Loading...
Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project_Public HearingMasterpiece on the Mississippi TO: The Honorable Mayor and City Council Members FROM: Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager SUBJECT: Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project CIP 3002142 - Fiscal Year 2011 Street Construction Program CIP 7401405 - Fiscal Year 2011 Watermain Replacement Program CIP 3001629 - Fiscal Year 2011 Sunset Ridge Street Lighting CIP 7101801 - Fiscal Year 2008 Sunset Ridge Sanitary Sewer CIP 7202242 — Fiscal Year 2011 Storm Sewer DATE: July 13, 2010 Dubuque kittri AB- America City I 2007 In 2002, Sunset Ridge was accepted as a city street retroactive to the original plat of 1926. Up until 2002, the street was considered a private street and was maintained accordingly. Sunset Ridge was originally constructed with concrete in the mid 1920's. Sunset Ridge is currently a concrete street with an asphalt overlay that is paved approximately 20' wide. The last asphalt overlay was constructed in 1977 by the residents. There is very little curb and gutter on the street, no sanitary sewer and no sidewalks. City Engineer Gus Psihoyos recommends City Council approval of the construction plans and specifications using the non - standard street width for residential streets of 21 feet with no street parking allowed, and sidewalks on the west side of the street, specifications, form of contract and estimated cost of $1,548,102.82 for the Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project. It is further recommended that the City Council adopt the Resolution of Necessity and the Preliminary Schedule of Assessments. He further recommends that any cost above City of Dubuque standards be paid 100% by the property owners. A group of residents is discussing paying for the upgrade from the City standard streetlights to historic streetlights. City staff has informed the residents that they will need to coordinate as a group and be responsible for all of the upgrade cost from standard streetlights to historic streetlights. This was the same arrangement that was done for the upgrade of the Fremont Avenue streetlights with the residents in that corridor. The Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project will provide for the reconstruction of the watermain, the installation of a sanitary sewer system, the installation of a street lighting system, the installation of sidewalk on the west side of the street and the reconstruction of the roadway with a new 21 -foot wide concrete roadway with curb and gutter. During the design process for this project, the Engineering Department met with the property owners as a group twice to discuss the pavement width, installation of sanitary sewer, the revised street alignment and installation of sidewalks. In addition, city engineering staff had numerous telephone conversations, on -site visits with many property owners and met one on one with all of the property owners to discuss the sanitary sewer system installation. In the many conversations Engineering has had with the property owners, there has been opposition to the sidewalk installation proposed and disagreement on what the street width should be. Engineering met with Public Works, Dubuque Fire, Health Services, City Attorney's Office and Human Rights to discuss these issues. The City Council has received several petitions from the residents requesting no sidewalks and a street width that remains at 21 feet wide. The residents as a group have repeatedly asked that the street width be kept at its current width with no sidewalks due to wanting to keep the intimate character of the neighborhood and to protect long- standing trees. Engineering has worked with the residents to try to come to a compromise on the street alignment, width and sidewalks to maintain the character of the neighborhood, yet still provide a street that can handle emergency vehicle widths and provide for a safe accessible route for pedestrians. The street is proposed to include the following: • 21 -foot wide street with curb and gutter — The narrow street will help maintain the current character of the street. The current street is approximately 21 feet wide and is centered in a 50 -foot right of way. The curb and gutter will be added to control the storm water runoff and to allow Public Works to identify the edge of the street during snow events and reduce damage to the abutting lawns. The curb also provides a barrier to protect pedestrians as well as being a detectable cue for pedestrians, especially those with visual impairments, that they are leaving the sidewalk and entering the street. • Sidewalks on one side of the street — The sidewalk is proposed to be installed on the west side of the street. Currently there is sidewalk on the west side of Wartburg Place, 30 feet north of the entrance to Sunset Ridge. The west side location has less of an impact on the long- standing trees in the corridor. The alignment of the street is proposed to be modified so the street and sidewalk together will be centered as much as possible in the existing right of way. The sidewalk installation would include a grass parkway in most areas. Engineering also followed up with a request by the City Council to review placing the sidewalk in the street. Engineering and Human Rights have serious concerns about pedestrian safety, available snow storage in the winter, and maintenance with this type of installation. The only time a sidewalk should be considered installed in the street is for a retrofit situation where there is absolutely no other way to provide for a sidewalk. That is not the case here. There is sufficient room for sidewalks to be installed on this project. City staff had a significant number of discussions concerning the sidewalks in this corridor. The installation of the sidewalk will help address a goal of the City Council to make Dubuque a walk -able community, improves the multiple modes of transportation to this neighborhood and provides a safe accessible route for pedestrians. Sidewalks will continue to build a connective network of sidewalks through Sunset Ridge and the connecting neighborhood. Standard street reconstruction designs call for 27' wide street with parking on one side of the street and sidewalk on both sides, as was detailed at the November 24, 2009 public information meeting. Assistant City Attorney, Crenna Brumwell, did extensive research on sidewalk inclusion with street reconstruction projects related to the Americans with Disabilities federal law and concludes the sidewalk must be installed, at a minimum, on one side of Sunset Ridge. Attached is the April 16, 2010 memorandum with legal findings. • No on- street parking — The 21 foot wide street will not allow for on- street parking. In order to maintain the existing street width, the parking has to be removed to provide sufficient room for emergency vehicles through the corridor. Emergency vehicles need a 20 -foot wide path in order to access the area. In order to provide for parking on one side of the street, a 27 -foot wide street would need to be constructed. Currently, there are many service vehicles that park in the street, leaving a 12 -foot lane to drive around the vehicle. Some residents want parking, some do not. Currently all of the residences are on septic systems. Several of these septic systems are non - functioning. The Health Department only has records on 10 of the 22 systems in operation. This project will utilize individual E -One grinder pumps at each residence and will install a forcemain system along the east side of the street. The cost of the individual grinder pumps and services will be assessed to each respective private property owner. The City will then assume ownership of the E -One pumps and will assume maintenance responsibilities for the sewer services for these residences which is consistent with other projects throughout the City. This project also includes the reconstruction of approximately 1,600 lineal feet of watermain, mainline valves, fire hydrants, and the replacement of 5 lead residential water services and installation of two new copper services for vacant Tots. The cost of the individual lead residential water service replacements will be assessed to each of the 5 respective private property owners. Additionally, the project provides for the reconstruction of approximately 500 lineal feet of storm sewer and 7 catch basins to improve the storm water conveyance in the area. City staff met with the City Forester on this project to discuss the condition and impact to the existing City trees within the project corridor. The Engineering Department and City Forester agree that one tree will need to be removed due to its deteriorating condition. The remaining trees impacted by construction will need to be pruned, but not removed. In an effort to inform the impacted residents along Sunset Ridge, the Engineering Department staff conducted two public informational meetings. The open forum meetings allows staff to discuss the scope of the project, construction schedule, special assessment procedures, availability of financial assistance, as well as to answer any questions relating to the project. The public informational meetings proved to offer mutual benefit to both staff and residents. The first public information meeting was held November 24, 2009 at Washington Middle School. The second public information meeting was held at Wartburg Seminary on April 20, 2010. The Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project will be funded through the annual capital improvement project appropriation of City funds in the amount of $871,549.26. The project, as outlined, will require Special Assessments in the amount of $676,553.56. I concur with the recommendation and respectfully request Mayor and City Council approval. MCVM:jh Attachment cc: Barry Lindahl, City Attorney Cindy Steinhauser, Assistant City Manager Gus Psihoyos, City Engineer Michael C. Van Milligen Masterpiece on the Mississippi TO: FROM: SUBJECT: INTRODUCTION BACKGROUND DISCUSSION Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager Gus Psihoyos, City Engineer Sunset Ridge CIP 3002142 CIP 7401405 CIP 3001629 CIP 7101801 CIP 7202242 DATE: July 13, 2010 Reconstruction Project - Fiscal Year 2011 Street Construction Program - Fiscal Year 2011 Watermain Replacement Program - Fiscal Year 2011 Sunset Ridge Street Lighting - Fiscal Year 2008 Sunset Ridge Sanitary Sewer - Fiscal Year 2011 Storm Sewer Dubuque klitd Al-Anita City 2007 The enclosed resolutions are in reference to the public hearing for the Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project. In 2002 Sunset Ridge was accepted as a city street retroactive to the original plat of 1926. Up until 2002 the street was considered a private street and was maintained accordingly. Sunset Ridge was originally constructed with concrete in the mid 1920's. Sunset Ridge is currently a concrete street with an asphalt overlay that is paved approximately 20' wide. The last asphalt overlay was constructed in 1977 by the residents. There is very little curb and gutter on the street, no sanitary sewer and no sidewalks. The Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project will provide for the: reconstruction of the watermain; the installation of a sanitary sewer system; the installation of a street lighting system; the installation of sidewalk on the west side of the street and the reconstruction of a new 21 -foot wide concrete roadway with curb and gutter. During the design process for this project, the Engineering Department met with the property owners as a group twice to discuss the pavement width, installation of sanitary sewer, the revised street alignment and installation of sidewalks. In addition, city engineering staff had numerous telephone conversations, on -site visits with many property owners and met one on one with all of the property owners to discuss the sanitary sewer system installation. In the many conversations Engineering has had with the property owners, there has been opposition to the sidewalk installation proposed and disagreement on what the street width should be. Engineering met with Public Works, Dubuque Fire, Health Services, Legal Counsel and Human Rights to discuss these issues. The City Council has received several petitions from the residents requesting no sidewalks and a street width that remains at 21 feet wide. The residents as a group have repeatedly asked that the street width be kept at its current width with no sidewalks due to wanting to keep the intimate character of the neighborhood and to protect long standing trees. Engineering has worked with the residents to try to come to a compromise on the street alignment, width and sidewalks to maintain the character of the neighborhood, yet still provide a street that can handle emergency vehicle widths and provide for a safe accessible route for pedestrians. The street is proposed to include the following: • 21 foot wide street with curb and gutter — The narrow street will help maintain the current character of the street. The current street is approximately 21 feet wide and is centered in a 50 foot right -of -way. The curb and gutter will be added to control the storm water runoff and to allow Public Works to identify the edge of the street during snow events and reduce damage to the abutting lawns. The curb also provides a barrier to protect pedestrians as well as being a detectable cue for pedestrians, especially those with visual impairments, that they are leaving the sidewalk and entering the street. • Sidewalks on one side of the street — The sidewalk is proposed to be installed on the west side of the street. Currently there is sidewalk on the west side of Wartburg Place, 30 feet north of the entrance to Sunset Ridge. The west side location has less of an impact on the long standing trees in the corridor. The alignment of the street is proposed to be modified so the street and sidewalk together will be centered as much as possible in the existing right of way. The sidewalk installation would include a grass parkway in most areas. Engineering also followed up with a request by the City Council to review placing the sidewalk in the street. Engineering and Human Rights have serious concerns about pedestrian safety, available snow storage in the winter, and maintenance with this type of installation. The only time a sidewalk should be considered installed in the street is for a retrofit situation where there is absolutely no other way to provide for a sidewalk. That is not the case here. There is sufficient room for sidewalks to be installed on this project. City staff had a significant number of discussions concerning the sidewalks in this corridor. The installation of the sidewalk will help address a goal of the City Council to make Dubuque a walkable community, allow multiple modes of transportation to this neighborhood and provide a safe accessible route for pedestrians. The current minimum standard street reconstruction design calls for a 27' wide street with parking on one side of the street and sidewalk on both sides, as was detailed at the November 24, 2009 public information meeting. Assistant City Attorney, Crenna Brumwell, did extensive research on sidewalk inclusion with street reconstruction projects related to the Americans with Disabilities Federal law and concludes the sidewalk must be installed, at a minimum, on one side of Sunset Ridge. • No on- street parking — The 21 foot wide street will not allow for on- street parking. In order to maintain the existing street width, the parking has to be removed to provide sufficient room for emergency vehicles through the corridor. Emergency vehicles need a 20 foot wide path in order to access the area. In order to provide for parking on one side of the street, a 27 foot wide street would need to be constructed. Currently, there are many service vehicles that park in the street, leaving a 12 foot lane to drive around the vehicle. There is disagreement among the residents on this issue. Some residents want parking, some do not. There are many encroachments into the right -of -way consisting of fences, walls and landscaping. Engineering will notify the residents to remove the encroachments prior to construction of the street. This project will be difficult to construct due to the deadend street, narrow corridor and the need to provide access at all times to the residents and emergency vehicles. The sanitary sewer main is proposed to be installed by directionally boring under the yards on the east side of the street to minimize disturbance of the yards and maintain access to the residences. The sanitary sewer services will be directionally bored to minimize the impacts on the established yards since all of the sanitary sewer service connections are in the backyards of the residences. The water main is proposed to be installed along the east side of the street so that access can be maintained by leaving most of the existing pavement in place during construction. All of the other utilities (gas, electric, cable, street lights and telephone) will be in a common corridor along the west side of the street, under the sidewalk. The concrete pavement will need to be paved in multiple phases in order to maintain access for the residents. Currently all of the residences are on septic systems. Several of these septic systems are non - functioning. The Health Department only has records on 10 of the 22 systems in operation. This project will utilize individual E -One grinder pumps at each residence and will install a forcemain system along the east side of the street. The cost of the individual grinder pumps and services will be assessed to each respective private property owner. The City will then assume ownership of the E -One pumps and will assume maintenance responsibilities for the sewer services for these residences which is consistent with other projects throughout the City. This project also includes the reconstruction of approximately 1,600 lineal feet of watermain, mainline valves, fire hydrants, and the replacement of 5 lead residential water services and installation of two new copper services for vacant lots. The cost of the individual lead residential water service replacements will be assessed to each of the 5 respective private property owners. Additionally, the project provides for the reconstruction of approximately 500 lineal feet of storm sewer and 7 catch basins to improve the storm water conveyance in the area. The existing street light system has not been operational for years. The new street lights are proposed to be the standard city residential street lights. Some of the residents have asked to install historic pedestal street lights similar to the lights that exist on lower Main Street. Engineering has informed the residents that any cost for the street lights above and beyond the City standard will need to be paid by the residents upfront. This is the same arrangement that was done for the upgrade to historic lights on Fremont Avenue during the Fremont Avenue Reconstruction Project. City staff met with the City Forester on this project to discuss the condition and impact to the existing City trees within the project corridor. The Engineering Department and City Forester agree that one tree will need to be removed due to its deteriorating condition. The remaining trees impacted by construction will need to be pruned, but not removed. RECOMMENDATION I recommend that the City Council approve the plans, specifications, form of contract and the estimated cost and to adopt the Resolution of Necessity and the Preliminary Schedule of Assessments for the Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project. BUDGET IMPACT The estimate of probable cost for Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project is summarized as follows: Construction Contract Contingency (10 %) Construction Engineering & Inspection Total Project Cost The estimated project category costs are as follows: Sanitary Sewer $466,549.50 46, 654.95 69,982.43 Street & Water Main $762,779.40 76,277.94 125,858.60 $583,186.88 $964,915.94 Cost Summary/Description Amount Street Construction Improvements $574,741.40 Special Assessment - Street Improvement, Residential Properties 107,936.29 Special Assessment - Street Improvement Deficiency, Paid by the City 0.00 Special Assessment - Water Services, Residential Properties 6,952.44 Special Assessment - Sanitary Sewer Lateral, Residential Properties 531,245.58 Sanitary Sewer Construction Fund 51,941.30 Special Assessment - Concrete Sidewalk, Residential Properties 30,419.25 Watermain Improvements 147,214.88 Storm Sewer Improvements 57,374.08 Street Lighting Improvements 40,277.60 Total Project Cost $1,548,102.82 The project funding summary is as follows: CIP No. Fund Description 3002142 Street Construction Program Special Assessments (Street, Sidewalk) 7401405 Watermain Replacement Program 7101801 Sunset Ridge Sanitary Sewer 7202242 Sunset Ridge Storm Sewer Improvements 3001629 Sunset Ridge Street Lighting Total Project Funding Fund Amount $ 574,741.40 138,355.54 154,167.32 583,186.88 57,374.08 40,277.60 $1,548,102.82 The Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project will be funded through the annual capital improvement project appropriation of City funds as noted above in the amount of $871,549.26. The project, as outlined, will require Special Assessments in the amount of $676,553.56 and expenditure from the FY2011 Annual Street Construction Program (funded through Local Option Sales Tax) in the amount of $574,741.40. ACTION TO BE TAKEN The City Council is requested to approve the plans, specifications, form of contract and the estimated cost and to adopt the Resolution of Necessity and the Preliminary Schedule of Assessments for the Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project. Prepared by Jon Dienst, P.E., Civil Engineer II cc: Crenna Brumwell, Assistant City Attorney Jenny Larson, Budget Director Don Vogt, Public Works Director John Klostermann, Street and Sewer Maintenance Supervisor Bob Green, Water Plant Manager Mary Rose Corrigan, Public Health Specialist Tim Link, Environmental Sanitarian, Health Services Dan Brown, Fire Chief Kelly Larson, Human Rights Director Greg Doeden, Civil Engineer II Deron Muehring, Civil Engineer II Dave Ness, Civil Engineer II APPROVAL OF PLANS, SPECIFICATIONS, FORM OF CONTRACT, AND ESTIMATED COST FOR THE SUNSET RIDGE RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA: That the proposed plans, specifications, form of contract and estimated cost for the Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project, in the estimated amount $1,548,102.82, are hereby approved. Attest: Passed, adopted and approved this day of , 2010. Jeanne F. Schneider, CMC, City Clerk RESOLUTION NO. Roy D. Buol, Mayor RESOLUTION NO. RESOLUTION WITH RESPECT TO THE ADOPTION OF THE RESOLUTION OF NECESSITY PROPOSED FOR THE SUNSET RIDGE RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT Whereas, the City Council has proposed a Resolution of Necessity for the Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project and has given notice of the public hearing thereon as required by law; and Whereas, the public hearing has been held, all persons offering objections have been heard and consideration given to all objections and is pending before this Council; and Whereas, this is the time and place set as provided for the taking of action on the proposed Resolution of Necessity. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA: Attest: That the proposed Resolution of Necessity described above is hereby: Adopted, without amendment, and all objections filed or made having been duly considered are overruled. Adopted as amended by the Preliminary Schedule of Assessments attached hereto as Exhibit A, and made a part hereof by reference. All objections filed or made having been duly considered are overruled. Deferred for later consideration to a City Council meeting to be held on the day of , 2010, next at 6:30 p.m. in the Historic Federal Building Council Chambers (second floor), 350 West 6 Street, with jurisdiction retained for further consideration and action at the adjourned meeting. Abandoned. Passed, adopted and approved this Jeanne F. Schneider, CMC, City Clerk day of , 2010. Roy D. Buol, Mayor APPROVING SCHEDULE OF ASSESSMENTS AND ESTIMATE OF TOTAL COST FOR THE SUNSET RIDGE RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA: That the attached plat, schedule of assessments, and estimate of total cost for the Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project are hereby approved. Attest: Passed, approved and adopted this Jeanne F. Schneider, CMC, City Clerk RESOLUTION NO. day of , 2010. Roy D. Buol, Mayor LOT 1.14 MINERAL LOT 129 6 LOT 2.1 SUNSET RIDGE KOORMANN, LEONARD 6 JUDY L 501 Sunset Ridge LOT 2.1.2 N9 LOT OWNER:... IMCHAEL NIDOLA 515 Sunset Ridge SUNSET RIDGE NO.. 2 LOTS 24 12.I SOTS OF MINERAL LOT 128 OWNER: WAHLERT, SUSAN L. 525 Sunset Ridge NERAL LOT +A SLOT S SUNSET RIDGE O 6 C HARLENE A 0.Y W 565 Sunset Ridge LOT 6 SUNSET RIDGE 6 LOT MINERAL LOT 129 OWNER KENNEDY, JAMES G. 6 FRANCES D. 595 Sunset Ridge LOT 1 SUNSET RIDGE N OWNER: CONLON. STEPHEN 0. 655 Sunset Ridge 120 - 4665.0 Units LOT 1 2 -12 ALL INSU.ET RIDGE INNER: IM R ERTHEIMER. MARK 725 Sunset Ridge 240 Scale: 1" = 120' 13434.0 Units 505 Sunset Ridge LOT 1.1 SUNSET RIDGE OWNER: WAGNER. 25850.0 Units INSERT • EWA N. 17694.0 Units 13077.0 Units 14115.0 Units 7.t7ts OWNER: LOT 60 SETe ni RI AMESG RANGES JAMES G. 36848.0 Units LOT OHM POTERL / SUSAN M. 755 Sunset Ridge 360 LOT 1 OWNER: SUNSET ANDREW E S CO LON 695 Sunset Ridge 22828.0 Units O W N T2 SUNSET RIDGE 63 ER: COLON. STEPHEN D. 10293.0 Units tux 18218.0 Units 3644.4.0 Units LOT LOTS 2 -15 6 2.13 SUNSET RIDGE OWNER: WOODARD, THOMAS M. • CRARLICE 754 Sunset Ridge 17084.0 Units 24870.0 Units 12925.0 Units 12925.0 Units 13050.0 Units 10419.0 Units 15780.0 Units 13163.0 Units 13240.0 Units 20398.0 Units 12968.0 Units 500 Sunset Ridge SU • 2 -29 T RIDGE SUB. OWNER: SEWERS. GEEVIEVE F. OT 2 SUNSET RIDGE 6S• OT IA IT SUNSET RIDGE OWNER: scTM MARGARET B. TRUSTEE 520 Sunset Ridge LOT 26 SUNSET RIDGE SUB OWNER .BRINK. BRUCE 6 KRIS, R. 530 Sunset Ridge LOT 2! SUNSET RIDGE SUB. OWNE aMON U R F NAIy NEW D. 560 Sunset Ridge LOT 2/ ET RIDGE SUB OWNER: DELO.. RA E. 580 Sunset Ridge KY OR SAL DT 21 SUNSET RIDGE SUB. OWNER: DELO.. LW. E 580 Sunset Ridge LOT 22 SUNSET RIDGE • S 20' LOT 22 SUNSET RIDGE SUB. OWNER: 1 KR ISS, JON N. 600 Sunset Ridge i. LOT 21 ONSET RIDGE OWNER: ROM., BENJ.. M. 650 Sunset Ridge 680 Sunset Ridge I LOT 1 6UN0ET RIDGE IA OWNER: RICHARDSON, WWI. R. O L NE SUNSETRIO GE R:1ME10. TONYA It ANNA, 890 Sunset Ridge LOT 16 S1A 7 RI00E J ,,700 Sunset Ridge ge Lor 1 -1T us raooE owxeRI McNA nMOTHr J. 700 Sunset Ridge LOT 1 -111 SUNSET RIDGE OW 12956.0 Units NER: MCNANARA TIMOTHY J. 700 Sunset Ridge 17708.0 Units LOT 1- 15 SUNSET eDGE OWNER: HER2MAN. WESLEY N. URRIET 750 Sunset Ridge 01 CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA SUNSET RIDGE RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT PRELIMINARY SCHEDULE OF VALUATION AND PROPOSED ASSESSMENTS DATE: July 6, 2010 The following schedule is hereby determined to show each lot proposed to be assessed for the improvement shown in the title together with the amount proposed to be assessed against each lot and the valuations shown opposite each lot are hereby fixed as the true valuations of such lots by the City Council of the City of Dubuque. Lot 1 -29 & 2 -28 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 1 -1 -2 ML 129 & Lot 2 -1 Sunset Ridge Lot 1 -1 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 2 Sunset Ridge & Lot 2 -1 -2 ML 129 Lots 27, 1 -28 & 2 -29 Sunset Ridge Sub Sunset Ridge No 2 Lots 2 -2 & 2 -1 Both of ML 129 Lot 26 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 25 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 2 -1 -1 ML 129 & Lot 5 Sunset Ridge Lot 24 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 6 Sunset Ridge & Lot 1 -1 -1 ML 129 Lot 22 & S 20' Lot 23 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 21 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 1 Sunset Ridge #4 Lot 1 Sunset Ridge #3 Lot 2 Sunset Ridge #3 & N 1/2 Lot 18 Sunset Ridge Lot 1 Sunset Ridge #5 S 1/2 Lot 18 Sunset Ridge Lots 13, 1-1-14, 2 -12 All in Sunset Ridge Lot 1 -15 Sunset Ridge Lot 2 Faldorf Place (4.6 Ac) & Lots 2 -14 & 2 -15 Sunset Ridge Lot 2 -14 Sunset Ridge Lot 2 -7 Sunset Ridge Sub N 80' or Bal Lot 23 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 2 Sunset Ridge #5 Lot 17 Sunset Ridge Lot 16 Sunset Ridge Lot 1 -1 & 2 -1 both of ML 132 "All" McDonald Wartburg Place 10 35 252 001 10 35 179 003 10 35 251 001 10 35 179 004 10 35 252 003 10 35 179 010 10 35 252 004 10 35 252 005 10 35 179 007 10 35 252 006 10 35 179 008 10 35 252 008 10 35 252 009 10 35 251 005 10 35 252 012 10 35 252 014 10 35 251 006 10 35 402 002 10 35 401 002 10 35 402 005 10 35 402 009 10 35 401 003 10 35 251 002 10 35 252 007 10 35 401 005 10 35 402 003 10 35 402 004 10 35 128 006 10 35 201 007 $335,137.98 5425,748 38 5386,326.13 $370,353 13 $354,574.75 5596,853.39 $488,39821 $358,45366 5301,127 38 $416,310 08 5442,653.97 $347,728.48 $343,231.32 3785,086.34 5353,535.13 3295,345.26 $411,222.65 3253,981.29 5553,781.04 $280,484.15 3555,436.91 3264,636.56 928,025.39 $66,534.67 578,230.04 $35,174.85 $50,885.30 5991,612.88 $737,616 35 94,207.46 91,148.90 $4,357.69 33,308.54 $6,125.01 56,366.36 33,183.18 53,183.18 53,220.62 53,213.97 53,476.25 $3,886.31 $3,241.80 $9,074.96 53,280.76 85,023.64 $5,622.10 $1,594.18 $4,48674 84,361.14 38,975.46 33,630.92 31,501.57 32,566.00 $2,534.97 $3,193.77 $3,190.82 $0.00 50.00 30.00 30.00 30.00 $0 00 30.00 30.00 30.00 30.00 30.00 $0.00 30.00 30.00 30.00 50.00 $0.00 30.00 30.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 30.00 90.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 $0.00 90.00 54,207.46 $1,148.90 $4,357.69 53,308.54 56,125.01 $6,366.36 $3,183.18 93,183.18 53,220.62 53,213.97 53,476.25 53,886.31 53,241.80 59,074.96 $3,260.76 55,023.64 $5,622.10 $1,594.18 $4,486.74 $4,361.14 38,975.46 33,630.92 31,501.57 32,566.00 32,534.97 33,193.77 33,190.82 $0.00 90.00 3918.39 3918.39 $918.39 5918.39 3918.39 31,442.10 5918.39 320,930.52 $26,199.48 $20,759.48 320,659.67 $25,031.35 521,790.10 $22,805.03 $21,152.09 $22,218.61 $24,596.11 $27,248.31 321,142.17 319,989.52 323,580.73 $24,274.37 $19,653.23 323,364.48 316,668.72 319,107.02 321,804.62 $22,99351 917,734.28 30.00 33,068.67 30.00 33,762.69 39,394.48 30.00 931,316.35 50.00 $0.00 $4,208.96 $1,784.92 50.00 53,496.93 50.00 90.00 $1,488.15 50.00 $2,729.41 $0.00 $0.00 55,630.65 50.00 30.00 33,436.07 80.00 52,087.28 30.00 $767.94 51,971.36 $0.00 $0.00 51,724.70 30.00 30.00 31,092.88 $0.00 Nemmers , Genevieve F. Koopmann, Leonard & Jody Scott Koopmann Wagner, Hubert & Elms N. Scot, Michael H. & Nicola M. Schmitz, Margaret B. Trustee Wahlert Susan L. Trustee Revocable Tr. Obbink, Bruce A. & Kristi R. Mohr, Matthew D. & Jennifer M. Eddy, Jeffrey W. & Charlene A. De Long, Myra E. Kennedy, James G. & Frances D. Kreiss, Jon N. & Molty A. Roling, Benjamin M. Conlon, Stephen D Richardson, James R. Their, Tony A. & Anna K. Kalb Andrew E. & Conlon Rebecca E. McNamara, Timothy J. Wertheimer, Mark & Barbara R. Hedzman Wesley W. & Hemet Woodward Thomas N. & Charlice L. Smith, Peter L. & Susan M. Kennedy, James G. & Frances D. De Long, Myra E Conlon, Stephen D. McNamara, Timothy J. McNamara, Timothy J. Wartburg Theological Seminary Conlon. Chnstine TOTALS= 325 137.98 327 348.38 329,326.13 325 753.13 332,074.75 $31,653.39 325 988.21 325,253.66 526,927.38 $27 810.08 833 453.97 925,028.48 $23,231.32 938 286.34 527,535.13 325,595.26 532 422.65 519,181.29 525,681.04 927,084.15 $32,736.91 $23,336.56 31,501.57 35 634.67 $5,701.77 37 874.85 512,585.30 31,092.88 931,316.35 5107,936.29 $6,952.44 $531,245.59 930,419.25 5676,553.56 SANITARY VALUATION NET PAVING NET PAVING TOTAL PUBLIC WATER SEWER CONCRETE PARCEL WITH IMPROVEMENT IMPROVEMENT IMPROVEMENT SERVICE PRIVATE SIDEWALK TOTAL NET PROPERTY OWNER NAME LOT DESCRIPTION NUMBER IMPROVEMENT COST DEFICIENCY COST COSTS LATERAL COST COST ASSESSMENT CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA SUNSET RIDGE RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT PRELIMINARY SCHEDULE OF VALUATION AND PROPOSED ASSESSMENTS DATE: July 6, 2010 The following schedule is hereby determined to show each lot proposed to be assessed for the improvement shown in the title together with the amount proposed to be assessed against each lot and the valuations shown opposite each lot are hereby fixed as the true valuations of such lots by the City Council of the City of Dubuque. Lot 1 -29 & 2 -28 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 1 -1 -2 ML 129 & Lot 2 -1 Sunset Ridge Lot 1 -1 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 2 Sunset Ridge & Lot 2 -1 -2 ML 129 Lots 27, 1 -28 & 2 -29 Sunset Ridge Sub Sunset Ridge No 2 Lots 2 -2 & 2 -1 Both of ML 129 Lot 26 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 25 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 2 -1 -1 ML 129 & Lot 5 Sunset Ridge Lot 24 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 6 Sunset Ridge & Lot 1 -1 -1 ML 129 Lot 22 & S 20' Lot 23 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 21 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 1 Sunset Ridge #4 Lot 1 Sunset Ridge #3 Lot 2 Sunset Ridge #3 & N 1/2 Lot 18 Sunset Ridge Lot 1 Sunset Ridge #5 S 1/2 Lot 18 Sunset Ridge Lots 13, 1-1-14, 2 -12 All in Sunset Ridge Lot 1 -15 Sunset Ridge Lot 2 Faldorf Place (4.6 Ac) & Lots 2 -14 & 2 -15 Sunset Ridge Lot 2 -14 Sunset Ridge Lot 2 -7 Sunset Ridge Sub N 80' or Bal Lot 23 Sunset Ridge Sub Lot 2 Sunset Ridge #5 Lot 17 Sunset Ridge Lot 16 Sunset Ridge Lot 1 -1 & 2 -1 both of ML 132 "All" McDonald Wartburg Place 10 35 252 001 10 35 179 003 10 35 251 001 10 35 179 004 10 35 252 003 10 35 179 010 10 35 252 004 10 35 252 005 10 35 179 007 10 35 252 006 10 35 179 008 10 35 252 008 10 35 252 009 10 35 251 005 10 35 252 012 10 35 252 014 10 35 251 006 10 35 402 002 10 35 401 002 10 35 402 005 10 35 402 009 10 35 401 003 10 35 251 002 10 35 252 007 10 35 401 005 10 35 402 003 10 35 402 004 10 35 128 006 10 35 201 007 $335,137.98 5425,748 38 5386,326.13 $370,353 13 $354,574.75 5596,853.39 $488,39821 $358,45366 5301,127 38 $416,310 08 5442,653.97 $347,728.48 $343,231.32 3785,086.34 5353,535.13 3295,345.26 $411,222.65 3253,981.29 5553,781.04 $280,484.15 3555,436.91 3264,636.56 928,025.39 $66,534.67 578,230.04 $35,174.85 $50,885.30 5991,612.88 $737,616 35 94,207.46 91,148.90 $4,357.69 33,308.54 $6,125.01 56,366.36 33,183.18 53,183.18 53,220.62 53,213.97 53,476.25 $3,886.31 $3,241.80 $9,074.96 53,280.76 85,023.64 $5,622.10 $1,594.18 $4,48674 84,361.14 38,975.46 33,630.92 31,501.57 32,566.00 $2,534.97 $3,193.77 $3,190.82 $0.00 50.00 30.00 30.00 30.00 $0 00 30.00 30.00 30.00 30.00 30.00 $0.00 30.00 30.00 30.00 50.00 $0.00 30.00 30.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 30.00 90.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 $0.00 90.00 54,207.46 $1,148.90 $4,357.69 53,308.54 56,125.01 $6,366.36 $3,183.18 93,183.18 53,220.62 53,213.97 53,476.25 53,886.31 53,241.80 59,074.96 $3,260.76 55,023.64 $5,622.10 $1,594.18 $4,486.74 $4,361.14 38,975.46 33,630.92 31,501.57 32,566.00 32,534.97 33,193.77 33,190.82 $0.00 90.00 3918.39 3918.39 $918.39 5918.39 3918.39 31,442.10 5918.39 320,930.52 $26,199.48 $20,759.48 320,659.67 $25,031.35 521,790.10 $22,805.03 $21,152.09 $22,218.61 $24,596.11 $27,248.31 321,142.17 319,989.52 323,580.73 $24,274.37 $19,653.23 323,364.48 316,668.72 319,107.02 321,804.62 $22,99351 917,734.28 30.00 33,068.67 30.00 33,762.69 39,394.48 30.00 931,316.35 50.00 $0.00 $4,208.96 $1,784.92 50.00 53,496.93 50.00 90.00 $1,488.15 50.00 $2,729.41 $0.00 $0.00 55,630.65 50.00 30.00 33,436.07 80.00 52,087.28 30.00 $767.94 51,971.36 $0.00 $0.00 51,724.70 30.00 30.00 31,092.88 $0.00 Nemmers , Genevieve F. Koopmann, Leonard & Jody Scott Koopmann Wagner, Hubert & Elms N. Scot, Michael H. & Nicola M. Schmitz, Margaret B. Trustee Wahlert Susan L. Trustee Revocable Tr. Obbink, Bruce A. & Kristi R. Mohr, Matthew D. & Jennifer M. Eddy, Jeffrey W. & Charlene A. De Long, Myra E. Kennedy, James G. & Frances D. Kreiss, Jon N. & Molty A. Roling, Benjamin M. Conlon, Stephen D Richardson, James R. Their, Tony A. & Anna K. Kalb Andrew E. & Conlon Rebecca E. McNamara, Timothy J. Wertheimer, Mark & Barbara R. Hedzman Wesley W. & Hemet Woodward Thomas N. & Charlice L. Smith, Peter L. & Susan M. Kennedy, James G. & Frances D. De Long, Myra E Conlon, Stephen D. McNamara, Timothy J. McNamara, Timothy J. Wartburg Theological Seminary Conlon. Chnstine TOTALS= 325 137.98 327 348.38 329,326.13 325 753.13 332,074.75 $31,653.39 325 988.21 325,253.66 526,927.38 $27 810.08 833 453.97 925,028.48 $23,231.32 938 286.34 527,535.13 325,595.26 532 422.65 519,181.29 525,681.04 927,084.15 $32,736.91 $23,336.56 31,501.57 35 634.67 $5,701.77 37 874.85 512,585.30 31,092.88 931,316.35 5107,936.29 $6,952.44 $531,245.59 930,419.25 5676,553.56