Claim by United Postal Service Copyrighted
February 17, 2020
City of Dubuque Consent Items # 2.
ITEM TITLE: Notice of Claims and Suits
SUM MARY: Linda Lucy for property damage, Emily Treanor for property
replacement, United States Postal Service for property
damage.
SUGGESTED DISPOSITION: Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Referto City
Attorney
ATTACHMENTS:
Description Type
Claim by Linda Lucy Supporting Documentation
Claim by Eleanor Treanor Supporting Documentation
Claim by USPS Supporting Documentation
J�n1311202�2:54�17 PM U5P5- Des MQin�s, IA 515-251-2�5a 213
Jan/31/2020 1;22:05 PM DBQ Fax->51�-25q-2�78 3J4
DBQ F�,x 1/31/202p 1;18;56 PM 1�AGE �/004 Fax S��ver
. N� ���
��� �
�,��5�,�� j P_C'V�C��S
����m �,��►i.r�s�r rM� ���r� c�� au�u�u�, .�vw�
This wr.itten r�po� GotlstlEutes yo:t�r��{ai1�1 �g�lillst the �ity �f D'ubuc�u�.r Io�xa, Y'ou shc�,td
compia�e t�.1s form fn Tuli and aftach any addlt#ar�al in�`nrmatio►a th.a�supparts�y��rr clsir�.
The Claim mu�t be �l.fect wlth the �ity Glark at Clty W���(, 50 Vll, 13�" St., �?utauque, iA 5��01. i.t
wiil #hen �a r�ferred by the City CounGl( ta th� �pRropriate e�spartmen4 far ir�vasti�a#1ore.
�nce tha# investlg�ti�n i� �ampleted, �repar� an� reaommer�datlan wl11 b� su�mittad ta th�
: �lxy ��un�il. Y'Qu �ncitl be pr�vid�d witl� a �copy of th�t�r�p�rt�nd r.ec�,x�m�ndatl:c�n.
TH� F1NA�.D�Cl�l4�1 C4N ALL CE.AfMS IS (VIAI3� �Y THE CITY Ct�U1VCll�. NO �MRLC?YE6 Qi�
Tr�� clTv Q�� ouBu�UE H�i� TH��u�€Hp�1TY TO M�KE ANY t���RESEh1TA7taN T� �Y�U
AS T4 V1(M�T4W�1�YdUR C�.Ail�it'WI�,L�R�VIItLL N�T �E�'AID.
1, A�att7e of Cl�imant; ,�eca� J�7`�-.�5 /��'S� ,�r�
2. Address; ..----.%�DG -tC,��u.r� �c�
Ct#y:. �S' `�'�e�rat,�' 5t�te: �i4 �Ipt 4,.3c� �..
3, Tetepf�nhe.Numl�.er. ...............�,�� c�,.�� — d�.� JQ
4, ��te�of Incident: /�-f�/ ��dt�
�, Tlm�of Inoi�d�nt: ......------�ra.or-.,� o�_i�co�
�. Lo�a#ion af Incid�nt�Be ��p�ec�ii��: r.,��/f�°. �?r���� �i�, _ �
,
T. DES�FlfBE ACCIE]ENT OR aCCURR�NC� 1"HAT CAU��D I�VJ.URY �3R DAM�I.G�. (�ive
fu11 details upan which y�au ba�e you'r cla�m. If a City emplQ.yee was tn�otved, .give the
emp�oyera's n�me�.)
� rxtrrt� f,�t.L�c� 7� .�.��c.ia fa��'�i� o-�-r �.�-7/�!�'� � �r/�� 7�r� �
� , , �
li � 4 r� � c��'�� �ra�� �
'y7� �� �P �' cx.. I.�Sp..� rn.n ,� /�'� x ��� '�'�°'
�. ���w�r�w�a�her condt�ians lik�? _ r'�'�.•,x�r��',_r1f�D�-�
9. Give name�nd addre�s of any�ritn��ses: �Gn� ,���a.�n �,.......
1p. I�id p�li'ce investigate7 (!f�c, glv� n�mea of af#icers•)
�V d
't1. Was anycrn� Injur�d? (!f�a, �iue names, addr�sses,and �xtent�f injurl�s�. �
�C�
J�n/31/2C720 2:54�17 PM USPS- �e� Maine�, IA 515-251-2C150 3/3
J�n/31/2D20 1:22:�5 PM D@p Fax-}515-251-237& 9f4
DBQ Fax 1/31/2D2D �. :18;�6 PM PA(�E �/pQ4 Fax Server
'1�. Was a��y dama�� dane ta prop�rty.? (ig sa, d�scrihe pr�per�y anc� the extent c►.f
damage�. A�tacF� ��tim�tes o� dam�ag�s ar describa basi� far a�cert�ir�ing sxtent af
c�am��e.}
"�� �,'� .��'�
, � � 7� �d'.� �dx �a� � �.�
13. What oth�r dama�es d.o yau �lalm, If any"� it/da� .
�
�4. Mave you bean �c�mperisa�ed f�r any part cr all �� your cfaim by �rty In�uranc�
campany7 (If sa, p[v� name and address af Itlsurance carnp�ny�nd amout����id)
��'
'{5. 1Nhat amount da you olairr� �rcim Ei�e Clty c�f t�u��uqu�? � �,��, ��,
YD 6C}" �f,a,d��� e���
16. Why�da you ciai,m'�he C(ty o�'Du�.uq�e fs rssponsibfe? ,�—.�--�
--- CJ���r � -�-��
17, H�ve ybu m�de any ci�im agalnst a.nyana sl.se far darnages as a re.�uEt af thls Ir�cid��t7
(if y�s, give name ar�d addra�s,} , I
/V�
'!8. ff the �nswer �o Questien 't7 3s yes, h�va yca i��ceived ,atny p�yment from that sou.r�e,
ar�d 9f so,, En what�amount? , )�
�(J
�s 11�a c nr�s
DaCed at�w�e', lowa E�►ls� aay of `�a rb ic�z.r , 20 ��, �
�� (5ignatur�)
��`c� � �e,�.�c�a � " �r����,,,,, L�Q .�i•��Fri�nt~Name).
��i�e.�r � 1..'�i�'�c"�'
�z.r�,J .�'�Z'�'s ��'.s��,..�rV'/c� � ,
��
� - � �:
��t�v. ���.sy =- c.. _�=. !�-;
— c�;� c�' �:
�� '� ;�f
� `n � �-
`r� � �,� �1�
s
p` c.r$ �
o f
�
�I
Jen/31/202a 2'S4'17 PM U�P�- Des Moin��, IA 515-251-2050 1/3
UN1T��7 STATES P�STAL �SERVICE,
Hawkeye District �perations progr�ms Support
FAX MESSA��
January 31 , 2020
This Communication is intended for the sol� use of the individual ar entity ta which it is
a�dressed and may contain infarmation that is Privi[eged., Confidential and Exempt fram
disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of#his cammunication is not the intended
recipient or the employ�� �r agent respansible far deliv�ring the message to the
intend�d recipient, you �re hereby notified #hat any dissemination, distributian, or
copying of this communication is stric#iy prohibited, If you have received this
cammunication in .errar, please notify me immediately by teiephan� cal[, and returrt the
cammunic�tion to me at the address listed belaw vi� the United S#ates Pastai Service.
Thank You.
To: Steve Fehsa!
Telefax Telephone#: 563W589-439�
Plea�e E�t me know if y�u need any addi#ianal information.
7hank you
Shauld you receiv� less than�_ a es, including this transmitta! page please aantact;
Scott R Yarrington
Tort Claims Coordinator
7900 Hickman Rd
Des Moines (A, 5Q324-4400
515-25.1-2370 - (FP►}C)5'15-251-2375
TORT CLAIMS(NVESTIGATIONS
HAWKEYE DISTRICT
��w. c���tQ�rr
i�i64..7�G([YR.c
December 30,2019 •
City of Dubuque—Leisure Service Office
Attn: Tom Kramer
2200 Bunker Hill Rd.
Dubuque IA 52001
Re: Damage to U.S. Postai Service Property
USPS Case#: 500-20-00460524A
Date of Incident: 12-11-2019
Certified Mail#: 7017 2620 0000 4628 3956
Dear Mr. Kramer:
This letter is to advise you that this office is making a claim in the amount of$955.86, for damages
sustained in a property damage incident that occurred on 12-11-2019, in or around Dubuque, la. Our
investigation reveals that the City of Dubuque is liable in this matter, in that: City workers were removing
a tree near a Community Box Unit(CBU) located at 2518 Hacienda Dr. A large limb was cut from the tree
and it caused damage to the top of the CBU. The damage is not repairable and the CBU will be replaced.
Therefore,we are making a claim against you for reimbursement of the costs of the damages sustained
by the Postal property in this incident. I enclose a copy of the"Cost of Repair to Postal Service-Owned
Property"for the damages sustained by us. This statement is made a part of this claim for all purposes.
In the event that you do not have liability insurance, then you should contact us immediately. If I do not
hear from you within thirty(30)days from the mailing of this letter, this office will have no other alternative
but to hand this matter over to our collections department to engage in further collection efforts against
you including filing suit against you. In addition, the Court may order you to pay an additional amount to
us to cover all court costs and attorney's fees incurred in the prosecution of this claim. These extra
amounts can become quite substantial. Therefore, it may be economically ta your benefit to make
ar�angements to pay this cVaim now. All checks for the payment of this claim should be made payable to
"United States Postal Service", and mailed to;
Scott R Yarrington
District Tort Claims Coordinator
7900 Hickman Rd
Des Moines, IA 50324-4400
All future contacts and/or correspondence should be directed to Scott R Yarrington at the above listed
address. No further communication will be sent to you prior to the time that this matter is handed over to
our collection department for further action.
Sincerely,
���
Scott R Yarrington
District Tort Claims Coordinator
cc: Office Fiie
7900 H(CKM,aN RD
DES MOINES,IA 50324-4400
515-251-2370 FAx 515-251-2378
Copyrighted
February 17, 2020
City of Dubuque Consent Items # 3.
ITEM TITLE: Disposition of Claims
SUMMARY: CityAttorneyadvising thatthe following claims have been
referred to Public Entity Risk Services of lowa, the agent
for the I owa Communities Assurance Pool: United State
Postal Service for property damage.
SUGGESTED DISPOSITION: Suggested Disposition: Receive and File; Concur
ATTACHMENTS:
Description Type
I CAP Referral Staff Memo
• dubuque
THE CITY OF �
AII�America City
DU� E ����,���
�' Il�mr
Maste iece on the Mississi 1 zoo�•Zaiz}zois
� pp Zoi7�2o19
TRACEY STECKLEIN
PARALEGAL
_ MEMO �
To: Mayor Roy D. Buoi and
Members of the City Council
DATE: February 3, 2020 I;
�
I
_ RE: Claim Against the City of Dubuque by the United States Postal Service
Claimant �ate of Claim Da#e of Loss Nature of Claim
�
United States 01/31/20 12/11/19 Property Damage ''
Postal Service ;�
This is a claim in which claimant alleges that while City employees were attempting to '
remove a City tree at 2518 Hacienda, the tree fell onto a USPS community mailbox �
causing damage.
This claim has been referred to the lowa Communities Assurance Pool.
�
cc: Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager
Steve Fehsal, Park Manager
Scott Yarrington, Tort Claim Coordinator, United States Posfial Service
�
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY DUBUQUE, IOWA
SUITE 330, HARBOR VIEW PLACE, 300 MAIN STREET DUBUQUE, IA 52001-6944
TE�EPHONE (563)583-4113/F,vc (563)583-1040/EMai� tsteckle@cityofdubuque.org