Loading...
Response to Possible Termination of Municipal Cable FranchiseTHE CITY OF Dubuque ~T "~R ~ All-America City ~J 1J 1 I Masterpiece on the Mississippi 2007 TO: The Honorable Mayor and City Council Members FROM: Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager SUBJECT: Response to Possible Termination of Municipal Cable Franchise DATE: December 3, 2009 Mediacom has notified the City that they have converted their municipal cable franchise agreement with the City of Dubuque to a State certificate of franchise authority. With this action, the City is vulnerable to losing many of the requirements of the City franchise that protect consumers and provide a certain level of service and benefit to Dubuque residents. Assistant City Attorney Tim O'Brien, Public Information Officer Randy Gehl and Cable TV Coordinator Craig Nowack will make a presentation to the City Council on the current situation and identified options for the Mayor and City Council to give direction on a course of action. Mic ael C. Van Milligen MCVM:jh Attachment cc: Barry Lindahl, City Attorney Cindy Steinhauser, Assistant City Manager Craig Nowack, Cable TV Coordinator Randy Gehl, Public Information Officer THE CITY OF D B E MEMORANDUM Masterpiece on the Mississippi TO: Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager FROM: Craig Nowack, Cable TV Coordinator DATE: Dec. 3, 2009 RE: Response to Possible Termination of Municipal Cable Franchise INTRODUCTION The purpose of this memorandum is offer options for the City to pursue in response to Mediacom's asserted conversion of their municipal cable franchise agreement with the City to a state certificate of franchise authority. This action, allowed by State legislation enacted in 2007, may have terminated Dubuque's 15-year franchise agreement with Mediacom, adopted in 2005. BACKGROUND Iowa Senate File (SF) 554 was signed into law on May 29, 2007, despite opposition from the Iowa League of Cities, the City of Dubuque, and other Iowa municipalities. It was adopted into Iowa Code as "Chapter 477A Cable or Video Service Franchises." The stated purpose of the legislation was to "encourage competition in the provision of cable service and video service in this state, to encourage new providers of cable service and video service, and to provide consumers additional choices in cable service and video service." Under the guise of fostering competition in the video services industry, Iowa Code Chapter 477A employs a "one size fits all" philosophy in allowing a video provider to obtain astate-issued franchise in lieu of negotiating with individual municipalities. While the City supports the intent of the legislation (to provide additional choices for cable and video services in our community), the City of Dubuque opposed and lobbied against S.F. 554 and offered amendment language to clarify and strengthen the bill when it was in the Iowa legislature. In a worst-case scenario, the legislation allows an incumbent provider to, in effect, terminate an existing franchise agreement with a municipality when a competitor merely applies for a state franchise. No commitment to a timeline for competitive service or showing of technical /financial ability is required. That worst-case scenario may have now occurred in Dubuque. On Monday, November 23, 2009, the City of Dubuque received notice from Mediacom that the cable company had converted its municipal cable franchise agreement with the City to a state-issued certificate of franchise authority. Mediacom did this under Section 199 IAC 44.5, which states that an incumbent video provider may apply for a state certificate of franchise authority in a municipality when a competitive video provider applies for a certificate of franchise authority in that municipality. In April 2009, Phalanx Technology Holdings, LLC d/b/a as fyreSTORM Fiber & Cable was granted a state certificate of franchise authority. Its application included a list of 298 Iowa communities, among them Dubuque, where it someday hopes to offer video service. When the IUB approved fyreSTORM's application, with no defined timeline or proposed level or area of service, it potentially enabled Mediacom to convert its franchise agreement with Dubuque to a state franchise. On Monday, November 30, 2009, Public Information Officer Randy Gehl, Assistant City Attorney Tim O'Brien, and I met with two Mediacom representatives: Vice President of Public Affairs, North Central Region, Mike Kohler and local Area Manager Kathy McMullen. Mediacom requested this meeting to discuss a possible community partnership agreement in light of their state franchise. During the course of the meeting we discussed what provisions of our municipal franchise might stay in effect under the Mediacom offer now that the the company claims the municipal franchise is no longer valid. For the immediate future, Mr. Kohler verbally agreed that Mediacom would not change current practices/policies without giving the City 30 days notice. Dubuque's 15-year municipal franchise with Mediacom was approved in May 2005, following two years of negotiations. Compared to a state franchise, it is remarkably detailed in addressing the operation of Dubuque's cable system. The Dubuque franchise also contains numerous provisions not found in the Iowa law, such as a 10 percent senior citizen discount, one free cable drop to local schools and municipal buildings, the requirement that cable service must be available to all city residents, reasonable provisions to extend service to newly annexed areas, a broader definition of gross revenues, requirements for Mediacom to operate two of the public access channels, annual requirements to upgrade the cable system, and specific penalties and remedies for franchise violations. Cable television franchise fees are compensation for use of public right-of-way and, due to federal regulations, only apply to revenues from video service, not Internet or phone service. From a budgetary perspective, the impact of the state franchise will most likely mean less revenue from franchise fees. In Fiscal Year (FY) 2008, the City received $641,711 in franchise fees from Mediacom. In FY 2009, the amount was $679,800. DISCUSSION Because of the state franchise legislation, Dubuque's municipal franchise agreement is threatened, the level of supervision under the state franchise is minimal, and Dubuque residents, as yet, have no competitive options for cable service. When notified by Mediacom of the franchise conversion, Assistant City Attorney Tim O'Brien, Public Information Officer Randy Gehl and I contacted the law firm of Miller & Van Eaton, the City's telecommunications legal consultant. Based on our discussions, we firmly believe Mediacom's action is contrary to the intent of the state franchise legislation. The legislation is flawed and Dubuque's experience warrants amendments to the legislation. Furthermore, because fyreSTORM has NOT notified the City of Dubuque of its intentions to offer service as required by the state franchise law, we believe the Iowa Utility Board's granting of the state franchise certificate to fyreSTORM was improper and therefore Mediacom's conversion of its Dubuque municipal franchise may not be valid. The City has several options in responding to the asserted termination of our franchise: Negotiate an Enforceable Community Partnership Agreement with Mediacom Mediacom has expressed willingness to craft a "community partnership agreement" with the City of Dubuque that could preserve some of the provisions of our municipal franchise not required by the state franchise. However, Assistant City Attorney Tim O'Brien informs us that such an agreement may not be enforceable. He is researching and talking with our Washington attorneys about ways to ensure that it could be made enforceable. The City could continue to dialogue with Mediacom and explore such an agreement. 2. Recommend Amendments to the State Code The root source of the problem is a flawed state law that has produced the consequences we currently face. It is not clear if amending the law would be retroactive to our situation and our goal to restore our municipal franchise, but the City could offer suggested amendments to our legislators to correct the legislation so it achieves its intended purpose, increased competition for cable and video services in Iowa communities. This was already attempted in 2007 when the bill was being considered. Minimally, the law would be amended to keep the existing municipal franchise in place until a competitor is able to provide service to a predetermined percentage of the community, perhaps 25 percent. 3. Litigation Assistant City Attorney Tim O'Brien advises that the City could pursue a lawsuit against the Iowa Utility Board for improperly granting fyreSTORM a state franchise certificate due to their failure to notify the City of Dubuque of their intentions to offer services here. Additionally, fyreSTORM and Mediacom could b~ named in the suit. The goal of such litigation would be to restore our municipal franchise and underscore the need for amending the law. However, a victory on this issue would most likely be short-lived because another applicant, or fyreSTORM, could apply and follow procedures properly, resulting in the issuance of another certificate. The lawsuit could also challenge the method that the IUB is using to implement the law and could include a challenge to the law as being in conflict with Federal cable regulations. Finally, litigation, or its threat, could result in Mediacom's immediate termination of the lingering provisions/benefits of the municipal franchise and result strict adherence to only the minimal requirements of the state franchise. 4. Combination of Options 1 & 3 Options 1 and 3 could be combined by giving staff the authority to negotiate an acceptable and enforceable community partnership/settlement agreement with Mediacom with litigation as an adjunct to negotiations. An additional path to pursue, perhaps concurrent with the above options, is to commission another feasibility study regarding the formation of a municipal telecommunications utility. In November 2005, Dubuque voters authorized the City to establish such a utility by a 2-1 margin. RECOMMENDED ACTION This memorandum and related documentation is provided for your information. I respectfully request direction on how to proceed. Attachments: Mediacom Notification Letter of Nov. 20, 2009 and Attachments Iowa Code Chapter 477A: Cable or Video Service Franchises cc: Randy Gehl, Public Information Officer Barry Lindahl, City Attorney Tim O'Brien, Assistant City Attorney Mediacom Thomas J. Larse~z Vice President ofLegal & Public Affairs November 20, 2009 Michael C. Van Milligen City Manager 50 W. 13th St. Second Floor Dubuque, IA 52001 and Craig Nowack Cable TV Coordinator City Hall Annex 1300 Main Street Dubuque, IA 52001 Dear Sirs:. The purpose of this letter is to inform you that, effective October 9, 2009, MCC Iowa LLC ("Mediacom") converted the municipal franchise issued by the City of Dubuque (the "City" and/or "Dubuque") to a state issued certificate of franchise authority (the "State Franchise"). - As the attached information indicates, Mediacom filed a Notice of Service Area Revision (the "Service Area Revision") with the Iowa Utilities Board ("lUB") pursuant to 199 IAC 44. The Service Area Revision added the City as now incorporated or as may be annexed in the future to the service area of Certificate Number C-0002 currently on file with the Iowa Utilities Board. Specifically, the Service Area Revision was filed pursuant to 199 IAC 44.5 which permits the conversion of a municipal franchise by an incumbent cable provider in the event a competitive cable service provider applies for a certificate of franchise authority to operate within a municipality served by an incumbent cable provider. By letter dated February 20, 2009 (see attached), Phalanx Technologies Holdings ("Phalanx") provided Mediacom with 30 days' notice of its intent to offer cable television and video services within a service area that included the municipality of Dubuque. Since Mediacom filed the Service Area Revision more than 30 days after the date that Phalanx provided Mediacom with the 30 days' notice of its intent to offer service, the IUB was required to grant the Service Area Revision to be effective on the date the Service Area Revision was filed. By letter dated -- ----- --- - November- lb,--2009-(see-attached)r_the-IUB_notified_Mediacom_that__the_Service Area_ Revision was accepted as filed on October 9, 2009. Mediacom Communications Corporation 100 Crystal Run Road • Middletown, NY 10941 • 845-695-2754•Fax 845-695-2669 November 20, 2009 Page 2 of 2 Mediacom's new State Franchise is subject to the terms and conditions of Iowa Code Chapter 477A ("Chapter 477A"). While Iowa Code §477A.2 specifically terminates Mediacom's municipal franchise with the City, certain provisions of the terminated municipal franchise are still relevant in determining Mediacom's responsibilities going forward. Specifically, the prior franchise is relevant in determining 1) the percentage of the franchise fee going forward; 2) the fees related to public, educational and governmental ("PEG") access channels required to be paid going forward; 3) the support required fo be provided to the institutional network going forward; and 4) the number of PEG channels to be provided and activated going forward. In many respects, the obligations of Mediacom and the rights of City will be different under the State Franchise when compared with the terminated municipal franchise. For instance, Chapter 477A contains a more simplified definition of gross revenues, places restrictions on the payment of fees other than those set forth in Chapter 477A and the statute prohibits using PEG fees for anything other than support of PEG channels. Chapter 477A also. shifts the burden of operating PEG facilities and producing PEG content entirely onto the City, and permits Mediacom to collect and identify franchise and PEG fees as a separate line item on the regular bill of each subscriber. We certainly recognize that the shift from a municipal franchise _to a state issued franchise significantly changes the role the City will play in the administration of cable franchise related issues. Nonetheless, Mediacom has long been a key pat~tner to Dubuque, and we certainly want to continue in the role of good corporate citizen. To that end, Mediacom would be amenable to working with the City to form a community partnership that would provide the City and its citizens with benefits over and above what Mediacom is required to provide under the State Franchise. After you have had an opportunity to xeview the information outlined in this letter, please feel free to contact either Kathy McMullen or myself to discuss. cerely, homas J. Larsen Enclosures Cc: Kathy McMullen Milce Kohler CHESTER J. CULVER, GOVERNOR PATTY JUDGE, I.T. GOVERNOR ROBERT B. BERNTSEN, CHAIR KRISTA K. TANNER, BOARD MEMBER DARRELL HANSON, BOARD MEMBER November 16, 2009 Mr. Thomas J. Larsen VP, Legal & Public Affairs Mediacom Communications Corporation 100 Crystal Run rd. Middletown, NY 10941 RE: VCA-2008-0002 Dear Mr. Larsen: MCC Iowa LLC d/b/a Mediacom's Notice of Service Area Revision, as filed on October 9, 2009, has been accepted for filing. If you have any questions, please contact our Telecommunications staff at (515) 281-5477. Sincerely, Isl John Ridgway John Ridgway Manager Telecommunications Section dr cc: Danielle M. Benoit Womble Carlyle Sandridge & Rice 1401 Eye St. NW, 7t~' Floor Washington, DC 20005 35O MAPLE STREET 1 DES MOINES, IowA 5031 9-0069 / 51 5.281.5979 /FAX 515,281.5329 HTTP: //ww W. STATE. IA. US/t UB To see what state Government is accomplishing for Iowans, go to: www_resultsiowa.org e~c Tlrorr:as J: Careers Yrce Pr•esrdent of Legal & Pzcblia Affairs Octaber.8, 2009 Executive Secretary Iowa Utilities Board 350 Maple Street Des Moines, Iowa 50319-0069 Dear Ex~eutive Secretary: FILED WITH Executive Secretary October 09, 2009 IOWA UTILITIES BOARD VCA-2008-0002 On behalf of MCC Iowa LLC ("Mediacom"), I submit a Notice of Service Area Revision (the "Notice") for fililig with the Iowa Utilities Board pursuant to 199 ]:AC 44. Tlxe Notice is for MCC Iowa LLC as an incumbent cable provider and revises the service area of Certificate Number C-0002 ciuxently on file with the Iowa Utilities Board. The Kling of this Notice is made pursuant to 199 IAC 44.5 which permits the conversion of a municipal franchise by an incumbent cable provider in the event a competitive cable service provider applies for a certificate of franchise authority to operate within a niuiiicipality served by an incumbent cable provider. By letter dated February 20, 2009 (see attached), Phalanx Technologies holdings ("Phalanx") provided Mediacom with 30 days' notice of its inteirt offer cable television and video services within a service area that included the municipality of Dubuque, IA. Mediacom clu7ently holds a municipal franchise to serve Dubuque and desires to convent this municipal franchise to Certificate Number 00002. Since Mediacom is filing this application more than 30 days after the data that Phalanx provided Mediacom with the 30 days' notice of its intent to offer service, Mediacom has selected today's filing date, October 8, 2009, as the effective date of the Notice. A check in the amount of $50 was sent to the Iowa Utilities Board on October 2, 2009 and represents the required filing fee pursuant to 199 IAC 44.4(6). Should you have airy questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact ine at (84S)695~2754. 'oIY' ,,---, Thffnlas J. Larsen Enclosures co: Office of Consumer Advocate {with 3 copies of the Notice) Mcdiaoom Communieatians Coi•poratian 100 Crystal ]tun 12oad Middletown, NY 10941 • 845-695-2754•Fax 845-695-2GG9 Form must be filed electronically IOWA UTILITIES BOARD NOTICE OF SERVICE AREA REVISION, TRANSFER OR TERMINATION OF CERTIFICATE OF FRANCHISE AUTHORITY PURSUANT TO 799 IAC 44 (Applicable Filing Fee must be sent to the Board's Executive Secretary at 350 Maple Street, Des Moines, IA 50319-0069) Type of Modification (Check one}: Certificate Number: C-0002 FILED WITH Executive Secretary ~ Service Area Revision ($50 Filing Fes) p Transfer ($50 Filing Fee) October d9, 2009 ~[~ Termination ($25 Filing Fee) Name of Applicant: MGC Iowa dlblal: Medlacom IQWA UTILITIES BOARD Address of Applicant's Principal Place of Business: 100 Crystal Run Road VCA-20~$-~0~~ City: Middletown State: NY Zip: 10941 Contact information for person responsible for this notice: Name: Thomas J. Larsen Address: 100 Crystal Run Road Middletown, NY 10941 E-mall address: tlarsen@mediacomcc.com Phone: 845-695-2754 For Service Area Revision: Effect)ve Date of Revision: October 8.2009 Describe the modified senrlce area and municipalities to be served by Applicant, including unincorporated areas, In a manner complying with 199 IAC 44. Multiple service areas maybe described. Applicants certified by the Board as local exchange carriers pursuant to Iowa Code Section 476.29 may choose to refer to descriptions (including maps) of service areas on file with the Board, Description(s) may be submitted as an attachment if more space is needed. City of Dubuque, Iowa as now incorporated or may be annexed In the future. For Transfer: Name of Successor: Address of Successor's Principal Place of Business: City: d/b/a/: State: Zip: Names and titles of Successor's principal executive officers with direct authority over cable and/or video operations: Sucoessor's Customer Service Contact Information: Name: Address: Phone: If service area and municipalities to be served by Successor, including unincorporated areas, differ from the current certificate holder, describe here in a manner complying with 199 IAC 44. Multiple service areas may be described. Description(s) maybe submitted as an attachment if more space is needed, Effective date of transfer, if later than 14 business days after date notice is tiled: For Termination: Effective data of Termination: RevlsedMarclr 2009 VCA-2U09-QQ04 FILED WITH ®OLAN LAW ®FFICES, A Professional Corporation 136 36th St. Dr. SE Suite Al Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52403 Phone (319) 363-'r'88B' Fax (319) 3G3-7999 Febntary 20, 2009 Mediacom Commtw.ications Corporation 6300 Council St NE Cedar Rapids, IA 52402 Ladies and Gentlemen: Executive Secretary ~"C' March 16, 2009 IOWA UTILITIES BOARD Chris#opher K. Dolan Attorney at Law FILED WITH Executive Secretary October 09, 2009 IOWA UTILITIES BOARD vcA-zoos-ooo2 This o££ice serves as legal counsel for Phalan7c Technology Holdings, L.C., an Iowa Limited Liability Company. This letter will serve as notice as required by Section 199-44(1), Iowa Adrninistrative Code, that Phalanx Technology Holdings, L.C. will provide competitive cable television services and video services within a service area. which includes your incumbent service areas as outlined in Exhibit A, beginning on a date not less than thirty {30) days from the date of this Letter. Said services will be provided pursuant to a Certificate of Franchise Authority to be issued by the Iowa Utilities Board. Please talce notice accordingly. Respectfully submitted, Ss/Christopher K- Dolan Christopher I~. Dolan cc. Iowa Utilities Soard VCA-2009-0004 EXIBIT A FILED WITH Executive Secretary List of Municipalities and ILEG Exchanges far Cable and Video March 16, 2009 Franchise in Iowa by fyxeSTORM Cable and Fiber IOWA UTILITIES BOARD FILED WITH Cities Listed by Municipality: Executive Secretary Octaber 09, 2009 Cedar Rapids IOWA UTILITIES BOARD Hiawatha Marion VCA-2008-0002 Robins Fairfax Watford Palo Ely ' Mt. Vernon Lisbon Marengo Anamosa Vinton Iowa City ~' Coralville ' Universtiy Heights Davenport Bettendorf Eldridge Clinton DewitC Maquoketa Dubuque Charles City Mason City Waterloo Ceder Fa11s . . Evansdale Ames Des Moines West Des Moines Clive Windsor Heights Urbandale C'rrimes Johnston Altoona Ankeny Exibit A -Page 1 Berwick Pleasant HiII Ottumwa Oskaloosa Community's listed by IowaTelecom Exchange Adair Afton Agency Ainsworth Albert City Albia Alden Alpha Alta Vista Aplington Argyle Arispe Arlington Atalissa Attica Auburn Audubon Avoca Bagley Bayard Bellevue Benton Bladensburg Bladenburg Glencoe Bouton Braddyville Brandon Bridgewater Brighton Buckeye Bussey Centerville Ce~atral City Chariton Charlotte Chelsea Chillicothe Cincinnati Exibit A -Page 2 Clarinda Clearfield Colesburg College Spxings Collins Columbus Jmic#ion Conesville Conroy Crawfordsville Cresco Creston Cylinder De Soto Dedham Delhi Delta Denmark DeW~tt Dexter Diagonal Dolliver Donnellson Douds Dows Dunlap Durant Dyersville Earlville Eddyville Edgewood Eldon Elkhart Elma Emmetsburg Epworth Exira Fairbank Faixlield Farley Farmington Farson Fayette Fonda Fontanelle Fredericksburg Fremont Garvin Exibit A -Page 3 Gladbrook Glidden Grand Junction Grandview Gravity Greeley Greenfield Grinnell Halbux Haxper Harris Hazleton Hedrick Hillsboro Holy Cross Hoplcizaton Houghton Humeston Jamaica Janesville Keilerton Kent Keota Knoxville Lacona Lake City Lake Vew Lamont Lanesboro Lawler Le Claire Le Grand Ledyard Leighton Letts Libeziy Center Libertyville Lime Springs Linden Linn Grove Lisbon Little Sioux Lockridge Logan Lohrville Lone Tree ExibitA-Page 4 Lovilia Low Moor Lucas Luxembtu'g Lytton Macksburg Madrid Magnolia Malcom Mallard Manchestex Manson Marathon Martensdale Martinsburg Maxwell May City Maynard McCallsburg Melcher Melrose Melvin Milo Milton Mia~den Mingo Modale Mondamin Monroe Montour Montrose Moravia Moscow Mt. Ayr Mt. Pleasant Mt. Ui~i.on Mystic Nevada New I-laxnpton New London New Sharon New Vienna New Virginia Newell Newton Nichols Qalrville Exibit A ~ Page S Ocheyedan Olds Ollie Orient Osceola Otley Packwood Panama Pella Peoria Percival Persia Peru Peterson Pisgah Plano Pleasantville Pomeroy Portsmouth Prescott Primrose Promise City Protivin Ralston Randalia Randall Randolph Redding Redfield Rembrandt Richland Ricketts Rippey Riverside Riverton Rochester Rockwell City Roland Rolfe Rowley Russell Ryan Sabula Salem Schleswig Seymolur Shannon City Exibit A -Page 6 Shelby Sidney Sigonrney St. L~icas Story City Strawberry Point Sluianer Svvea City Tabor Thurman Tingley Tipton Toledo Tracy Trasr Troy Mills Ute Vail Volga Wadena Wallcer Wapello Washington Wancoma Wellsburg West Chester West Point What Cheer Williamsbuxg Williamson Wir~f'ield Woodbine Worthington Lxibit A -Page 7 Iowa Code 477A Page 1 of 11 CHAPTER 477A CABLE OR VIDEO SERVICE FRANCHISES Purpose of chapter; 2007 Acts, ch 201, § 1 477A.1 DEFINITIONS. 477A.2 CERTIFICATE OF FRANCHISE AUTHORITY REQUIREMENT. 477A 3 APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS -- CERTIFICATE OF FRANCHISE AUTHORITY. 477A.4 APPLICABILITY TO FEDERAL LAW. 477A.5 MUNICIPALITY RESTRICTIONS. 477A.6 PUBLIC EDUCATIONAL AND GOVERNMENTAL ACCESS CHANNELS. 477A.7 FEES -- FINANCIAL SUPPORT. 477A.8 CUSTOMER SERVICE STANDARDS. 477A.9 NONDISCRIMINATION BY MUNICIPALITY. 477A.10 PROVIDER DISCRIMINATION PROHIBITED. 477A.11 APPLICABILITY OF OTHER LAW. 477A.12 RULES. 477A.1 DEFINITIONS. As used in this chapter, unless the context otherwise requires: 1. "Board" means the utilities board within the utilities division of the department of commerce. 2. "Cable operator" means the same as defined in 47 U.S.C. ~ 522. 3. "Cable service" means the same as defined in 47 U.S.C. ~ 522. 4. "Cable system" means the same as defined in 47 U.S.C. ~ 522. 5. "Competitive cable service provider" means a person who provides cable service over a cable system in an area other than the incumbent cable provider providing service in the same area. 6. "Competitive video service provider" means a person who provides video service other than a cable operator. 7. "Franchise" means an initial authorization, or renewal of an authorization, issued by the board or a municipality, regardless of whether the authorization is designated as a franchise, permit, license, resolution, contract, certificate, agreement, or otherwise, that authorizes the construction and operation of a cable system or video service provider's network in a public right-of-way. 8. "Franchise fee" means the fee imposed under section 477A.7. 9. a. "Gross revenues" means all consideration of any kind or nature, including but not limited to cash, credits, property, and in-kind contributions received from subscribers for the provision of cable service over a cable system by a competitive cable service provider or for the provision of video service by a competitive video service provider within a municipality's jurisdiction. Gross revenues are limited to the following: (1) Recurring charges for cable service or video service. (2) Event-based charges for cable service or video service, including but not limited to pay-per-view and video-on-demand charges. (3) Rental of set-top boxes and other cable service or video service equipment. (4) Service charges related to the provision of cable service or http://coolice.legis.state.ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=billinfo&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009 Iowa Code 477A Page 2 of 11 video service, including but not limited to activation, installation, and repair charges. (5) Administrative charges related to the provision of cable service or video service, including but not limited to service order and service termination charges. (6) A pro rata portion of all revenue derived, less refunds, rebates, or discounts, by a cable service provider or a video service provider for advertising over the cable service or video service network to subscribers within the franchise area where the numerator is the number of subscribers within the franchise area, and the denominator is the total number of subscribers reached by such advertising. This subparagraph applies only to municipalities that include this provision in their franchise agreements as of January 1, 2007. b. "Gross revenues" does not include any of the following: (1) Revenues not actually received, even if billed, including bad debt. (2) Revenues received by any affiliate or any other person in exchange for supplying goods or services used by the person providing cable service or video service. (3) Refunds, rebates, or discounts made to third parties, including subscribers, leased access providers, advertisers, or any municipality or other unit of local government. (4) Regardless of whether the services are bundled, packaged, or functionally integrated with cable service or video service, any revenues derived by the holder of a certificate of franchise ,authority from services not classified as cable service or video service, including, without limitation, revenue received from telecommunications services, revenue received from information services, revenue received in connection with home-shopping services, or any other revenues attributed by the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider to noncable service or nonvideo service in accordance with the holder's books and records kept in the regular course of business and any applicable rules, regulations, standards, or orders. (5) Revenues paid by subscribers to home-shopping programmers directly from the sale of merchandise through any home-shopping channel offered as part of the cable services or video services. (6) Revenues from the sale of cable services or video services for resale in which the purchaser is required to collect the franchise fee from the purchaser's customer. (7) Revenues from any tax of general applicability imposed upon the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider or upon subscribers by a city, state, federal, or any other governmental entity and required to be collected by the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider and remitted to the taxing entity, including but not limited to sales or use tax, gross receipts tax, excise tax, utility users tax, public service tax, and communication taxes, and including the franchise fee imposed under section 477A.7. (8) Revenues forgone from the provision of cable services or video services to public institutions, public schools, or governmental entities at no charge. (9) Revenues forgone from the competitive cable service provider's or competitive video service provider's provision of free or reduced-cost video service to any person, including, without limitation, any municipality and other public institutions or other institutions. (10) Revenues from sales of capital assets or sales of surplus http://coolice.legis.state.ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=billinfo&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009 Iowa Code 477A Page 3 of 11 equipment. (11) Revenues from reimbursements by programmers of marketing costs incurred by the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider for the introduction or promotion of new programming. (12) Directory or Internet advertising revenues including but not limited to yellow page, white page, banner advertisement, and electronic publishing. (13) Copyright fees paid to the United States copyright office. (14) Late payment charges. (15) Maintenance charges. 10. "Incumbent cable provider" means the cable operator serving. the largest number of cable subscribers in a particular franchise service area on January 1, 2007. 11. "Institutional network" means the system of dedicated fibers, coaxial cables, or wires constructed and maintained by an incumbent cable provider which is reserved and dedicated by the municipality for noncommercial purposes. 12. "Municipality" means a city. 13. "Percentage of gross revenues" means the percentage set by the municipality and identified in a written request made under section 477A.7, subsection 1, which shall be not greater than five percent. However, if the incumbent cable provider is a municipal utility providing telecommunications services under section 388.10, "percentage of gross revenues" means the percentage set by the municipality and identified in a written request made under section 477A.7, subsection 1, which shall not be greater than an equitable apportionment of the services and fees that the municipal utility pays to the municipality, or five percent, whichever is less. 14. "Public right-of-way" means the area on, below, or above a public roadway, highway, street, bridge, cartway, bicycle lane, or public sidewalk in which the municipality has an interest, including other dedicated rights-of-way for travel purposes and utility easements. "Public right-of-way" does not include the airwaves above a public right-of-way with regard to cellular or other nonwire telecommunications or broadcast services or utility poles owned by a municipality or a municipal utility. 15. "Video programming" means the same as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 522. 16. "Video service" means video programming services provided through wireline facilities located at least in part in the public right-of-way without regard to delivery technology, including Internet protocol technology. "Video service" does not include any video programming provided by a provider of commercial mobile service as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 332, or cable service provided by an incumbent cable provider or a competitive cable service provider or any video programming provided solely as part of, and via, a service that enables users to access content, information, electronic mail, or other services offered over the public Internet., Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, §2, 15; 2008 Acts, ch 1062, ~1 477A.2 CERTIFICATE OF FRANCHISE AUTHORITY REQUIREMENT. 1. After July 1, 2007, a person providing cable service or video service in this state shall not provide such service without a franchise. The franchise may be issued by either the board pursuant http://coolice.legis. state.ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=billinfo&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009 Iowa Code 477A Page 4 of 11 to section 477A.3 or by a municipality pursuant to section 364.2. 2. a. A person providing cable service or video service under a franchise agreement with a municipality prior to July 1, 2007, is not subject to this section with respect to such municipality until the franchise agreement expires or is converted pursuant to subsection 6. b. Upon expiration of a franchise, a person may choose to renegotiate a franchise agreement with a municipality or may choose to obtain a certificate of franchise authority under this chapter. An application for a certificate of franchise authority pursuant to this subsection may be filed within sixty days prior to the expiration of a municipal franchise agreement. A certificate of franchise authority obtained pursuant to an application filed prior to the expiration of a municipal franchise agreement shall take effect upon the expiration date of the municipal franchise agreement. c. A municipal utility that provides cable service or video service in this state is not subject to this section and shall not be required to obtain a certificate of franchise authority pursuant to this chapter in the municipality in which the provision of cable service or video service by that municipality was originally approved. 3. For purposes of this section, a person providing cable service or video service is deemed to have executed a franchise agreement to provide cable service or video service with a specific municipality if an affiliate or predecessor of the person providing cable service or video service has or had executed an unexpired franchise agreement with that municipality as of May 29, 2007. 4. A competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider shall provide at least thirty days' notice to each municipality with authority to grant a franchise in the service area, and to the incumbent cable provider, in which the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider is granted authority to provide service under a certificate of franchise authority that the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider will offer cable services or video services within the jurisdiction of the municipality, and shall not provide service without having provided such thirty days' notice. 5. As used in this section, "affiliate" includes but is not limited to a person that directly, or indirectly through one or more intermediaries, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with a person receiving, obtaining, or operating under a franchise agreement with a municipality to provide cable service or video service through merger, sale, assignment, restructuring, or any other type of transaction. 6. If a competitive cable service provider or a competitive video service provider applies for a certificate of franchise authority to operate within a municipality, the incumbent cable provider may,,at its discretion, apply for a certificate of franchise authority for that same municipality. Such application shall be automatically granted on the same day as a competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider files a thirty days' notice of offering service as required pursuant to subsection 4. The franchise agreement with the municipality is terminated on the date the board issues the certificate of franchise authority to an incumbent cable provider. The terms and conditions of the certificate of franchise authority shall be the same as the terms and conditions of a competitive cable service provider or a competitive video .service provider pursuant to this chapter and shall replace the terms and conditions of the franchise agreement previously granted by the http://coolice.legis. state.ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=billinfo&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009 Iowa Code 477A Page 5 of 11 municipality. Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, ~3, 15; 2008 Acts, ch 1062, ~2 Referred to in ~ 477A.7 477A.3 APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS -- CERTIFICATE OF FRANCHISE AUTHORITY. 1. The board shall issue a certificate of franchise authority under this chapter within fifteen business days after receipt of a completed application and affidavit submitted by the applicant and signed by an officer or general partner of the applicant. The application and affidavit shall provide all of the following information: a. That the applicant has filed or will timely file with the federal communications commission all forms required by the commission in advance of offering cable service or video service in this state. b. That the applicant agrees to comply with all applicable federal and state statutes, regulations, and rules. c. That the applicant agrees to comply with all applicable state laws and nondiscriminatory municipal ordinances and regulations regarding the use and occupation of a public right-of-way in the delivery of the cable service or video service, to the extent consistent with this chapter, including the police powers of the municipalities in which the service is delivered. d. A description of the service area to be served and the municipalities to be served by the applicant which may include certain designations of unincorporated areas. This description shall be updated by the applicant prior to the expansion of cable service or video service to a previously undesignated service area and, upon such expansion, notice shall be given to the board of the service area to be served by the applicant. e. The address of the applicant's principal place of business and the names of the applicant's principal executive officers. 2. The failure of the board to notify the applicant of the completeness of the applicant's affidavit or issue a certificate of franchise authority before the fifteenth business day after receipt of a completed affidavit shall constitute issuance of the certificate of franchise authority applied for by the applicant without further action by the applicant. 3. The certificate of franchise authority issued by the board shall contain all of the following: a. A grant of authority to provide cable service or video service in the service area designated in the application. b. A grant of authority to use and occupy the public right-of-way in the delivery of cable service or video service, subject to the laws of this state, including the police powers of the municipalities in which the service is delivered. c. A statement that the grant of authority provided by the certificate is subject to the lawful operation of the cable service or video service by the applicant or the applicant's successor. d. A statement that the franchise is for a term of ten years, is renewable under the terms of this section, and is nonexclusive. 4. A certificate of franchise authority issued by the board is fully transferable to any successor of the applicant to which the certificate was initially issued. A notice of transfer shall be filed by the holder of the certificate of franchise authority with http://coolice.legis. state.ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=billinfo&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009 Iowa Code 477A Page 6 of 11 the board and the affected municipality and shall be effective fourteen business days after submission. The notice of transfer shall include the address of the successor's principal place of business and the names of the successor's principal executive officers. The successor shall assume all regulatory rights and responsibilities of the holder of the certificate. Neither the board nor an affected municipality shall have authority to review or require approval of such transfer. 5. The certificate of franchise authority issued by the board may be terminated by a person providing cable service or video service by submitting written notice to the board and any affected municipality. Neither the board nor an affected municipality shall have authority to review or require approval of such termination. 6. The board shall only have the authorization to issue a certificate of franchise authority as provided in this section, and shall not impose any additional requirements or regulations upon an applicant. Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, §4, 15 Referred to in § 477A.2 477A.4 APPLICABILITY TO FEDERAL LAW. To the extent required by applicable law, a certificate of franchise authority issued under this chapter shall constitute a "franchise" for the purposes of 47 U.S.C. § 541(b)(1). To the extent required for the purposes of 47 U.S.C. § 521--561, only the state of Iowa shall constitute the exclusive franchising authority for competitive cable service providers and competitive video service providers in this state. Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, §5, 15 477A.5 MUNICIPALITY RESTRICTIONS. 1. A municipality shall not require a holder of a certificate of franchise authority to do any of the following: a. Comply with a mandatory build-out provision. b. Obtain a separate franchise. c. Pay any additional fees, except as provided in this chapter. d. Be subject to any additional franchise requirement by the municipality, except as provided in this chapter. 2. For purposes of this section, a "franchise requirement" includes any provision regulating rates or requiring build-out requirements to deploy any facilities or equipment. 3. Section 364.2 shall not apply to a holder of a certificate of franchise authority issued pursuant to this chapter. Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, §6, 15 477A.6 PUBLIC, EDUCATIONAL, AND GOVERNMENTAL ACCESS CHANNELS. http://coolice.legis.state.ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=bill info&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009 Iowa Code 477A Page 7 of 11 1. Not later than one hundred eighty days after a request by a municipality in which a competitive cable service provider or a competitive video service provider is providing cable service or video service, the holder of the certificate of authority for that municipality shall designate a sufficient amount of capacity on the certificate holder's communications network to allow the provision of a comparable number of public, educational, and governmental channels that the incumbent cable provider in the municipality has activated and provided in the municipality under the terms of a franchise agreement with a municipality prior to July 1, 2007. If no such channels are active, the municipality may request a maximum of three public, educational, and governmental channels for a municipality with a population of at least fifty thousand, and a maximum of two public, educational, and governmental channels for a municipality with a population of less than fifty thousand. a. The public, educational, and governmental content to be provided pursuant to this section and the operation of the public, educational, and governmental channels shall be the responsibility of the municipality receiving the benefit of such capacity. The holder of a certificate of franchise authority shall be responsible only for the transmission of such content, subject to technological restraints. b. The municipality receiving capacity under this section shall ensure that all transmissions, content, or programming to be transmitted by the holder of the certificate of franchise authority are provided or submitted to the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider in a manner or form that is capable of being accepted and transmitted by the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider, without requirement for additional alteration or change in the content, over the particular network of the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider, which is compatible with the technology or protocol utilized by the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider to deliver services. At its election the municipality may reasonably request any cable service provider or video service provider to make any necessary change to the form of any programming, furnished for transmission, which shall be charged to the municipality, not to exceed the provider's incremental costs. The municipality shall have up to twelve months to reimburse the cable service provider or video service provider. The provision of such transmissions, content, or programming to the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider shall constitute authorization for such holder to carry such transmissions, content, or programming, at the holder's option, beyond the jurisdictional boundaries stipulated in any franchise agreement. 2. Where technically feasible, a competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider that is a holder of a certificate of franchise authority and an incumbent cable provider shall use reasonable efforts to interconnect the cable or video communications network systems of the certificate holder and incumbent cable provider for the purpose of providing public, educational, and governmental programming. Interconnection may be accomplished by direct cable, microwave link, satellite, or other reasonable method of connection. A holder of a certificate of franchise authority and an incumbent cable provider shall negotiate in good faith and an incumbent cable provider shall not withhold interconnection of public, educational, or governmental channels. 3. A court of competent jurisdiction shall have exclusive jurisdiction to enforce any requirement under this section. http://coolice.legis. state.ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=billinfo&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009 Iowa Code 477A Page 8 of 11 Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, ~7, 15 477A.7 FEES -- FINANCIAL SUPPORT. 1. a. In any service area in which a competitive cable service provider or a competitive video service provider holding a certificate of franchise authority offers or provides cable service or video service, the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider shall calculate and pay a franchise fee to the municipality with authority to grant a certificate of franchise authority in that service area upon the municipality's written request. If the municipality makes such a request, the franchise fee shall be due and paid to the municipality on a quarterly basis, not later than forty-five days after the close of the quarter, and shall be calculated as a percentage of gross revenues. The municipality shall not demand any additional franchise fees from the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider, and shall not demand the use of any other calculation method for the franchise fee. b. All cable service providers and video service providers shall pay a franchise fee at the same percent of gross revenues as had been assessed on the incumbent cable provider by the municipality as of January 1, 2007, and such percentage shall continue to apply for the period of the remaining term of the existing franchise agreement with the municipality. Upon expiration of the period of the remaining term of the agreement with the incumbent cable service provider, a municipality may request an increase in the franchise fee up to five percent of gross revenues. c. A provider who is both a competitive cable service provider and a competitive video service provider shall be subject to and only be required to pay one franchise fee to a municipality under this subsection regardless of whether the provider provides both cable service and video service. d. At the request of a municipality and not more than once per year, an independent auditor may perform reasonable audits of the competitive cable service provider's or competitive video service provider's calculation of the franchise fee under this subsection. The municipality shall bear the costs of any audit requested pursuant to this subsection, unless the audit discloses that the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider has underpaid franchise fees by more than five percent, in which case the competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider shall pay all of the reasonable and actual costs of the audit. e. A competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider may identify and collect the amount of the franchise fee as a separate line item on the regular bill of each subscriber. 2. If an incumbent cable provider pays any fee to a municipality for public, educational, and governmental access channels, any subsequent holder of a certificate of franchise authority that includes that municipality shall pay this fee at the same rate during the remaining term of the existing franchise agreement with the municipality, even if the incumbent cable provider elects to convert to a certificate of franchise authority pursuant to section 477A.2. All fees collected pursuant to this subsection shall be used only for the support of the public, educational, and governmental access channels. 3. a. If an incumbent cable provider is required by a http://coolice.legis. state.ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=billinfo&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009 Iowa Code 477A Page 9 of 11 franchise agreement as of January 1, 2007, to provide institutional network capacity to a municipality for use by the municipality for noncommercial purposes, the incumbent cable provider and any subsequent holder of a certificate of franchise authority shall provide support only for the existing institutional network on a pro rata basis per customer. Any financial support provided for an institutional network shall be limited to ongoing maintenance and support of the existing institutional network. This subsection shall be applicable only to a cable service provider's or video service provider's first certificate of franchise authority issued under this chapter, and shall not apply to any subsequent renewals. For the purposes of this subsection, maintenance and support shall only include the reasonable incremental cost of moves, changes, and restoring connectivity of the fiber or coaxial cable lines up to a demarcation point at the building. b. For purposes of this subsection, the number of customers of a cable service provider or video service provider shall be determined based on the relative number of subscribers in that municipality at the end of the prior calendar year as reported to the municipality by all incumbent cable providers and holders of a certificate of franchise authority. Any records showing the number of subscribers shall be considered confidential records pursuant to section 22.7. The incumbent cable provider shall provide to the municipality, on an annual basis, the maintenance and support costs of the institutional network, subject to an independent audit. A municipality acting under this subsection shall notify and present a bill to competitive cable service providers or competitive video service providers for the amount of such support on an annual basis, beginning one year after issuance of the certificate of franchise authority. The annual institutional network support shall be due and paid by the providers to the municipality in four quarterly payments, not later than forty-five days after the close of each quarter. The municipality shall reimburse the incumbent cable provider for the amounts received from competitive cable service providers or competitive video service providers. c. This subsection shall not apply if the incumbent cable service provider is a municipal utility providing telecommunications services under section 388.10. 4. A franchise fee may be assessed or imposed by a municipality without regard to the municipality's cost of inspecting, supervising, or otherwise regulating the franchise, and the fees collected may be credited to the municipality's general fund and used for municipal general fund purposes. 5. To the extent that any amount of franchise fees assessed by and paid to a municipality prior to May 29, 2007, pursuant to a franchise agreement between a municipality and any person to erect, maintain, and operate plants and systems for cable television, exceeds the municipality's reasonable costs of inspecting, supervising, or otherwise regulating the franchise, such amount is deemed and declared to be authorized and legally assessed by and paid to the municipality. Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, ~8, 15 Referred to in ~ 477A.1 477A.8 CUSTOMER SERVICE STANDARDS. 1. The holder of a certificate of franchise authority shall http://coolice.legis. state. ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=billinfo&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009 Iowa Code 477A Page 10 of 11 comply with customer service requirements consistent with those contained in 47 C.F.R. § 76.309, and shall maintain a local or toll-free telephone number for customer service contact. 2. The holder of a certificate of franchise authority shall implement an informal process, for handling inquiries from municipalities and customers concerning billing events, service issues, and other complaints. If an issue is not resolved through this informal process, a municipality may request a confidential nonbinding mediation with the holder of a certificate of franchise authority, with the costs of such mediation to be shared equally between the municipality and the holder of a certificate of franchise authority. Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, §9, 15 477A.9 NONDISCRIMINATION BY MUNICIPALITY. 1. A municipality shall allow the holder of a certificate of franchise authority to install, construct, and maintain a communications network within a public right-of-way and shall provide the holder of a certificate of franchise authority with open, comparable, nondiscriminatory, and competitively neutral access to the public right-of-way. 2. A municipality shall not discriminate against the holder of a certificate of franchise authority in providing access to a~municipal building or through a municipal utility pole attachment term. Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, §10, 15 477A.10 PROVIDER DISCRIMINATION PROHIBITED. 1. The purpose of this section is to prevent discrimination among potential residential subscribers. 2. A competitive cable service provider or competitive video service provider holding a certificate of franchise authority shall not deny access to any group of potential residential subscribers because of the income of residents in the local area in which such group resides. 3. a. A video service provider operating under a certificate of franchise authority that is using telecommunication facilities to provide video services and has more than five hundred thousand telecommunication access lines in this state shall extend its system to a potential subscriber, at no cost to the potential subscriber, if all of the following criteria are met: (1) The potential subscriber is located within its authorized service area. (2) At least two hundred fifty dwelling units are located within two thousand five hundred feet of a remote terminal. (3) These dwelling units do not have cable or video service available from another cable service provider or video service provider. b. This subsection shall be applicable only after the first date on which the video service provider operating under a certificate of franchise authority is providing cable service or video service to more than fifty percent of all cable and video subscribers receiving cable or video service from the holders of http://coolice.legis.state.ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=billinfo&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009 ' Iowa Code 477A Page 11 of 11 certificates of franchise authority and any other providers of cable or video services operating under franchise agreements with a municipality. Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, X11, 15 477A.11 APPLICABILITY OF OTHER LAW. 1. This chapter is intended to be consistent with the federal Cable Act, 47 U.S.C. ~ 521 et seq. 2. Except as otherwise stated in this chapter, this chapter shall not be interpreted to prevent a competitive cable service provider, competitive video service provider, municipality, or other provider of cable service or video service from seeking clarification of any rights and obligations under federal law or to exercise any right or authority under federal or state law. Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, §12, 15 477A.12 RULES. The board shall adopt rules necessary to administer this chapter. Section History: Recent Form 2007 Acts, ch 201, X13, 15 Previous Chapter 477 Next Chapter 477B x~. http://coolice.legis. state.ia.us/Cool-ICE/default.asp?category=billinfo&service=IowaCode... 12/3/2009