Loading...
Work Session - Sustainable Dubuque Quarterly Report Copyrighted November 18, 2019 City of Dubuque Work Session - Top # 1. ITEM TITLE: 5:30 PM WorkSession - Sustainable Dubuque SUMMARY: Sustainable Communities Coordinator Gina Bell and network partners will provide an update on the City of Dubuque's path forward to improved air quality. SUGGESTED DISPOSITION: ATTACHMENTS: Description Type Sustainable Dubuque Work Session-MVM Memo City Manager Memo Staff Memo Staff Memo Air Quality Update_Sustainable Dubuque Presentation Supporting Documentation Dubuque THE CITY OF � AIFMerisa Cfh DuB E 'ill �' Master iece on� tl2e Mississi i zoo�•zo�z•zo�3 P PP zoi�+zoi9 TO: The Honorable Mayor and City Council Members FROM: Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager SUBJECT: Sustainable Dubuque Quarterly Work Session Agenda DATE: November 14, 2019 Sustainable Community Coordinator Gina Bell is transmitting information for the Sustainable Dubuque Work Session. ��� �� ���� Mic ael C. Van Milligen �� � MCVM:sv Attachment cc: Crenna Brumwell, City Attorney Teri Goodmann, Assistant City Manager Cori Burbach, Assistant City Manager Gina Bell, Sustainable Community Coordinator Dubuque THE CTTY OF � All America Ciq DuB E ;��I.� �, Maste iece on the Mississi i z°°'.Z°lz=z°13 rP PP zoi�*zoi9 TO: Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager FROM: Gina Bell, Sustainable Communities Coordinator SUBJECT: Sustainable Dubuque Work Session Agenda DATE: November 13, 2019 The purpose of the memo is to set the agenda for the Sustainable Dubuque Work Session scheduled for Monday November 18, 2019 at 5:30 pm in the City Council Chambers. The presentation will address the following topic: 1. Update on Dubuque's Path Forward to Improved Air Quality Thank you. . � � . . -�.-� ,M�_ �„� ` � r� , ,� �,� '�6.�. r ' � ' � ' � � i � ' ` -r- `� ` � ` .✓ � ' / " �� �, � � . + ' 1l �• _ � ► , , i � - ' , , � � `. — , .. � � , - �. � ; . �t _�' K � ' r'�[ ' �1. . , • '`�"";`� � • P� '� � . ' M i .'1t • � • t ' �� • �1 ` �, _ _ ,��� �? •_� ��• ..• n �� ,� J Y'�il .• �ti i�- �`�„r _Y ' 1 i V� • ��r • � � �`J �/ �`� � .. .�T,S- r.+. .�7�'� � ' �i . �;" ♦• � ' + � th .�. � � , �_�'�l� . .'- � . � `�: , ( 11�• t , '-'�ij1�.. .' {:`,.,. ,.�� � , � • • 1 • • 1 • , `. ' _ • - - '-'.` � t � ' '� �n. . `M.L''� r. `', '1i.��� � _ ^ . 1 '� V. �ti Z .,�,.�. : �- �` ` ' �. : , � ., �yi�:'� � , ,�!•.�, ��4„`:t� ;=��� ; alj*�l. � ' �. y �—� ` y ��i 1 �`,••, • ;� '��• �-�- �y, `�``%'I . ; . � ' .� ., � � •' • • • • , ' • • ' _� i . ' . �' ' �. � �:• . w. ' .. ,; 1� � ' . ___ � ' , • ` � � • � • • . rL� � .ti • � . , �� ` ' � �� A`� ( I , r ! � ���� � f - + . � ' j� �r I , d } � . .- - � � _ '� � . . �+ '�:. �• �.• r . � : . , ��v f � �. ` \ +~ � • .y ,� ^� � � �..` _i r�.. I 1. `�, '��,p*t��.' �1j.' • � �'. �� �+. , r„� • �� � �,J� . ,:,. ; , y� 1 ' . '`"'f� ' • � `- �. - - ' -�M„��- ' v�• " ��,I , � .. `�'P . '�, -', � C .•�� • ` 1 - � \ ��.` �r� �._ .' � . �• ' '� .*,' • ��� . �.�'. ' � / � , � r-� . , � =.s�i. • � ., . .�+ , 1 ' �`' � ' + ; i ' ���� . t ,�` `!- � . � '�r� - •VA�:�. '� � r . - � .►tk -y'-` � , -' '' ��� � � f' ' ' ' .� _ - .•� . I f � lr....,� - _ k , �,..�,��l��,t `' � � •��' - _��_ -� � � "�'���y//'p� r� - ...M_. �. _ ' ' ��1 �/ � • 1 •I� � � �1 � ' ,' � �C�'.� � �y,� ti���{p,' ` �,�� i • • '��� � ��.�. � � �I ..� ♦�t. � � � . � T� :• ' ' I"�'� * . �• � ~ + I � �,• t "1�` �� �:.f� :t} •r• .: . _� _�. �• t�,t,� �r .+�• :� ���� Y� , �'� _~:-7�^'�sr' + :v E ;,,�y_ . •� �r '�� • . �y' ' -• L � l � � �,� � � . . —� �� � l - ��' '. . ,y� .` t�• � ' ,`� � � i� � �� . � _ 1' i: �"'r -- . ', .:'1 �`_�i �•�• . ''� �'y -. . i , i� � • ' ll'• .:L� --v1 `• ' '! �� �.r ' '' � ' � "�'►' � 's' � � _ •� ; r � ? �. ` � ' � i /' + + _ / � • ` �� / � ' � . �� % � � • r .r . � � T _� ► �•T 1 .., . L� r e � ` � � '� � , - � 1 . ��. � \ . • ' � j�� � \t• . �' a '� \l ,� "�'� • � J, . ,\ �1v, 4 ♦ JII � � / ♦�, ��r � i � , � ., . ` If.Y � , w_ /�.-.. t �; � � I '' � � �a �� I �r• � 1 � ' � 1- ♦' . 1 ' ' ' � ' . � � t `� - , . . , _ w , �,� � }; ��<� � �, -�� . ��; ��.�. � , �,�'�;: ' • � dy ; ::,► :�U,a.. :� -Y„t�,�r� � . • , � ^ , '� ' , l, , �` , • �' � . ,, ;yrt 1 , � , °� � • :��� � 1 , � � , , , . . . I �� L r. � � � ����, � �, - . .y 1 . i•'-..'' . �!' . � +ti'• ?(�"'�1��'1`.0 �'�/,� ,1��;�'�'. � y �,•I�4 ` . 'l1 +' - �i � : � F" -�� ' (y` � ` 1 1'� �., � � •� � .T ►L ����'� ��" �•� � \ ��1�� �� , , � �'� 11R. � _. ���� � j 1� � ..f�i� ��- , �v� �� ��#� �` .• ! . � �., ,' � . . . - v . * .• �- J f. .y ��I . 1� �r� '�� .►�1 �� r �1 q�� . '']� 1 '\ �� f � '! � ���► ' _ � _ �I ' �� ' . -' . ��'� � �� ' �r(. � �� ti'1.1 ��`� � ..�� I /�.I �� 1 � � � � . . r . � , � � ;, n .�7 . �- . .r. � _ -�_ . � I . �'[t�'1' ,�� '� � � � �� � � 1 •� ' ;� ••� . .� ..jC w � - .��� ' (�7i ��� �� �` , .,�( r � � ��� � , ' •i I,+ 'J�I � � "i�jt, t _ ' � fi ..��-�'rk�`r�'�� � . . �'`{�� . ��;:� � �'�_ • �'�',� 'I ,�' •�` •, • , •f � 1,� �, ' r•' _ �"'�. � . •" - � � 1� +'i � .� �. � � � ��x- ������ I � �11 �� •r� •� •*� .�r � � �� � � • .' Y �• � .� - � IfIGCI'TYOF � __ i ;�"�i � , � ' r .: �. �_ . �`�' T '� �� �;,� � �, ''�� �.�� \ • � a ' '� S - � �� �- �, � ,� �� � , �i�.��; �,�,if!� . .� x ,. , : , � DUB E ECIA � . ► �'' � ,� �, .� �,,� , �•, � , _ • �f �� -#`� � _ ��. , � --`�. ,.� ; �• �.r, � �� ���, � �,, ��; ;�� / �T .� , ,. �,t�r��,�,���«� �,» t,r�� 1�9i.:1:.rJ�pl GreaterDubuque � � �Ji �� • . . �� � 'w �� '�� _ �•.�� � 7�� � ; ' � Irl �� i.� � ti'i�r�l �' ' ,•C• ��I r � �� _irfl, � Em ission Basel i ne I nventor 2008 — y Emission Contributors rox, s,233, Miscellaneous 15,358 10°.'o ���, �,991, Natural Resources 4,707 lo°% _ PI�I10-PRI, 9,672, O F F-H i g hway 8 683 19% � o Highway Vehicles 11 ,964 a..' � Y � Waste Disposal & Recycling � 1 ,059 � � � Storage & Transportation � 615 P14i25-PRI, 2,046, 4% .o Solvent Utilization � 1 , 147 CO, 18,688, �60o w Other Industrial Processes � 138 502, 3,883, 7% � Fuel Combustion - other � 1 ,497 ,t '` �'oc, �,i�i, Fuel Combustion - Industrial 4 899 i��o � Fuel Combustion -Electric Utlity � � 788 sour�e: EPa2oos Nat�ona� Em�ss�ons �n�ento� 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 Tons Source: EPA 2008 National Emissions Inventory Em ission Basel i ne I nventor 2008 — y Potosi Monitor PM 2.5 Annual Design Value from Potosi Monitor PM 2.5 Hourly Design Value from Potosi Monitor 12.5 36 � 35 PM 2.5 Hourly design value 35 35 .2 PM 2.5 Annual design value 34 34 34 34 12 33 � � m m � .6 � 32 � 11 .5 . � 0 � 0 31 � � 30 w 11 w 2 z z 29 O O V V 28 2$ 10.5 27 26 10 25 2001 -2003 2002-2004 2003-2005 2004-2006 2005-2007 2006-2008 2007-2009 2001 -2003 2002-2004 2003-2005 2004-2006 2005-2007 2006-2008 2007-2009 YEARS YEARS Source: Wisconsin DNR Design Values for Potosi Monitor Ozone Desi n Values 1999 - 2010 — g Stockton, CI � " � n & Coggon Monitors fStockton, IL fClinton, Rainbow Park fCoggon, ElementarySchool 80 : � . . . . 75 Current Ozone Design Value (75 ppb) � � Proposed Ozone Design Value (70 ppb) 70 - � � — . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Proposed Ozone Design Value (65 ppb) � � � � 65 — ' 60 1999-2001 2000-2002 2001 -2003 2002-2004 2003-2005 2004-2006 2005 -2007 2006-2008 2007-2009 2008-2010 Source: EPA Design Values for Stockton, Clinton & Coggon Monitors Pro rams and Pro ' ects Im lemented from 2008 to 2018 — J J p � � Under Sustainable Dubuque Initiative �� The task force working with the City, Dubuque MPO, GDDC and private sector implemented programs between 2008 to 2019 to reduce emission in the region. The programs are divided into four categories, Transportation which includes � � � � ' all modes, Water treatment , Public Outreach and Private sector improvements. Millwork District Complete Smarter Travel US 52 Trail Alliant Power Plant Streets TIGER I grant RNG Phase 1 : WRRC Transit Bus Replacement Transit Intermodal CLE4R STREETS i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i � . � � � � � � � 1 1 1 1 1 1 � 1 1 . 1 1 : I � I � I � I � I I I � I � I � I I I I I I I I I I I � John Deere Dubuque i Water and Resource i East-West Corridor i i Works Bus Storage Facility Recovery Center Improvements Safe Routes to School JELD-WEN Diesel Emission Bus Storage Facility Reduction Act NVIDIA Program Com arison of Pollutants from 2008 - 2014 — p (Note: 2017 data will be available Spring of 2020) Source: EPA 2008, 2011 & 2014 National Emissions Inventory 20,000 18,688 18,000 17,723 16,000 5,802 14,000 12,000 N 9,672 � 10,000 9,764 8,903 8,406 8,000 7,341 ,625 6,000 5,233 4,991 4,259 4,000 3,82� 3,883 2,761 2,581 2,046 1 ,962 2,000 1 ,544 1 ,068 39 0 Carbon Monoxide Ammonia Nitrogen Oxides PM10 Primary (Filt + PM2.5 Primary (Filt + Sulfur Dioxide Volatile Organic Cond) Cond) Compounds ■ 2008 ■ 2011 ■ 2014 Pollutants Com a rison of Em ission Contri butors f rom 2008 - 2014 _ p (Note: 2017 data will be available Spring of 2020) Source: EPA 2008, 2011 & 2014 National Emissions Inventory 15,358 Miscellaneous 15,024 12,884 4 707 Natural Resources 5,219 4,392 8,683 OFF-Highway �,696 6,549 11 ,964 Highway Vehicles 11 ,064 9,862 � ° Waste Disposal & Recycling _ g84059 � 880 � .� � � 615 � Storage & Transportation 380 719 � 0 •� Solvent Utilization 1 141 ,504 � 1 ,132 Other Industrial Processes �148 210 1 497 Fuel Combustion - other z,zsz 1 ,807 4,899 Fuel Combustion - Industrial � 914 119 1 ,788 Fuel Combustion -Electric Utlity �,591 41 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 16,000 tons ■ 2008 ■ 2011 ■ 2014 Com a rison of em issions reduction i n Du bu ue & Scott Cou nties p q _ 2 00 $ � 2 O � 4 (Note: 2017 data will be available Spring of 2020) Source: EPA 2008 & 2014 National Emissions Inventory Dubuque County Scott County � � /� A /� A � Zn � �1 A �'1AA ��� Lb . - - Z � Q . � � J,"' 7,636 225 6 657 , Carbon Ammonia Nitrogen PM10 PM2.5 Sulfur Volatile Carbon Ammonia Nitrogen PM10 Primary PM2.5 Sulfur Dioxide Volatile Monoxide Oxides Primary (Filt Primary (Filt Dioxide Organic Monoxide Oxides (Filt + Cond) Primary (Filt + Organic + Cond) + Cond) Compounds Cond) Compounds ' • . 11 : 1 � ' • . 11 : 1 � Savings in number of tons 103,466 Savings in number of tons 73,842 % Savings -32% % Savings -15% Com arison of emissions b sources between Dubu ue & Scott p Y q _ CD � �"'� � � � S 2 00 � � 2 0 � 4 (Note: 2017 data will be available Spring of 2020) � ) Source: EPA 2008 & 2014 National Emissions Inventory WASTE DISPOSAL & RECYCLING _179 WASTE DISPOSAL & RECYCLING 90rj STORAGE & TRANSPORT _235 STORAGE & TRANSPORT _$O$ SOLVENT UTILIZATION _15 SOLVENT UTILIZATION � � . 0 OTHER INDUSTRIAL PROCESSES 72 OTHER INDUSTRIAL PROCESSES gg 4 � ! z OFF-HIGHWAY � -2 134 � OFF-HIGHWAY -2,373 0 � MISCELLANEOUS -2�4�4 MISCELLANEOUS O$6 HIGHWAY VEHICLES _2, � HIGHWAY VEHICLES FUEL COMB. OTHER ; 10 FUEL COMB. OTHER _3 FUEL COMB. INDUSTRIAL _4,780 FUEL COMB. INDUSTRIAL 196 FUEL COMB. ELEC. UTIL. _1,747 FUEL COMB. ELEC. UTIL. -1�763 Em ission I nventor f rom 2008 - 2018 — y Potosi Monitor 13 PM 2.5 Annual design value 12.2 12.3 12.2 12 11 .4 11 .6 11 .5 11 11 .5 11 0.7 � m � � � 10 � 10 z 9.5 O Q � w 9 8.7 V p 8.3 V 8 7.6 7.2 7.3 7 6 2001 -2003 2002-2004 2003-2005 2004-2006 2005-2007 2006-2008 2007-2009 2008-2010 2009-2011 2010-2012 2011 -2013 2012-2014 2013-2015 2014-2016 2015-2017 2016-2018 YEARS Source: Wisconsin DNR Design Values for Potosi Monitor Em ission I nventor f rom 2008 - 2018 — y Potosi Monitor PM 2.5 Hourly Design Value from Potosi Monitor PM 2.5 Hourly design value �� �� 35 34 4 33 33 31 � m � � 29 29 29 � � � 0 .}, � 27 � � a� V � 0 � 25 25 23 21 1 20 19 2001 -2003 2002-2004 2003-2005 2004-2006 2005-2007 2006-2008 2007-2009 2008-2010 2009-2011 2010-2012 2011 -2013 2012-2014 2013-2015 2014-2016 2015-2017 2016-2018 Years Source: Wisconsin DNR Design Values for Potosi Monitor Potosi Monitor Raw Data from 2008 - 2018 — 60 � � 50 � � 40 � m � � � � � � � � � • •° 30 � � � � � � p a � _ � • � � � � � � � • o • � V � � _ �� � � � • � �� • 2� � � � � • � � •� � •� •• • • � � � � � � � � � • •� 1 � � � � � � �� � � � � � �� � 10 � � • 0 • � ' 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Years Potosi Monitor Raw Data from 2008 - 2018 — Source: Wisconsin DNR • Fall �Spring iSummer �Winter � � � � . � I , . — _ . , : : . . . ; . � ` / 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Ozone Desi n Values 1999 - 2018 — g Stockton, Clinton & Coggon Monitors fStockton, IL fClinton, Rainbow Park fCoggon, ElementarySchool : � . . : : Current Ozone Design Value (75 ppb) , � �� Proposed Ozone Design Value (70 ppb) � � — � � . . . . . . . . . . • � ` • � • � Proposed Ozone Design Value (65 ppb) . . . . . � . . . . . . \ . . . . , � . , . , . , . , . . . . . . . . . . � o'` oti o� o°` o� o� o� o� o� ,�° ,�'` ,�ti ,�� ,�o� ,�� ,�� ,�� ,�� ,�o �o �o ,�o �o �o ,�o �o �o ,�o �o �o ,�o �o �o ,�o �o �o �� o� �� ti� �� o�� �' �� �' �' �' o � ti � o� � � �� o° o° o° o° o° o° o° o° o° o° o'` o'` o'` o'` o'` o'` o'` � ti ti ti ti ti ti ti ti ti ti ti ti ti ti ti ti ti Source: EPA Design Values for Stockton, Clinton & Coggon Monitors US 52 / SW ARTERIAL PROJECT (2020) EAST-WEST CORRIDOR IMPROVEMENTS (2024) 4 WATER AND RESOURCE RECOVERY CENTER - RNG EXPANSION PHASE 2 (2020) � Traff ic Routi n with Eff icient & Effective Traff ic S stem STREETS g y ( ) . . . . . . � -� t . , . . , . � �� � FAP,�' � � DiiiA : . : . . •-•-....._..-••-•...............•-•---�•------•--•----- ' � ...__....._......__..__ ... -� --------------�----------------�---�-------- p --- > �v .i�a��-��� ' ' ��� tr� � � �� . �,�� r��c_uw . , ATA , � , , � TRAVELTIME ' ................. �.,,.',, �; . SA.TELlTE ��� SYSTEM Q -•----- � :'".............. ._: ; _ . . � . � .�_ ; , � _. , � •., , _ , , ,,_ , : . , ; : *Y ---- ------------------ --------------- �er --n�n �+ Tri,{r � T=,"F= :- i:;,.i�;:F�,,-,�- ,.r.�-rF ; Field Data Performance Measures " • Traffic Count • Travel Time ; _ . ... ... ; i I ; '•�� � • 5 eed Data • Traffic F ow , .., o�s prvis P , ; ; • O-D • Traffic Pattern ; ___� � • Signal Phasing & Timing • Incidents : • Camera analysis • System Performance ' , • � � ? � ,, O —�AVELER ---- : "' � ; `dFO�MAI ln�� ' � � : ......... Process y • ---.._.. ... � Demand Model / Microsimulation Model , � I . . , dl� Decision Decision Support _ -- '� - - -- - -... -- - - ` --- - --- -- -- ---------- - - ------------- - : System dl� � � , , � � • Route Recommendation • Timing Recommendation SAVI NGS CO VOC(HC) NOX �------------------------------- � � Peak hour Emissions for 2020 (g/hr) 205,673 60,600 9,413 ATIS ATMS/ASCT Daily Emissions for 2020 (Peak hour *10) 2,056,727 605,998 94, 131 • DMS Adaptative Signal • Apps Control ATMS • 511 Enhancements Annual Emissions in (Kg/Year) = Daily *365/1 ,000 750,705 221 , 189 34,358 EMISSIONS SAVINGS CO (Kg/Year) VOC(HC) (Kg/Year) NOX (Kg/Year) YEAR 2020 750,705 221 ,189 34,358 Universit Avenue Overla section _ Y p ' q�, ' �,� ��' � _ \�` -,�� � - � � -�r��. s— , . . ,�•,, �., - � _ -_ �� "��' � .a ���ct �' � l, . �. .. ' ,: _;r�'�, ��. ,- f- , _+� �, � ' �,, d�" . �, � �, _, .. •� � ` / , '`1 � _ � ,r;'_�� " ' .. ' � , � � —f� , 'r�"�'�'`► ..,r, � �� r � N � 4� � /�, "�1 �� •f,� .� . ' � + J I M '� i� I � � i tl _ c� i a'1� �►" , � � i _ � . - . _ .1 - - '�.-._ . � ��. " i � . �. �� ���/ ��-I�e�J� � /'a1 I = � �� . , ;� __ _ ,..1►�. ' •' ' � ` ` 1� �� � , I . ,� � � �' �� I � �t. � � � ♦ `1� � "� ' • ,� � �,�J ;�,� / �.�� .� ,. �'-' Enhancrd �' w - � 'r • Crns�walb � � _ , ,�!!I _ � � . � � � .f i � ��; �. ' . , . � 7 � r �. � , 1 �`-�-- - ` i . ,.�. \I - � � � .�� `;` � I � _- • . � . �• � . �. �� � � ��' i . !►�., '� S � �1 - �, � �' /�'1 r U'' ` r . � \ � - ' , � � { ,�\� ; � , � - _ ��� 1 �y,`� . �� � ' , ;� ,� � � ���� -___ , au, . . , � . .� � Cost of ' �ir+ .� ' F -----�-�-t-_____ _ ' �' -'�`� C o st of _ , � ;�, -� � ` ; ��J� ,/ � �~ - ' - `=__ ___'_=__-;' ;'' r''` C {�/�/� •'� - Undiscounted Emissions - 1��" w �Y �14� . ♦ -,� V � ' ' � � `A�nM�WY - "��� -. �f� ���_ � ,� +� � � • `�� a� ' �' " � f��, , ��-__ _ - - _ , - _ __.`c� - _ = i Pollutants Cost of E�missions at at 7% s �, , , ' . -� '� ;r� � , . --___ _� ` .__- - �� - _ 3 /o d i sco u nt ,, � , .c' ,. . . , ,�� ,- ;� :_ ; _ , -- ----_ _� `, �-._____ _ _ _- ; Emissions rate discount ' r ' . ' r � � �� - �, - �, , , ' ,. �. . , ' � ,�- �. _� ,. — � � rate � 1 .w. :`� j L ; � �1► I �. '� � . /� - ti � ,` .�'� , '� � / , ^. ' ' '\`�c• _ � -. ��;� r , r 1 �\ ,/ � �E�anaed � .� � ' ' Y, %J }� „ " � . f - � S �� . � Cf'OitWQ��tf :��� � � � Q J` � I , y ' ' � _ * �..,.�j -• � � I � ''' 1t � ,.�•. �, i _ ' - � ` �; � � �. � � �r� �� i ` �+5. , _ - .- \ , � �- ' -- � R �-, -` _ \`+ L , � ' • ��� ' -{ - -_ \' '+� �r � -� . , � ��� � �� --j � i� "----_ • ; , r � � : � .�- �.. � ,� ,� ` �.=:.� _ �� � ' �;�'• � ��= - . _� -�� `'. . �, �i� VOC $737,963 $352,455 $ 135,969 . , � � \ �, � . � . _ � i �� , . r � �, , -;-- �'i- ����'"' �. . � ; � �, ;� ,� .� 1� ` i . R ��� r � � -- �` •r. � - , . �� , - � ' ,, • . , �, ��n, � , . �� ,r�, ��. .;f�, � - _ ' ' '" _ _�° ,. UNIVERSITY OF � ,. '� . ,� � .,' . . • .► . �, . ,�'' ;� � - �� . •�• - - - ---- .�� -- ' ,��. � � .�� Nox $2,089,434 $997,925 $384,976 . , � � �,� , � ;,�' - _ _ .,�- ,� , DUBUQUE .,� ���' . O � '`r� - ' �, � � � �rr ` . '� � , � � � n ` / � w �R : �, , .,,, y < < - �i " ♦ . � / � '.t����/ l � t , � ��:-�~, •'��f �a1 •_ , J'��:. • � � 1/ �� �� � . ` / • PM $ 1 ,202,713 $ 574,422 $221 , 599 Sox $87,606 $41 ,841 $ 16, 141 TOTAL $4, 117,715 $ 1 ,966,644 $758,686 Lon Term Pro ' ects after 2020 — J J INCORPORATION OF AIR QUALITY • • REGULATION I NTO CO U NTY H EALTH GOALS ' I PUBLIC/PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS � � NON-POINT SOURCE ' ' ' COLLABORATIONS , , � � � � , . � INNOVATIVE INFRASTRUCTURE • SUSTAINABLE DUBUQUE'S WORK � � ON AIR QUALITY I . M ' , � i i � i i i ENGAGING THE ENTIRE BUSINESS INNOVATION � BUSINESSES COMMUNITY THROUGH COLLABORATIONS LIKE THE PETAL PROJECT . � � . . -�.-� ,M�_ �„� ` � r� , ,� �,� '�6.�. r ' � ' � ' � � i � ' ` -r- `� ` � ` .✓ � ' / " �� �, � � . + ' 1l �• _ � ► , , i � - ' , , � � `. — , .. � � , - �. � ; . �t _�' K � ' r'�[ ' �1. . , • '`�"";`� � • P� '� � . ' M i .'1t • � • t ' �� • �1 ` �, _ _ ,��� �? •_� ��• ..• n �� ,� J Y'�il .• �ti i�- �`�„r _Y ' 1 i V� • ��r • � � �`J �/ �`� � .. .�T,S- r.+. .�7�'� � ' �i . �;" ♦• � . + �` h ,., r -.,'.'-� `� �•� f `� ��'�� ����n . !'t�h.�`�x,.�`'; ' �'-1.�� � . ' • - - _ ��� .y ' ti� `I ✓�r i � � • �� . V. . . � Z .,��f .. . �- �` ` ' �. : , � ., �yi�:'� � , ,�!•.�, ��4„`:t� ;=��� ; aljl. � . � �. -' �� � �y 'M i � �`�•r, • ;� ��• ��- �y, `��`%'I . ; . � ' .� ., � -'• � _� i . ' . �' ' �. � �:• . w. ' .. ,; 1� � ' . ___ � ' , • ` � � • � • • . rL� � .ti • � . , �� ` ' � �� A`� ( I , r ! � ���� � f - + . � ' j" �r I , d } � . .- - � � _ '� � . . �+ '�:. �• �.• r . � : . , ��v f � �. ` \ +~ � • .y ,� ^� � � �..` _i r�.. I 1. `�, '���*t��.' �1jr • � �'. � . �� i � r ''�� •�.��� t ') y 1 � ,�.� . , . � - , _ _ ,� , r� � i���`. . .-:�,-4 : , ; C .�� � ' � ,. • . • 1 . , �_ � _ . .� �:,- � .� � r-� .. . , � =.%��K. • -� �� ;, . .�+*.1�.. 1 �l\ "� . i ' r!- . + : , _` .��;;�� . f �r I •v�',-�, � 1 r . - ' wt'Ar. '�►-` � ' f'. ' ' .� � - ?. . r � L....,� - _ k , �,..,,��1�',t `_ � - � •��' - _��_ -� � � "�'���y//'p� r� - ...M_. �. _ ' ' ��1 �/ � • 1 •I� � � �1 � ' ,' � �C�'.� � �y,� ti���{p,' ` �,�� i • • '��� � ��.�. � � �I ..� ♦�t. � � � . � T� :• ' ' I"�'� * . �• � ~ + I � �,• t "1�` �� �:.f� :t} •r• .: . _� _�. �• t�,t,� �r .+�• :� ���� Y� , �'� _~:-7�^'�sr' + :v E ;,,�y_ . •� �r '�� • . �y' ' -• L � l � � �,� � � . . —� �� � l - ��' '. . ,y� .` t�• � ' ,`� � � i� � �� . � _ 1' i: �"'r -- . ', .:'1 �`_�i �•�• . ''� �'y -. . i , i� � • ' ll'• .:L� --v1 `• ' '! �� �.r ' '' � ' � "�'►' � 's' � � _ •� ; r � ? �. ` � ' � i /' + + _ / � • ` �� / � ' � . �� % � � • r .r . � � T _� ► �•T 1 .., . L� r e � ` � � '� � , - � 1 . ��. � \ . • ' � j�� � \t• . �' a '� \l ,� "�'� • � J, . ,\ �1v, 4 ♦ JII � � / ♦�, ��r � i � , � ., . ` If.Y � , w_ /�.-.. t �; � � I '' � � �a �� I �r• � 1 � ' � 1- ♦' . 1 ' ' ' � ' . � � t `� - , . . , _ w , �,� � }; ��<� � �, -�� . ��; ��.�. � , �,�'�;: ' • � dy ; ::,► :�U,a.. :� -Y„t�,�r� � . • , � ^ , '� ' , l, , �` , • �' � . ,, ;yrt 1 , � , °� � • :��� � 1 , � � , , , . . . I �� L r. � � � ����, � �, - . .y 1 . i•'-..'' . �!' . � +ti'• ?(�"'�1��'1`.0 �'�/,� ,1��;�'�'. � y �,•I�4 ` . 'l1 +' - �i � : � F" -�� ' (y` � ` 1 1'� �., � � •� � .T ►L ����'� ��" �•� � \ ��1�� �� , , � �'� 11R. � _. ���� � j 1� � ..f�i� ��- , �v� �� ��#� �` .• ! . � �., ,' � . . . - v . * .• �- J f. .y ��I . 1� �r� '�� .►�1 �� r �1 q�� . '']� 1 '\ �� f � '! � ���► ' _ � _ �I ' �� ' . -' . ��'� � �� ' �r(. � �� ti'1.1 ��`� � ..�� I /�.I �� 1 � � � � . . r . � , � � ;, n .�7 . �- . .r. � _ -�_ . � I . �'[t�'1' ,�� '� � � � �� � � 1 •� ' ;� ••� . .� ..jC w � - .��� ' (�7i ��� �� �` , .,�( r � � ��� � , ' •i I,+ 'J�I � � "i�jt, t _ ' � fi ..��-�'rk�`r�'�� � . . �'`{�� . ��;:� � �'�_ • �'�',� 'I ,�' •�` •, • , •f � 1,� �, ' r•' _ �"'�. � . •" - � � 1� +'i � .� �. � � � ��x- ������ I � �11 �� •r� •� •*� .�r � � �� � � • .' Y �• � .� - � IfIGCI'TYOF � __ i ;�"�i � , � ' r .: �. �_ . �`�' T '� �� �;,� � �, ''�� �.�� \ • � a ' '� S - � �� �- �, � ,� �� � , �i�.��; �,�,if!� . .� x ,. , : , � DUB E ECIA � . ► �'' � ,� �, .� �,,� , �•, � , _ • �f �� -#`� � _ ��. , � --`�. ,.� ; �• �.r, � �� ���, � �,, ��; ;�� / �T .� , ,. �,t�r��,�,���«� �,» t,r�� 1�9i.:1:.rJ�pl GreaterDubuque � � �Ji �� • . . �� � 'w �� '�� _ �•.�� � 7�� � ; ' � Irl �� i.� � ti'i�r�l �' ' ,•C• ��I r � �� _irfl, �