Claim by Eagle Window & Door Copyrighted
February 4, 2019
City of Dubuque Consent Items # 3.
ITEM TITLE: Notice of Claims and Suits
SUMMARY: Paula Beecher for vehicle damage, Robert Decker for
vehicle damage, Eagle Window& Door, Inc. for property
damage, Patricia and Lyle Galliart for property damage,
John Kirk for vehicle damage, Kelly Keenan O'Rourke for
vehicle damage.
SUGGESTED DISPOSITION: Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Refer to City
Attorney
ATTACHMENTS:
Description Type
Beecher Claim Supporting Documentation
Decker Claim Supporting Documentation
Eagle Window& Door Claim Supporting Documentation
Galliart Claim Supporting Documentation
Kirk Claim Supporting Documentation
O'Rourke Claim Supporting Documentation
_ � V
� �-a�i C��:�' -
CLAI�V1 AGAIN�T TH� CITY (�F DUBUC�UE, IOWA � ���.P����`j
�..�,�
� �
T�is written repor� constitutes your c�aim,againsfi the City of Dubuque, lawa. You shouId
complete this form in fuil ar�d a#ta�h any additic�n�l inforrr�ation �ha#supports your+c�aim.
The Claim rnust be fi{ed with the City C1erk afi City Ha�l, 50 V11. '13xn ��., Du�ugue, IA 52001. lt �
� wi11 tl�en be referr�d by the Ci�y Council to the apprc�priate d�par-�ment fc�r investigafia�n. �
Once that investigafiion is comp��ted, a repor� and recommenda�ior� will be submi�ted to the ,
Gi�y Council. Yc�u wi11 be provided with a copy of that repart and re�omm�ndatic�n, �
�
THE F[NAL D�CISIQN C}N ALL CLA€]VIS 1S MADE BY THE GITY CUUNCIL: NQ EMPLUYEE C1F
TNE CITY CtF' DUBtJQUE HAS THE AUTHOIRITY TC} MA�{E ANY I�EPRESENTATION TC3 Y011 '�
AS TO WNETHER Y�UR CLAIM W1L.L OR WIL� NOT BE PAID.
_ � . . �
1. , Name of Claimant: ����--� ��,�-- � � � �- - ;
�
Z. Addr�ss: ���� ����.:,���. �t�l�I� �
City: �����,,�� �tate: �� Zip: �C� � �
�
3. Telephone Numb�r: � �c���� �� ��'f �� `� �� _ _ ��
,
;
4. Date of �ncident: ��! � � ��� `�' �;�5���:���� �
�
, � ;
5. Tim� of lnciden�: `..�.' ����, ;
, ,�
, ,
. ( p } �`��� ��'� �- _��.�� �����-���� �
6. Locat�on �# lncident Be s ecific : �'(�.��,� ��j 11� ,
�
���t-.� �,�.;�1����d �'����;`�. �
7. DESCRIBE A�C[DENT C}Ft �C�URRENCE TI�AT CAUSED 1NJUR'Y OR DAMA�E, {Giv�
full details tapon which you ba�e y�ur claim. If a Ci�y employee was involved, g9ve the
employee's name.�
�
�.��- ��'� ���...:- .� ���� ��' '
�,1��4�.,,,. �--- i c���.�c.��'�r� �. �.jr, ��t ���" c� l���-�-�. �' � ��f�
��1�.��`�--�,�,,' `� C�o,�� ����i�y�try� �'� . �' a� tl`�f�'1 � �C3C`�' 1`�3f�� � Cli"'.� �yl��T'�t`�
`� �itY�.- Cf6}�#i�'4 , . �(.��'. . �,,.,...-
8. 1Nhat w�re wea�h�r con�at�ons��? ��.�' i ��
9. Give nam� an�l ad�r�s� o# ar�y wi�nesses. �,,l���
1Q. Did police invesfi�ate? {1f so, giv� names of c�fficers.}
� �-f `�" °�'�`l t�F���' V'"� ��i �� � �"'t���'�tl��� ���' �i� �CC� C.���t`�c�4r�`-�' . �
��c� ��"�i,a"� �
'�'�. Was anyone injur�d"? {If s�►, c�ive names, addresses, and ex�ent of injuriesj, . �
� C�
�� --
�12. Was any .d�mage done to property? -{If so, d�scribe praperty ar�d the extent of
damages. Attach estimates of damages or describe basis for asc�rt�ining �xfent flf �
damage.} �
s _ r
�-�.� ���.�.1'�� ��'�;� �C K�.� t1 �- C�;{ t'�t �a.c� �
�3 ��G��... ��, � ' �
� �
'13.���tl�hat c�ther damages do you ciaim, if�ny? � ��C��� �..��,�'� �-c����-`f�s�i� r
� 1� � ; . �
�:��' ���� �, � ���.� �� ��� t�c.�c,.��'�'� ������ ��� �
� _ �
7
�[4. Have yc�u b�e� compen�ated for any par� or �ll of �rQur claim by any insurance �
compan�r? �If�o, giv� namie and a�dress of i�s�trance compa�y and arnount paid.) �
� � � � � �
4
15. What �mou� c�c� Yo�u��irn��om fihe �ity of �ubuc�ue? �
� � . • �
16. V11h�� do you +cl,aim the City c�f Dubuque�is re�s�po�r�sibl���� M1 � � ��.. � � `��- �
�.�.1°�t �t�v�cf.. . i � " ��, . � .s=' ,�
���6` ��, �t.�.J f�'�i��'0� ,
� '�7. Have yota made any claim aga��s� �nyone else fc�r damages as a result of this incident? �u
(If yes, give n�me and address.} �
� �
�
�
18. 1� ��� answer to Questicrn '17 is yes, �ave you received at�y paymen� frorn thafi source, �
an�1 if so, in whafi amount? �
, �
�a�et� a� i�u3�uque, lawa this day of , Z�i
. �Sic�nature}
���� � �
��.�t-- � 64��..�� �prin� Name}
�
� �
� � � �
-���
-� � �a..$
� ��- `�' ��
(�ev. 51`98� � �' � �
C,; �'s�
� � � �s�
� �
�
Confid+�ntial
Tt�is carnmunication anc{ any attachments rnay cant�in information_ wh'rch is confidentiai
and privileged by law and is for the use of the designated recipient, If yau are not the
intend�d recipient, yora are hereby nfltified that yau I�ave received this c�,m'municatia�n in
error, and that any review, disclosure, clissemination, r�istribu#ion or copying of ifis contents
is prohibited. Piease natify City of Dubuque immediately by telephflne at �563}-58�-4'120 of
your receipt o# these ifiems and des�roy the communicatian and any attachments
immedia#ely. �urther disclosure of this it�formatian may vicilate state and federal
restrictions. � '
�
� Canfid�t�tial informatian may include �he €ol�owing: � � � �
1} SociaJ Security Number(s) !�
2) M�dicallHeafth Informatian ;;
3) Pers�nneliDisciplinary Inf�rrnatic�n � � � � � �
4) Bank Account lnformatian ;i
5j Financia( Inf�rmation ;
6) Credit Card Numbers ;
�d
I
If any document�ti�n yau d�sire to submit to the City of Dubuque contains any �f the ifiems abave �
this cover sheefi musfi be attached directly to the confidential infarmation and indicate the type af
informatian tha# is included. �
l
h
h
l
�
1, , her�by certify that the �tt�ched dacuments �
;,
include the folf wi protected information: ;
�,
�
� Social Securifiy Nut�ber(s) Bank Account fnformation �
�
Medical/Nealth lnfarmation Financial lnformatic�n �
Personnel/Disciplinary lnforma#ion Credit Card Number{s) �
,
! understand that this information may be distributed within the City organization or to agents of the �
Cifiy for processing �nci I hereby authorize the City to act accordingly fiaking all precautions to
. protect my ir�formation from unnecess�ry distribution.
�
� �
_ ��--- /��- ��� �
s����t aat� �
,
�
�
�
I
�
�
3
Ea�le Winda►w and Doc�r Sew�r I.ine Back Up t
_ _ f
�
R�einnbursement Request �
�
a
12J11-Sewer line backed up into the building,sewage coming up thraugh the floor drains in office �
restrc�oms,quality lab,and plant restrooms.�ity was called,said leveis were low at the time, but �
�
showed higher readings fram their meter the night before.
�
Mr. Roater called to come clear the line from our plant to the city m�in.They said there was a blockage ;
the last few feet right aff the city m�in, {$631.19} `
�
i
Service Master of Key City was called to clean all restrooms and quality lab floors where backed up �
occurred.{$84.8.59) � �
�
i
Carpet tiles r�placed in affice haflway,from backup that had oceurred (1 box-$304)
i
Eagle Window and Door Labar: Problem reso(ution anc!clean up,7 hrs @$45 per hr{$315) �
a
,
�
I
12f 19-Sewer line 6acked up again into the building,sewage coming up through the flaor drains in
afifi�e and plant restrooms.City was call�d,said levels were low at the time, but showed higher readings ;
from their meter the night befiore again. ��
j
Mr. Roc�ter calEed to come clear liroe from plant to city main.They again said there was a blackage the
last few feet right off the city main. {$667.31}
Service Master ofi Key City was called to clean all bathroorn floors that backed up. {$321.77� '?
'1
�
Eagle Windaw and Door Labor:4hrs�a �45 per hr($180} i
;
ij
,,
�
We are rec�uestin�reimbursement from t�e City of Dula�que for the�ollcawin�exqenses: �
�
4
Mr. Roater: {631.19+667.31}=Tota11,2985
�
Service Mast�r�f Key City: ($848.59+321.77)=Total$1,170.36 �
i
1 Box of Carpet TiEes:$300 {
t
Andersen Window Labor Reimbursement R�quest: 11Nr� ��5 per hr.=Tatal$4.95 �
�
Total Reimbursement Request:��y2G3.$'�r �
�
�
�
,
�
i
�
�
Copyrighted
February 4, 2019
City of Dubuque Consent Items # 2.
ITEM TITLE: Disposition of Claims
SUMMARY: City Attorney advising that the following claims have been
referred to Public Entity Risk Services of lowa, the agent
for the lowa Communities Assurance Pool: Paula Beecher
for vehicle damage, Robert Decker for vehicle
damage, Eagle Window& Door, Inc. for property damage,
Patricia and Lyle Galliart for property damage, John Kirk for
vehicle damage, Kelly Keenan O'Rourke for vehicle
damage.
SUGGESTED DISPOSITION: Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Concur
ATTACHMENTS:
Description Type
ICAP Referrals Staff Memo
THE CITY C7F
,
� E MEMORANDUlVI
Masterpiece on the Mississippi
� I
1 RACEY jTECKLEIN � �
PARALEGAL � �
�
To: Ma or Ro D. Buol and ��
Y Y �
Members of the City Council
DATE: January 24, 2019
!i
RE: Claim Against the City of Dubuque by Eagle Window & Door �
Claimant Date of Claim Date of Loss Nature of Claim �
Eagle Window & Door 01/18/19 12/11/18 & 12/19/18 Property Damage
�'���
This is a claim in which claimant alleges that the sewer backed up onto claimant's i�j
- property. ;;
�
This claim has been referred to Public Entity Risk Services of lowa, the agent for the lowa �
Communities Assurance Pool. �
�
cc: Michael C. Van fVlilligen, City Manager ;
John Klostermann, Public Works Director �'
Brandon Schardt, Eagle Window& Door ��
�
�
�
�
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY DUBUQUE, IOWA
SUITE 330, HARBOR VIEW PLACE, 300 MAIN STREET DUBUQUE, IA 52001-6944
TE�EPHONE (563)583-4113/F,vc (563)583-1040/EMAi� tsteckle@cityofdubuque.org