, 1902, 1915, 1925, 1934
Bruce Kriviskey, Dubuque, lowa--Architectural Survey 1978/1979, Atlas of City Wide and District
Survey Maps, Dubuque; n.p., c.1979
Dubuque County Assessor's Data
Newspapers and other primary sources as noted in the text above.
Historical photographs, Center For Dubuque History, Loras College
Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs
State Historical Society of Iowa
Iowa Site Inventory Form
Continuation Sheet
Site Number 31-00477
Related District Number
Paqe 2
Name of Property
426-428 West 5th
Address
Dubuque
County
Dubuque
City
10. Additional Documentation:
Legal Description: City Lot east 62.5' of west 170' Lot 614.
Map:
~~~~i~:e:~~~: I~..r~?l:~'
..-r'~;";~::' '. .';
!,
.fee 1/
I 0 'Iff /'~
~:i ;
[':;.
r.--
l~:~&oIev 1~r iOlV~
.': :." ~ '. " - .......... --..- .- ._~A ~
l~~' 1M ...--..
,
iC'::
~. :.'
......
CITr..:- LOT E-62.5' 1170'
t. ..
LAND RECORD
NO UTILITIES
NO SEWER
NO WATER
NO OAS
NO ELECTRICITY
NO &TREE'
DIRT STREET
SEMI.IMPR. ST.
NO SIDEWALK
LOW
t-IIOH
ROUOH
ROCKY
SWAMPY
HILLSIDR
WOODED
BRU8HLAND
TILLABLE
~'~:J.~i
-...
~0-?,.
fJy W,'LL
K~22JY
~.i:.... ~
"'------
~
614
~ 2~S' {, II
FRONTAGE AVERAGE
FlOURED DEPTH
~~
"<iiJJ.tJ:~~NO. JMC-=-...____ __.._.__~u___
UNIT
PRICE
:;'J."~;:!3.-2;L -./')z .... }}" ;,," , ~ '.
~'1
~~{~S~;:~;,;..~h
\}"
~...;,; ~'}
: ..
R EM A R.lKS
~..,~-;.:~'"
~,"''': ~':c' ...-: ~~;'.' '.z../'.,' ~.~
~;":'~ ~; . >f.,:" c'!..;,:~"'!Y$.:' ~ ,,~~, <,:':.t~~~
.~~'.";':' :", :~.'7; ':-;.. ~~.:::~t~
'>:'ASSESSM E.NY'- SU M MA~\)t~~
.~fy:r~~~gj
~;:;l
;... . ;.;~~
· ;:.)t::
::~ .
/4-A~6'O If/~ :~~,.. ....~ LAIID
'r'fti ..,,~ .
/"6?-~t.tJ/S.,o.t!- $'qL ~aA:"- ~ S""~f:Ji4 -A/,(!. CD BLOIS.
~ ~ ~
"
t
'. !
LAND VALUE COMPUTATIONS
PE~~~~T FR:>'::~lrT. COR.INFL. " TOTAL
" DEPA.
VALUE
7fJ .s/'~~
/~ 90$-0
· TN. J. II. CL&III,.HAW CO.i.APPRAI..... ·
aL&Y1ILAND. OHIO
TOTAL
LAND
CD BLOIS.
~
TOTAL
LAND
CI ILDI..
..
TOTAL
UNO
CD ILDIS.
..
TOTAL
LAND
01 BLDI..
...
TOTAL
LAND
oa BLOIS.
...
TOTAL
LAND
CD BLOIS.
...
TOTAL
LAND
0) BLOIS.
..
TOTAL
"~
",':->.~
.:~,f.~~
;:F\ '.. .i>i(;~~t~
,';';,''l: ~;:';-:
" ':'.:~;~.r.~ ~'L~
t;.~~
....>.."1
." .~;~~j
. ~1~ ':'" ,':.:~~i,c;j
:: >
~;,... .~...
>",;~'j.,..
;.,-,d
;;~..,';:~;<'~
.i'.i
.,.. ;~J
\ }:~~F ,~ ~~
.~ ~l
.'.. . .:. ,',.
..
.L?~'~
:.~..!t~:~
..'
.:::..
.' ..;' ...")."i.~"
'.~::
.l;';;:;::?f~
:'\~
:"'7l':J:
..;~~~::
!;::~,{i!~~ ~
..; .:.:;.:' .,.~~\~~#JI
.' ._.~_~~_.~. .,-,.' ,:':~'<>'::;:.Z;/
r'.. nA,~ ~-;~ ~..;.... JAY.. 7 ~p_ ~~.Y:'< ~- -~.\'.Jit.~~ ,l'X :/' ,- : '. '.';"i-J'4~~~
le~ OCCUPANCY /I.JJ~ wv. CONSTRUCTION , PHYSICAL VALU. ; Ac+UAlt\f ~~bc:~~
81.% IE GRAD.. AGE RIMODL.D ' CONDo '"'.01'., FUIICT, DI'. REPL. VALUE :~.
1)WPL~~I-;t ~'. BPK. -. .4rr~,~ ,~.: ~u,'" r ~~ .2 _"\~ ;. ~ ~.;'9'7 t:" .'"c:1 t?.' .v.'r ~,f / s: ~ .,.~t,.~
rr ..~-,~ )> ....;.:' .. , ..... . :,</....~:),.::?;
i' "'1,Y"
\ ;/,_:. ~i::
~ FOUNDATION ATTIC Be S~T. FIN. p--P.;.- ,- TOTAL }~;';:':'."'~'~'::
, nLE W ALLI ATTIC FL. a STAIRS y V .:',r
nlEIIT ILK..WALLS "N. AnlC AREA .5~tJ ,- I~ &}rf b r ~~~. ~/4- ~f BUILDING COMPUTATION ..
.~
COftCRETI WALLS FIN. BSMT. AREA b --- ~~~.~I!:',..
,. , ~~ --- .z ~ .s- .2.5. F. /..~," .s-
BRICI WALLS RECREATION RII.8SMT. ;J~ F6;
,/ - ~,--- 95 s. F. 3'. ~t:> ...g~~
. no... WALLI. GARACE IN BSMT. +-;..
.~ ~4- ::L~S-tJ . (., ~t:J
?d~.ff./1 s. F.
BAftMENT AREA ROOMS I +-3 s. F. ~ 4~q
'4 11J.. ~~ 88MT I 1st l' ~4- " a:~
EXTERIOR WALLS 2ND Y I 3110 /38 /. ,., I ~ 'I- s. F. ~,'.6- ~3~'
" S101"8 ON SREAnUNi INTERIOR FINISH j,-
" . . .
I SINeLE SIDINO , UT 2ND lID {}M't/.;~ r-- ~~2::---C.-.
WOOD IRrNOLES PINI L?,II p/.s... . ..:
COMPO. SHINeLES ENAMELED ,/ d fI,I..!', /?j7' ~ ' /. tJ AI F-,
STUCCO Oft FRAME . CHESTNUT
aTUC):O ow nLI OR C.B. HARDWOOD ./ ~ :~hf, 11:I 111. ,c- wAf' ~ · .,.',
FACI IRICK' VENEER PIAl ~V (ii?J ",f" t:Z!t!//it~ ).
FACI IR.'ON TILl OR C. I. WALL 10ARD BASE PRICE /3./7
COM. IRICK YINIIR "ATCH BIAD U$#A/' BStAT. A~EA
COM. IR. ON nLI OR C. 8. UNFIN.INT. "'" )..0 ,." t/j.",t: 1 .... ::i";
SOLID eoM. IRrCK t/ . ~ P WALLS
STONI Ylftl!R INT. COND. ", /",' ~ .sI()~1J1 r.;.. I /fay nJ'}PL;'P . .J-.A1~ 7" ./, Ii ..~
LAYOUT ,/ ./ f71,/P/,vc f, i ROOP' ~
BLANKET INSULATIOJt.~-t... ./ ~ .....
STR-UCTU RE _.4:~ l..r~ -~ '" f
ROOF INSULATION W~lI . HEATING P~/de," ,-.' FLOORS
ROOF TYPE HOT AIR ~/;;.~. ...7~. ~ .. . · ..:2. , . . irLOORIJ 'f.';'.
~ V .....,., . I ~-- /1'.. ~- 6'- r /3' :!/"
"IP crABLE STEA M ATTIC + . ~..2.
MANSARD FLAT HOT WATER LIGHTING a/ TILING II/CJ OUT BLOCS. 1 2 MEASURED BY BiJ~T. P'INIBH:t..\, ~j;~l\~:'-",' .... .:~~~.:$k:
GAMBREL VAPOR NO ELECTRIC LTG. BATH FLOOR a WAlftSCOT WALL FOUNDATION 4 ',f"f!">'-. ''':'
SATH FLOOR" WALLS INf,:..FINIS.... ;;:"':'.'~' .....\ .,,..,/;{
ROOFING AIR CONDo OAS LlOHTlNG PIER FOUNDATION ., -";,,,
ASPHALT SHINGLE V FL. OR WALL FURNACE PLUMBING BUH FLOOR ONLY SINGLE WALL SDG. LISTED BY ..lA1IN';O SVSTIM :;~ ,~~.~ J " 1-' I.~r;i)i~>
WOOD SHINGLE PIPELESS FURNACE 8ATH ROOMS .~ Y TOILET nM. FL. a WAINS. ooueLE WALL SDG.. 4- ,. + .\S.~:~.~~<
AUTO HTO~ UNtT"
AS8ESTOS SHINGLI NO HEATING SYSTE" ST. SHOWER 8ATH ROOM TOILET RM. FL. a WALLS SHINGLE WALLS
SLATI OIL BURNE'~:Z v STALL.SHOWER EXTRA TOILET RII. fL. ONLY ~ ~ AREA 'COIIP. BY FIR.P~ACEi o:'r.~~~~#~;t.~:t'
'. STUCCO ON . . .
COAL STOKER TOILET ROOMS CEMENT 8LOCK7/1/ )J ~ PLUMBING + "19;$Sl/:~'?
. FLOORS GAS BOILER WATER CLOSET EXTR~ KITCHEN WAINSCOT 8RICK '--" PRICED BY T
2ND TILlNO
8 1ST 3RD LAVATORY EX1'RA -' LOCATION CONe. FLOOR
CEMENT V F,REPLA'CES SINK NlMI\ ~ tI' GOOD iii" FAIR POOR EARTH FLOOR V TOTAL BASE PRlcr / S:O~ '.::;..
\ EART" . FIREPLACE STACK!r<;' I,. TOTAL ~b;iI::?i4
'IREPLACES \l'~ "
PINE SEPTIC TANK OR CESS PL. INCOME SHINGLE ROOF +~~ : .- vy. 9 4J1/$~t
\..HAROWOOD ,/ a--.' A-RnFICIAL FI.,EPLACES WATER ONLY ;,:;~, ~P/HO COST FACTOR
ROLL ROOflH9 ;;'--;j' q . '7,1'/1, 'i/
11NGLE fL INCINERATOR NO PLUMlltNG , ELECTRIC LIGHTS REPLACEMENT VALUE
~...
, . '-:':':"':S*~:'