The URL can be used to link to this page

Request to Rezone Property Located at W. 32nd Street & N. Grandview Ave._Ehlrich Properties Copyrighted February 18, 2019 City of Dubuque Public Hearings # 1. ITEM TITLE: Request to Rezone Property Located at W. 32nd Street& North GrandviewAvenue SUMMARY: Proof of publication on notice of public hearing to consider a request from Ehrlich Properties, LLC to rezone property located at the corner of W. 32nd St. and N. Grandview Ave. from R-1 Single Family Residential District to R-4 Multi- Family Residential District, and the Zoning Advisory Commission recommending approval. ORDINANCE Amending Title 16 of the City of Dubuque Code of Ordinances, Unified Development Code, by reclassifying hereinafter described property located at southwest corner of W. 32nd Street and North Grandview Avenue from R-1 Single-Family Residential District to R-4 Multi-Family Residential District SUGGESTED DISPOSITION: Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Motion B; Motion A ATTACHMENTS: Description Type ZAC letter Staff Memo Application Supporting Documentation Vicinity Map Supporting Documentation Staff Material Supporting Documentation Ordinance Ordinance Suggested Nbtion Wording Supporting Documentation � Pl�nning Seivices Deparhnent �' City Hatl Dubuque 50 West 13��Street THE CITY OP DuUuque,IA 52001-4564 uH� (563)559-4210 phone � V L L r�l I I'I (563)SS9-4221 fax (563)690-6678 TDD zom�zoiz planning<,cityofdubuque.org 11/IQStG'Y�72CCL' 011 f�1C M1SS1SSlp�71 zoi3-zot� February 7, 2019 The Honorable Mayor and City Council Members City of Dubuque City Hall — 50 W. 13�h Street DubuquelA 52001 Applicant: Ehrlich Properties LLC Location: Southwest Corner of W. 32�d Street and N. Grandview Avenue Description: To rezoned R-1 Single-Family Residential District to R-4 Multi-Family Residential District. Dear Mayor and City Council Members: The City of Dubuque Zoning Advisory Commission has reviewed the above-cited request. The application, staff report and related materials are attached for your review. Discussion Rick Ehrlich, the applicant, explained that he would like to place an apartment building with 8 to 12 units on the lot at the southwest corner of W. 32"d Street and N. Grandview Avenue. He is explained that the property is currently zoned R-1 Single-Family, and he could place up to 9 smaller, single-family rental homes on the property. He explained by placing an apartment building on the site that he could have approximately the same number of units or more and have less stormwater run-off. Linda & Ike La Soya, 808 Spires Drive, owners of an 8-plex located across N. Grandview Avenue from the subject property, spoke in opposition to the request. They both stated they have concerns with stormwater run-off. Staff reviewed the staff report, noting the history of the property with respect to zoning regulations, off-street parking requirements, characteristics of the site and flood plain regulations. Staff noted that, if approved, a site plan will be required to be submitted and would be reviewed by city departments (Planning, Building, Fire, Water, Engineering, etc.) to ensure compliance with the Unified Development Code, Building and Fire Codes and SUDAS (Statewide Urban Design and Specifications). In addition, storm water controls will be reviewed in detail as part of the site plan if the subject property is successfully rezoned. The Zoning Advisory Commission discussed the request and found it appropriate. Service People Integrity Responsibility Innovatlon Teamwork i The Honorable Mayor and City Council Members I Page 2 I � Recommendation By a vote of 4 to 0, the Zoning Advisory Commission recommends that the City Council approve the request to rezone the subject property from R-1 Single-Family Residential District to R-4 Multi-Family Residential District. A simple majority vote is needed for the City Council to approve the request. I Respectfully submitted, I .�—_� I Thomas Henschel, Chairperson ' Zoning Advisory Commission , Attachments I j Seivice People Integrity Responsibility Innovatlon Teamwork rriecrrror . City of Dubuque ; DT 7� J � Planning Services Department j �J Dubuque, IA 52001-4805 � �1�tastc��riccc or� the Mi;+is+iE�pi Phone: 563-589-4210 j Fax: 563-589-4221 � planninqC�citvofdubuou2.org �, PLANNING APPLICATION FORM �I ❑Variance ❑Preliminary Plat �Simple Subdivision ❑Certificate of Appropriateness � ❑Conditional Use Permit ❑Major Final Plat ❑Text Amendment ❑Advisory Design Review (Public Projects) ' ❑Appeal ❑Minor Final Plat �Temporary Use Permit ❑Certificate of Economic Non-ViabiliN i ❑Special Exception ❑Simple Site Plan DAnnexation ❑Historic Designation cnoose one , ❑Limited Setback Waiver ❑Minor Site Plan ❑Historic Revolving Loan ❑Demolition 'I QRezoning/PUD/ID ❑Major Site Plan ❑Historic Housing Grant ❑Port of Dubuque Design Review Please rioe or orint leaiblv in ink Properry owner(s):EhPIiCh P1'Operties LLC Pno�e: 563-556-0467 ' Adare55:10662 Diesel Dr �.ry;Dubuque state:�F'` Z;P:52001 ', FaX#:N�A ceu a: 563-213-0072 E-ma�i: ehrlichco@aol.com App�icant/n9ent: RICk EhrliCh Pnone: 563-213-0072 nddress:558 Mill Run Ct �.ty Dubuque state:�p` Z;P;52002 Fax u:N�A ce�� u:563-213-0072 E-ma�i: ehrlichco@aol.com Site location(address: Neighborhood Association: N�A � R-1 � R-4 � N/A � Existing zoning: Proposed zoning: District: Landmark: ❑Yes 0 No Legal Description (Sidwell parcel ID# or lot number/block number/subdivision): ��4�55�� Total propeKy(lot) area (square feet or acres): � .283 AC Describe proposal and reason necessary(attach a letter of explanation, if needed):Construction of apartment building CERTIFICATION: I/we, the undersigned, do hereby certify/acknowledge that: 1. It is the property owner's responsibiliry to locate property lines and to review the abstract for easemenks and restrictive covenants. 2. The information submitted herein is true and correct to the best of my/our knowledge and upon submittal becomes public record; 3. Fees are not refundable and payment does not guarantee approval; and 4. All additional required written and graphic materials are attached. Property Owner(s): /�� Date: �-0 2 -/"� Applicant/Agent:�� 1 �.�/ Date: �` d Z � �� . � FOR OFFICE USE ONLY—APPLICATION SUBMI L CHECK ST C��. i 1 , � Fee� N�•B� Received by: / � Date: r • Z {�Docket: �-3 gG� THE CTCY Oi Dubuque � w�aua W DUB E 'I�jl` i001 E012 Masterqiece on the Mississippi ,�,,.m,> Vicinity Map AG ��. R-1 �c'P ',� � � �-,_`��A.�P �° � � � �� -� � o�a. -, �_ ; �:-- -�,�; / ,-- '�,.' ''__ j- , , -, ; s � �; �` I -s ,�-'�-LD � �'��`�� ' -� = �� R_� �'_ ��' �,`�� --,� R_� I l ' ' ' .' __'., _>. - J � _ yQI W 33ND ST � {—� y II City of Dubuque � R 1 I�I�i R-3 Applicant: Ehrlich Properties LLC � R-4 i I Location: SW Corner of W. 32nd St. and � � � ; � �� North GrandviewAvenue __...j f ,,,,_I _ �� . . Description: To Rezone R-1 Single-Family � � �� Residential District to R-4 � ;� '� Multi-Famly Residential District. .._..I �..--....._.._ , , . R-1 � i i i � � r----ti i � City limits � AG �""a Parcels R-3 � � - a O Subject Property R-4 s = R-1 < � OISCLAIMER:Thls inbrmatlon was compiled osing t�e z Ou�uqueNeeGeogrepM1lclnforma�lonSYstem(DHGISI,wM1ic� N ' IudesdetecreatetlbybotM1�heCiyofOuboqueantl � �ubupue Counly. It is unCerstoodlhal,w�lle I�e City of �ubuQue enG partidpating egencies Nilizetl iM1e masl arzenl R�A entleccura[emformetionevaila0le,�AGISanOilssupplierstlo . � notwerramineaccuracyorcurrencyofine�mformanonortla�a � ��"-------�—... containetlherein. TM1eCiyantl0a�icipafingagenciesshallnot �e�eld Ilable for eny direct,Indirect,incitlenlel,consequen�iel, p�mwe,o�:ae��aiaamaaes.wneme�roreseeameo� 1:2,500 0 125 250 500 unforeseeeble,erisingoutoMeeumonzetloruneumonzetl e of t�is&te o��M1e inebiliry lo use�Ms dafa or oul ol any Feet bseacn on,-ama�ry wnacsoever. REZONING STAFF REPORT Zoning Agenda: February 6, 2019 Property Address: Southwest Corner of W. 32nd Street and N. Grandview Avenue Property Owner: Ehrlich Properties LLC Applicant: Same Proposed Land Use: Residential Proposed Zoning: R-4 Existing Land Use: Residential/Vacant Existing Zoning: R-1 Adjacent Land Use: North — Agricultural Adjacent Zoning: North — R-1 East — Multi-Family Residential East— R-4 South — Vacant/Residential South — R-1 West — Residential West— R-1 Former Zoning: 1934 — R-1; 1975 R-1 1985 — R-1 Total Area: 1.28 Acres (55,757 sq. ft.) Property History: The subject property was annexed into the city in 1936. The property has been undeveloped and used primarily for agricultural purposes. The Bee Branch Creek flows through the site. A portion of the property is located in the 100-year floodplain. In 2006, the property was platted as part of the North Grandview Estates Subdivision. The legal description of the property is Lot 37 North Grandview Estates No.2. Physical Characteristics: The subject property is an approximately 1.28-acre (55,757 sq. ft.) lot located on the southwest corner of the intersection of N. Grandview Avenue and W. 32�d Streets. The Bee Branch Creek meanders through the property and empties into a box culvert that extends under N. Grandview Avenue. Volunteer trees line along both sides of the creek. A portion of the property has been designated as part of the 100-year regulatory floodplain. Approximately 34,500 sq. ft. of the 55,757 sq. ft. lot is located outside of the floodplain. Concurrence with Comprehensive Plan: The Comprehensive Plan encourages a mix of housing affordable for all segments of Dubuque's population throughout the community, including options for those who might be saving for their first home. The plan also encourages new multi-family development in proximity to jobs to minimize transportation costs and fosters the development of new and additional housing products in suitable locations throughout the City. The City's Future Land Use Plan identifies this area as residential. Rezoning Staff Report — SW Corner of W. 32�d Street and N. Grandview Ave Page 2 Impact of Request on: Utilities: All City utilities are available to the property. Traffic Patterns/Counts: The following charts shows the 2013 & 2017 lowa Department of Transportation Annual Average Daily Vehicle Trips (ADT) along the subject property. There has been a reduction of 970 AVT along W. 32"d Street and an increase of 150 AVT along N. Grandview Avenue. � � . . - �. - �. .. . . � 4,190 3,220 . . �. . . � 2,440 2,590 • ; . Public Services: Existing public services are adequate to serve the site. Environment: Staff does not anticipate any adverse impact to the environment provided the development adheres to Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) floodplain regulations. Adjacent Properties: The adjacent property to the north consists of a graded, but not fully improved, residential single-family subdivision. The property to the west consists of flood plain and vacant land. The property to the north is W. 32"d Street and a wooded hillside which is part of a farm. The property to the east consists of N. Grandview Avenue and an 8-unit apartment building. The proposed rezoning should have minimum impact on the neighborhood. Staff Analysis: The applicant is requesting rezoning of a lot from R-1 Single-Family Residential District to R-4 Multi-Family Residential District. The subject property is an approximately 1 .28-acre lot located on the southwest corner of W.32�d Street and N. Grandview Avenue. The property consists of floodplain and land that has been used for agricultural purposes. Approximately 34,500 sq. ft. of the 57,757 sq. ft. lot is located outside of the floodplain. The applicant has indicated he proposes to develop the property into a 12-unit apartment building. Rezoning Staff Report — SW Corner of W. 32°d Street and N. Grandview Ave Page 3 I Included in this staff report is a chart of the 2013 & 2017 IDOT Annual Average Daily Trips (ADT) for the subject area. Along the subject property, there has been a reduction of 970 AVT along W. 32nd Street and an increase of 150 AVT along N. Grandview Avenue. The Institute of Traffic Engineers Trip Generation Manual indicates that for apartments, a trip generation of 6.47 vehicles trips per dwelling unit during the weekday. This translates into approximately 78 ADT when the 12-unit apartment is constructed. The submitted application is for rezoning to R-4 Multi-Family Residential District to accommodate the construction of a 12-unit apartment building. The applicant/developer is required to submit a major site plan. The site plan will be reviewed by city departments (Planning, Building, Fire, Water, Engineering, etc.) to ensure compliance with the Unified Development Code, Building and Fire Codes and SUDAS (Statewide Urban Design and Specifications). The parking requirement for apartments in an R-4 residential district is 1 .5 spaces per dwelling unit. The proposed 12-plex would generate a demand of 18 paved off-street parking spaces. Water and sewer utilities are available along both W. 32�d Street and N. Grandview Avenue. In addition, storm water controls will be reviewed in detail as part of the site plan if the subject property is successfully rezoned. The Comprehensive Plan encourages a mix of housing affordable for all segments of Dubuque's population throughout the community, including options for those who might be saving for their first home. The plan also encourages new multi-family development in proximity to jobs to minimize transportation costs and fosters the development of new and additional housing products in suitable locations throughout the City. The City's Future Land Use Plan identifies this area as residential. Planning staff recommends the Zoning Advisory Commission review Section 9-5 of the Unified Development Code that establishes criteria for the review of zoning reclassifications. � f Prepared by: �,-- �� +y—�;Reviewed: .�%'J f �Date:_l .��' ��1`i ;1 ` >°% '" ,. � �$'�. � r: , � s a�� '.'.� , �` i��` ,�M..(�� i fi ' �,,,�� W '."4 A �4 �� . ti} ,�i � ' � ..: �� !' �" J4ic � � , M �. �Y. r ,r` � . * ' `♦ x. �1 ♦ � �e Y +r `� . . � c• y��i`i�,"L pc*�j.+ .ii 4 * �.' �".. c . + ��q ��Iv 2 :�X . _ q� �/ �. !. r� �^�. �`�" '!ST 4.. y�:�..� { .�'j } . . . ,i �+€�Q�' ��,R�/,��'^k y ^ �� s �' , - � � t�' ,y � - 6 "��.;,�i+ k ._ u-"�, � ..� . "' ,�, hy.. � s� S� � �' � i��, t�r + �" +�� . - � � t . , � �Q.. �fi. r,. � ; '{r .!f . ?��PM1�' ^�,fr��} tr � S,, �"' .. .c> t�r•�, � ' .. - f��y� r ��,. � : �.�� f r'.;; ��'r: �,� y,Sy' �'t �a� ��. ��» �✓. 'w �qX� t . :� r 'r �� ' �1� ��.� � Tlf�y� - 4 � .:�'Y�t�� •4'�. � y�1005 , �i r ♦ �; • i�.. 1'� M }i. �,' • 't � � � � ,�� 1. �� F. �� '{ ."� f� .. '`��"r�"`7 ��f h b r < � 1�01i" _1F ,�p�tin � �.W.c � 4� -� '�� ' +r^. �`. , �+ 4 Y � i }� i N 4 `� r } J fp �.'.#�!t! '� �� 1 �lW +�n ��' f . k;• , ..�j�_� .: � 5 �/: :,'�� + '. f` f, � ,,�y, '�!r s ' F R `�c� �m.:�;_ e- ,` - \ t L +. 'P` � , „� �1 f i _: r .u''h �� .xei y�'' 1� � ""_ ' �,y ��IiT�+_ � G��` � .,t:_'.. „� ��'x,iXt` �;.''�K �� 4. _ ��`,��t ��.'� 'P'i1�'wy 4 t 4 5M'My�� .;��y-0,��'~w� <. - A . .�r�_ �: S �'�& Y ♦, a. . l `Zi � �.n;t 1. . � .. t W��yMj'�M �� yr� . .f:.. � " . � � ' ' 1 ..:.��i �`,: . r � � � � �jG ��]�� r ` J�.?'^ �� ;,. f � '�� a� • � . i '� ,.!`. ' "�+''�.. � � s..: � t ' a J�"'w �';"�t�,�'1"' �4 n .h �w r , . � a '�." '� y'�t�� ,�'Y'� 4_ ':y„" '�*i � x f < ;��.�.� -,� p „� , �oi>q. � . � T��,� �� a ::��.y�1635r `1615� n� } *-7�''x� ,•�.�•"F��.. .,C 1221�� . J � � 1175� Fy10� - 2��,: ��J � l � - 1195 � 1 �� ' � � _ �r � : ,�. . �r ��4 � - ,� . .� ,, ,w�`�,.;; ; �s�a:'� . ' ' ,' ,n. , ��.r �. , �.�+ r , `�a , .. [ __ __. ... � r� " �' � � r'�-* . "` . A ' . . W32NDST �� y�. �� -= ...._ ' .. . . . �- .. �. . . . .„ .. _ : . _ .� .. +1��d n6S� .,R... �,"SG 3=:_ 2970 � � �_ _�_._..� .. �-p : , � � - � \ , ,�i�oi " "'^�>��, ."A; ..,,�„� .ry r tiUBJECTPROPERTv d ,r . .1� +�` `�`�"��"�. +,. c " �Q'r,,� *: .a4,� �. �' .,-, '� �„ � �2io� �� e� �°�. r � n.- �,z '+ � �c . . £ -4 4��1:, y✓./P, -�"- �� K t _-�\. Y ��Ibi'4 . i, �'"�v . _, '� .: �.�,'�'dnE" .��" " v+�:7 -.r� ,xi �� 3090�:. �� _:A�� , �yyqy��W�'''"Y . �4 x, �r sy,� �. . � , Y -^ �i ��"4' .2965 . # � y.''� Fsk�$jy..� 1.yg,, .'� V.' , � y .�._..�..P � a d, w ' ...�N .,,.� ,M(. 4 g� � ��f ' i� Y : �, � 1110'� } ��1 ..P'a• � �`��'a.> :. '�` - �� .. w l r �4�. _.h+�� ` �',� ba�'` �{ a . . �' ^.. ''�tf�-. ,. ��'� 4`:�; {� ir - + '^ � :. 1'4 � ...Ay�!. n, e� S, : �vi?t '• � `�v .. � -. t � �+ � .*�2�j _I " � wk` 2955 ��1� } �� " y �'�'t w1 ��' e7`M ��r � ' . l�' �. �.' - � 3060 � w��. �l : �.�„� � a �.�� : r �;�,U ��. t � .. � , l C �'y,9� ' ^(� ^. �:�� , .�. L.�yt�r � 'r'�i�� F� ri ,�" .,, ". ' �� .i ^,��7 'N��f' r '� -,'S� �u.. �' 'y. �.,� �,➢ • t'7'� ,aR�kX � Re."�rl,,� 1 �..��x ��„ r � '�v�'�4 * •..'�+'s.4 7�J35 'A� -J o' dl, . 1`k �opp � � �. � � . , � � k`'�' � S.� 'la,;y 1 � t _ � ,� 30(i7�:' ,]j� +r k h, ��'�e`, `+ i - � v.F � a .. � � . a �� s F" ��y'•.�-0 . ^ .�.� �'7 � . � ��`� �a _ '�le i !ry v ,.. . � :� �i�; � 2925 � } i�, � . . J . . , ' . ' � . , �C .� � : Jlu a�n .�..'t,e�,� r t - �..�,. i �,,,� k-aY . �,yn '{y�'y -. f �m,�.[�� .�'i y�� ,1r, �;'�r � �� . r¢ . .7�v t { +y � , , �'`�"i{.�p 1 T �.Fi��`,p�K4i t�.� e , .�2R1�1� � 1600i.i 1 �'5� 'L:"..^�k. �;.x �'�c.'�y �.,.,vy�q! �y, ..C;�'{_ � '`- .. i- �� ' �j,j*�f �4 :�kw,�'^�Z�I.�,� �,:_, . � �,7,'+�. ( 2R91� ��29i5 R-�. �y.. 5��.. 'x1.s � . . U If '°'+' ��ti �� '��? ..i� ^'.r ��' , ��Il„j._ p . . , r� �"/` hN"' r - � Y � '� r :+� ^ �'� .. � � � '.�� w ' :� ,A� 2875� �"" i� �2895 -.,.k PL .i � t. ° � i.. Y'° �.(" . ,�: h� �'' , e,�" y' . . p +� 3025� s y � ., �4 e�, .... — . .. 2t190 , - ",Y �l s�i�..�A�`� , .s�k�'..�' �,� � -�;� , .w r,; �r� �.� ; S� • Y 1 "�+fi �.��c��,�•*��t,�� ,^�«,.��67• . �I� �'�� ,��2885 y� ' �e. y; '�I� �.. . � ... w �K �'r�' V�''� , � , �^' '�' , .�` '�.,. » .' . ,� �p�,gs4 L"t .. �; f ..:q � Gt` �I �:'� f,..� v ey . af ,s„ :V'�'. = y', QZ °�'..�Y�-i. �„�'`'�7- � � �, .. lfl:�/ �. 1,Q��0 �0 2f180 ��2879 n� ;. -W'` ,�r` ..' . iN� ' �,. _ � yH yf�»�l,r* ;4 �:.., ..`�y- `-:_n� . . pF`�. ;;� � � [, i� :. �� 8�:1� . � , � '•_� '�� `""+ � .oa. ' A .{. Z ?�E' '�� +. . . ... "�t" � 873. . ' � �ti��' ` r , 2973 �>r� r ' �. � " ��,�,. . �� ,. � s-. �� ,'��„��s" �� . Legend -1� i�� a . ! ::�' �,1 \r-_�� .. # . � Y ,'!,ry(.;.�y o- �� rph y �.� ry1 . �. . �. . << �. - � S� ��,��,�, ,�+'Y*��.�,. 100 YEAR FLOODPLAIN za�s ° �;a � , ��'" +� g �; �"�* �� r ." r ` � . Fg' M� �y �.+,. . ! � i 293.;:�f� . 4 ' Parcels .�2870 • � ._ } ° � � • `; -{ • . > � ,,� _ r . . �., �� r �. . .. n+ '. :� y`., , � . �� . i '.. �,� °� 2910�b � �` 283 � ' ,�b � . . .' � �i� � � , , ,,. ,.� . ,: 2877� 2890 ;�, ..�-� � r __• ' N,...^ � r:�S�� . ._ . _ . . .._ .. _. __ . . . r �w :�...:.�.. .2833��1 . ��2870 _� . ...i2823\\ 2820 " i R' `4 � i� R .n � I " y y. .� . � � -' < , ' 4 � rh :: F � �.� €'A � i. �w � . 14* j� � . � ��. � r}P .�. r ..� s. rv` ,�'�''iTk F� .'a� \ '-+ I��i Yt +j�T ,�Qr ah�4_ �h x . ,. " +.` , � k ' i r i .0 �M1� � ^��` �` .t ti., �� t r '3 �� a 4`tfr.. n � _'�� ,,[ it�^ 4 t�t{ .K .i .. ' - ,s�. �-� 7� ��s,F rp'� ..e .�`�r�� r4 .�c t .: ' . �Y ' �� S[�[,(l t,1 �(,�+S�v�yi '* . �:, `� �, � 'E''`�r° r y, i'„ �, � �sp f� ;�j t '��,,� 4 at� � �;. � � �O':. . '�" �' . � � � ,f'3t�J � : , � _ r f :J ��. , � �- � - `_ ':'�s�.w t `'' ?� .I a +�^'X€ �S t � �. ' ''�, i �E s'�:t ` ,`. iI . � y} _ � _ ' ,�t �,a�5'�.:^Yc,, r •.y�P .� ',t . .:� �'�, � , '�.�,'f t, - � � "�r� �'�rq: 1•� ':e ` �+..>'- �i:-. , � . '' v v�♦ y.,_. � ' , y�y i� 1 -. _ '�.� ?' . .. . � �� . e. �, l�\ !F� �. . � I � A�•' ,' V �.. _ .�,� . 'C ' � � " � iT � � i. }�•.v d� .''X � � / � � `l. .� . "` J �:�� .. _4 1 �� / e l� I�. I� 1 e:. , ( � � . . � nF', ~ ` '�-�� f�4�, .�v � *` � � �k <' ,,� � w�� r , : , .. - ', " "'# �c, .�..� , r .�,k ,:'� .� �' .. �:. � � .� � �..�< : . � , .. . . � �� F:.,��F c'z.'�g.�w�..«:�. .�: ,. �� _ ;� `st�,1�•96, '- � PICTOMETRY VIEW LOOKING NORTH � � 4 � , . �' 1 i:.. . . � . � c � -f' ., yy` .� � �r :.� � = ., f, _ n _. . . ; �' ,� "'��rx�;, i .. �.. -.-'�+� ��-� ` � r 1� �. , 1, w•� a.�? ^ r r.� ,��:; a � r : -�. .��E t ,�. f z, -{ � . �r. . � � x J' _ , �' �Y : - E�' �.t. �. 3� Qj . . .. .� 1 Y, �`r� ..kif j �& ...�r> 'V'R�4� �. ��' � e�..�! " fii•� !,F . . .� . � .. j . . ' ? < ' e ' . . ' ,, 1> .. .[ � `t �� , + *I' � �"t n .f� �. . •�r yv �,:a}�Va t'' Y'1 Y +� �'$:�.' �`k•';��{ ��dt �> C r y� . 4. ii� . • . Y Yf �'itT��`+Mt��.l * h�� . I � ,c�^t r t �' ` ,�� ;.{ _. s +� .�'�t a �` ` k � � � . r � j `s a ��yZ ,�,r � "�+� r� • a�,.��e 'i� � f � �. ' ` � x 't`'S s'� d s �. r * � 1 1 ' `� s�ti�: �+, f '� ►' •rf' ��' v �. ��e : �„ , � ,r .-� -#�•� ,��q y. . � ��,.,r `R ,�y,, . �.. . , �.?.iS �. . , . ..� ,t�i�� i �li 'K-iwry � .. .. _ .v �Jr . 4�n►y i.r+ i 4 . . + - .��g i: .. � �4� � � . , ,y _ � � �l�ftIJ Z� t �� 'Y� ��' _ ' � , e,y£' E � t* �-�y � }'�� 1� . zF � 4� �. � �f .� } $t. . �. _._ . ._ ' A , t �'S f � � .;:` -�, a - �°Stz.� • �� : . ,. l, 1'.�. * �Sk`� � .>. � � � R. � � � } >:�r �, Y ,� a.. .:, . ;f f} `� '. ` s �•1i 'C '°�. . :, x .,'" c�� +�,�: .�iy , � 1 n/'�- � ��.L"� i�l.. y ,-:�r 'f �t.'1,' t �. � ,� '�T- `� � �'t��ff��i1C.,1.i v� ..4 . ' / i� ` �a ^ ',� #;n Y � � ' 2w qt .� ..t . / _. G_'/� i� I, , �`A �...1 ♦ i Y �: PICTOMETRY VIEW LOOKING WEST i - _ y� � . � _ �+ �� CN �y 1� r. . �i f •4 �( • .a'�j( �•��,If . . ` L . '' th Yl � ,µ�r ��' . ,' , t Y� 1/�" 'Mh � ,� � t .'1: �r r �. � �'_ i :� � }~ �'`� '-(" ' ' t ,�! � a y� r '.Y �„� �y�y � �S � �a' y L•Y - � ��r ;��•y� ` � .�., y�t.��{� : : �' ; y4,' :.d�} ::� T. .. .Sti i �""� , � � �4 ��L t� 'F a1�3. .�_ � 1�" 47 � , 'Y t '�/QY _ ' � ]f. . ` . � �,# '. a � ' �t �" � � ��., � � .. e �. . _ � {��+,::. k . `�Y �.��'Y 4r 3�F�'t 'f. Fr.V-� Y �` ` iE . . iY Y'S {y� 4 y.� �� p. � '^�e�w:..� h *��.t+�'�' �,�-` a � ", � �y Fr -� +laR4 . `4 �f�h�� . T .+�J��Y. . .. / !' � f � " . ` .:. .�� •.� J �3 `��[+ J� � " f, �I � ♦ �.��.�iL1_#i �<.'1 ��. ` � �y.,�,� t 5� ' �- _ .._... - . , � . . ' x�y l�a � �` yy' P "i' a.y: �:.. '. -._�.:./✓' � a � � � E 'k 4 4 � �, ,:� y�,tF�* � x "�'11i f � lAt �� x �J t+'/ ♦ �� 'x4' s `L ��y� .+s. '.,- x. ,�xq., { le%(� �7 �;`. yyy y sn c Y" - s 4 a' .v;� �t s r ��. .'E� � r ��5 �t '.. r � � '�� 'f :4.f wh`c .��s �3 . ' t4� �jj� � {Se "z�. ��i . 'i.� �A,,ry�� @ ..��} ✓ �. • „ 1i >.�kFn !, y _ + �� y' ''` � q;i"!� � -- }�'� �[��Z�Y�I „4y`S�� .f.. � ._ i _ �_ h.Ti.t�. �-. T� ~ Y +[,;'� `._�...' . :.11.... . i - '�1r PICTOMETRYVIEW LOOKING SOUTH � � A 3' � ` � , �c . �at�`► �t' - «3 ��- ..,..,� < e c�!c �� z+ �a �� ;.� s * S" � , .�y'a� 4� ..�.� a. ,,i,;; n�,f� �> v . _z I � S d L ! � �6� y' '��tz�i �, . e . �'4't:.,�'� �t'�`+>f� �� a `��. i � .�-i. t S �'R � IF �.' . 4Y' c . .^i i &� y'T ('.. T �h, . ��`� . P .�. .t '� �;��.�y - . _ � r "i �. f s , ' !:�* '�Y ��y�R��Jif' a{_„ � ... " � ��•�- 1 � .� Y(�� y !'i � �:i �"p 6 y�i. �. < i <�_: �{�t ' cj,♦ '�L, ", i �r"� i..iK�i r3 > i.` � j� / _ ' ;ra � '��y�'+-�k� gr '� �tY,' " � _ Y��k ' ►�, a':,3E :` � #� �� , � �� •- s� e � - . !� � � y� � _ ' � ''' �' `��' .i�' �a µ. ��'`'��.�i N�. J� �"� _ t , , . fi+.��'�' . ,. l"�e'' ' . �. � a _ ' _ . . , -r ' .. �' ,�p'R .,`ki;'h i � t � � �' y� �..,st' � p , . ��,�� ,�� •��.�1 � �� Yi, �'s �'\ �IA+.�F�.,�J�� ,� �. 3 � ^ } �-Y �f � �`� e + ' r' T• a �� . � ,�i 3-: �,�,�q F�' �;a � ) � �� . .. . � F�� Y'R I'{ � TJl'�'�./'�J . S.i��:T f�� II L �( Y�� `�$�yT ' �. � • . . t yE`y��,A�iN� j �� sy�{f T � � � I ^7� '�" .,: � + s ��'.+J' h F . t,�•,� =r•` L � r�Y'�F?� y._..r � � ' '.: a1-. .:""sn; . y PICTOMETRY VIEW LOOKING EAST \ 1 �:}p yr �v .T. . -�y.y t5 � ��1� � a! '1 y �+i' � 4"s � 'K (K�L 9F� �!'�Y�a^iR '� �.K y N � ��flv 1 :h . �� ` L") ' 1�'� '�r ��N } . . f � : �. �� _F � �� k�;.,,�sa�p�� - �Rr°�_'.�� A +.�_.ry y,. . �,i . '�e ��: '°�; ° .� _ -- 1 � . -�'.�.�:,1"+��v�., `K, ,,; tr.'S'�-..'+r�i- "',� � � . i''.5 . I —_—_ i ---�i�c� � - . ` -.: , �� :_J/"" ' t�� ,� .�{,��q'~ - _ _ ._. r�.+� t VIEW LOOKING WEST FROM INTERSECT�ON OF W.32ND STREET AND N. GRANDVIEW AVENUE NOVEMBER 2016 GOOGLE MAP IMAGE �j� _ _. ' f . � :. � µ� � . r :#: 3 , �g�."`—�— w. , � .� ,�` s• _ � ga. `x� . ��.�°�.�+t��'�,`s._.._ _.._. jP�'� �`^�• � r;t.f r; � �,#'. �1 � Y 4, !e ��v�� a�5�t+"f�,��,c+Ft'r !„ �'±�+ � ` . � ` � 1 a«� . " ` '?p'"x+ ��17F..t�rs� �T ,..- � :.y+i��,� -, d'�. r. us.. � . d„� r_ . d-�. � S* � t .:. 4 �( � � '�'' '.1`. '"�t S �:�.r y�4 ..�t L � ' tk �' � � V �� ,� s�t�- c ��4.. � yf�� _ V��3�{ 1. VIEW LOOKING EAST FROM W32N°STREET I, BUILDING IN BACKGROUND IS 3090 N. GRANDVIEW AVENUE (8-PLEX) � SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON THE RIGHT NOVEMBER 2016 GOOGLE MAP IMAGE . � , d7l � _ � i � / ,�� , � y _ � 4�`x F ' , \'q� p Y ' .—_ � , � 1 ��` � f. � -t�. � F� . Z�' � 4 ..�J��{. I:' I iV d -i -. , s' {fi� ' /'A . . d �L�Vyy f � { v s K 't�,y�� Y Y , ?J��. y�y �,1 � f��[ -if� ��r�� t 'Y< � �. '; ,S.ny w`i ',` �4 �n.y� �`�•� � . . ' . •� � �!1^,F�`',�F� "f � "*'*.. ,. , � . s�s � _. 4 Y� 'r �"' ; ' '� ..� ;G��''1t„< �_ .. � H '- .�. �. . �fi�� Y � y' . a ��q ` S. � ' ��/ �k� .fi;s,'A� !- _ �� 'i,' r �� ;r.H } " 1 '��.. ~ � _ f� �� h � _' _ _. � n 94"�:., � . _ R�.'� _.x{Ay�- �,��i .r"' - ._ , '-a txJ'i.� .d'. . �,.r�' - _.. .� ��. ! �. '. �,_.::✓z"a.+ VIEW LOOKING SOUTH FROM W.32ND STREET ACROSS SUBJECT PROPERTY NOVEMBER 2016 GOOGLE MAP IMAGE :� . SUBJECT PROPERTY ; `�� " � s :_ . a�� .:� a. � �.� w �` � �- � � ' . � ,�.�y "` - �r-. .t� �i��#"i� ! � ,T'�''� ] --• �.,e , �� +� R '��'� ' � -�4 � 4�� t � t �„✓� '�' �7-,: . . �}t�. �` .'�3N. � zt ^{ � �� ` ;r y � �(w+.�.-t,� i,..�,y 6'�.`- *y}�' r, .}lt'� \`J:' �r � �I�- �"�`.� 1'7� -,-,.^Y'.3f�wc.r� . ?` w"3�.�C3'�` .,�M�-p}•�� e' �e"r pft,� (f }- _ .� - r.++K �s' ��1��1�' � 717 � ..t'd�F . . ,. . :+�'. ' a f�y�, �'AW " �A.— -- _. _— '� �rri::`�"� •aa ,. ;:� � _ .. _ `�_ VIEW LOOKING NORTH ALONG N. GRANDVIEW AVENUE NOVEMBER 2013 GOOGLE MAP IMAGE 1� Section 2-Land Use Regulations Artide 5: Zoning Districts � �� 5-6 R-4 Multiple-Family Residential The R-4 District is intended to provide residential areas of moderate to high density de- I�" �,� , �� velopments located adjacent to a major street and serves as a buffer or transition behveen � ' { ' �, commercial developmenY, non-residential tises, or heavy automobile traffic and medium � '�� ` � r� 4 , •.�� ', � density residential development. ':z�t } .o�' MWtiple-family 5-Gl Principal Permitted Uses dwelling The following uses are permitted in the R-4 District: 1. Cemetery, mausoleum, or columbarium 2. Multiple-family dwelling(three to 12 units per buildings) 3. Place of religious exercise or assembly i 4. Public or private park, golf course, or similar natural recreation area : 5. Public, private,or parochial school approved by the State of Iowa(K-12) -- -; 6. Railroad or public or quasi-public utility, including substation ��a�� 7. Single-family detached dwelling !' �=� 8. Townhouse(three to 12 units laterally attached) � ;�, 9. Two-family dwelling(duplex) �v' � �.,, r_. � ' �5 I �� -6.2 ConditionalUses t ��'� Tlie following conditional uses may be permitted in the R-4 District, subject to the provi- � 'tx Townhouse sions of Section 8-5: 1. Bed and breakfast home ' 2. Bed and breakfast inn 3. Group home � 4. Hospice 5. Housing for the elderly or persons with disabilities ' 6. Licensed adult day services 7. Licensed child care center ,, '�` `� � 8. Mortuary, fimeral home, or crematorium . �', _�:��? 9. Multiple-family dwelling of 13 or more units � � ' -` �a b 10. Nursing or convalescent home � -+ : ;; +je/1� ' 11. Off-premises residential garage �ti1� 12. Off-street parking `;� -� .��e 13. Rooming or boarding house ...k-- - 14. Tour home Nursing home 15. Tourist home 16. Wind energy conversion system ?:" 5-6.3 Accessory Uses The following uses are permitted as accessory uses as provided in Section 3-7: 1. Detached garage ; 2. Fence � "57 k::�. ^� 3. Garage sale; no more than three per calendar year or three consecutive days per sale � 4. Home-based business i � 5. Noncommercial garden, greenhouse or nursery � �_ � � 3 �,� 6. Off-street parking and storage of vehicles ' � 7. Satellite receiving dish � °" 8. Solar collector �� 9. Sport,recreation,or outdoor cooking equipment � ' 10. Storage building Off-street parking 1 1. Tennis court, swimming pool or similar permanent facility ��;�. � crtror � �� Dus E � Section 2—Land Use Regulations Article 5: Zonin Districts I B I 12. Wind turbine(building-mounted) I i 5-6.4 Temporary Uses � Temporary uses shall be regulated in conformance with the provisions of Section 3-19. 5-6.5 Parking ' Minimum parking requirements shall be regulated in conformance with the provisions of Article 14. 5-6.6 Signs % *;:: Signs shall be regulated in conformance with the provisions of AMicle 15. THECRYOF DUB E- i Section 2—Land Use Regulations Article 5: Zoning Districts 5-6.7 13ulic Regulations —� r , — t� iPotr � f �� . I�iYv � rf� � Ndi9 i�„�i� ( Nu� i = r 1- i � , ' �• l�aPl�d-��l=Ca'aTirll� f`r 1 / y� , � I L7�i(4ir3 � ��ar S?r I�iuiil c-kr ; f� "!*�� A��9} 1'. dZ �V�� I 'i �'��iiL'• � � . � . — �M Jt� � II � 1 _ — I�� ¢ rY�: {�c_'4i � re -{, � I��nd, � I�i".S;y .� (6i Ct'F �� (�'r7�; ' � � �.. . .___ — _ ._ — _ � Penniited Uses � � '- �� - -- � i, Single-familydetached dwelling � 5,000 � 50 � 40 20 � 50 4 � 20 30 Multiple-family � 2,000/du I 50 � 40 I 20 --- � 3� 20 40 i Place of religious exercise or 20,000 100 40 20 -- 20 20 75 z � assembly,School Townhouse(12 du max) I 1,600/du I 16/du I 40 20 --- I 0/3' 20/0 40 Two-familydweliing � 5,000 � 50 40 20 50 4 20 30 Conditional Uses � � � �� I Bed and breakfasthome ,_� 5,000 _I_ 50 J_ 40 � 20__ 50 4 �_ 20 30 i Bed and breakfast inn � 5,000 �� 50 40 � 20 50 � 4 � 20 � 30 � iGroup home I 5,000 �__50_ 40 I 20__I_-- 3' I_ 20 I 40 Hospice ------ __ �_ 5_000_ � 50— I-- 40 --I---20 �.�-_- I 3' I 20 � 40 I Housingfortheelderlyor ' � disabled I 20,000 100 40 20 --- 20 20 40 ILicensedadultdaysenAces, 5,000 I 50 40 20 --- 3� 20 40 � Licensed child care center ' Mortuary,funeral home or �, � 20,000 100 40 20 --- 20 20 40 ; crematorium �I I Nursingorconvalescenthome � 20,000 � 100 � 40 20 � -- 20 20 40 j Off-premise residential garage � -_I --- _ �� 20 --- 3 6 15 � Rooming orboarding house i� 5,000 I 50 _I_ 40 I_ 20 _ I --- J 3' I 20 I 40 � � ' Plus one additional foot perfloor above the second floor. Maybe erected to a height not exceeding 75 feet, provided that such buildings shali pro�nde at leastone additional footof ! � yard space on all sides for each additional foot bywhich such building exceeds the mabmum height limit of the district in i which it is located. _.. -- �� . ------ ---- ��W1� ' �— P � Lot De Re mred Side 'yr' ' � Neight Mid omt � � j � I � � �. '_ � �'r�I5et65ck ! ` I I � i ��I � I I ! �� y ,. ,, i � i � "i'" � :. � � � i Shed Koof � i � I r u ti '� i I � . � � � i N i � �I ; � ,fl�,.p �� y � I �Midpant �. � � I . �y, . I : u : �.. r � � � ��?�'�z ', � � . j lie�ght S ��J � �a I Q y .`, �Q� N i I � i V K � 3 ,� � c �, ++ I i, Gable or Fip Roof � p Q �� I z _ � � I �� ' ' _ � � � . � �Deckline ,. y 6 � ` � C 6+ i �� K = � � i , i Height ��I. `� - � _ � � �� fc` — '`3� i � <� I �i I � � � Z o ; > : °o� ' ��. I Mansard or Gambrel P.00f ' i � r ,�.,.j � ' � �'��' { 9 , � ., } � . ,--- -----' �•s�i ' �� I Hi hest IPvel �.� � I i ., i I I .• I I Property �ne �'� o �� Required S�de �_;+�.ytr I ��' Yfeight � Setback � � . _ _ . _ 1 _� �Flat Roof ��,a. � Dus E Prepared by: Laura Carstens, City Planner Address: City Hall, 50 W. 13th St Telephone: 589-4210 Return to: Kevin Firnstahl, City Clerk Address: City Hall- 50 W. 13th St Telephone: 589-4121 ORDINANCE NO. 10-19 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 16 OF THE CITY OF DUBUQUE CODE OF ORDINANCES, UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE, BY RECLASSIFYING HEREINAFTER DESCRIBED PROPERTY LOCATED AT SOUTHWEST CORNER OF W. 32ND STREET AND NORTH GRANDVIEW AVENUE FROM R-1 SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT TO R-4 MULTI -FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA: Section 1. That Title 16 of the City of Dubuque Code of Ordinances, Unified Development Code, is hereby amended by reclassifying the hereinafter described property from R-1 Single -Family Residential District to R-4 Multi -Family Residential District, to wit: Lot 37 North Grandview Estates No. 2, and to the centerline of the adjoining public right-of-way, all in the city of Dubuque, Iowa. Section 2. The foregoing amendment has heretofore been reviewed by the Zoning Advisory Commission of the City of Dubuque, Iowa. Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon publication, as provided by law. Passed, approved and adopted this 18th day of February 2019. Attest: Kevi Firnstahl, ' ity erk Roy D. Buol, Mayor CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA OFFICIAL NOTICE NOTICE is hereby given that the Dubuque City Council will conduct public hearings at a meeting to commence at 6:00 p.m. on Monday, February 18, 2019, in the Historic th Federal Building, second-floor, 350 W. 6 Street, Dubuque, on the following: Rezonings Request from Ehrlich Properties, LLC to rezone property located at the corner of W. 32nd St. and N. Grandview Ave. from R-1 Single Family Residential District to R-4 Multi-Family Residential District. Copies of supporting documents for the public hearings are on file in the City Clerk’s th Office, City Hall, 50 W. 13 St., Dubuque, Iowa, and may be viewed during normal working hours. Written comments regarding the above public hearings may be submitted to the City th Clerk’s Office, 50 W. 13 St., Dubuque, IA 52001, on or before said time of public hearing. At said time and place of public hearings all interested citizens and parties will be given an opportunity to be heard for or against said proposal. Any visually or hearing-impaired persons needing special assistance or persons with special accessibility needs should contact the City Clerk’s Office at (563) 589-4100 or TDD (563) 690-6678 at least 48 hours prior to the meeting. Kevin S. Firnstahl, CMC City Clerk 1t 2/8 STATE OF IOWA {SS: DUBUQUE COUNTY CERTIFICATION OF PUBLICATION I, Suzanne Pike, a Billing Clerk for Woodward Communications, Inc., an Iowa corporation, publisher of the Telegraph Herald, a newspaper of general circulation published in the City of Dubuque, County of Dubuque and State of Iowa; hereby certify that the attached notice was published in said newspaper on the following dates: February 08, 2019, and for which the charge is $19.76 S PS Subscribed to before rne, a Notary Public in and for Dubuque County, Iowa, this 13 day of ,2019. Notary Public®.nd for Dubuque Coun , Iowa. K. PAPE Commission Number 199659 1y Comm, Exp. DEC 11, 2019 3,1,7 CEVI.V1111,35117•190,S IOWACITY OF DUBUQUE, OFFICIAL NOTICE NOTICE is hereby giv- en that the, Dubuque City Council will con-' duct, public hearings at a meeting too•" com- mence at 6:00 p.m.' on Monday, February 18, 2019, in. the Historic Federal Building, sec- ond -floor, 350 W. 6th Street, Dubuque, on the following:, Rezonings Request from Ehrlich Properties, LLC to re- zone property located at the corner of W. 32nd St. and N. Grand- view Ave rand-view"Ave from R-1 Sin- gle Family Residential District to R-4 Multi - Family Residential Dis-:,' trict. . Copies of'supribrting documents forthe pub-,, lit hearings areonnfile'! trite ity. Clerk's Of- fice City Hall 50 ` W 13th St., ' DUbuque, Iowa, and may _ be viewed 'during ,•normal working hours. 0c garWrttendthe aCombove pments,ubre- ing he `hearings 'may', be -I subriitted to the 'City Clerk's OffiCe, 50 W. 13th St., Dubuque,'` IA 52001, on or before i, said time of .:public" hear ng: At saidt time and place of ':public hear ngs all interested, citizens and parties will be given, an oppor- tunity to ppor-tunityto be heard for or against said; propos al Any visually or"hear- ing-impaired persons needing;, special :assis- tance ;.or persons with special accessibility needs ,should- contact the 'City Clerk's ;Office at (563) 589-4100 or TDD (563) 690-6678 at least 48 hours prior to the meeting. Kevin S. Firnstahl, CMC, City Clerk it 2/8 STATE OF IOWA {SS: DUBUQUE COUNTY CERTIFICATION OF PUBLICATION I, Suzanne Pike, a Billing Clerk for Woodward Communications, Inc., an Iowa corporation, publisher of the Telegraph Herald, a newspaper of general circulation published in the City of Dubuque, County of Dubuque and State of Iowa; hereby certify that the attached notice was published in said newspaper on the following dates: February 22, 2019, and for which the charge is $15.96 Subscribed to before me, a Notary Public in and for Dubuque County, Iowa, this / 02, day of "42,1pe—A) , 20 /9 . - - Notary Pu 0(c in and for Dubuque Co ty, Iowa. MARY K WESTERMEYER Commission Number 154885 My Commission Exp. Feb. 1, Nal OFFICIAL PUBLICATION ORDINANCE NO.10-19 AN ORDINANCE •AMENDING TITLE 16 OF THE oiTy OF DUBUQUE CODE OF ORDINANCES, UNI- FIED DEVELOPMENT. CODE, BY RECLASSI- FYING HEREINAFTER DESCRIBED PROPER• - TY LOCATED AT SOUTHWEST_ CORNER OF W. 32141)sTREET AND NORTH GRAND - VIEW AVENUE FROM R-1 SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DIS- TRICT TO R-4 MULTI- FAMILY RESIDENTIAt DISTRICT NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY 05ppALIQUE, IOWA: tagwoia Sectiont FIN Title 16 of - tlfe• City of Dubuque Code of Ordi- nances, Unified Devel- opment Code, is hereby amended by reclassify- ing the hereinafter de- scribed property froin R-1 Single -Family ReS1- dental District to R-4 Multi -Family Residen- tial District, to wit:. Lot Lot 37 North Grand- view Estates No. 2, and to the centerline of the , acljoihing public right- of-way, all inthe city of Dubuque Iowa. Section 2. The forego- ing amendment has heretofore been re- I .viewed, by the Zoning , Advisory, Commission •of the City of Dubuque, town. Section 3. This ordi- nance Shall take effect immediately Upon pub- lication, as provided • law. - Passed, approved and adopted this 18th day of February 2019. /s/Roy D. Buol, Mayor Attest: /s/Kevin S. Firnstahl, CitV Clerk - Published officially in the Telegraph Herald newspaper on the 22nd day of Februa r'y 2019. /s/Kevin S. Firnstahl, City Clerk 1t 2/22