Loading...
Claim by Steve Ruden Copyrighted September 17, 2018 City of Dubuque Consent Items # 2. ITEM TITLE: Notice of Claims and Suits SUMMARY: Kelly Casperson for vehicle damage, Jerald Kinsella for property damage, Gerald Klein for property damage, Abby McGrane-Ralston for vehicle damage, David Prince for vehicle damage, Steve Ruden for property damage, Daniel Scott for property damage, Sisters of the Presentation for property damage, Brock Tyner for vehicle damage, Morgan Weaver for vehicle damage, Doug Winner for vehicle damage, Suit by Michael and Jacqueline Wood for vehicle damage/personal injury. SUGGESTED DISPOSITION: Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Refer to City Attorney ATTACHMENTS: Description Type Casperson Claim Supporting Documentation Kinsella Claim Supporting Documentation Klein Claim Supporting Documentation McGrane-Ralston Claim Supporting Documentation Prince Claim Supporting Documentation Ruden Claim Supporting Documentation ScottClaim Supporting Documentation Sisters of the Presentation Claim Supporting Documentation Tyner Claim Supporting Documentation Weaver Claim Supporting Documentation Winner Claim Supporting Documentation Wood Lawsuit Supporting Documentation � �,, � ��� . � �� . .� � GLAIM AUA�NST TH� CIT`� QF DUBU+QUE, tt3WA L"��` - � hThis wrttten report +constitutes your claim against the City of Dubuque, lowa. You shoutd � complete this form in futt and attach any additionai information that supports your c[aim, a � i The Ctaim musf be fi�ed wi�h the �ity Cierk at City Ha(�, 5�0 W. 93� S#., Du�u+��a�, IA �20�11a �t ' will fhen�be referre€� by the �ity Council #o th� ap�ropriate dep�artmer�t f+ar investigation. � Once tha# investig�tion i� completed, a report and r�commea�dation witl be subm�tted to #he Ci�y Councit. You wiCE be pra�vided w�th a co�ry of fihat report�nrd rec�mmendatEan. � ii THE FINAL DEC�StON ON At�L CLAIMS IS MA�E BY THE CITY' Gt3UNCtL. NQ EN[�"L.C�I�EE C}� iI TH� CITY OF DUBt1QUE HAS TME AIJTHORITY TO MAKE ANY REPR��ENTA7IL'9N TC! YOU ;� AS Tf,?1NHETHER Yt�UR CLAIIl� W�L.L UR U�dlLL NflT BE PAID. i; ',; '!. Name of ClaFinant: .� �� � i� 2, Address: ��� � �� � �� 'Ii City: � Sta#e: .��. �ip°�,�� �,�� � j �� f � �.��, .,.�� , �. i 3. Telephone Number: ` _ „'� � . l � ; °`4. �ate of�ncident: �'" �'�'`�� '�+`"� �.� � � ��� ' ��,�',��� I '� � �� ; ,:�:.,�" �� ,�,.-0 `� i 5. Time of tnc�d�nt: �".,� ��� �' .� � ,�� � � �� �� ' - � � . � - ...�..-� . � 6. . Location Qf lncident{Be s�eci�+�): � � ���„� , .,,� � � � I; ° ,'; 'i i� i 7. DES�RIBE ACGIDENT C3R QCCURI�ENCE THAT CAUSED tNJURY QR DAl�AGE. (Give j� full details up�n which you base your claim. If a City employee was involved, give th� I! emptoyee's nam+e � �,'I .� r , l � . � � � 8. What were weather conditions lake? �� � � 9. Give name and address of any wifinesses: , ° ..� . „� ,��- d 10. D1CI PC>�IC@ lIIVE,'5'�i��t�'�' (If so, give names of offic�rs.j f � f � w � � 1"�. Wa� anyan� in,�urect? (t#sa, give narr�es, addresses, and exfen�a€injuriesj. � "� - � � � � i S� � � � ' � � ,. I J � ' , � I� °12. 1Mas ar�y damage dc�r�e to prc��er�y? �ff so, describe properfy and the extent o� I damages. Attach estimates of dar�ages c►r describe basis for ascertaining ext�nt of 1 damage.} . � :�� � ���� _ , '�' � '�� � ;� . �� , 13. What other damages do yau claim, if any? . � l � 94. Have you been carr�pens�ted for any par# or alt of yaur claim by any insurarace ��! company? (If so,give r��sme and address af insurance company and amount paid.) '�! � f�� 'I �� � I; 't5. V#/hat amount do �ou cfaim #rom the City of�ubugue? � F .- :;::• �..� �� � .:. ` � �a � , � 16� hy dc� you clai�n the Gi#� ca C?ubu ue is spc�rtsibt�? � ; � ;,,, t` ��;,�G�^��r��..P' � # � � � r � � I 17. Have ou mads an claim a ainst am m�� else fior dama es as a resuft���his incident? ; Y Y 9 y g {if yes, g�ve name an�t ad+dress.) I �''�� � 18. !f the answer to Quest�on 17 is yes, have yrau received any payment from #hat saurce, � and if so, in wh�at amaunt? . � � ,�� � Dateed at Dubuqu�, �or��t#�is��` eia�y e�f � , 2ip � � , �. �� ��` .�► �� � (signature� �y��� ��°��� �,��. �J�,� �� (� � �Print Name) ,::� 4:-:-0 .�. �---� c��a _..�. `,�= �u� _�.- _�< _ � �,k—, - �,� .�a =� �?`a �a.p �.'� ;._� ;, 4..; . (R�v. 5l�I$) ,�� cr' --� ,` - , r�m �.;� � !�i_. :�. � � ;� � � � � ��� : � � ___ ___ ,;_ _____ ,,� ..--- _.- ---_ -- - _.... _. ____.__._ .. ._ ' __._ ._._._ _______w______._ ------ � � r �--�--�, � � ,� ,� x _ � ; � ,. , �.�- _..__ __ _ � __ -..,�`, __ � _ __.._ . _ _ . _. . 'r ` ���'�.r�,..�'`�" a. y'�_ � r-��„.,,-'� y.�*�,�,� �' q �:� W ;I i� � _... ___ . .___ _.__.__ . _.___ ._ ,_..�__ .___. � , — --- _ __._. _ —.... _ _.._ _._. _ __._ . __... ----- _._... . _`'���_✓_.°_��,.✓�.-�__�°'`�_. �..�,..�'"��.''��.�°��,� .���.... �,;,, f�v�� ___ I, �j���� !J � / � �,�� , � . _'___"...,_ __..,"'.._ _..e. _.y�r��.,��-�1.u/ _.r_CC'_._�_+'�/t'�.��'°_�a9_.YLJ f......f..r�'_.�.��"r�4��'4w°`(�„y!}�.._._ .._._.:�___... _ .R�.._ _,._... . , _ .......,_. �� i ' �1 N _.__ . ___ _ .� __ -�.��''�.�.. _____�_.� ___._. _ ___�'--�'�_.... ._., _. _ __ ._ . r�~�i� � _ ��s t � i. . °a. � .: .� �� � ' - _..- --. _,__ _._ ._._ _ ._ . _:� ._- ._ ___ __ __ � .__ .. _� } ---�-"��___.� . _ _. � _._ _ _- . . ._'__ �'r��__-��`��'r��.��'�.�✓+ .__.��.�1''-�_ :_�!���"'�..�'_.__._ _,:. __- -�i:�''+�:�'. �''�' . _ t°, �; I _ ������ ,� �,,,� ; _,r� � �i _ . __ __.�a'�"'"_. �� _ _ __ . __ '- �__ ___��i"`��`'./ ____ �.�����.����._�..�''''..�'�� � '� -� ._ _. . __._ . _.._. . ._______ . ._.--. __.. . _ __.�._--_�._____ ___ ; � +- u.._.. ��_.�'.`�__. _:. ._��.�,'�'�,,r:._. . '-e^` i � Z � ._... ' , __._ . __..__ .�'-'�°..^�''"-�'� -_��!'��a�`�..'"'��_.�."�.��'''�� �°"�"'��,�,�+���, _ _ ....r�_- - __._�.��'.�'r"��""�'�,,..,�°'____ _..__� � �� � ; i __ � � �, i .� _...�-�� � -----_ _,�- ___. ---�,�__�^-�'�c � �� �� __ __ - �- - ��.._.... .__._._ _._ __._ .. .. _., - -� -_ � ..._..- � Li' _ _._.__ _._�,___��'� -��''-���.�_���_ _ ._�__ _ ___. _ ,�.._ __. _ _,.._..__ .__. _ _____. _ ... __ ; _.�°'�� __.----. .__ _. ._i ._.____ _. _ __ G���� 'I _._ - -._ _ __.___.._ _ __ . ____. �_ _ ___ ___ _ ___. _. . � ,; li _ . ..._. __ _ ___ '; ._. __. , __ _ _- - -___. _.__.__._ . . __. __ . ______ . ..�_... . __ __ . . __. . .___. . __ �i -- __._. _..---__ .T_ ._--_� _ .___ _,._____- -- -_.._ .___._ _____ ... _ . .._______.__. ..__ , ......�. _. ._._ il _ _ _ ,_ __..._ __ . : � � ... _ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � d �� e I� _ . . _ ___ _ �- _ _ _ _.. _ _ _.. __.._ . .__. _ _ _ _. �� . . ,� .:�� • ���- ?_. _ _. _ _ - _ __ ___ _._. __ __ __..__ �� � � . � ' _ � _.._ ___ __ -� __ ___ _ � �__. �,�.�a��-,°'�,'-�-� ._� _ ____ _.__ ._._ _ __ . _ __. � . �M1 ,{I �,_,.� • , � t'� �.� :,t;��„� -_ ___ _.-- ___ ___ __ _ _ __ _ i� . _ ___ ___ . __ _ . � i ;; � __. _- __ _ _ _ __ _ ... . _ __ __._ � .._.. _. ��.�. _ _ ����'_ ___ 'y'_ ���r,.�.. ..._____ � .__ ___ .__. .... _._ _ _ _ _. . . _ _ ,i `.�,'" ' _ q� i , � '�-'°�.-� �" �.��'�°.� �,�"'�`,.-�i`�r.,,,.�`� ����- �,,' _ . �'_ - _ �<�_. __..__ .___. ____ .__. . _.._. _..._�_ _� _�--_ _1�". _. _ ___ _. ._ . ; _ ___.__. ___ , . .._ _ _. �� �_ ���`� �-�'� �-_� � _ _�4-°`�J`��--�'_ �; f � :.� �� _ _ _ __ . _ __ _ ____ . ` __ i ._.. _ ��.. _.._ ___ _._ __._ __.. __. ____. __ _._ _ _..,_ ii ___ _._ _ _. �� � _ _: . .���...��� �._-.��� _�.,���_._ ,__.__.. _ ___. _.._ _ --_ .. ._._. . _... _ i _. .� �.--• �,' �� __ __ _. _ _ _ ,. _ :� ° �, _. _ _____ _��>_ _ r � _ _ _ __ -- ._ _ _. ___ .. . .. � �, � _ �. �',.� ��= � �; --__ -- , t �, y , � . , � , __.__._ _ . .._._ . . .. ... ��.' _�� �� �._. .� .. .._ . ; _.._ . __._- ,.._._.. ... ._.. __ . � __... . __... _ . __ _... _ I � ;,.�.. ,__ _... . �� I ; _._ _ _. �._. ___ _. ; ___ _ _. ``� g� tf���''�� �'��-�..1'"{����__ _ __... ..____. __ _— _ _ _ -_�.. _ _.._ _ i # w __ ___ �,,+� _ . ._ .- - � _. _._ •-_� _ .._, . � � �' � � _ __ _ _ . _ - - __ _ _ _ R ,�` F � I ____ __ - C��„��_� _.. � ��._ ��t-'" t,,_��;��°''P�'_. . ' _ _ � f � „a"' � __ __ . _..._. _ __ ��'.�_���__ _ �,�.__ __....__. _.,___.�.__ ,.._, ._.__. __ _ ___ ___ _ ___ .._ ___ . . _ _ _ ._ ; ; � ;, _ . _._ _. .. _. _._._. _.... _...._.. y __.._.._. _.-- _ . _...... _..._.. .... ._._.._...._.__.._... _.... __ � � L � � � 4 I / , � " � � � e li y � __. . ___. ..._ ..__ __ P� _ �._. __ __ _. _ _ _ . q ��� �� � �'��e;,��```�.�..- ���t'�, ;�"""�t`.�"�� `�r .,__ ___ _._.___ _ __. __ _ _ _ _� - - .._.. . � _ -- . . � . ._ ___ . . ,. __.� __. . � �; ___ , f�l � - �.1.,.�m.✓.._ ,��sk��" _�� �c�""_ "" .._G- _. _ '� ____ _. _ �. __ . _ _._. � / V / , . ` ' � q ___ . .��'�.�J..___ �.}��'���____ _�:.__ _. .���/__�. _t�,.�"L.s�-�a__�,,�,�� ",.�"'�`������� _ . _ _ _ rr, . . `Kal������!'�f y � , . ....._... . ..__......__. ._„V � . ....._. . _ ..: .. _. . / ,....,s fr...f._'^�_.,..._ _ _.'N_� �li . . . _..".__ ....__.. _....... _ __.._ ........,..� .. ......al _ ..__..._ . .... __ _ . �'����'`"�'�.x�'..�!'-—��._.. _ __ _._. . .. _ _ ...: ___ r'�'_ _ _. _.. _ ._ __: . _�"�"�"+�"'' i� � � , ��� '� _��-�_�_ w� _ _..�'�. � _ . _.�,��—����_ -�`�4..—:�_��� —� . � _ i .__ _ �_ __ __�� � �� � , , ___ �� _ __. _ , , . __ _ _ _ __,.-��� ������_.�''��`'�''� �`'�-_. _-_ � __.. ._ P x s. i� __..___.. . ._.�./""�_ �._.._. .. .�_ ��.���_... _ ..,�t`��,,._ _ ,_ ___ r.,�' �� �� ._.. . _ . _ _ � � � , , � _. � . _ __ __ _... _ _ . � °� _ __ .��`- . _ . ___ - -- - � , y _. . . ___ _ __. . __ _ ; � _ . __ _ _- -,. � i _ ��_.�`.�',��_���?'�- -„�'--�,�:' - _- ,-_����=-? . .,:�-'� _,_ _ _ , � ���`'��,`'� � � � __ __. .�� I y �� 1 . ........_, �............. �,...�g_ �� . ..._ .. . . � � �'' . . � .. ,.._ ...._ .,__ . ...._.. _. __... _ �� .�,. .... : .� . .�.. . .. ...... _I.......... ..._.. .... i _ �_ __ __��' ___ _�_ � __ �_. _ � _ �_ _ . _ . _ _ _ __ _ _ � _ ` �. __ �-�� ____ �- _ '. �_ ___���- _� ._ _ _ _ ___. � _ �.���___�`� �� � , _ . __ �_ _:._ ��� ..� � :- _ �� _ __ � ��� a � ; __ _ . _ _� _ __ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ . _ � � a ,�" � � �� I �# t p ��r /� �'� .v^"'"r� � '"!,,g !" � i .Cf�e°� .d�'+�t s" �� �" If . _ __:.:;__�""__._�... � '—`"' __- ___� .�!�r'r�:.:' �_:..1.�'"?rP� �t��e°"��?� �..._ ,f'}� �� �e? �?'=n �^�,�`a;' fi� � � Q J� --� M F 1 _ I �_ . ___ _ ,_. . _ - - � � � j� �..J�.C'� ���.?, t�,�t°�.�a°°� ._. s � ,�,��,,,��`3.'P...*' ,',�t'3.' s^'�' l.,��''P a��tl����r k.:._c�%�.i� li . .._.....,. ._______ �_,... .. ' ,�g� y � . f w�,��. �...����,_'.``�..�__,., __ .... �� -s:�*r. i p _ !...t� v - . _ _N .�'9' .,..�^" ._„e,.n�....>�' �P > �.�� � ,�;� 3 �� ".�� g ,!__ _ __._ ` ,fi /_;'r..�` , '� .r �.. �__ _.__._. ,. . �_ �,. a _ _._.. _ __.__ __..___ _.____..._. .. _...__ _... .. ___. � �I _ _. __.. _ : I� __. __.__ . _ _. ..;_._ ._.....__.. . _.__ ..__ .. . __. ._.. _.__ _____ __ N ..._.___ .._____.. ____.._ __.-- . _____.__ __._ . _ �� ____ _ ._. __ _______ _ _.__ _.._ __ _ , . _ k I' ._ __ .._...__. _ . _ _ ___. ____ .. __ .. . _ __ _.. _._. _ d __ .._ .__ _ _ ___ _ __. . ,___ _._. ___ il , _ � � �� � � � � �y 8 � N 1 9 �� � � , p _ . __ _ __ _ __..__ __. ___ ___ __ _ . � _ __ _ _ _ _ _ 1 P . _ ___ _`���'`�' �.� �._�"._��-�.�._ �' �_ .� �����.���y.��'. '� ___ __ _ ___ _ �� .- -- - -- - � , �� _ - . __ _____ . _ _ _� k .,�'�.�- - - _` _ ��-"__ -�.�� .__�.-�� � �.��.___ _ __ .__. _ _ . � . �� � __ _ _. . _ __. _ �'� _ � � , .�� _ _ - _ __ _ _ � _ _ -- _:_ :_ _ . _.. _ ._ � _ ; � � _ . ___ ., ;:�����L,,� -. _ . :. __ _ . __ . ,.__--. . . .. ...... . ... _ _ _._ _. _ _._ . _ _ ._.. ____ _ __ _ _. i � � • w _._ __.._ . . _ __. .�_ ���..__�--����°' �_ _ _�"� _��� ___. ___.._._���_ _ __ _ __ _. , .�� � �°"�� ___ .. ___. . ___ __ __ -�� �,���� _ _ ._ _ _ _ . __ , - � . _ ��°-�-. !, _ �� _.__,�__ �_�. ._ � �� - ; _�,�.���'_��`.�_ _���..��_ �� �� ___. _ _ _ _ .� _�_ _ _ , �_ � � g � _ _ . �� . .._._.__ __.......- --- _.:.., _..�r_.✓."'....,__�""'�_..�� .___ . � ! � � n .... _ ° r �i . ., _......,. .._ . ._ � _......_._._..-.__..._.__. .__..,,...__ __ __._.. :_..._.__. ._.__,.....__ �...._.�. .__,._. ..__._. ,_... . ? ''���� � � �� � � ___. __..... . . . �.. _..__. _.,,,�.!_.,c���,�.d.�_� -���"��'- �,x,.�,, -� � _�` -- -. _._. _ _. . _. _ _.__. . .__ _..__.. _ � _ _ , __-___. ,..._._ . . �.�-° �, __ . . _._ .'_ _ ... ;.��_�`�_�.�''����.._._���"���� �,���A�'��.�t. ... ��� ___ i � .. _ :�. „ � . ' �.'' ____ �. _ _ _�;_._ ---_ -�--��-���`�� ` .,_ �. ..___ , ,' _.,_ _� _.__� _.___ ____:__._-- --_ ----_. ,_ ..__.. ___ �:___ .___ ,___�;� �� � �_._ _�._. �...� _.__.__ �� �`�f �,�,,� ��� ___�___ . _^-�.� - ���'`- A �` . .�� �i '.t. : y.. . . � // . -.... . . ..., . ;Yd.. � .,�X '+�' .�. _._...� ,�, �...... ,i �* ��L / V _........_"_ '_. ._.....,._, __:� . ._._.__.,. ""_� �_�__._. ..� ,_ . .-%d-/-.-..-:'_'-� . _.;._�,_...,_:�� ._..__,___�.,. �.._._�..�.. . . . . "i ' a "'._ �....a �__..—�._.. ,. _. �-�� ...._,:-J_.__._....,- .. - : . "'. .. ..,..,...._. ,....... , _... ._....... , ....... . ,_... _.__..... ��K���----�..._ . .� � � . . , . ' ..� ._.. ! .... .... . ` � . . ....._ _-•� ... � -' i. . __._ , � _ .._,.__ __.,_.__._:_. �_ _ - --- ---_.:.._. ._ . .._.�� . _ _._... _ _._ . __ _.... _. _.. __ II �`� �`y���� ".�',.�' ___._�m���-...-i�-..�€t✓C.�°' , '�-�'��_��,�.,r✓ ��"'»� __ --__ _._ _r._ ._.. .. ._ -----G�'- --- . �i �__ _ _.__-- - - .. _ `�'`��_�-�t-�-___.___;��.�-�-''�r �'.-' �.�..���__ _r��./_ _ � -- __ __����._._. .._ __ ___ _ . __ ' �� ' _.. . __ _ .:;...��--������:� ���.���_ �_ . �_�.-�--j._ ��__ ____ _ _. ___ ��� ___ �� li � -• � �" � _ . . , � .� �� _._. �_� _ .. �_,�.,�...�-��. "°"' _. ._ .. . . __._..�� . -�. _,,�m��� II Copyrighted September 17, 2018 City of Dubuque Consent Items # 3. ITEM TITLE: Disposition of Claims SUMMARY: City Attorney advising that the following claims have been referred to Public Entity Risk Services of lowa, the agent for the lowa Communities Assurance Pool: William Baum for vehicle damage, Jerald Kinsella for property damage, Gerald Klein for property damage, Lynn McCormick/Partners Mutual Insurance for vehicle damage, Abby McGrane-Ralston for vehicle damage, David Prince for vehicle damage, Steve Ruden for property damage, Daniel Scott for personal injury/property damage, Sisters of the Presentation for property damage, Morgan Weaver for vehicle damage. SUGGESTED DISPOSITION: Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Concur ATTACHMENTS: Description Type ICAP Referrals Staff Memo 'THE CITY C?F � ��...J .V _�� L � � � 0 1\ � 1 \ � �J � ) �� MGZS�BI"�22G2 OYl t�ZC'L�iSS1SS2�)Z � q i� � TRACEY STECKLEIN � � PARALEGAL �I I� p ii To: Mayor Roy D. Buol and j; Members of the City Council � i� DAre: September 6, 2018 ;i ��; RE: Claim Against the City of Dubuque by Sfeve Ruden i! i'' ,; Claimant Date of Claim Date of Loss Nature of Claim ,; �; ;� Steve Ruden 09/05/18 Every Rain Event Property Damage '' This is a claim in which claimant alleges that during each rain event, water runs from the ,� I� street onto claimant's property at 820 Mt. Loretta Street, flooding the basement and yard. ' '; This claim has been referred to Public Entity Risk Services of lowa, the agent for the lowa �I Communities Assurance Pool. � . � cc: Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager �; Jon Dienst, Civil Engineer II ',i Steve Ruden !,; II � � � � � � � � OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY DUBUQUE, IOWA � SUITE 330, HARBOR VIEW PLACE, 300 MAIN STREET DUBUQUE, IA 52001-6944 � TE�EPHONE (563)583-4113/F,vc (563)583-1040/EMai� tsteckle@cityofdubuque.org �