Loading...
Lawsuit by Jerry Brandenburg Copyrighted February 18, 2019 City of Dubuque Consent Items # 2. ITEM TITLE: Notice of Claims and Suits SUMMARY: Trever Allen for vehicle damage, Brian and Dee Collins for property damage, Robert Krohmer for vehicle damage, Eric Mueller for property damage; lawsuit by Jerry Brandenburg for personal injury. SUGGESTED DISPOSITION: Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Refer to City Attorney ATTACHMENTS: Description Type Allen Claim Supporting Documentation Brandenburg Suit Supporting Documentation Collins Claim Supporting Documentation Krohmer Claim Supporting Documentation Mueller Claim Supporting Documentation , . ` � E-�ILE� 2,01°�JR,N 1;� ��:'i�i I'€�� C�UBUClI.lE-CLER�C OF DISTF�ICT C(J1.�RT j � ������'�r'��j I, �� , IN THE IOWA DIS�rr��:'�' COURT F�R D�IBUQUE �'OUN'�'I��I�A�� �;�� �: �� '', �� --------- ; �IC`iJ� ti.Ji4'C�4t� ��1f�`� ��I f 1�V+J � JERRY BRAI'�DENBURG, �''L��f�t�,��;, J�4 I �_." � , Plaintiff, il vs. LAW NO. 01311_ Ii CITY OF DUBUQUE, ORIGINAL NOTICE CHAD E. BAXTER, CARRIE E. BAXTER, ' and JAMES W. WATTERS, � Defendants. �li I� ,,I � TO THE ABOVE-NAMED DEFENDANT: i �i Yoii are notified that a Petition has been filed in the Office of the Clerlc of this Cotiirt, naming you as a Respondent in this action. A copy of the Petition is attached to this Notice. The attorney for the Plaintiff is Susan M. Hess,whose address is Hammer Law Finn, PLC, 590 Iowa Street Suite 2 Dubu ue IA 52 001. The attorne , I , , , s hone number is 563-582-1560 facsimile q Y P number 866-921-6143. 'I ;, You must serve a motion or answer within twenty(20) days after service of this Original ,�' Notice upon you, and within a reasonable time thereafter,file yol�r motion or answer with the Clerlc of Court for Dubuque County, at the County Courthouse in Dubuque,Iowa. If you do not,judgrnent li by default may be rendered against you for the relief demanded in the Petition. 7 ,u If you need assistance to participate in court due to a disability, call the disability i"' coordinator at (319) 833-3332. Persons who are hearing or speech impaired may call Relay Iowa `i TT�'�1-8�0-735-2942). Disability coordinators cannot provide legal advice. (SEAL) �� Clerk of Court i�' Dubuque County Courthouse � PO Box 1220 " Dubuque, Iowa 52004-1220 IMPORTANT: ;; YOU ARE ADVISED TO SEEK LEGAL ADVICE AT ONCE TO PROTECT YOUR �� INTERESTS. � �i i �� i� i7 ii r `� N i �� ; � �� ; � � , E-FIL�D 2019 JAN 16 �1:t79 AM DIJBUQtJE-CLERK t�F DiSTRICT COURT � � 1 il �TAT� OF IOWA JUDI�IARY caSeNo. LACV108580 II County �ubUqUe �' CaseTitle g�ANDEBURG V CITY OF DUBUQUE ET AL �� ��I I� THIS CASE HAS BEEN FILED IN A COUNTY THAT USES ELECTRONIC FILING. I� Therefore,unless the attached Petition and Original Notice contains a hearing date for your appearance,or unless you obtain an !I exemption from the court,you must file your Appearance and Answer electronically. '; 'ii j You must registerthrough the lowa Judicial Branch website at http:(Iwww.iowacaurts.state.ia.us/Efile and obtain a log in and � password for the purposes of filing and viewing documents on your case and of receiving service and notices from the court. i I FOR GENERAL RULES AND INFORMATION ON ELECTRONIC FILING,REFER TO THE IOWA COUl2T RULES CHAPTER I 16 PERTAINING TO THE USE OF THE ELECTRONIC DOCUMENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM: !;i http://www.iowacourts.stale.ia.us/Efile � FOE2 COURT RULES ON PROTECTION OF PERSONAL PRIVACY IN COURT FILINGS,REFER TO DI'VISION VI OF IOWA � COURT RULES CHAPTER 16:http:l/www.icawacourks.state.ia.us/Efile u Scheduled Hearing: �II I� �i ',II � If you require the assistance of auxiliary aids or services to participate in court because of a disability,immediately call your district IIIII ADA coordinator at (319)833-3332 . (If you are hearing impaired,call Relay lowa TTY at 1-800-735-2942.) 1 01/16/2019 11:09:15 AM �' Date Issued �II � ��, ,; �� � _.�.. � �, ���T ��� ,, ` � �� � � � `��'�'` 3�' � 1,�;.t ..,� . �l � . + District Clerk of Dubuque County � /s/ Chandal Link ;; � ; � � i � j � � e i ' � ° E-FIL�C� 2t319 JAN 15 12:16 PM DUBUQUE-CL�RK OF DISTRICT COURT I � i � �`a `�`�C� ICC���'.� I��S'�'RICT CC)UliT F(3R DLTBLTf�UE CQtil�'T'�,IC�t�V.� � i I -____� .�.--- ii � I .��I��r BI�1i�I)Ei�tBLiR�, ; ii Plaa.��tzff, ,) �rs. , LA��1'�t�. �I 311 �I 'I �`TT``�' C)�`D�J���.T�7�(7E, �'ET�TTt�N� F!T°L�i�V A]�T3 J�JR�' � �`I-�A.TT:��. BA�.'CER, CAR.RIE E. .BA�TEP, I�E1�Ir�ND ; ',� �i�� J�I��ES�V. t��AT`TEP.�, i �'�i Def���al�ts. I' �€�i�IE�t�1��`tl��..Plai��titt, ;iE��� BR.4�1���;BUI;.t�,hy a�ie�th�Qu�l���is atta�-�i�y�, i �ti�s�n�vi�-Iess, ��I���v��r;r L�,�v�irt�a,PT..C, �t�cl fc�r IZi� �etiti€�n �:t La���, st�tcs tcr the C���r-t�� , f�l�c�ws: P�.I�'-T'I.ES 1. Pl<�i�t�ff .IERP�' �3R�.�DE-t`�IB�F�t� is � citizen �f Dul��.�q�.i� �e�i��ty, I�r��x� anc� r�sicic.s ,�t �3T9 1�.ck:�e��-t �t., Dut��.l����, �o�ra, �'"I�z��ti�f is �ep�-es���ted by ��xsa�� Iv1. Hes� t�� �i'; TH�tnx��e�La�v:�"ix-z��, k�LC, 59(� T��v�St., �tc�. 2, I���b�.�e����.�a�ra���C11. f '�� `?. ZZ��fes�c�aiYt Cl�a�i E. B�xt�r ai�d �ar-�ie E. ���:tex �xe citi�ens o��u�at���ae Cc���ntY, Ia���a��c���v�l pr�per-�y�t �1�5 Sli�r�s A��ei����,Dut�uq��e,I�ubuc��.�e County, Ic��va 52�}C�1. �. �+e:fec�c�ax�t ��i�nes �G�i, �att�:r� i� a cifiiz�zl c�f 1�7uh�:�q�.ie �c�unty; I:�c�b�.�c�ue +Cc�unty; Ic��°� �nd o�,v�-�s�rc�pe�.�y �t 3??5 5�zir�s Avenue, l���bti�c�ue,I�wa 52C1fJl. i 4. Defen�i�nt City �f D�1b�,����e, I�w°� i� �: Cit�r ct��i�-�iz�d i�� tl�e Stat� �f I��,�� j (�z��a'f��I Pv'�tic� �tzd a c��y ��tl�is P�titic�n at I.a�w rnay �� sea-v�d u��c�t� t�e �'ity� �f'T��i��tq,ue, ; Io�va,t�z.�-c�a.z�l�ifis Gity Cle��c, 5C� ��%, (3$r��t., I7t�i�eaq�.�e, I3L�1�L���ze Cdunty, Ioti�•a. � J[1I�ISDI�T�CDN AI�tI)�EI�vrTJ� ; i 5. Tl�i� Co�lrt h��s s���sj�ct zn�tt��-j��-isdictia�� �z�� pers���al jurisciictit�n c���r �acl� of � fize �arties lzur�to, anc� tl�e �u-���t�7�t in ct���trav�xsy, e:��l�asive c��i.�xt��•�s� �nd costs, e�ceecls tl�e ' rniaairra��t�z ju�isc�i�;tic��ial rec��iirer�aezits�f'tl�is�c�u�-t. ;i i ��i �� , , Pa;4 1 of S ' ; ; I - i � ' i �^�IL�lJ 201�Jt1B'1 IJ 12. €V I-IVI IJL7U��SCL/��L.+LLRI\VB- BJI�I�ilr i ��LJfl� � ,,��I � 1 � � 6� Venc��is prc��aez•ii�tl�is Cou�.-t�u�-s��al�t to To�va Coc�e ��16.�� (?�31'7)in�of�r a�t1i� ; i��ci�e�lt tl�at Gva� t1t�:�ro�ir�7�t�c�;usc�f fil�e z���j�rt�ies �r�d�sim��;es s��sfiazn�cl�y t��e F'lai��tiff Uccc�rze� in I7�z�a��r��ze Coz���ty,Ic��va. ,i i ',' �f�L�N`T�-CIT�'C1F�UP>U�DUE � 7. PIai�ltiff r��tat�s a����e-alleges �ara�t-�p]�s 1 tl��c��.z��l��, i�zcl���i���, as t1�o���� sct f�ar•t1� �n fii�ll�ecea:�er. � b. �tn a�l�.�:�-i.ar tc��`ebzttat•;r 17,?O l��t��.�Plaintiff;Je�•�Brancler�l�ur�,���s� �•�szc��nt c,� '�319 3�e1:5c��� �t7•ect, Tlub�.�q��e,Dub����tae�c>����t�, Ic��,v��?'f�tJ�. �. f��� c�r�I�c��€t Febr�Gary 17, 20X�, t1��, L�efenci�z�t, City of.��a���c��:���v�s ciz��-�eci�viti� _ _ a�n�i��taiz�zi���it�r streets,�+c�tl� i�-�c�ividc��llv a�1d�y�nd t1u�uJ1l�i� a��nts, sea-va��ts and �I eznplavees, i�c;luc�i��g a city� �trc��t a�ti�e a����c��31.�5 a��c���?5 �hir�s Ave��:�r�, I�Lil��zq��e, Ic����a 5'?C���. I 1 Q.A�t����ai��e tim�a�a.� �t���,the�laintiff; ��%�s l�wfLzlly wall�:in�c�z�sa�ct s�re�t x��ar th� cl�-iv����y��a�r��ac�z�t a l�5 a:nc� �i22� S1�icas A�en�.��ts� 1c��a1< at�truel�. �c���a-ti5�d fc�.� s�l�. ,' 1 l. T��erc is n� sic�e�vatl�����1-c�side oftlle�`ity Str��t w�ere PIG�ii�tiff��tas wall�i���, �' 12. At�i�e s�.��te ti���e�i��I.��1���� t�sc�L�e�'�i�c�a���,�y a��d t�xr�u�;1�i�� ��e��t�, ��rva�t� anc3 + ��n��I�yee��ai�ecl tc�����.i��tait�tl���f�r�m���fii���ec1 st�eet az�c� �t clet��i�r�.te� �;��.��iz��a 'I la�-�e c�peia�athale at�z°���ar tl�e cl�-i�re�a�F�:pprc����Z. �I 1;. �t t11e sa��e tir���a��c��lac�t1�ex e�r�s a���c�w a��c�i��. �c;c�:�tn��Iati���.t�i7 tl���tz-�ets, j sidev�a�I�aiid c��i�fcw�y. J �I 1�. �t t��e s�s��e tinz�:�nc1�-�l�cc�, as�IZe �Iai��tiff stepped%n tl-se Iar�e��t��c�l� cc���re�in �a�o�v; cau�i���hit�i7 t� f��lZ �n� ��ast�in ser-iat��i�j e�z-v tc�1�is ri���t til�ia a��d an�1�, �,I 15, L?�.fen�Ia�ifi, i��z�.ivi:cl���lly ai�ti b}� ancl th:��c�l��l�i�s a�ents, s�z������ts ��-�d einplc�yce�,h�d� I�' elu�y t� ���i��t�z�az tl���fc�r�er7le�tic�n�c��t�e�t,iz�c�udir��st7icl.sti•�et� tc�r p�rsazas 1��v�f'ully j� c��i�ai� �tt���t, �c�incl�.�clin�t����Iainfiif�. 'j 16. D�f��cla.���, �s���e z���is�tai��er�f�he a�ore�nel-�tio��e�t�tree€ �it���r�ndivicl�all ar b � ar�� tl�r��.��1�it� ��en�s, ser�,�ant5, ai�tcl e����lc�yees fdil�cl tc� �ct��rith r�asanaE�le eare a�7c� �I vv�s tl�ec�ai�� there gt�alty�f or�e c�r n�c�z-e c�f�l�e�ollcawin�c�reless a��d ne�Ii�erit�c;ts � a�d�tnissiaz��: j �. Fa�le� tc� inai��t�in �1liras ��r�z1��e a��� t��place�f`tlze f�I1, ' ; �a. F'ai:le� t�a repair tli�street; !� ;i ! , Pag�Z of 8 �i ' ( . y ' �-�ILED 20�9 JARI 15 12:16 PM QUBUQUE-CLERK C�F DISTRICT COURT I'I � , 'i ; c. Failecl tc� ���r��Plai�zti�'t a�zcl ��t�ier persc�z�s 1��,�jfc�liy on said strc;et t�fth� c�r��1��r-c�us c:c�z�rliti��1�vllen �efez��a�lts l�i�e��ar shc���l�lz�ve�nati�j�� z�����e I e�e��ci�c crz�ac�c�i���ry e.arc il1�t saicl �fa��t�in���as x��ces��ry t�}�rey�cnt������ry�o � tl�e�'Iaintiff; j , � c1. �'�il�cl tc�m�ke a reasc�na�Ie insg�e�,tic�n e�f'it�st�-�et��°�ezz xt�Cr�cu° �r, in t1�c � � ��erci�c of c�rcii����ry caz•e s����;�I�l l��ve kn��-n f�����ai� iz�s���cticsx��vas II ���c�ssary tc��re���z�t injuiy�o t��� �laintiff�z�c�otl��rs lEiw�izlly on��icl strc��, j f �. �.1:1c�wecl t��e�£c�r��n���tic��leet�z•e�ni���ta rez�ai�� i:l� a�Gil���rc�tzs c�nc�it�n.€�; '; �. F'��ile� ta pe�fc�i-t�a sna��• �zad ice remc���l �ei�°ie���n� c�l.�.�ti�s in a l�az�r�er strc�� �s t� a��•+..�ic�t��e cr�atixl�saf'ai�uau�at�tra� acc���mt�l�tia�n c�f ice arnc� s��c�w in t}�c� f1 �ac�thole ax�CI�e�tr�et,; �;. ��ileci fi�����f�a�t���cat�: ancl ice r�;��,����1 i�� a�;cc�r�ancc�vltl-� �ustic:�x����d �r�cti�c ir�tl�.e iz��.u�tr�resi�ltiil�in���ocv��zd ice�c��.�������:�tin��:rnnatu�-ally:�t li t��e 1c�t�atic�n c�f`said��c1c�e��t� 1�. G����era�ly,i�a fa�li��tc� excrc�s�z:��.s�a�a�le car�cl�.ae��cl��tri���� �u1� tr�vel�rs t��.tl�e��.�t��i�.�t�����s� j .i � � i. �ti�� c�tlz���v�s�e�reless ar��i �e�li�;����in.t�x�mai�te�x�nc�af tlxe str�et at t��is ', 7aca��ti�n. ;� f l 7. �� a d'arc�.t�t�d�rr��iz��tc�r�sult�f c,r�e �r anc�rc��'t��e farc���i���ne�li�eni�ct:� c-��• i o���issza��� c�f t���Def�i�����t, tl�� �'1�i��ti.��s�lstGii��.e� �eve�•e�i�d p�laner�t i�ju�-ics; � b�tl1 intern�l�v anc� ��t�n7ally, ��� ��;��s �nel will be l�i���cz�d ���c��revez�t�d��-c�rr� !i att�n�i���;�'rs�.�sual�iuti.es ���d atfairs of 1��e; aza�h<�s lc��t���� �ill i�i tl�e�.�t��r�l�se I' v���:�e c��'that t��a���s �f�r������tic�nzcl. I� 1�. �s a�irect��t�cl p�•c�xi�nate z�e�;��lt c�ftl�e�f�resa.id carele�s ar�cl n��1i��7�t acts ���tl�e �'laintii�; tl�et� ar�c�t�1er�suf�cre�l �,:,n•e�t pait� a��e� aa-��uis�,bc�tl� gn inin� �nc��ocly�z�d ���i11 zc� �l�e fi�tX�r�cc���tz�i�:ae ta sizffcr.'T1�e Plax��tiff�.irti�er e�tpc��ac�r.� �nci �;�r�t1������cl ii �i�� becon��lie��l:e fc�r l�r,�e s��z�as�f���cy fi�z•��reelic�l�:�re�nd ser�,�i�e� er�d�ai�c�rii�� d ta he�oz�n�I�ealc� �n� cL�z-�� c�f sai� iz�atxr��es. '� '9 , ,� "t4r�IEf�EFC3�2.E,Piaz��t���, Jen�Br�nci��ib�r��ray� f�r j����znent��ai��st t1-�e D�f�rt��a��t. �� i11 s�.�cl� ai1 asn�unt tl���t�wi1� fairly�r�� aci��uat��v cc�znpez�s��t�tl�c Pl��int�ff��r�is i��j��ries,Ic�s�es � ata� c1a�n�;es r�s li�rciil�1�c��Fe��ll��ee�, �c��ts �ft�i� s�,�it, �ncl a��y�crtl7er�•�lie���.71�ic1�t1�is � Hc���c���bl� Cc�urG�z�d tair a��cl j�ist, � � � 0 �y k � �E � �. �: P<��e 3 af� k R � � tl . I E-�ILECD 2019 JAN 15 12:16 PM DI.iE�iJQUE- CLERK C}F DlSTRICT C(JURT I�I CQi�1'�T �1-CFi.�D F3.��:TE� L�. �'�:�.T�.IE B�-��YTER I'' , l9. 1�1�intiffr��t�fies anc��e-�I���es:1?�ra�,���phs I tl�r€�L��h 6, zi�clz��i�=e, as til�t����h set t��l� I, i� fixll l�er�af't�� � �; '?�. �n���ci�ric��t�Fel��-u�ry 1'7, 2���, tlie 1'1�inti:��,:Iez�ry Br�u�c��i7t�ur�, �,�,�as a r�sa�et�t c�f 2�19 Jacl;�s�z1 S�rc�t, D�:z1�zx.��t�:,�u��.�c�ue Cc�ti�a�ty, Ic��va�?€�{�l. i `?1. CC��� :I�e�rL�azy l7,2f�1� l�e�ea�claz�t Ba�t��-s c�wn�el��-����•�y at 3185 Shiras Ave��ue, '� I;��:it���c�u-c�a����ty,T���v��. ??, C?il�z-����ut �e�:t�:tar� 17, ?G1�, tl�.e L3efeilc��nt$��t��•s were cl�ar�;e� �vith��ai��t�i��'r�� �hcir premises. � 2V. �,� tlxe s����c ti7�ze�.��c��l�c�, tl�e F'��i��tiff�, �,�r�s I�wfi��ly�r�1�i11�c�a� s�id st���t at the �irive���y a�1�rc��cl7 bet��ee� �'?'"?5 4�nd�1�5 a�tiX��s 1��eriu�i��:t���Ci�y�af Dubitc��t�:�o Icsc�k�t a tz-�:�c1�ad�erti�ect fc�r�a1e al�1:°� Shir�s Avez�ti��. ?=�. A.t tl�e s�i�zc ti���e an�p1ac�., t1�e I�e�e���lai�t Ba�ter�, i��c�i�ridta��ly��d�;y az�c�tl�rc����,i� fil�e��•a�e��t�, se1-��a��t� a�d �lx�pl�y���r����.cl� duty tc� ��az��taiz� t��e�fc�r��-i�er�ti�r�ed ����e�-�y, clrave�,�r�y, siete��atl� a��cl stre�t, fo�•�e�•:�r���s 1��fitlly on ��i� st��e�t,'tv iz�c,Iudia��tl�e P1�i��tift. ?�. r�,:t���e sa��i�ti���e��cl pl�ce, th�U�f�z7d�:���t B�xters,by a��cl t1�c��zb1� its a����ts, �� �er�r�x��s ancl en��1���es t�i1�c1�o n-��iniain till�ir�rc��a�rtv z��s�.�c;t�a m�nrl�r w��l���-e�I�e i' area�bec�i�e a�-�ci ea�s�cl a fa�l�ia.��rcl. � ' �I �C. At k�ae s������in���r�ci placc;x tl�e�ef�rzd��t���:ters, as t�ze prap�z-ty�o���n�r,eit��er � ii�c�ivicl.ual[y c�a�by�aa1�� t1�t:c�ug1� its a�ez�ts, �erwantss �n� en�plovees fai�e�l tc� ��:t�vit1� ; re�sc���at�le car� al�� svas then���c� there���ilty�c�f on��r���.�a���,f t11�fc�11���in��arele�s ��� a��cl ne�li�ent ac:ks and�rmissi�ns: f� '�� a. �°ail�rzb td ��-c�perly���a���tai��their�t'c��crty�n�l��d��z�szci��vall��, �rive��ay an.� '� clriv�.wa�r�.p��-�act�; � i�. F�iled tc� �,v�n�Plaizztiff�z�ci c�tller��.rsc�ns 1����t�z1l}����s�icl �r�p�ztwf c�f t�1e l:r d��l��;crc�t�a e,�r�ditzo���v11c��Defe��d�t�ts lct����t o��l�c��ild have k�,own in t1�e j 'i e��er�.ise���rciir�ary ca�-e t1��t saicl���arzzi���;�vas i1c��ssary�a�t:ev�ent injury tc� � �> tlle PI�i��ifF; ' � c. �`E�ilecl to znake �r����z-rab�e i�aspe�,ti��}ot i��prc��er�fy i��cludi���sidcw�lIc, � dri��e���y azx� drive��ray app.raa�la���1i��� it k��eti�r c�r i�� flt�e:�ercis�af or�i��az�� � ea1-e,����uld have Itinc�����tl���t sai�i i��s�e�kic�n��as_l�e�e�sary tc��revent i��jtt�rj; � tc�tl�e P�air�tiff�n�l r�t��ers la��r�iilly��� ��zd street, ; C q � � S "F � ���2�O�$ � � f � � li� , �I, ' E-FILE�t 2Q19 J1�N 15 1�:`i6 PIVI l�llBUQUE -CL�RK OF DISTRICT CC3URT ��i �� " I �I. �. ��lla�vcci t1�e�foren��t�tic�Yl�d��•ei��usc tc�rerrzai�� in a�a�.���r���i� ��zzci sli���er� '. cc�tlt�itic�n; � , �� � e. Faile�l�r�p�r#�is�� sa�c��v �i�cl i�e�ein�va� s�,��sices a1�e��uties i:i� �r r1�at�t.z�et:suci� II �s ts� ��r��z� tl-�e cz�eatrl���,�'a�1 uz��atural acc�.2�n�alatic�z-�c��ice and s�io�;�r i��t1�� � �II }?�t�-�c�le it�.tl?e 1�catiaa�,af tlae i��cic�e��t; �, f. Gen�raliy,i1� f��li�;tc� exerc:is�reasc�r���bl�c:�re ���e,pi;�estlz�n� �lad����er II; �e��o3�� 1�tvfiilly�a�� fl�e pre���iscs,, �I �. As � c�it�ct ���c��rc��ig�-iat�result��at�e t��a�c�re c�f t1�e�`�are��in�;za��li�;ent�ct� ; c�r c>i��issis�r�s at t��c�e��;a�dant Baxtcr�, tize Plaia��iff s��stait��� ����ere�nc� , p��-�na��e�zt x��j�ric.s; l�c�th i�ztern�lly=���.cl extez���lly, arz� �vas az1c� ��jill b� �° l�in�e�e� a��cl��r�v����tec� �'i•r���t��tter��:ir��l�i�iisual c��.lties ��a� a��aits c�f'la��, �iz��� �� ��L�s lost �l�d will�r�t���futt�r�lase�•al�:a��a�t���t ti�x�e as �foz•�c��entic����rl. �;� ; 1�. �hs�clirect ai�cl prc��zzn�te resL�lt�[ t1�e�fc��-�sai�i�arcless at��:I i�e�li���7t�cts c�� I � t���L�f�z�c��.�zt�axt�rs;t����'1�intifftl����.ar�d �t�e�•e sl�f�e�-ed �re<�t�azn���c� az���is��,b�t�� in zni��c� a:z�.c� 1�ociy�z�c���i11 in thc f�xt�.ir��a��ti.nti��ta su�t�r. T17;e I'I�i���iff ti�rtllc�r ex�e�z��e1 a��� �vi11 e�penct��zc1 l�Ec���e�iable f�x•l�r�c� s�xzns c�E'�nc�n�y�'e�r aneclical ca����t���e���icLs er��icav��rin�tc�bccfln�c heal�;� a��c� e;uTed c�f saicl inj�:��-ies. � 4�'II�I���C7I��, Pl�iz�tif�, Jc;�-�•y Br�z�c��zsE��,ir�g��-�t}�Ys ���r ji���rn�nt�gaiz�st tI1�I��fez��l��t Ba�.t�,rs,i��a s��c�z t����znc,z��1t�IZr�t�vi1l f�irly ai�d�d�c��.��tely co��.�ez�s�te t1�e Pl�zx�ti�'t f�.�r l7is i inj�.�rie�,�c�sses a��c���a�����es as�er�i� ab�v°e a1le,�ec�, �otits�f t�is suit, ���d a���fi.irt�l�r zeli�f' �' ��rl-�ici2 tliis Hs.�sz���able C'c��,�z-�faz�d f�ar ancl j�.ist. �; C(�LII�TT III-J��1��I�S�V,��✓�TT��� I,I ' �?7. Pl�.ir�t�f�`xestates a��c� �e-a�l��es �'ara�'�p��s I thrflL��� �,i1��ILFsivc, �s t�-�a�c�h set fUrt�� ',, in f�ilt�cr�after ; �.i � ?�. C7�7 a�icl p�-ior tc�Feb�-�z�ry 17, '?.(�1�,t��e�'',l�:iz�tiff� J�z�ry.Bt'a��cle���ti��'�.�xas a resi�ei�t t�fi '� 23I�J��lcS�a�a St�•er�t,I��i�su�ue, 1��.�buc�zz�Cr�c�nty, Ic��;ra 52��1. � � 29. Cln Febr��z�ru 17, 2f31� Def�;nclant�vVa�ters o�:v���e�l�rc��a�rty at 3'??� Shiras A.���t��.i�, �' II:tc��sur�����'c���iat��, lc���:T�. � i 30. Jn c�r at�c���t Febx-c�ar� 1 i, �Q�8,t�1e L�efenetal�t��1att�.rs���as cI-�ar��cl�v1th r������zt�iz�za�,� �� t11�ir�remises. 4, u � 31.At t��e �ar��tz�7�e a��ci�alace, tl�e Plaizzti�f;w�s l��r�fully walki���on�aid str-eet at tlle �'� clrive���ay apprt�acl�bctyveen 3`�`?'S �nd 31�5 Shira� Aw�etaue in tl�e Cit�,r o��ttbttqt��t� � 1«�k at a tr�,aek �c���ertisecl fQr s�l� at ?�1�5 Sl�ira� �v���tae. ` �; 1 �, , i F���e 5 c�t'8 !I r , ,, ,JII P n � � � l ° E-FILED 2d19 JAN 15 12:16 PM DUBIJQUE-CLERK OF QISTRlCI`"COURT � i � ; �'?. �t thz sa�n�ti��1e ai-�cl�Iacc,�I�e DeFez�c�a��t'4�I��tt�rsa i��cli�rici�i��ly�ncl by��2d tlara�z�� , 'I l�is aget�ts, �e�-�r���ts ai�d e�n��I€�y�.ae�,11�d� c���ty t�����iir�tain tl-�� afc�re�nexatic��7�� t I �7rop�rty�, cil-�ve«�av, c�rive�v���r���Yc�ach, ��7d si�e�va.l.l�, f�r p�rsc�ns la��'f��lly�n saic� a �t��e;�t, to ii�cl�.idi���tl�e 1'laintiff. 1 � �33. �t t1�� sa1�2e tiin����d}�tace, th�L?�f�nda��t��'attc-rs,l�y�ta.ct t�rrr��,�g1i its age�ats, �'i ser�:�ax�.ts an� e�nplt����;e5 i`��ile�i tc� za�ai�at�in l�zs�ra�crt�=in s�.�ch �����rll�er��r�ier�th� I! ai-e��}�eca�ne��i� ca�1��� a t�.11 �1az�rd, ' j i � ��. At tl�� :�aine ti.����art� �als�c:e, the L;1�fe��rl���1t`���te�•s, as t11�;�i-aper�y c�v�rz��r, eit��er I i��c1i�{icl�rally�r�v ancl t11i~au�I� i�s a���x��, s��-�;��its, �nd�����Zc�ye�s f�ilec�tu act��r�t�. � reasc�nabl�care at�� ��,°as tl�ela a�1c�t11e�e gt�iltY c�fc��te �r t��arc�f tll�frall.c�`��zt��e�.retess '� ar�c� n��1i�e.r7t aGt�at1� c��nissic�t�s: I� �; �.. �'��ili�t�ta}��-a��arly�Z��ii�t�ai��tl��;ir�t:o�crt�•iizcl�.G�iz��si.t����ra11��, c�rive�ray�r�� � clri�,r��,vay a����s��c�ach; I b. �ail�� tc� ����r;��'lf�i�ti�f`a��c� c�tl-�er�e��c���zs�a�vfi.�11y o�� said pz�c�pert�c�ftl�e c[aii��ei-cau��can�itic�za ���l�en ��f�1�c�a�zt�tc�z���� c����13c���r�l�.�v��n��v�� ita til�� I ex�rczse o���rdi��.�ry�car�t��at s�icl �v���-z-�i����va�neces�ary�c��are�'er�t i���itry tc� ', t1-��Pl�iiztiff;. c. �ai�ecl tc����al����e�sc�n��l�f�:���ectir�n ot its p�•cs��rty inc��.�c�ti���si��e�a11�, �iri�.�ew�y az�d cl�i�Fe�vay������€�acl��,�°l�er� it I��e��; �r in tl�c�e�ercise c�f��r�in�r-y c�r� s�2c�'��lc�1�a�{e l��c��vi-�tJ�at s�icl in��s��tic��1��as��eces�a�-�tc� ��e�f�:nt iz����ty �; to t1i�Plain�i�'��a�e�c�t���;r� l��ufially c��� s�ic��t�c�t; ,; ; ; I � d. AII�����cl tl�e a�or����x�tit�n��prc�n��e to re����'r��i� � cl�;�z���:rc�tits ���c��l.i���er� � ctasaditiaz�; 'i � c�. l�L1e� tc��aerf�rzn s�lc�w a���1 ice r�i-rrr�v��l services �z����.uties ii�a�n���ner su��� ',� �s t� avc�ici th��reati����f a�z�is�nat�.��•�T acc�.aznc�I�tiQn of ice a�.�.s�c��v ii�the � pr�k l�olc i.z���e lc��atic�tt cs�t1��i17c'r�.�c�nt; ��1 � � f. GeF1�raIly, i�z f�iiiz�y ta e�;ercrs�:r�as�iiabl��a�•�c�u��eclestri���s �1�c1�ther I� pers�z�s�a��fially 0�1 t��e prex��ises, ',i ,�,1 g: As � �ir�ct���d�}r:�xir-nate z��s�:��t af c�a1�c�r mc�re��'tl�.e fc�re�c�iz��;ne�;li�ent �cts '� ��c�r�iy�ic�z�s�t t1�� De;fe���lant��'atters,t�7e I'lt�ir�ti�f su�tain�cl s���eze ���c� r pcn�2�ne�zt in�u�-��s, bc�tla i��err�ally�anc�exter��ally; ar�ci�v�s a�1d v��i11 l�� � �inderec� a���pre.v�ntecl frorn a�te�ldi���;l�is�.�su�.I cl�t#ies and�ftai��s of life,a��c� � �-�as k�st azxc� ��fi1l ia�tl�e fi�t�.lre�Qs��;�al.��� of tl�at tii��� as�fore��leT�tzone�. G � h. As �t direc.t an� pr�axi�nate r�s�ilt af t11� �f�resa�cl eareless ���c1����;li,�erat ac�s �f �' t1�e��f����iant���at#�rs, tl�e Plaiz�tif�tlier�an� there st��ferec�gr�at p�ir� �x�� � � � � Pag�6 0l 8 � € � � '� " 'ii �-�I�E� 2019 JAi�I 15 12:16 PM C3UBlJQUE-CLERK C)�' C71STf;f{�T�i7t���" i � 1 I ai�Gx�.lisla, i�{�tla in i-��i�d �zx��b�ci��atz�i ��-il� iz�tl�e fr�t:�ir�coz�tez���c tc� sl�ft�l•. T���; ''I I'la.i��tift��z-ti��z-e�p�izcled a��cl v�,�ill ex��ezacl��a.ci�ecc��x�e 1zt�b��.fc�r 1���•�e sl�r7is � c���n����°v for��net�ic�I ca�e �����s�r��.ic�s ei�cic�vc���in�tc�b�ca����I�e�leci a��� '� i ��:�a�e� pf��i�:l i.nj��ries. € � i '4ti'�I1C:I�:�T`C3F�.E, �1�intift, :T�t-c��Bra��clenl��.�t���r��y� Far jt�d4���.��7t a��ir.�st t11�D�ter�dant ; �fi�'�tters,izx s�.tcli �x� aa���c�x�t t���t u�ill �'airly Z�t� acicc�ia:�tel.�• cc�rl���eris�te.t��e�':I�.iz�ti:fF f��,l�is I iz�j���-i�;s, �c�s�c� �i�d ��a1����;�cs as���re��� ��c���� alle�ecl, �osts c��tl�i� s��it, �nd a��r��fi�rtl�er aeli.c;t �' vvhicl-�t��is �Ca���r�.ble Cc��:t-t fi�zd tair az1cl just. ',i �[:)T�"�"T��:14I�NL� J C'OiV��� �'�tC���' �I�i€�tiff; T�r-��y �r�nc��zlb��r�, ���icl h.e��e�y �°ec�c�e�ts t�ial ��� j���-y ��' tl-�� ; , ��t�rs�,�-c�,�.pti�n��1��a�t�.r. �.� ; � . r �f� �� I � �� � i 8��: � s'���:�, � �;� cis�z���, Hess A"��1�3f��7�5 �I�1���v��E� Lr1�� FTI�IVI, :�.�.C. ��C� ic���ra�t., St�. `� L�ita��q�te; It� S?Q�}l �"e�e}�l�c�r�:�. (��3) 5�3'?_1 S��J F��: (��6} 9`�I�CI�� ����ai�: �ti�.�;Z����i;li���Z�����r1z���c;�ll:�c�5,cc���� Ii i �I �i Ili ;i i 'li I u i ,' ;' I� i i ii Ij � �ti 'I �I. II I�! I�il I II. � § I ��������� � d li s s li I� : I' E-�'IL�I� 2a19 J�ON 15 12:16 PM C31.lBUQUE-G�ERK OF DISTR9CT C(3URT ' 'i i i : , �i �TATE {��' �C}�T�. � �I � ss: C'C)UI�IT� QF DLFB[J�UE ) � I, J�i�v Brai�d�t��+��r�, b�it��� tir�t d�.�ly° ���c�rn c��� o�tl�, �e�a:se ��cl st�te tl��f I arn t��� i Flai��tit�ma�in� t1�- tc7�•��in� P�t:ztiQl�; tl��;�t I hav°�z����� tlle s����� a���I kz�c�u� t��� c;�an�e���� 4��ercqf: ��' a��c�tl�at t�3� �t��e��n�t�at� ai�.� a11��,atira�Is t�l�rezz� r�.�c�c����•� tct.�e a�ci�n�c�ct as I�e�•i1y b�licve. ; li ����� ���� �����.�'� ��' �'�' Q�..� -. �I Jetry� r��c1e,r�b��r� . '� i vs.� � f r'.,. 5�.���eri�red a��t� s��r��tc�1���"i�re an�tlais ���� c�ay����.. �"'���,�.�.��.#�� ����,� �,..�_ � a..� � � ..� �0 � � i _,m � , � � `,:�i ���i i�R as��`� � ` $ ,.�l> �.����,� �� �C{a� ���. °e # ���, `�-���: i14�R f`� 3�.�f '�' q� «d � ��.. � . „ � � ... �; 4 � 1 if�&,5�1�$�LFf6-^�3i Wd�tf-fb ' � �tPLL�( 4YV�lA�.. lf�b41.A�xl.�k�-l��G'�I�LLIV��iVYYL4 ,.'_. �', E �� 3 A .,��„ 4..,2ta,��..:ua�:� `�+�=a'�r5.5 ��.' `� . �..��I���� � I I� li I��, li �' I! jl II �� I�I � � II I! �II L II y