Loading...
Recreation and Open Space Plan Dubuque, Iowa October 1973R 711.558 Iowa Books R 711.558 REC Iowa Books IMMIDMEM recreation and open space ;plan, Dubuque, Iowa Recreation And Open Space Pan Dubuque, Iowa October, 1973 3 1825 00486 0071 DUBUQUE CITY COUNCIL Joseph J. Bitter, Mayor C. Robert Justmann Dr. Wayne A. Moldenhauer Walter A. Pregler Allan T. Thoms DUBUQUE CITY MANAGER Gilbert D. Chavenelle CITY CLERK CITY SOLICITOR Leo F. Frommelt R. N. Russo DUBUQUE PLAYGROUND AND RECREATION COMMISSION 1 Paul Frommelt, Chairman Thomas Breitbach John Coffee C. Michael Reilly Gilbert D. Chavenelle Mrs. Patricia O'Brien Mrs. -Betty Nugent DIRECTOR OF RECREATION Richard J. Slattery DUBUQUE PARK BOARD Frederick R. Appel, Chairman Dominic Goodman Thomas Schrup SUPERINTENDENT OF PARKS Richard Kramer L. STAFF ASSISTANCE Richard Kramer Superintendent of Parks Richard Slattery Director of Recreation Terry Trueblood Asst. Director of Recreation Daniel Dittemore Development Planner Lawrence Sommer Asst. Development Planner Mary Pape Secretary Loretta Meyer Secretary GRAPHIC ASSISTANCE Larry Dunkin Dubuque County Zoning staff PREFACE "More and more American municipalities become concerned with the provision of adequate recreational facilities for their citizens. Recreation is no longer considered one of life's luxuries to be enjoyed by a few, but a necessity for all re- gardless of their economic status. And so, as our American cities increase in size and population, they need proportion- ally greater recreational facilities, greater in number as well as greater in area." Comprehensive City Plan, Dubuque, Iowa 1936 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION 1 THE PHYSICAL LANDSCAPE Dubuque's Setting Local Geography Climate Economy Land Use and Development 3 3 3 5 6 7 RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE DEMAND 10 Population Trends and Projections 10 Social and Economic Characteristics 14 Participation in Recreational Activities 15 Implications for Dubuque 17 EXISTING FACILITIES 19 Classification 19 Existing Community Facilities 22 ADEQUACY OF EXISTING FACILITIES 30 National Standards 30 Local Area Analysis 33 Community -Wide Facilities 45 Other Facilities and Needs 45 FIVE YEAR OUTDOOR RECREATION PLAN Goals Proposed Projects Regular Maintenance and Replacement Projects Additions or Improvements to Existing Facilities New Development Projects 47 47 48 49 51 52 PROJECT FUNDING AND PRIORITIES 62 Project Cost Estimates and Priorities • 63 Funding 69 Other Means for Open Space Establishment 69 IMPLEMENTATION 72 Coordination 72 Updating the Plan 74 APPENDIX I: INVENTORY OF EXISTING LOCAL RECREATION FACILITIES . 75 APPENDIX II: REGIONAL RECREATION INVENTORY 102 SELECTED REFERENCES 109 f MAPS AND ILLUSTRATIONS DUBUQUE'S REGIONAL SETTING NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES COMMUNITY -WIDE FACILITIES GENERAL OUTDOOR RECREATION AREAS RECREATION PLANNING SUBAREAS NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES (1) Less than 1% of subarea devoted to Neighborhood Recreation Facilities (2) Less than 2.0 acres per 1000 persons devoted to Neighbor- hood Recreation Facilities POPULATION DENSITY AGE STRUCTURE 23 26 28 34 37 38 39 40 NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES SERVICE AREAS (1) City of Dubuque Facilities 41 (2) Dubuque Community School District Facilities 42 (3) Archdiocese of Dubuque Facilities 43 AREAS NOT SERVED OR INADEQUATELY SERVED BY NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES 44 NEIGHBORHOOD PARK AND PLAYGROUND DEVELOPMENT 53 TYPICAL NEIGHBORHOOD PLAYGROUND BIKEWAY DEVELOPMENT BLUFF CONSERVATION AREAS 54 57 59 INTRODUCTION It has been well noted that the outdoors lies deep in America's tradition. This tradition has had a great impact on the nation and those who have made its history. When an American looks for the mean- ing of his past, he seeks it not so much in ancient ruins but more often in the mountains and forest, by a river or at the edge of the sea. Even as the supply of open space in America dwindles, the demand for outdoor experiences and recreational opportunities is increasing dram- atically. Whatever the measuring rod, if it is to federal, state or local recreation areas, number of fishing license holders or number of outboard motors sold, it is clear that Americans are seeking the out- doors as never before. Not only will there be more people, they will have more time and money for participating in leisure activities. Providing adequate outdoor recreational opportunities for the next twenty years is a major chal- lenge that will require large investments of time, money and resources. Leadership, vision and judgement will be needed to guide this invest- ment into the most effective channels. Over the years the City of Dubuque has committed itself to the development of parks and recreation facilities. Superb Eagle Point Park has been the focal point of an extensive open space and recrea- tion system that has generally served the citizens of Dubuque and surrounding area in a varied and high quality manner. Recent years have seen increased interest in recreational boating on the Mississippi River, creation of the Flora Park Barn, a popular multiple use facil- ity, the mushrooming use of bicycles, and growing concern over the City's historic and cultural resources. Both public and private inter- ests have nurtured these developments., Despite long-standing efforts to provide recreational opportunities, deficiencies exist. Lack of, or inadequate size of neighborhood parks and playgrounds and disorganized development of small institutional building sites within residential areas are among the priority prob- lems at this time. Thought must also be given to future open space and recreation land needs over a long-term planning period. Natural beauty, undeveloped land, water and wildlife are still abundant, but as Dubuque expands these irreplaceable resources will decrease. Indeed, during the sec- ond half of the twentieth century we are involved in finding entirely new meanings for the word "conservation". Mere "saving" is no longer sufficient unless we know what we are saving, why it is worth saving, or for whom or what purpose it is being saved. We shall continue to alter the land just as we have done since the discovery of America by 1 -2 3 white men. As the supply of land diminishes and as populations increase, we must use our land and other natural resources much more wisely than we have in the past. It is vital and valid that the beauty and abundance that inspired the first Dubuquers and still im- presses us today must be equally impressive to those who will follow. This report will attempt to do several things. First of all it will inventory and analyze the present recreation and open space base with- in the City of Dubuque. It will also outline for the next five years a plan designed to not only correct existing deficiencies but also to provide major new recreational opportunities for the people of Dubuque. Finally, it will take a more general look at some of the long range "conservation" opportunities that exist and that should be considered while there is still time to do so. Throughout the preparation of this recreation plan close liaison and and cooperation was maintained with all of the local departments in- volved in existing park and recreation activities as well as in implementing proposed programs. Coordination with the Dubuque County Metropolitan Area Planning Commission, the Dubuque County Conservation Board and the Iowa Conservation Commission has also been of particular importance. The City of Dubuque can look forward to continued cooper- ation with these agencies as the plan is implemented in order to avoid duplicative efforts and to provide the broadest base of public recrea- tion and open space opportunities and facilities possible. Because the Dubuque County Metropolitan Area Planning Commission is preparing a recreation plan for Dubuque County, the planning area de- fined for this plan is limited to the city itself. Throughout the preparation of both recreation plans constant cooperation between city and county staff has assured thorough analysis of existing facilities and recreation demand as well as coordinated proposals for plan imple- mentation. The basic concept behind both the city and county plans has been that the two separate plans should be regarded as complemen- tary and used jointly. THE PHYSICAL LANDSCAPE Dubuque's Setting Dubuque is Iowa's oldest City. It is located on the western bank of the Mississippi River at the tri-state corner of Iowa, Illinois and Wisconsin. The City lies at the center of the large midwestern area circumscribed by Chicago, Milwaukee, Minneapolis -St. Paul, Omaha, Kan- sas City and St. Louis. It is almost equi-distant from its surrounding comparable cities of Davenport, Cedar Rapids, Waterloo, Madison and Rockford. Dubuque functions as the regional city center for an area approximately 70 miles in diameter and includes the small towns of Maquoketa, Dyersville, Guttenberg, Platteville and East Dubuque. Important deposits of lead drew the first settlers to the area before 1800. The Mississippi River provided the first transportation route to Dubuque. It brought explorers and later settlers into the region while lead, lumber, grain and other products were shipped out. Later a system of railway lines and highways was developed. Today Dubuque's economic and physical existence depends upon these transportation fac- ilities, and their relative adequacy is a measure of its prosperity and the competition it faces. Dubuque is oriented in an eastern dir- ection toward Chicago. The present regional highway system does not provide particularly good vehicular connections with any of the sur- rounding major metropolitan centers. Like most other cities today Dubuque has no rail passenger service, but enjoys direct mainline rail connections with Chicago, Minneapolis and Omaha and indirect connec- tions with Kansas City, Des Moines, St. Louis, and Milwaukee. Air transportation is provided by a modern airport facility served by second and third level carriers as well as charter and private aircraft. The Mississippi River remains a major transportation corridor for a variety of bulk commodities as well as -for rapidly -growing recreation- al boating activity. Local Geography From its beginning Dubuque's two basic physical features, the Mississippi River and the high bluffs have shaped its physical develop- ment. The local geography of Dubuque is characterized by sharp, high bluffs, deep ravines and rolling farmlands. The City has developed along the Mississippi Valley floor and on the western bluff tops be- tween the Little Maquoketa River on the north and the multiple branches of Catfish Creek on the south. The landscape around the City is a pattern of small farms, forested bluffs, broken ridges and rav- ines, scattered settlements and winding rural roads. While the river provided access to Dubuque, the 300 foot high bluffs contained development for almost a century. Only since World War II Li MINNESOTA Minneapis IOWA • �" f. • .:f 9 �,p re'C', f+ 1vYT.... .'iW 'f..ix ���. WISCONSIN DUBUQUE ®Des Moines maha MISSOURI St. Louis Maiison lilwaukee ILLINOIS Chic, g DUBUQUE'S REGIONAL STTNG has new residential and commercial growth spread westward beyond the bluffs to any great extent. Not only did the limestone bluffs serve to contain and shape Dubuque's development throughout most of its his- tory, they also provided stone for building, were riddled with the shafts of early lead mines, planted with vineyards and utilized as spectacular building sites as the City became more affluent. Perhaps most important, Dubuque's bluffs have served as outstanding scenic and natural backdrops for the City. Climate A varied climate supports a wide variety of recreational opportunities. During the spring and summer months contrasting masses of cool, dry air from Canada and warm, moist air from the Gulf of Mexico provide measurable rain on 59 of the 180 days of these seasons. The combined spring and summer accumulation of 22.49 inches is about 60 percent of the 35.71 inches average yearly total. Skies are clear or partly cloudy on 105 days during this same period with average high tempera- tures in the low eighties and average low temperatures in the low sixties and upper fifties during the prime outdoor recreation months of June, July and August. It is rarely too hot for the most active outdoor sports or too cool for swimming during these months. During the autumn precipitation amounts and average temperatures decrease as the clear, dry air masses become more dominant. Tempera- ture extremes still vary over a wide range during late September, October and November, and the demand for outdoor recreation is revived sporadically throughout the late fall. The 179 day growing season ends in October which is perhaps the most scenic month with the hardwood forests aglow with all the imaginable colors of autumn. Winter emphasizes the variability of Dubuque's climate even though the daily temperature ranges stabilize between highs reaching the thirties and average daily lows dipping into the low teens. Midwinter thaws occur fairly frequently. The record low during the past twenty years was minus 32 degrees. Although most recreation has moved indoors dur- ing these months, the rising popularity of skiing and other winter sports has focused new attention on the rugged hills in the Dubuque region. Snowfall for winter sports averages about 42 inches per year. While artificial snow -making equipment has allowed skiing on a reason- ably reliable basis, snowmobiles add another dimension to the winter recreation scene. During December, January and February, it is sunny on an average of 41 days so that winter recreation is often possible under ideal conditions. 7 6 Economy Dubuque serves as the employment center for a multi -county region within the three states of Iowa, Illinois and Wisconsin. Total employ- ment in the Dubuque area (defined as Dubuque County) is currently about 45,300 persons out of a total work force of 46,500 persons. Manufacturing represents the largest single portion of this total. Dubuque's diversified industries employ over 16,000 persons and in- clude firms ranging in size from the John Deere Dubuque Tractor Works (6,500 persons) and the Dubuque Packing Company (3,000 persons) on down to numerous small firms that employ 25 people or less. Non -manu- facturing employment includes workers in the fields of construction, transportation, utilities, wholesale and retail trade, finance, govern- ment and services. These categories employ 21,900 workers at the present time. Agriculture currently employs 2,900 persons virtually all of whom are outside Dubuque. Since World War II Dubuque's economic base and total employment has shown steady growth with the general exception of agriculture which has declined consistently following national trends. Major causes for the growth and diversification of Dubuque's industrial base are the rapid growth of the Dubuque Packing Company, started in 1931 with 40 employees and now employing over 3,000 persons and the growth of Dubuque's John Deere plant since its beginning in 1946. During this same period Dubuque also lost one of its major employers, the Farley and Loetscher Manufacturing Company, once one of the world's largest woodworking firms. The composition and character of the Dubuque labor force indicate the relative importance of the various economic sectors and the extent of industrial diversification within the local economy. The economic ranking highest in terms of employment include manufacturing, services and trade. Government ranks fourth and agriculture fifth. The manu- facturing group alone accounts for 36 percent of the total Dubuque County employment, followed by services (17%), trade (16%), government (7%), and agriculture (6%). During the coming decade Dubuque is going to be faced with the problem of providing substantially more industrial land if this segment of the local economy is going to continue expanding. The City is virtually without any readily -developable industrial land at this time. The next decade may also see changes in the trade and related segments of the economy with more emphasis on tourism following the completion of the Five Flags Civic Center, new hotel construction, completion of the Urban Renewal Project, increased recreational boating, convention busi- ness encouragement and generally -increased tourist awareness of Dubuque's and northeast Iowa's attractions. ) R Is! aq_ Land Use and Development Dubuque's development pattern has been shaped by the strong influences of the river and its related bluff topography. Industrial land uses concentrated mainly near the Mississippi River. Residential develop- ment occurred first along the valley floor and spread northward along the terraces. As the City grew, newer residential areas were developed on the next most available land on top of the bluffs above the City center and then progressively westward, northward and southward. Com- mercial land uses clustered first around the original town center and slowly shifted northward. Small neighborhood stores developed at the junction of important streets and roads. During the last five years major new commercial development has occurred in the western sectors of Dubuque primarily along J.F. Kennedy Road and Highway 20. Today the extent of this commercial development rivals and in some instances surpasses the central business district. Large institutional land holdings were purchased around the periphery of the City during its various development periods. Today these insti- tutional holdings form important portions of the City's open space network although from time to time parcels are sold for development. Generally, the large sites of the various religious orders, colleges, high schools and golf courses separate and define residential districts, give value and stability to neighborhoods and provide a pleasant en- vironment for quiet, spacious living. Their distribution throughout nearly every part of the City provides part of the framework for orderly future development and for improvement of existing neighbor- hoods. Public open space includes two large parks and a wide scattering of other parks, playgrounds and recreation facilities. All of these fac- ilities will be discussed in detail later in this report. Public, institutional and open space land comprise a quarter of the total de- veloped acreage of Dubuque and are one of the principal reasons for the City's attractiveness and character. In general Dubuque's development pattern represents a variation on the concentric ring pattern of development that has resulted from its loc- ation on the Mississippi River. The City has grown outward in a series of three clearly -identifiable parts: the industrial district adjacent to the Mississippi River east of the City center; the central business district between the industrial area and the bluffs; and the various residential areas to the west, north and south. Recent commerciali- zation to the west has altered the historical concentric development pattern so that two main commerical districts now exist with residen- tial and institutional land uses between. A detailed study of Dubuque's land uses has not been undertaken for nearly a decade so presently available land use statistics can offer only an approximation of the current situation. Land use statistics 8 for 1964, however, do indicate the relative amounts of land used for different purposes. Summarized Land Use Statistics City of Dubuque Category Single Family Residential Two Family Residential Multi -Family Residential Commercial Industrial Recreation Public and institutional Railways, streets & highways Percent of Total Acres Developed Area • 2,169 145 78 182 346 579 1,067 1,686 35 2 1 3 6 9 17 27 6,252 100% Source: Dubuque Development Plan, 1964 Since 1964 significant increases have occurred in the multi -family and commercial categories as rapid urbanization took place in western Dubuque. Less dramatic changes have occurred in the other categories. Several comments should be made regarding the land use patterns in Dubuque and their implications for outdoor recreation. Although rec- reation and open space land acreages represent an acceptable standard of nearly ten acres per 1,000 people, existing parks are concentrated into large tracts distant from the most heavily populated residential neighborhoods. Marked deficiencies in -both number and location of smaller park and playground spaces exist in every portion of the City but particularly in the older residential areas. The large acreages of public and institutional land do not indicate the prevailing inad- equacy of public and parochial school site sizes in most parts of the city. The following specific observations may be made: A. The total acreage of recreational land use in Dubuque is considerably higher than usual for a City of Com- parable size. This large total acreage reflects the existence of large golfing, picnicking and hiking fa- cilities located without relationship to residential 101 density and does not indicate the severe deficiency of smaller local parks and playgrounds that exists. Dubuque clearly needs more recreation spaces of the local play- ground type located within walking distance of the residential areas they are intended to serve. B. Recreation is one land use that is directly affected by public policy responsive to the needs of the citizens. As Dubuque grows and internal open land areas begin to vanish, there is a much greater awareness of the need for additional neighborhood recreation space. The creation of neighborhood parks and playgrounds can occur not only through the pre -acquisition of land in the developing areas to the west but also through the expansion of existing sites and the creation of new sites in older neighborhoods through the community renewal process. C. The current rate of increase in public land use in the city has been disproportionately slow compared with population and development change. As already mentioned, most residential neighborhoods lack adequate local recreation facilities, and many existing public build- ings are due for replacement. An increase in public land use can therefore be anticipated as lands are acquired for local playground facilities, new elementary school sites and other public buildings in older portions of the city as well as for school, park and playground sites in future development areas. 9 - 10 RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE DEMAND During the 1960's it became apparent that serious shortages of public parks and recreational opportunities were developing. Primarily as a result of this so-called "increased demand" for outdoor recreation serious attempts were made to analyze and understand recreation demand and needs. On the national level the Outdoor Recreation Resources Review Committee was established to analyze recreation needs. This group conducted extensive surveys and issued a series of reports between 1960 and 1963. Their chief contribution was in the area of "demand analysis" that more clearly defined what Americans did for outdoor recreation, what social and economic factors give rise to new recreational needs and how those needs will affect the current supply of recreation facilities and programs. Recreation demand is abstract and somewhat difficult to precisely measure. It is influenced by a wide range of demographic, economic, social and physical variables. For example, the general assumption that the current strain on recreational facilities is caused by an increase in leisure time is only partially true. Americans today have only slightly more free time than they did ten years ago. In Dubuque, the average industrial work week has been nearly stable for the past decade. The real basis for increased recreation demand are much more closely related to growing populations, rising incomes and educational levels and increased mobility. Population Trends and Projections The City of Dubuque and surrounding urbanized area have been growing at a rate comparable to the North Central United States as a whole and much faster than the State of Iowa. Population Trends 1940-1970 Percent Increase 1940 1950 1960 1970 1940 1950 1960 1950 1960 1970 United States 131,669,275 150,697,361 178,464,236 207,976,452 14.4 18.4 16.5 North Central States* 40,143,332 44,460,762 51,619,139 56,571,663 10.7 16.1 9.6 Iowa 2,538,268 2,621,073 2,757,537 2,824,376 3,3 5.2 2.4 Illinois 7,897,241 8,712,176 10,081,158 11,113,976 10.3 15.7 10.2 Wisconsin 3,137,586 3,434,575 3,951,777 4,417,731 9.5 15.0 11.8 Dubuque County 63,768 71,337 80,048 90,609 11.9 11.2 13.2 Dubuque Urbanized Area** 45,367 51,368 59,497 65,550 13.2 15.7 10.2 City of Dubuque 43,892 49,671 56,606 62,309 13.2 14.0 10.0 Source: U.S. Census of Pooulation 1940-1970. *Includes Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Kansas, Wisconsin, Nebraska, Illinois, South Dakota, North Dakota, Indiana, Ohio and Michigan. **Includes East Dubuque, Illinois NI!!! NI!' AI!! Pig illo! - 11 During the decade from 1960 to 1970 the rate of national population growth was the second lowest in our history, but the absolute growth (29.5 million) was the second largest in history. The decline in the national population growth rate is due to the declining birth rate that in 1971 was 17.4 births per thousand people, a lower rate than during the depression of the 1930's. Population growth in the North Central states has been increasing at a slower rate than other regions of the United States with the result that the population of this region is becoming a smaller percentage of the total United States population. This same trend is true of Iowa. Iowa's population grew less than 2.5% during the past decade and dropped to only 5% of the North Central states' total population. Within the urbanized portion of Dubuque County population growth has been influenced by migration from rural areas. Dubuque County City of Dubuque Table Mound Twp. Growth of Townships Surrounding Dubuque, 1960-1970 80,048 56,606 (Iowa) 1,736 Mosalem Twp. (Iowa) 782 Dubuque Twp. (Iowa) 3,186 Peru Twp. (Iowa) 980 Dunlieth Twp. (Illinois) 2,443 Jamestown Twp. (Wisconsin) 1,490 90,609 10,561 13.2 62,309 5,703 10.1 2,843 1,107 68.3 1,142 360 46.0 3,798 612 19.2 1,108 128 13.1 3.393 950 38.9 1,965 475 31.8 Source: U.S. Census of Population, 1960-1970 The main implication of these figures for outdoor recreation is that with the largest increases in Dubuque County's population centered in and around Dubuque additional urban -oriented recreational facilities may have to be provided if in fact the forecast population growth for this area does occurr. A series of population forecasts for Dubuque and surrounding area have been prepared for the target year 1990. These include forecasts made for the 1990 Transportation Plan, forecasts prepared by the Iowa Office of Planning and Programming and forecasts made recently by the Dubuque County Metropolitan Area Planning Commission. Studied to- gether these population forecasts can offer a reasonable approximation of what to expect in terms of population change over the next twenty years. At best, any forecast is only an educated guess that is dependent on many different assumptions and variables. Generally, however, births, deaths and migration are regarded as the three major components of population change, but other things such as economic growth are also related. The forecasts summarized below give figures for Dubuque County's urbanized area and the remaining rural portion of the County. No reliable forecast figures are currently available for the City of Dubuque itself. Dubuque County Population Projections 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 Dubuque County 87,400 91,400 97,200 103,000 109,000 Dubuque Urban Area 67,000 70,700 74,500 78,200 82,000 Remainder of County 20,400 20,700 22,700 24,800 27,000 Source: Dubuque County Comprehensive Plan, Green Engineering Company, 1963. On the basis of these forecasts 1990 population levels in Dubuque County can be expected to range between 108,000 and 122,000 persons. The Dubuque urban area will contain from two-thirds to three -fourths of this total. While These forecasts cannot be regarded as absolute, it is important to note that each of the five separate forecasts show continued growth for Dubuque and Dubuque County. One might naturally expect that the demand for recreational facilities would be proportion- ate to the area's population. Compared to other factors, however, rising population levels may prove to be only secondary. - 13 Iowa Office of Planning and Programming Population Projections Dubuque County Dubuque Urban Area 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 90,609 95,758 100,617 105,033 108,535 62,309 69,120 65,842 67,457 68,743 Source: Iowa Office of Planning and Programming, 1966. Dubuque Transportation Study Population Projections 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 Dubuque County 90,609 - 101,075 - 115,825 Dubuque Urban Area 69,527 79,546 92,660 Remainder of County 21,082 - 21,529 23,165 Source: Dubuque Transportation Study, 1970. Dubuque County Cohort Survival Projection 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 Dubuque County 90,609 104,075 - 118,825 Source: Dubuque County Metropolitan Area Planning Commission, 1972. Revised Cohort Surival Projection 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 Dubuque County 90,609 - 103,661 - 122,432 Source: Dubuque County Metropolitan Area Planning Commission, 1973. 14 Social and Economic Characteristics Other social and economic characteristics of the area's population that have a more significant impact on the demand for recreational facilities and opportunities include: 1. Disposable Family Income. Bureau of Outdoor Recreation studies show that increasing use of recreation facilities are more closely related to the rise in disposable income than to any other single factor. In the Dubuque area the standard of living is con- tinuing to rise with the result that basic necessities consume a decreasing portion of the family budget. 2. Spending for Commercial Recreation. In the Dubuque area recreation spending is increasing faster than disposable income which indicates that recreation activities are becoming less a luxury and more a necessity. 3. Age. The Bureau of Outdoor Recreation found that age is the most influential factor in the amount of recreation participation. Young persons engage in outdoor recreation much more often than middle- aged and older persons. In the Dubuque area the median age level is lower than either the State of Iowa or the nation. 4. Education. Through education people are exposed to a wider range of choices and more sophistication in their wants and needs. In Dubuque as well as across the nation a steadily rising educational level reflects itself in the growing demand for more diverse activities. 5. Increased Leisure Time. As the average work -week decreases in length and as modern technology lessens the amount of time needed to complete necessary household chores, added leisure time will become an increasingly important focus of life. Some social scientists believe that by the year 2,000 people will work only thirty hours per week, with thirteen weeks vacation annually. 6. Recreation Activity Participation. A 1966 Iowa recreation survey study projected that the average Dubuque resident will increase his participation in outdoor recreation activities from 30.8 occasions per year in 1970 to 33.3 occasions per year in 1980. - 15 Participation in Recreational Activities The image of outdoor recreation is closely tied to popular concepts of the "good life." Actual participation in outdoor recreation activities has been rapidly increasing. By the year 2000 the nationwide demand is expected to increase threefold. In Iowa participation is also increasing as illustrated by a study conducted jointly by the Iowa Conservation Commission and Iowa State University. This study evaluates the recreation desires of Iowans and was presented in the 1972 update of a report entitled Outdoor Recreation in Iowa. The study reveals that: 8 out of every 10 Iowans over 8 out of every 10 Iowans over 6 out of every 10 Iowans over 5 out of every 10 Iowans over sports events or programs. 4 out of every 10 Iowans over 3 out of every 10 Iowans over activity. 2 out of every 10 2 out of every 10 1 out of every 10 1 out of every 10 1 out of every 10 Iowans Iowans Iowans Iowans Iowans over over over over over 12 12 12 12 years years years years of age drive for pleasure. of age picnic. of age walk for pleasure. of age attend outdoor 12 years of 12 years of 12 12 12 12 12 years years years years years age swims. age engages in boating of age ride bicycles. of age fish. of age hunt. of age rides horseback. of age plays golf. These survey findings show that Iowans like to participate in both active and passive recreational activities. In many cases they are willing to travel to engage in these activities. Additional outdoor recreation participation data is available for northeastern Iowa's region I that includes Howard, Winneshiek, Alamakee, Chickasaw, Butler, Fayette, Clayton, Bremer, Grundy, Blackhawk, Buchanan, Delaware and Dubuque counties. Because the socio-economic and physical resources of these counties differ widely and because the data is regional in scope the regional data may or may not reflect the exact situation in Dubuque County. It does, however, provide an indication of regional habits and trends in outdoor recreation participation. L_ Outdoor recreation participation: rates and tota'. participation, Northeast Iowa: 1966, 1975, and 1980. 4$ 1966 1975 Per -feral Per Total Activity Person (1,000 Person (1,000 (days) days) Percent (days; days) Percent Driving for pleasure 7.8 2,680 15 8.5 3,122 -1 T Bicycling 6.6 2,2.66 12 5.7 2,078 9 Picnicking 6.5 2,221 12 7.4 2,697 12 Walking for pleasure 5.5 1,380 10 6.1 2,202 10 Fishing 3.7 1,270 7 3.9 1,401 6 Sightseeing 3.1 1,070 6 3.8 1,380 6 Pool swimming 2.7 935 5 3.6 1,314 6 Attending outdoor sports events 2.7 9 1 3 5 3.2 1 ,1 55 5 Playing baseball or softball 2.4 813 4 2.6 940 4 Playing golf 2.1 711 4 3.9 1,406 6 Boating 2.1 705 4 2.3 820 4 Motorcycling 1.4 478 3 2.0 710 3 Hunting 1.3 429 2 1.3 470 2 Camping - 1.2 421 2 1.5 548 2 Horseback riding 1.0 327 2 1.0 351 2 Natural environment swimming 0.8 270 1 0.9 318 1 Taking nature walks 0.6 219 1 0.9 330 1 Attending outdoor plays or concerts 0.6 2 1 3 1 0.9 331 1 Bird watching 0.6 200 1 0.9 341 1 Playing volleyball 0.5 1 78 1 0.7 26') 1 Ice skating 0.5 1 78 1 0.7 246 1 Water skiing 0.3 103 1 0.4 139 1 Totals - 16 1980 Per Person (days) Total (1,000 days) Percent 8.9 4.7 7.8 6.1 3.9 4.2 3.8 3.3 2.4 4.6 2.3 2.1 1.2 1.7 0.9 0.9 1.0 1.0 1.1 0.8 0.7 0.4 3,264 1,731 2,885 2,248 1,431 1,556 1,398 1,231 897 1,707 854 776 459 608 346 1 325 1 387 2 384 1 401 2 282 1 264 1 153 1 14 7 12 10 6 7 6 5 4 7 4 3 2 3 54.0 18,480 100 62.1 22,561 100 63.8 23,587 100 The 1968 Iowa Natural Resources and Outdoor Recreation plan estimated 1966 participation rates in recreation activities for Dubuque County and made projections for the year 1980. The following table compares selected recreational activities in the 1966 state report and the 1968 Dubuque County recreation plan. PROJECTED INCREASES COMPARISON 1966 - 1980 ACTIVITY REGION I* % DUBUQUE COUNTY+ % Driving for pleasure Swimming Picnics Bicycling Golf Walking for pleasure Motorcycling Hunting Fishing Attending sports events Horseback riding Boating Camping Ice skating Attending concerts & plays Water skiing Nature walks +22 +35 +30 -24 +140 +20 +62 + 7 +13 +35 + 6 +21 +44 +48 +80 +49 +77 Sources: * Outdoor Recreation In Iowa - Conservation Commission 1972 update, Iowa + Natural Resources and Outdoor Recreation - 1968, Dubuque County Conservation Board +37 +59 +43 -11 +163 +31 +66 + 9 +24 +48 +16 +33 +58 +41 +97 +52 +94 1.1 0,1 0111 L The differences in the figures indicate substantial socio-economic differences between Dubuque County and the remainder of northeast Iowa's Region I. Dubuque County has a higher urban and rural non- farm population than the majority of the counties in the region it is included in. Median family income is higher; the number of professional and skilled workers is higher; and the county's median age is much lower. This situation implies that residents of Dubuque County have a higher potential for outdoor recreation participation than the majority of the counties in Region I. The demand for recreational opportunities should therefore be expected to be greater. Implications For Dubuque In summary, the following statements outline the recreation planning implications for Dubuque: 1. Substantial general increases in outdoor recreation activities can be expected. The rate of increase for Dubuque County is higher than for other north- eastern Iowa counties in Region I. 2. Past state and county 1980 projections for partici- pation in selected outdoor recreation activities have already been surpassed by 1970 actual increases. 3. The facilities required for swimming golfing, out- door sports events and other activities that are expected to show large increases in participation often require substantial capital expenditures that often must be programmed several years in advance. 4. Although the participation projections for bicycling show a decrease in this activity, participation has actually skyrocketed since the projections were made. Dubuque already has nearly half as many bicycles as cars registered (over 10,000) and sales are continuing to rise. 5. Rising educational levels and the effects of mass communication enlarges individual interests and sophistication by providing greater awareness of recreational choices. The local effect is reflect- ed in a growing demand for more specialized recreational and cultural activities. - 19 - 18 6. Increased personal mobility, as indicated by the decreasing ratio of population to licensed automobiles, will provide generally easier access to community recreation so that specialized recreation facilities will attract users from a widening region. 7. At the same time that demand for recreational opportunities is increasing, the availability of land for outdoor recreation is decreasing because of other urban pressures. Steps to reserve future open space should be a high priority. 8. Merely keeping pace with the demand for recreational activities may not be enough for that will only assure that things do not become worse. The quality as well as the quantity of outdoor recreational opportunities will both need improvement. log 041 Pig 114 EXISTING FACILITIES Classification The Outdoor Recreation Resources Review Commission and the Bureau of Outdoor Recreation have developed a uniform standard classifica- tion system for listing and evaluating different types of recreation facilities. The following categories are utilized: Class I - High Density Recreation Areas Ia - Neighborhood Facilities: Neighborhood facilities include small parks and miscellaneous urban open spaces with none or with only limited facilities. They also include tot lots, playgrounds and other small to medium size recreation areas used for a variety of purposes. Equipment may include playground and games equipment, ball fields and possibly picnic equipment. These facilities are designed primarily for local neighborhood use. Ib - Community -Wide Facilities: Community -wide recreation areas and open spaces are usually medium to large, highly -developed areas that serve a broad range of functions for the entire City. Examples include picnic areas, swimming pools, organized playfield and game facilities, golf courses, skating rinks, etc. These facilities are subject to substantial development and are intended for intensive use. Class II - General Outdoor Recreation Areas General outdoor recreation areas are large, open space -oriented facilities located in rural areas or adjacent to urban areas. They are usually substantially developed and equipped for a variety of activities such as picnicking, camping, swimming, games, hiking, trail riding, boating, etc. Class III - Natural Environment Areas These are usually large areas with a minimum of man-made facilities. The user is encouraged to use the area in its natural state with a minimum of man-made development provided for access and sanitation. Scattered use is typical and may include such activities as picnicking, camping, hiking, fishing, bird -watching, canoeing or snowshoeing. - 20 Class IV - Unique Natural Areas These areas are unique in scenic splendor, natural wonder or scienti- fic importance. Recreation activities are strictly limited to those which will not affect the unique value of the natural features. Class V - Primitive Areas The natural, wild and undeveloped features are distinguishing charac- teristics of primitive areas. The natural environment has not been disturbed by development, and mechanized transportation is non-existent. Primitive areas must be sufficiently large to remove the user from the sights, sound and smells of civilization and provide the recreation- al user with a feeling of true wilderness experience. There are no primitive areas in the State of Iowa. Class VI - Historic and Cultural Sites These are sites associated with the history, tradition or cultural heritage of an area and are of sufficient significance to merit preservation or restoration. Management is directed to restoration, preservation and interpretation for sightseeing, enjoyment and study of the historic and cultural features. Limited day -use facilities may be provided if they do not detract from the primary purpose and value of the site. Class VII- Reserved Open Spaces and Undeveloped Lands Lands and waters in this classification are those desirable recreation sites that are acquired, pending eventual development, to preserve them from loss to undesirable uses. They may be located anywhere and acquired through several methods ranging from easement agreement to fee simple title. When finally developed, such areas would be class- ified under the appropriate category. Wildlife Areas Wildlife areas include lands and waters specifically developed and managed for wildlife purposes. Areas in this class may be open to hunting or closed as in the case of refuges,. Other recreational facilities may be available although the ma'n intent is for wildlife management. - 21 Water Access This category includes those relatively small areas developed to provide boating or hunting access to the waters of the State. Other facilities may or may not be present as secondary uses. Rest Areas These are highway -oriented areas specifically developed to provide the traveler with a place for rest, relief and relaxation from driving. They are generally small and not intended for overnight use. Rest areas are considered incidental and serve to facilitate travel to other destination -type recreation areas. Private and Other Facilities This general category includes a wide variety of recreation facilities. Areas included tend to be organization or facility oriented rather than being dependent upon any particular natural resource attributes. Examples include such things as clubs, camps, resorts, vacation farms, ski areas, miniture golf, race tracks and the like. This broad cate- gory includes any private and other recreation facility that cannot be grouped elsewhere. Existing Community Facilities Within the City of Dubuque existing park and recreation facilities can be classified into the following Bureau of Outdoor Recreation classifications: Class I Ia Ib Class II Class VI Class VII High Density Recreation=Areas Neighborhood Facilities Community -Wide Facilities General Outdoor Recreation Areas Historic and Cultural Sites Reserved Open Spaces and Undeveloped Lands Water Access Areas Private and Other Facilities In order to evaluate Dubuque's park and recreation facilities in terms of generally accepted standards of adequacy as well as in terms of specific local deficiencies and needs, the inventory lists all facili- ties by both type and by ownership or control. Refer to the appendix of this report for detailed inventory tables. viilatLiAwgAgar:, Fr e. \ l stt.se*..itadraako.uwaewiuol.e/ltacWUMMla4 nrauF�4►?&APA cF - 22 With one or two exceptions no facilities outside the City are included in this inventory. A detailed analysis of Dubuque County facilities can be found in a separate recreation plan prepared in 1973 by the Dubuque County Metropolitan Area Planning Commission. This County recreation plan should be regarded as a complementary document to this City plan, and both should be referred to. Existing Community Facilities The following inventory lists existing recreation facilities in the City of Dubuque. It is arranged by type of facility and by owner- ship or control. The numbers refer to site locations on the accompanying maps. Detailed information on site size, condition, use and equipment provided at each facility is listed in the appendix to this report. Neighborhood Facilities - Dubuque Park Board Map No. Name and Location 1. Cleveland Park: end of Cleveland Avenue 2. Jackson Park: 15th and Main Streets 3. Washington Park: 7th and Locust/Bluff Streets 4. Madison Park: end of North Main Street 5. University Park: Asbury Road and Clarke Drive 6. Caledonia Playground: Caledonia and West 8th 7.- Frith Playground: Queen and Regent Street 8. Jefferson Park: Walnut and University Avenue 9. Flat Iron (Phoenix) Park: Main and Jones Streets 10. Grant Park: Bluff and 15th Streets 11. Oakwood Park: north of 32nd Street Neighborhood Facilities - Playground and Recreation Commission 12. Booth Tennis Court: Booth and Dodge Streets 13. Burden Playground: Windsor and Burden Streets 14. Falk Playground: Ideal Lane and Earl Drive 15. Gay Playground: Gay and Primrose Streets 16. Peter Cooper Playground: Sycamore and 14th Street 17. Valley High Playground: N. Grandview and Cerro 18. Waller -Cooper Tot Lot: Cooper Place 19. Hillcrest Tot Lot: Hillcrest Road 20. Hilltop Playground: Caledonia and Wilson Streets 10% 101 IP" I"! 111101 r`3 •F NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES 45. St. Patrick's School / 21. Audubon School 22. Bryant School 23. Fulton School 24. Irving School 25. Jackson School 26. Kennedy School 27. Lincoln School 28. Marshall School -\- 29. Prescott School =,� 30. Hoover School 31. Eisenhower School 1. Cleveland Park 2. Jackson Park 3. Washington Park 4. Madison Park 5. University Park 6. Caledonia Playground 7. Frith Playground 8. Jefferson Park 9. Flatiron Park 10. Grant Park 11. Oakwood Park 12. Booth Tennis Court. 13. Burden Playground 14. Falk Playground 15. Gay Playground 16. Peter Cooper Playground.,. 17. Valley High Playground -- 18. Waller -Cooper Totlot 19. Hillcrest Totiof >" 20 Hilltop Playground \,._ `. 46. Resurrection School 1 47. Immaculate Conception Schoolf /; F148. St. Elias Playground lam; .. . 499. St. Peter's Playground • WAHLERT HIGH / SCHOOL � 46• l\y^ • .67a ill --- TV-7' e 30 \\\ (44.-" ye`J: tL \+ J f *1. ' v,. r1 - c, �l i 32. Jefferson J.H. School- 33. Washington School 34. Marshall Playground 35. Valentine Playground 36. St. Raphael's School 37. Holy Ghost School 38. Holy Trinity School 39. Nativity School 40. Sacred Heart School 41. St. Anthony School 42. St. Columbkille's School 43. St. Joseph School 44. St. Mary's School ri (7--;41(4 t7-4-1r,1 Li_3 La i l �•� r�� IA ri Vr) ('71 n d LI 9UAKER a HILL GOLF COURSE • s tl. �r [s ;.shu \ • - 23 • t'T CGRMEL \•. Park Board Facilities * Recreation Commission Facilities_ • School District Facilities ♦ Religious Institution Facilities - 24 Neighborhood Facilities - Dubuque Community School District 21. Audubon School: 535 Lincoln Avenue 22. Bryant School: 1280 Rush Street 23. Fulton School: 2540 Central Avenue 24. Irving School: 2520 Pennsylvania Avenue 25. Jackson School: 715 West Locust Street 26. Kennedy School: 2135 Woodland Street 27. Lincoln School: 1101 West Fifth Street 28. Marshall School: 1450 Rhomberg Avenue 29. Prescott School: 1249 White Street 30. Hoover School: 3259 St. Anne Drive 31. Eisenhower School: 3170 Spring Valley Road 32. Jefferson Junior High School: 1105 Althauser 33. Washington Junior High School: 900 Alta Vista 34. Marshall Playground: Rhomberg and Whittier 35. Valentine Playground: Valentine Drive Neighborhood Facilities - Archdiocese of Dubuque 36. St. Raphael's School: 223 Bluff Street 37. Holy Ghost School: 2931 Central Avenue 38. Holy Trinity School: 1703 Rhomberg Avenue 39. Nativity School: 1001 Alta Vista Street 40. Sacred Heart School: 2212 Queen Street 41. St. Anthony School: 2175 Rosedale Street 42. St. Columbkille School: 1198 Rush Street 43. St. Joseph School: 2105 St. Joseph Street 44. St. Mary's School: 1600 White Street 45. St. Patrick School: 180 West 15th Street 46. Resurrection School: 4300 Asbury Road 47. Immaculate Conception School: 1001 Davis Street Neighborhood Facilities - Miscellaneous 48. St. Elias Church Playground: 1075 Rockdale Road 49. St. Peter's Lutheran Church Playground: 3200 Asbury Road Community Wide Facilities - Dubuque Park Board 1. Allison -Henderson Park: Loras and Grandview 10! 111111 - 25 Community -Wide Facilities - Playground and Recreation Commission 2. Bunker Hill Golf Course: Bunker Hill and Fairway Drive 3. Municipal Swimming Pool: 1800 Hawthorne 4. Petrakis Stadium: East Fourth Street 5. Comiskey Field: 2400 Jackson Street 6. McAleece Recreation Area: Kerper Boulevard and Hawthorne Street Community -Wide Facilities - Dubuque Community School District 7. Dubuque Senior High School: 800 Clarke Drive 8. Stephen Hempstead High School: 3715 Pennsylvania Community -Wide Facilities - Archdiocese of Dubuque 9. Wahlert High School: 2005 Kane Street Community -Wide Facilities - Miscellaneous Private and Other 10. Dubuque Country Club: Randall Place 11. Dubuque Marina: Hawthorne and Waterfront 12. Dubuque Yacht Basin: City Island 13. Schmidt Harbor: City Island 14. Senior Citizens Centre: 1099 Iowa Street 15. Creslanes Bowl: 255 South Main Street 16. Dubuque Bowling Lanes: 10291 Main Street 17. Fischer Bowling Lanes: 880 Locust Street 18. Holy Trinity Bowling Lanes: 1703 Rhomberg 19. Riverside Bowl: 1860 Hawthorne Street 20. Imperial Lanes: Stoneman Road 21. Eagle Point Funland:. 2705 Rhomberg Avenue 22. Skate Country: Highway 20 West 23. Dubuque Shooting Society: Highway 52 North 24. Dubuque Water Ski Club: City Island 25. Dubuque Flatboat Club: City Island 26. Dubuque Conservation Society Park: City Island 27. Dubuque Boys Club: 1299 Locust Street 28. YMCA -YWCA: Dodge and Booth 29. Roberts River Rides: Hawthorne at River 30. Clarke College: Clarke Drive 31. Loras College: Loras and Alta Vista 32. University of Dubuque: University Avenue COMMUNITY WIDE FACILITIES r/ 1. Allison -Henderson Park 2. Bunker Hill Golf Course 3. Municipal Pool 4. Petrakis Stadium 5. Comiskey Field 6. McAleece Recreation Area 7. Senior High School 8. Hempstead High School 9. Wahlert High School 10. Dubuque Country Club 11. Dubuque Marina 12. Dubuque Yacht Basin 13. Schmidt Harbor 14. Senior Citizen's Center 15. Creslanes Bowl wn�ERT 41(jN HOOL �„ n9 16. Dubuque Bowling Lanes . 17. Fischer Bowling Lanes .... i 18. Holy Trinity Bowling Lanes BUNKER ,'r` H 1LL is 19. Riverside Bowl 60LF COURSE 20. Imperial Lanes ,2 21. Eagle Point Funland 22. Skate Country 23. Dubuque Shooting Society 24. Dubuque Water Ski Club • - t9i.-...� 22 25. Dubuque Flatboat Club 26. Conservation Society Park 27. Dubuque Boy's Club 28. YMCA -YWCA 29. Robert's River 30. Clarke College 31. Loras College 32. University of Dubuque Rides e? U / 51 tr.ve Ps, • ) r M: CAR MEL \-. t• L_ - 27 General Outdoor Recreation Areas - Dubuque Park Board 1. Eagle Point Park: Shiras Avenue 2. Louis Murphy Park: Grandview Avenue 3. Flora Park: Pennsylvania and Green 4. Maus Conservation Park: Huff Street 5. Franklin D. Roosevelt Park: North Cascade Road General Outdoor Recreation Areas - Playg.round and Recreation Commission 6. Veteran's Memorial Park: Carter and West 32nd St. Natural Environment Areas - U.S. Government Upper Mississippi River National Wildlife Refuge (1,290 acres bordering Dubuque County). Unique Natural Areas (None in Dubuque or nearby vicinity). Primitive Areas (None in Iowa). Historic and Cultural Sites Present day Dubuque probably has more historical and architecturally sig- nificant structures than any other community in Iowa. The educational, cultural, aesthetic, environmental as well as the simple historic value of these structures should not be overlooked by any recreational or other planning program for the City. During the spring of 1973 a street by street survey of Dubuque was made in an attempt to inventory the City's historical and architecturally sig- nificant structures. Over 600 separate structures were inventoried, map- ped and photographed by City Planning and Zoning Commission staff in co- operation with the Dubuque County Historical Society and the State of Iowa. On the basis of information supplied by the field survey it was possible to numerically grade and rank each structure relative to every other one and to its impact on the Dubuque scene. Using nationally accepted cri- teria, four categories were defined for grouping the structures surveyed on the basis of their individual scores. For the purposes of the present study the categories used may be defined as follows. Group I (60 or more points): The landmark structures of Dubuque. These exceptional structures of major significance are worthy of maximum protection and continued preservation. The 24 structures that scored 60 or more are listed on the following page. Franklin D. p ( Cam"+ ' .Li ' ,! u r Roosevelt Park - 28 101 PM - 29 Group II (41-59 points): These outstanding buildings of much sig- nificance are worthy of protection and should be preserved. Group III (26-40 points): This group includes structures of signi- ficance that contribute to the overall character of Dubuque. They are worthy of protection and preservation if possible and particu- larly in groups. Group IV (0-25 points): These minor structures and background build- ings are generally of little significance but often have details wor- thy of note. In groups they may be of some special interest or sig- nificance that would warrant protection. Dubuque Structures Scoring 60 or More Points on Basis of 1973 Field Survey (not listed in order of significance) Shot Tower, East 4th Street Star Brewery, East 4th Street Rhomberg House, 508 W. 7th Street Cooper House, 504 Bluff Street Dubuque City Hall, 13th & Central F. Stout summer house, 2790 Asbury' St. Mary's Church, 15th and White Lacey House, 1640 Main Ryan House,1375 West Locust F. Stout House, 1145 West Locust Dubuque County Jail, 7th & Central Ham House, 2241 Lincoln Langworthy House, 1095 West 3rd Street Bissell House, 325 Alpine Orpheum Theater, 4th and Main Streets Fenelon Place Elevator, West 4th St. Eagle Point Park Pavilion Seminary Hill steps, 17th & Madison Loras Academy Buildings, Loras Blvd. Fischer House, 1389 West Locust H. Stout House, 1105 West Locust Dubuque County Courthouse, 7th & Central Dubuque Brewing & Malting Co., 3000 Jackson Julien Dubuque Grave and Mines of Spain Reserved Open -Space and Undeveloped Lands - Dubuque Park Board 1. Twelfth Street Hillside: along 12 Street 2. Montrose Terrace Hillside: adjacent to Montrose Ter. 3. Eighth Street Hillside: Along 8th Street 4. Grandview Avenue Blvd: South Grandview Avenue Private and Other Facilities - U.S. Government 1. Lock and Dam #11: Mississippi River at Eagle Point General Outdoor Recreation Facilities Located Within Dubuque's Zone of Influence A separate appendix lists seventy regional outdoor recreation facilities located in the counties surrounding Dubuque. Nearly all of these facili- ties are federal, state or county controlled. While local recreation planning work would probably not recommend construc- tion of facilities that would duplicate those listed in this regional in- ventory, it is important to be aware of potential opportunities for joint development of multi -purpose trails, open space reservations, scenic roads, parkways or campground facilities where more than purely local interest in involved. - 30 ADEQUACY OF EXISTING FACILITIES National Standards It is customary to appraise the adequacy of existing park and recreation facilities according to a number of standards including site size, num- ber, location relative to population served, facilities and the like. The table below summarizes select standards as recommended by the National Park and Recreation Association and the Athletic Insitute. These stand- ards should be utilized simply as a test of adequacy of Dubuque's park and recreation facilities in relation to nationally desirable guidelines. While such standards may be regarded as desirable, it should be remember- ed that local variations in topography, population density and patterns of community development affect the applicability of these standards. Desirable Park and Recreation Standards Location (area served) Ages Served: Site Sizes: desirable: minimum: Acres per 1000 persons Class Ia Facilities 1/8 - 3/4 mi.max. varies with facility 3 - 6 acres 2500 sf 1/4 - 1.25 Class Ib Class II Facilities Facilities 3/4-14 mile all 30-80 acres 15-30 acres 2.00 30 min.travel time all 80 acres & up 30 acres & up 4.50 - 12.00 Note: Figures given are for selected categories. Source: National Park and Recreation Association and the AthJetic.Institute. There are two other general "rule of thumb" standards that are widely recognized for measuring the overall adequacy of an entire community's park and recreation facilities. 1. Ten percent of the land in a community should be used for recreational and open space purposes. 2. There should be ten acres of easily -accessible develop- ed recreation space and one acre of additional park re- serve available for every 1,000 persons. - 31 The following tables summarize Dubuque's park and recreation facilities in terms of these nationally used size standards. Class I - High Density Recreation Areas Ia - Neighborhood Facilities Total Maximum Minimum Average Acres per Acreage Size Size Size 1000 persons City Parks 26.26 City Playgrounds 33.71 Public School Grounds 44.97 Parochial School Grounds 20.58 20.00 8.50 15.00 0.14 0.30 0.50 5.25 0.30 2.25 0.50 3.21 0.60 4.80 1.71 0.30 Totals: 125.52 20.00 0.14 2.72 1.80 Notes: Figures given are from inventory of facilities. "City" categories include both Park Board and Recreation Commission facilities broken down by type. Ib - Community -Wide Facilities Total Acreage City Facilities 127.35 Public School Facilities 39.90 Parochial School Facil. 12.80 Misc. Private Facilities 224.00 Maximum Minimum Average Acres Per Size Size Size 1000 persons 105.00 1.35 21.22 1.80 20.00 19.90 19.95 0.50 12.80 12.80 12.80 - 150.00 - 3.30 Totals: 404.05 150.00 1.35 - 6.00 Note: Figures given are from inventory of facilities. Average figure for "misc. private facilities" category includes only the 9 uses listed for which acreages were provided. The Dubuque Golf and Country Club accounts for 150.0 acres of that total. - 32 - 33 City Parks W/O FDR Park Class II - General Outdoor Recreation Areas Total Maximum Minimum Average Acres Per Acreage Size Size Size 1000 persons 570.90 210.00 8.90 95.15 360.90 164.00 8.90 72.18 8.50 5.30 Note: Franklin D. Roosevelt park is presently undeveloped so the smaller figures more accurately reflect the current situation. Summary Total Maximum Minimum Average Acres Per Acreage Size Size Size 1000 persons Class Ia-Neighborhood Fac. 125.52 20.00 0.14 Class Ib-Community-Wide Fac. 404.05 150.00 1.35 Class II-Gen.Outdoor Recrea- tion Areas 570.90 210.00 8.90 Totals 1100.47 210.00 0.14 2.72 95.15 1.80 6.00 8.50 15.95 16.30 If we examine merely these acreage figures and compare Dubuque to the desirable national park and recreation standards, the following situ- ation is noticeable: Class Ia Neighborhood Facilities Class Ib - Community -Wide Facilities Class II - General Outdoor Recreation Areas Desirable Acreage Desirable Acres/1000 3 - 6 acres 0.25-1.25 30-80 80 + 2.00 Dubuque Average Dubuque Acreage Acres/1000 2.72 4.50-12.00 95.15 1.80 6.00 8.50 Source: National Park and Recreation Association and Dubuque Planning and Zoning Commission staff 01- By using acreage analysis alone as a means of evaluating the adequacy of Dubuque's park and other recreation facilities, it is apparent that the City fully meets generally acceptable standards. In fact the total Du- buque figure of 16.30 acres park and recreation space per 1,000 persons exceeds by 6 acres per 1,000 persons the national standard of 10 acres per 1,000 persons. Even this figure may be misleading because none of the Dubuque figures include the substantial amounts of college campus, institutional grounds and bluff areas within the City. Adding these acreages to the total would more than double the amount of open space per 1000 persons population. Local Area Analysis While acreage analyses provide an overall picture of park and recrea- tion facility adequacy, such analyses fail to directly address the crucial question of how well existing facilities actually serve the community. As already mentioned such diverse things as topography, population density, community development patterns, neighborhood socio- economic characteristics and even street patterns all affect utilization of existing facilities and demand for additional ones. In the case of Dubuque these are of major importance. The table below summarizes select socio-economic data for eleven sub- areas within the City. The sub -areas used are based on census tracts and are outlined on the accompanying map. 1. The sub -areas with the highest population density (Areas IV, VI) generally rank low in terms of re- creation space per 1,000 persons and as a percen- tage of total area. 2. The sub -areas with more than 3.0 percent of the total population under age 14 (Areas II, IV, V, VII, X, XI) generally have moderate to serve deficiencies in terms of adequate neighborhood recreation facilities. 3. If only City of Dubuque facilities were included, the total acreage of neighborhood recreation facilities per 1,000 persons would be as follows. Area I Area II Area III Area IV Area V Total 1.7 1.0 1.0 1.0 2.7 City Only. 1.1 .0 0.5 0.1 2.5 13 Recreation and Open Space Plan Recreation Planning Subarea AREA I. AREA II AREA III AREA IV AREA V AREA VI AREA VII AREA VIII AREA IX AREA X AREA XI Census Tract Census Tract Census Tract Census Tract Census Tract Census Tract Census Tract Census Tract Census Tract Census Tract Census Tract 1, 2, 2.99 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Total Population 3,724 4,031 3,586 7,066 4,856 10,485 7,592 5,540 849 5,369 9,201 Persons under age 14 730 1,239 1,048 2,272 1,477 2,887 2,477 1,455 34 2,190 3,757 Median years of school completed 9.6 11.5 12.1 10.6 12.0 12.3 12.7 12.4 17.1 12.4 12.5 Median income $ 3,563 $ 8,759 $ 7,934 $ 7,204 •$ 9,145 $ 4,348 $ 10,320 $ 7,050 $ 909 $ 11,503 $ 7,711 Mean income $ 4,212 $ 9,606 $ 7,640 $ 7,406 $ 9,033 $ 5,795 $ 12,892 $ 7,779 $ 1,662 $ 11,799 $ 8,486 Total size of area (acres) 476.8 565.0 457.2 379.5 505.4 654.7 2126.7 500.0 379.2 1805.4 1630.0 Population density (persons per acre) 7.81 7.13 7.84 18.61 9.60 16.01 3.57 11.08 2.23 2.97 5.64 Class Ia - Nbad Recreation Facilities City (total acres) 4.33 2.00 0.75 12.25 3.38 4.07 6.00 20.00 10.69 2.50 School District (total acres) 0.50 3.80 )1.83 2.78 1.20 1.40 0.86 3.60 15.00 14.00 Archdiocese (total acres) 1.80 0.50 3.99 1.38 5.65 2.46 4.80 6.63 4.30 3.83 7.52 13.45 6.16 10.58 12.06 20.00 30.49 16.50 Total acres per 1,000 persons 1.7 1.0 1.0 1.0 2.7 0.5 1.3 2.1 2.4 5.6 1.7 Percent of area 1,3 % 0.7 % 0.8 % 1.9 % 2.6 % 0.9 • 0.4 % 2.4 % 5.2 % 1.6 % 1.0 • Area VI Area VII Area VIII Area IX Area X Area XI Total 0.5 1.3 2.1 2.4 5.6 1.7 City Only 0.3 0.5 1.0 2.4 1.9 0.2 -36 It is evident from these figures that Dubuque relies heavily on neigh- borhood recreation facilities that are supplied by the Dubuque Commun- ity School District and the Archdiocese of Dubuque Schools. A comment should be made about Area IX. This area includes primarily the Bunker Hill Golf Course and a number of institutional land uses. The twenty -acre figure includes only University Park which is not ade- quately equipped for neighborhood play purposes. The following three maps graphically illustrate what could be called the "service area" of each neighborhood -type recreationa facility. Only Class Ia, neighborhood recreation facilities (as listed in the inventory), are mapped. The maps separately show City of Dubuque fa- cilities, Dubuque Community School District facilities and Archdiocese of Dubuque facilities. Service area boundary lines were determined by the following parameters: 1. Topographical and other natural barriers 2. Heavily -traveled arterial streets that tend to act as barriers 3. Sub -area population 4. School enrollments and areas served 5. Size, condition and use of existing facilities In analyzing these maps it is important to note that other park and re- creation areas not inventoried as Class Ia facilities also serve local neighborhood park and recreation functions. Examples would be Flora Park, Allison -Henderson Park, Murphy Park, Veteran's Memorial Park and the Dubuque Senior High School. In addition the Bunker Hill Golf Course, Dubuque Golf and Country Club and the various institutional campuses and grounds provide neighborhood open space that may or may not be used ac- tively by local residents. The mere presence of a neighborhood park or school playground does not necessarily mean a particular neighborhood is adequately served by neigh- borhood park and recreation facilities. Some indication of the overall inadequacy of neighborhood recreation facilities in Dubuque is shown on the map that outlines area not served or inadequately served by these fa- cilities. One should note that if only City park and recreation facili- ties were included, the amounts of unserved area would be significantly large. The role played by the Dubuque Community School District and the Archdiocese of Dubuque Schools in providing neighborhood recreation fa- cilities cannot be regarded lightly, and continued cooperation by the City with these other agencies is necessary to provide a balanced base of park and recreation facilities. NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES Less Than 1% of Subarea Devoted to Neighborhood Recreation Facilities' -S J 117 r E)1i n p 471 ' •1 :tom ./ \ .'. El u i f r ti U ag at - 37 • .^e^s-a* -- - w .i Y•-s s mow. ;er; Zav L!. NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES — Less Than 2.0 Acres per 1,000 Persons / Devoted to Neighborhood Recreation r nri \...; • i j !It OFT30.00,4110116. ELI / A rn 3 FIR) Li r.'s,T‘ /7, 77N, % , rfit C) rri1 LI • L ( ,7ra..1 4 7..41 i ,•••••••,....... mow, •ostv.i-k4•74-4: •T CARMEL AGE STRUCTURE More Than 30% of Population ' , Under Age 14 I I II •••••••• 117.7.1-ri:777"""1"4 '• • ,t • ...• • • .n • • .• •-• - • • • • • XPSE • • • • ' '• • .. • • . . • • • • • • , • • • • • • •• ••••• t5m.) n C.1 L 1,, i( t( n 2 • • :•. : • .; • •. • • • • • ...A21•11011111.11111Kiyamterl-sa.-..i : "tr..1110:A..ast"?`.. \ 14-1 f I _ NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES CITY OF DUBUQUE , 1 . Cleveland Park 2. Waller -Cooper Totlot ) 3. Caledonia & Hilltop 4. Jefferson Park 5. Washington Park 6. Jackson & Grant Parks 7. Madison Park 8. Sycamore Playground 9. Frith Playground .1. 10. Burden Playground 11. Gay Playground 12. Valley High Playground e 13. Hillcrest Totlot 14. Falk Playground ,,'"•• • • ! ' - I:, I • • \.\ -kth • \ .1'21 :\ u — ‘• I \ Location: Service Area: _ / h Facilities NOT Providing Neighborhood Service I. Booth Tennis Court II. Flatiron Park III. Oakwood Park IV. University Park rn n (?71 • ..... 1/4 ....;=V1--;;4A. 7oue .•••• • • 1 "_,'_e,i‘vt•_"<i):.„"i,I,\ 2./•.„-.‘--..•,.'-o...i.c.c-'.,,,, ,,,,:..‘ `c.•,„-r..-,-.--.;Pq;-:-,•:,.,••:-•:•‘,,'--_;',,,-;.,,',•.'-'- ..- - — V " • woe, 1-1 \ .,0*(T•4 1%74 ,2 ..-- i 1 -41-r--.--....: ill (........:,,,,tv.:77;.7... ; "•,,, ,::: . ://;-•'; / 7)'-`, • i -__,,, \ ' ,), k• ......,-,,, \ s.:. \ ' • ./ ..ts.,i •,.•....„ •'''' -1 \ ''`.f• ';'`'', 1..\.,.,.1 ....'" /..,.! ....-- t '.. -- -,......, \ ‘'.,.).-----,\ : '•;'-2._...;_..- ' '`'.../' •''',. ''''' t , „' "..... - 41 •'f .0* • ' DUE1JUE OuN•ry • I • CLUB \ ) it r " — 1 M: CARMEL • r i J W,=*:4.:"a``-wi.'"".t.• a..-raa''...r "+ti7 • NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES SCHOOL DISTRICT I f 1. Bryant, 2. Lincoln 3. Washington J.H. 7 4. Irving 5. Hoover 6. Kennedy 7. Eisenhower 8. Jackson 9. Prescott 10. Fulton 11. Audubon 12. Jefferson J.H. 13. Marshall 14. Marshall Playground Location: ■ Service Area: 1 lam) r- 4' • L21 Cp.)) C:d Tic-) ni I f1 1 1 E7E 1 - 42 MT CARMEL r viLawialwata NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES ARCHDIOCESE OF DUBUQUE Iy 1. St. Columbkille's y 2. St. Raphael's 3. Holy Trinity 4. St. Mary's 5. St. Patrick's 6. Sacred Heart 7. Holy Ghost 8. Nativity 9. St. Anthony's 10. St. Joseph's 11. Resurrection • : . _4 ,7 dI l 1 F:t: 1111 ` 1. •. 1 ._. , _ Location: • m "--,y,.•r- *-.+^, ... cr .. , •W. n{ .tf' .,;ve-err ..T.'°Se`^^:-+za..*.c r- r,.h^*j'e."yR ✓ -•'. s, ,$gswr.- . •ve...,•. -r e-.+.ar, .;ytit n+. -ai — - " -•—^• ,:. :.v:2scS.wt.:,i: k `vs ,:: a<: ..saaSi• . sx.-Y:.:..-x.a.:+.a:s +«td• ",`s ,r3nr.,h;:'<::era•.:d.sn£';i.' .:r •kr 3e_=w:r - am .b«r,: Service Area: C [re E 103— rtrl %.? • - 43 t+T CARMEE / AREAS NOT SERVED OR INADEQUATELY SERVED BY NEIGHBORHOOD RECREATION FACILITIES • v ' \; - L 11 ri ^'{ rr, f{-7,j i1 ' - 44 I'T CARMEL 10111 i - 45 Besides a total lack of local neighborhood facilities in several parts of the City, many other existing facilities are inadequate in terms of size, facilities or condition. This is true of both City and school facilities. In another section of this report proposals for correct- ing deficiencies at the neighborhood level will be outlined. Community -Wide Facilities The strong points in Dubuque's overall park and recreation system are the large, well-equipped and expertly maintained community -wide parks. Eagle Point Park ranks among the finest in Iowa and is generally re- garded as the cornerstone of the City's park system. Murphy Park, Flora Park and Veteran's Memorial Park are the other major parks that enjoy widespread useage. When fully developed, Franklin D. Roosevelt Park has the potential for being another one of the state's finest City parks. Perhaps the major problem being faced with regard to these park facili- ties is intensive use, particularly at Eagle Po-int where in excess of 450,000 persons annually use the facility. With the exception of Flora Park which is used by over 230,000 persons annually, more people use Eagle Point Park than all of the other City park and recreation facili- ties combined. Total attendance at Dubuque's parks was 1,221,483 in 1972. This figure included 96,483 reservations of shelter buildings at Eagle Point and Murphy Parks, up nearly 10,000 persons from 1971. In addition to developing Roosevelt Park during the next several years, it will be necessary to expand and provide additional facilities at Eagle Point Park or else limit use. Additional facilities will also be need- ed at the other large parks as well as at Bunker Hill Golf Course, the swimming pools and other community -wide recreational facilities. Other Facilities and Needs Other open space and recreation -related needs of Dubuque include such things as: 1. Development of ways and means to protect and preserve vital open space including bluffs, creek valleys, ra- vines and flood plains. . 2. Development or promotion of a transient -type campground facilities in or near Dubuque. 3. Implementation of a local bikeway system and cooperation with other governmental units in developing a regional multi -purpose trail system. 4. Cooperate in preparing and implementing plans for the use and redevelopment of City Island and other remaining water- front areas of the City. . ee^r•^.-•. .e[zs-- a .' z--v.R'3' i"`,`. e'.`"S:>"a' Fx<*ir vt,,.n,.......,.,..r..;+s........ .,c.-.k. ^a .,?*'::^°;..m'a? - 46 - 47 5. Assist however possible in the preservation and use of Dubuque's significant buildings and through pro- grams of tree planting and other landscape design improvements. 6. Cooperate with county, regional, state and federal agencies in providing a balanced system of park and recreational facilities for serving both the citi- zens and the increasing number of tourists and other visitors coming to northeast Iowa. FIVE YEAR OUTDOOR RECREATION PLAN Goals "Recreation is an emotional condition within an individual that flows from a feeling of well-being and self satisfaction. It is character- ised by feelings of mastery, achievement, exhileration,acceptance, success, personal worth and pleasure. It reinforces a positive self- image. Recreation is a response to aesthetic experience, achievement of personal goals or positive feedback from others. It is independent of activity, leisure or social acceptance. Recreation improves awareness, deepens understanding, stimulates appre- ciation, develops one's powers and enlarges the sources of enjoyment. It promotes individual fulfillment. It encourages self-discovery. It helps give meaning to life." David E. Gray, "Exploring Inner Space", Parks and Recreation Mag- azine, December 1972, The values and importance of all types of recreation programs cannot be underestimated. Major responsibility for the direction and implementa- tion of the public aspects of recreation in Dubuque is given to the Du- buque Park Board and Recreation Commission. The program goals of these agencies may be stated in three parts as follows: I. Leisure Time Opportunities Program A. To provide for all citizens, to the extent that is practical, a variety of year-round leisure oppor- tunities that are accessible, safe, physically at- tractive, and provide enjoyable experiences. These opportunities should contribute to the mental and physical health of the community as well as to its economic and social well-being. In addition they should permit outlets that might help decrease in- cidents of anti -social behavior such as crime and delinquency. B. The leisure time opportunities program includes: 1. Unsupervised outdoor recreation 2. Supervised recreation and physical activity 3. Cultural programs 4. Special events 5. Administrative support 48 - 49 II. Recreation Department A. To serve people of all ages throughout the year with a variety of recreational opportunities for enriching their lives through the use of areas and facilities, leadership resources and special guidance in assistance services for individuals and groups. B. The range of programs is almost unlimited and in- cludes all of the means by which a recreation de- partment normally works. These programs reflect the leisure -time needs of the citizens, community resources and the growth of persons as individuals and members of groups. C. Programs and activities can be classified into three categories and include: 1. Provision of recreation area, buildings and facilities. 2. Furnishing of professional leadership or or- ganized individual or group activity. 3. Provision of assistance to individuals in self - determining groups who wish to enjoy recreation- al pursuits through their own continuing member- ship. Park Department A. Under the direction of a three -member elected Park Board, the Dubuque Park Department is responsible for the development and maintenance of the City park system, the direction of the tree trimming program, and removal of snow from the downtown Plaza and parking ramps. Proposed Projects The projects described below can be grouped into three catgories: 1. Regular maintenance and replacement projects 2. Additions or improvements to existing facilities 3. New development projects Many of the proposed projects are of a routine nature to be accomplished in the normal year to year operations of the park, recreation and other agencies involved. Others such as swimming pool or ice rink construction and neighborhood park development will require expensive land acquisi- tion and substantial capital expenditures that must be planned several years in advance. An attempt has been made to outline project develop- ment and funding priorities in the five-year capital expenditure tables that follow the proposed project descriptions. Regular Maintenance and Replacement Projects Eagle Point Park Improvements: Programmed improvements to Eagle Point Park include: 1. Tennis court resurfacing 2. Park road blacktopping & 3. Outdoor lighting 4. Repair Riverfront Pavilion 5. Toilet facilities 6. Play area improvement 7. Bandshell improvement sealcoating 8. Bleachers 9. .Re -roof Indian Room 10. Wading pool 11. Miscellaneious painting Flora Park Improvements: The following improvements should be made at Flora Park during the next five years: 1. Construct new tennis courts 6. 2. Bleachers 3. Park road blacktopping & sealcoating 7. 4. Air condition the Barn 5. Recreation building and warming house improvements Repair and paint swimming pool Remodel entrance and dress- ing areas at change -house for swimming pool Louis Murphy Park Improvements: Programmed improvements to Louis Murphy Park include additional light- ing and tennis court improvement. Municipal Swimming Pool Improvements: Planned improvements include installation of new filters, repair and painting of the pool tank. Allison -Henderson Park Improvements: In addition to painting the park building at Allison -Henderson Park other planned work includes re -surfacing the interior floors. Comiskey Park Improvements: Planned work for Comiskey Park at this time includes remodeling and repair of both the exterior and interior of the park building as well as relocation of the recreation workshop to Bunker Hill. - 50 Veteran's Memorial Park Improvements: Improvements planned for Veter- an's Memorial Park include: 1. Construct bridge, pave road and parking lot. 2. Install lighting at softball fields, baseball diamond and tennis courts. 3. Move bleachers. Bunker Hill Golf Course Improvements: Planned improvements for Bunker Hill Golf Course include: 1. Painting exterior of building 2. Replace furnace 3. Re -roof portion of building 4. Blacktop parking lot and path areas 5. Storm drainage system improvement 6. Re -build trees and greens 7. Fairway improvement Park Greenhouse Operations Necessary improvements to the Park Board's greenhouse operation includes replacement of the present inadequate heating system, expansion of the present greenhouse and construction of a new potting shed. Equipment Acquisition The following pieces of equipment are needed by the Park Board and Recreation Commission and should be programmed for purchase during the five-year planning period: 1 heavy duty truck 2 automobiles 1 bus greens mower pressure spray system sound system for Barn misc. program equipment 2 jeep vehicles 1 end loader 1 program van mowers - leaf blower chairs 3 pick-up trucks 1 tractor/loader 1 piano fairway mower soil shredder portable toilet facility Tree Trimming Operations During the next five years Dubuque's continuing tree trimming and dis- ease control program will require a new truck, a truck loader, new saws and other trimming equipment. General Urban Beautification The importance of continued tree and flower planting and general land- scape improvement to the streets, parks and other spaces throughout the City cannot be underestimated as a positive contribution to Dubuque's well-being. The Park Board's urban beautification is among its most significant work and deserves strong annual support. - 51 Additions or Improvements to Existing Facilities Maus Park Development: Continued improvement and development of the Maus Park area over the next several years will include: 1. Construction of toilet facilities 2. Additional tree planting and landscape design work 3. Continued improvement of Maus Lake shoreline 4. Access road and parking area surfacing Franklin D. Roosevelt Park Development: Development of F.D.R. Park to its full potential could cost several hundred thousand dollars. While planning the different stages of development for this 210 acre tract special consideration should be given to some of the unique opportunities that exist. In addition to the usual types of park development and activities, the much discussed children's zoo will provide a totally new recreational experience for Dubuque area residents. Perhaps even more important, a portion of the proposed park offers an exceptional opportunity for cre- ating interpretative exhibits and possible reconstructions related to the lead mining history of Dubuque. These opportunities should be stud- ied in planning for the development of this park. Washington Para Improvement: Major redevelopment and landscaping of this important downtown open space is proposed following the loss of nearly all of the elm trees in the park. Completion of this redevelopment work would greatly enhance the popularity of Washington Park as a major downtown focal point. McAleece Recreation Area: Programmed improvements tion area include: 1. Installation of bleachers 2. Lighting system improvement 3. Construction of ice rink and warming house 4. Sealcoating of play areas 5. Parking lot improvement for McAleece Recrea- University Park Development: Minimal development and improvement for day use activities is planned at this time. r i L - 52 Grant Park Development: Work on this small downtown open space is to include general land- scape design improvements, tree planting and placement of benches. Gay Playground Improvement: Planned work at Gay Playground includes moving the skating rink and construction of a warming house/playground building. Petrakis Park: If Dubuque is going to continue maintenance of a baseball stadium, consideration must be given in the near future to either relocat- ing Petrakis Park to a new site or undertaking extensive improve- ments at the present East Fourth Street location. A detailed study of the alternate possibilities and a final decision on what to do should be made before 1975. Floodwall Development and Maintenance: Completion of Dubuque's new floodwall assures reasonable flood pro- tection, but many opportunities exist for floodwall beautification, fishing and general public access to the river, hiking and bicycle trails. The Dubuque Dock Commission will have primary responsibil- ity for floodwall maintenance and should actively seek support from the Park Board and other agencies in implementing the full range of possibilities for ultimate floodwall development. New Development Projects Neighborhood Park and Playground Development: Dubuque's most pressing park and recreational need is to provide ad- ditional neighborhood park and playground facilities in many parts of the City. Several existing neighborhood parks should also be sub- stantially upgraded or redeveloped to better serve their intended function. Areas of deficiency throughout the City have already been generally identified. Possible target areas for first and second priority neighborhood parkland acquisition and development are shown on the accompanying map. In the immediate future actual sites for new neighborhood parks within the first priority target areas should be located and detailed design work undertaken so that land could be purchased and two or three new facilities could be completed within a five year planning period. • NEIGHBORHOOD PARK & PLAYGROUND DEVELOPMENT First Priority Target Areas Second Priority Target Areas i `At rr Li L 7177 n Ed Li a Li n ,� .1'`� �,rJ \Jn `: `.r ``motes i » c_ h I_t a.'' - 53 MT CARMEL ' - 54 •//,/, •////, '////' //// //// /,,,,,7�,,, •/,,,/,/////,// ////////// „p //,//////////////////,////1 •,/////////////////////////� •//,////,////////,///,///// /////////////,/////1 ///,///////////,// , ////, •/,//////////////,• ,//////„/////,//- //// • d.////u/////////i„ ///////// Wading Pool / /1,L0)///////// ///,///////,/ ////////,//// //////,/ / /,/,////,/'x(16f.✓////,// i// ,,,, ,,,,/,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, , • ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, Apparatus Area Soccer Touch Football! Softball Low Organized Games Multiple -Use Surfaced Area Jolleyball Basketball Typical Neighborhood Playground - 55 The basic purpose of neighborhood park and recreation facilities are twofold. First of all, neighborhood parks provide an attrac- tive setting for passive recreation use by people of all ages. Secondly, neighborhood playgrounds provide primary recreation op- portunities for five to fifteen year old children. While local conditions will influence the actual size, layout and equipment required for a neighborhood park or playground, a typical facility may be two to six acres in size and include space for softball, touch football or other field games, play apparatus and perhaps tennis court and separate tot's play area. Depending on the neigh- borhood conditions and available space it might also be feasible to incorporate passive recreational uses into the same developement. In such cases plenty of shade trees, landscape plant materials, tables, benches, pools and fountains would be desirable features. Lyon's Trust Parkland Acquisition: Using local matching funds from the E. B. Lyon's Trust, acquisition of the thirty-four acre Marjorie D. Reed property just south of Du- buque should occur before the end of 1973. It is the stated intent of the Lyon's trustees to either purchase or obtain options on ad- ditional land surrounding the Reed property. Because the purchase of this property has occurred as a "bonus" for the City, develop- ment of any recreation facilities in this area has not been consid- ered in any planning work for Dubuque. The future potential of the property as a natural area or open space preserve, however, is great. Planning for the potential use of this property should be closely co- ordinated with the Dubuque County Conservation Board and the state to avoid duplication of similar facilities in the same general area. If at all possible, the Park Board should work closely with the Lyon's Fund trustees 'in an attempt to direct use of a least a por- tion of the trust money for acquisition of high priority open space and recreation lands within the developed portions of Dubuque. Some of the potential project areas have already been listed above. Indoor Multi -Purpose Facility: Consideration is currently being given to the feasibility of con- structing a multi -purpose facility that would provide year-round indoor ice skating and swimming. An indoor year-round swimming pool would dramatically increase the opportunities for recreation- al swimming as well as for expanded programs of swimming instruc- tion, life saving courses and competitive swimming activity. Con- struction of an indoor ice skating facility with an artificial ice surface would offer far reaching possibilities for year-round recreational skating, ice hockey, skating classes, curling and ice show activities. Skating opportunities in Dubuque are currently quite limited and wholly at the mercy of the weather. - 56 Swimming Pool Development: In addition to an indoor swimming facility consideration should also be given to the construction of two small (25 meter) out- door pools, one in the older residential areas and the other in the western portion of Dubuque. These facilities might best be located near schools. Making them heated would expand by one month the useable swimming season. Dubuque Waterfront Improvement: Completion of Dubuque's new flood protection system has dramatically increased the value and developmental potential for the Mississippi River waterfront in general and the East Fourth Street area in par- ticular. Preliminary studies for the possible redevelopment of this area have already been completed, but further planning and implemen- tation of a number of specific projects would serve as the catalyst for major public and private redevelopment efforts. Again the Park Board and Recreation Commission should participate jointly with other local agencies to accomplish such things as: 1. Floodwall landscape work and maintenance 2. Creation of an access and viewing point near the Dock Commission office and Pillsbury terminal utilizing the old stone levee and overlook already in place. 3. Landscape design improvements in the vicinity of the Shot Tower, one of Dubuque's most important and popu- lar historic landmarks. The Pillsbury Company should also be encouraged to improve the exterior appearance of their terminal facility. 4. Start re -developing the north shore of the Ice Harbor for a variety ofpublic access and commercial uses. 5. Preparation of an overall redevelopment plan for the entire East Fourth Street area. City Island Development Plan: Pending closure of the present Dubuque landfill site on City Island in 1975, a final plan for the use of the property should be prepared for implementation after that time. Among the developmental possibil- ities might be a tourist campground near the Dubuque Yacht Basin. Such a facility could be leased to a private operator. Other develop- mental possibilities include multi -purpose trails and picnic areas in addition to adoption of necessary flood plain control regulations. Bikeway Development: In cooperation with other City departments and local agencies a final plan for City-wide bikeway development should be prepared and imple- mented during the next five years. Dubuque already has half as many • BIKEWAY DEVELOPMENT .:_.:�:ss:av2r.:.r.�*.+':;�_."..A�•�"�.'SA"..'1"xffr2•.�'.^.'Y'L'".•.'Y7:YS:`A'C�'i�lVffi!S�"n�k`�_n4:fYdY'. • • .� • ( N/-' wAHLERT HIGH SCHOOL ------ Major Routes: 1973-1975 W---- Long Range Considerations J 2 V'7 , r �,. sr k i L71- > Lza tf' r t, L a itr``Fl�;'�f> f{ 1 w 1 r.�-1 • t I Li L It V ea J. 1 I 1. - 57 M' CGRMEL f , bicycles as automobiles and the importance of this transportation mode for both recreational and commuter use will continue to in- crease. The accompanying map is based on the 1972 Bikecology re- port prepared by the Dubuque Playground and Recreation Commission and outlines a basic system that would serve all of Dubuque. Five Flags Center: Support and encourage early completion of the Five Flags ter project. The importance and potential impact of thi multiple use cultural facility is too great to postpone than absolutely necessary. Concerts, theater, art displ tions, banquets and multi -media presentations represent of the possible uses this facility could be put to. -58 Civic Cen- s community any longer ays, conven- only a few Bluff Conservation, Maintenance and Protection: Along with the Mississippi River, Dubuque's greatest natural assets are the rugged and scenic limestone bluffs that have shaped the City's development since its beginning over a century and a half ago. In or- der to assure the continued preservation of Dubuque's bluffs in their present natural state a joint effort by all City departments and other local interest groups should be made to implement a program for estab- lishing legal protection, scenic enhancement and regular maintenance of these areas. At present there are no legal tools to control bluff development. In many parts of the City the bluffs are being destroyed by gravel pits, quarrys and various developments along the bases. Large numbers of dead and dying trees, thick brush and other dense foliage pose serious fire hazards at certain times of the year. All of these conditions need attention. Metropolitan Open Space System: The reservation of park and recreation lands during various phases of Dubuque's development has provided the City with natural landscape areas of great value. The availability of local recreation and open space has a direct bearing on the character and liveability of the City's residential neighborhoods. The Victor Gruen Plan of 1964 pro- posed a comprehensive open space program for the preservation of the Dubuque area's dominant natural features. This plan encompassed the following elements both within the City as well as in the surrounding metropolitan area. 1. Public acquisition and preservation of the river bluffs from Julien Dubuque Park on the south to Eagle Point on the north, encompassing the present municipally -owned spaces of Louis Murphy Park, Cleveland Park, the Eighth Street hillside, the Eleventh Street stairs, the Mont - BLUFF CONSERVATION AREAS S ki *%', 17 7=.-_ ,, --L \� 7 u<C''* a -0. . \ ,,i J �47 r Ors11 11 ? �r r� d L 1 ,_,,,, 1 r; 12:!::�i , (v-4, _._o;�e�"-•rr:t�'...t.tc�rcc.�:9rro�-ors.-�.-....-,........._ - 60 rose Terrace hillside, the North Main Street stairs and Madison Park. 2. Preservation of the bluffs, and ravines along Catfish Creek, Julien Dubuque Drive, Rockdale Road, Southern Avenue, Valley Street, Lower Dodge Street, West Third Street, West Fifth Street, Hill Street, University Avenue, Lower Loras Boulevard, West Locust Street, Kaufmann Avenue, Central Avenue, Pinard Street and Thomas Place. 3. Preservation of the following topographical, natural or geographical areas: a. Nine Mile Island in the Mississippi River b. Granger Creek from Catfish Creek to Key West c. Swiss Valley from New Melleray Abbey to Rockdale d. Furnace Hollow from Asbury to the Little Maquoketa River e. Union Park Hollow from Couler Valley to Kennedy Road f. Sageville Road Ravine from Couler Valley to Kennedy Road g. Yellow Hill Road ravine from Sageville Road to the Little Maquoketa River h. Little Maquoketa River valley from Durango to Peru Flats i. Couler Valley bluffs from 32nd Street to the Little Ma- quoketa River Mississippi River bluffs from the Menominee River to Sinnipee Creek in Grant and Jo Daviess Counties. k. Plum Hollow and Boatyard Hollow to the Mississippi River in Grant County 1. Menominee River Valley in Grant and Jo Daviess Counties m. Permanent farm land open space around the runway approaches to the Dubuque Municipal Airport. 3. Since the Victor Gruen studies of 1964, some of the areas listed above have already been lost to development or misuse of one type or another. In order to reasonably assure preservation of the remaining portions consideration should be given to utilizing easements, conservation zon- ing, donations, tax encouragement and other.means besides direct public acquisition in order to minimize the total cost involved. Preservation of Dubuque's natural environment will be a principal deter- minant of the City's future character. Natural preserves can be used to define and border residential neighborhoods, to enhance their long-term value and stability and to provide the basis for a system of continuous open spaces. Besides preservation of the predominately natural areas outline above, additional open space land acquisition for both immediate and future use is necessary within the older residential areas as well as in the rapidly -developing fringe areas to the west, south and north. Coordin- ated acquisition and development of school, park and playground sites can go far toward minimizing the economic burden involved. Similarly, coordination with parochial school location and institutional land pur- chases can assist in extending the open space land network. w Scenic Drives, Parkways and Trails: Long-range efforts should be directed toward developing and desig- nating an expanded system of scenic drives, parkways and trails. This would have to be done in cooperation with the state and county. The key national link in this proposed system in the Great River Road, already a major tourist route. In Dubuque County a number of roads offer potential for designation as scenic drives. The Dubuque Tourist Trail and the Grandview Avenue parkway are popular local attractions. The development of bikeways and other multi -purpose trails should be given high priority both within the City as well as in the County. Historic Resources Development: Active participation of the Park Board, Planning and Zoning Commis- sion, Recreation Commission, Housing and Redevelopment Department, Dubuque County Historical Society and other local agencies is need- ed to jointly develop and implement a comprehensive plan for the continued preservation and use of Dubuque's historic resources. This plan should be realistic in assessing actual preservation needs and should relate to overall community needs in terms of older neigh- borhood renewal, adaptive use of old buildings, changing patterns of living, tourism development, and general maintenance and enhancement of the local urban environment. Historic preservation should be re- garded as much more than creating museums out of old buildings. Ra- ther, it is really a part of keeping Dubuque a pleasant place in which to live and work. Historical and architecturally interesting buildings are diverse elements in our rapidly moving and constantly changing modern world. They are educational, and they provide a sense of "place" and awareness of Dubuque's history. For these rea- sons alone they are worth preserving, and fortunately, with few ex- ceptions old buildings can adapt well_to performing modern functions. - 62 PROJECT FUNDING AND PRIORITIES Implementation of the many proposals outlined in this plan report will require the cooperation and combined efforts of several City of Dubuque department staffs, the Park Baord, the Recreation Com- mission, the Dock Commission, the Dubuque County Conservation Board, the Dubuque County Historical Society, local business and community organizations and many private individuals. Many of the specific projects listed above are within the scope of regular annual work by the Park Baord and Recreation Commission, Others, such as develop- ing a plan for City Island, bluff protection and development of a metropolitan open -space system will require a concerted multi -agency effort to complete. For some of the larger and long-term projects described earlier it has been difficult at this time to pin -point the actual costs that may be involved because the specific scope of the project has not yet been defined. The costs and priorities for projects that are projected into the future are understandably subject to uncertain- ty and fluctuation. Such projects, however, should not be disre- garded or "put off" if they are desirable for the best interests of the public. wit PROJECT COST ESTIMATES AND PRIORITIES Proposed Projects Agency Total Cost 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 Long Term Eagle Point Park Improvements Flora Park Improvements Murphy Park Improvements Municipal Swimming Pool Improvements PROJECT COST ESTIMATES AND PRIORITIES Proposed Project Agency " Total Cost . 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 Long Term ALLISON-HENDERSON PARK IMPROVEMENT Rec. Comm. painting 4,000 4,000 recover floors 8,000 8,000 COMISKEY PARK IMPROVEMENTS Rec. Comm. remodeling 20,500 20,500 move workshop 25,000 25,000 VETERAN'S PARK IMPROVEMENTS Rec. Comm. • bridge, road, parking, bleachers 25,000 25,000 lighting 85,000 85,000 BUNKER HILL GOLF COURSE Rec. Comm. painting 4,000 4,000 replace furnace 5,000 5,000 re -roof building 2,500 2,500 blacktop parking lot 15,000 15,000 storm drainage improvements 50,000 50,000 re -build greens and tees 3,500 500 3,000 fairway improvement 17,500 1,500 16,000 PARK GREENHOUSE OPERATIONS • Park Board improvements 111,000 111,000 PARK BOARD EQUIPMENT PURCHASE Park Board truck 3,400 3,400 2 jeeps 6,300 3,100 3,200 mowers 10,300 1,700 4,500 1,600 2,500 • PROJECT COST ESTIMATES AND PRIORITIES Proposed Project Agency Total Cost '1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 Long Term PARK BOARD EQUIPMENT PURCHASE Park Board tractor loader 6,500 6,500 end loader 35,000 35,000 2 pick-up trucks 7,000 7,000 pressure spray system 1,575 1,575• patrol cars 6,000 1,500 3,000 1,500 soil shredder 2,500 2,500 used truck loader 5,000 5,000 saws truck 700 700 RECREATION COMMISSION EQUIPMENT Rec. Comm. PURCHASE program equipment 22,750 4,000 4,250 4,500 5,000 5,000 bus 35,000 15,000 20,000 pick-up truck 5,500 2,500 3,000 program van 8,000 8,000 piano 1,000 1,000 sound system/Barn 3,000 3,000 fairway mower 9,000 • 9,000 greens mower 3,750 750 750 750 750 750 leaf blower 800 800 car 2,500 2,500 chairs 4,000 4,000 misc. maintenance equipment 10,000 1,000 3,000 2,000 2,000 2,000 TREE TRIMMING OPERATIONS • (include in equipment purchase) Park Board GENERAL URBAN BEAUTIFICATION 'Multi-agency ') regular landscape design work '.--__ _... 125,000 25,000 25,000 25,000 25,000 25,000 X rn PROJECT COST ESTIMATES AND PRIORITIES Total • 1973 ' ' '1974 ' 1975' : 1976 1 1977 Tern Longrop Proposed Project Agency Cost MAUS PARK DEVELOPMENT t,, toilet facilities -�l Park Board 3,075 .3,075 F.D.R. PARK DEVELOPMENT Park Board initial work completion 40,000 5,000 10,000 10,000 15,000 X WASHINGTON PARK DEVELOPMENT Park Board redevelopment 40,000 17,000 23,000 McALEECE RECREATION AREA Rec. Comm. bleachers 6,000 6,000 lights 13,500 13,500 ice rink and warming house • 19,000 19,000 sealcoating 4,000 4,000 parking lot Park Board 10,000 10,000 • X lr ,' UNIVERSITY PARK DEVELOPMENTT;. ) >t �{, GRANT PARK DEVELOPMENT Park Board general work 2,500 2,500 GAY PLAYGROUND IMPROVEMENT Rec. Comm. move ice rink 3,000 • 3,000 building construction 15,000 15,000 PETRAKIS PARK relocate or redevelop Rec. Comm. X PROJECT COSTESTIMATES AND PRIORITIES Proposed Project Agency Total Cost • 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 Long Term FLOODWALL DEVELOP & MAINTENANCE Multi -agency maintenance and improvement 125,000 25,000 25,000 25,000 25,000 25,000 X NEIGHBORHOOD PLAYGROUND DEVELOPMENT Rec. Comm. minimum 3 new facilities 75,000/per facil- 15,000 75,000 75,000 75,000 X ity for planning, land and development LYON'S TRUST PARKLAND PURCHASE Park Board Project #1 28,000 28,000 X INDOOR MULTI -PURPOSE FACILITY Multi -agency planning and design 200,000 25,000 75,000 100,000 construction 2,000.000 P.000,00 SWIMMING POOL DEVELOPMENT Rec,Comm. construct 2 outdoor pools 500,000 250,000 250,000 CITY ISLAND DEVELOPMENT PLAN Multi -agency develop plan 15,000 5,000 10,000 X BIKEWAY DEVELOPMENT ; Multi -agency implement system 25,000 15,000 5,000 5,000 _____ FIVE -FLAGS CIVIC CENTER Multi -agency BLUFF CONSERVATION AND PROTECTION Multi -agency X METROPOLITAN OPEN SPACE SYSTEM Multi -agency X c rn F 1- PROJECT COST'ESTIMATES AND PRIORITIES -68 cy L o v F- Multi-agenc,( X Multi -agency X MMulti-agency) • 50,000 50,000 • 01 SD ol LO e-I cr- rn CO n 01 H —4-) (U U1 +- o o c) F- v a) Q • -> U a, O 5- a -o W v) o i- a. cn J W F- . >- 3 ¢ a• ^ cn o '--4 ce CI U z _a.l F- z W a_ O _1 W 0 W U CY = O W CC U '-+ CC F- N F- z rn W C Lai = C• O rts ce t--• a. eL 1--1 "o z� ` O - eC i- u- O CC Fw- aU ¢ 4-3 3 rtzt W 'O 7D W CO . ot R pit mot - 69 Funding In planning for the financing of the proposed projects, the City of Dubuque must give first priority to use of its own annually -appro- priated funds for park and recreation purposes. These local tax funds are used for the regular operations and maintenance of exist- ing facilities as well as for a limited amount of capital improve- ments each year. Local tax funds for park and recreation purposes are, of course, limited and must be supplemented by other funds in order to undertake major capital projects. For acquisition of future park and open space lands, the City of Dubuque will be able to utilize funds from the E. B. Lyon's Trust. Acquisition of one 34 acre parcel near Dubuque is now being final- ized using these trust funds. With proper planning and coordina- tion it will be possible for the City to make significant addition- al acquisitions using these trust funds. Land and Water Conservation (LAwCON) funds from the Bureau of Out- door Recreation have proved beneficial to Dubuque and Dubuque County in the past. LAWCON funds can be used for both acquisition and de- velopment purposes but are intended to supplement rather than replace regular local funds. Several of the proposed projects outlined above could potentially utilize LAWCON funds. It should be noted at this time, however, that Iowa's proposed 1974 B.O.R. allocation of LAWCON funds is significantly less than in previous years and therefore may affect scheduling of these funds for a number of years. In addition to regularly -budgeted local funds, Lyon's Trust funds and LAWCON matching funds, the City of Dubuque can also utilize federal revenue sharing funds, other private donations and bond issues to fi- nance various park and recreation projects. Other Means for Open Space Establishment In addition to direct public acquisition and development of park and open space lands there are a number of other means and techniques for the acquisition or preservation of recreation lands and public open space. Each technique has a specific application and purpose accord- ing to the results desired and relation to an overall comprehensive plan. The techniques that will be discussed here include (A) acqui- sition of full ownership; (B) acquisition of rights, and (C) regula- tion. A. Acquisition of Full Ownership: Outright acquisition of lands either through negotiated purchase or eminent domain enables the City to exercise the greatest flexibility in developing park and recreation facilities to suit the general community needs. 70 B. Acquistion of Rights: The purchase of easements can be used to acquire rights for certain purposes including: 1. Retention of land in its natural state. 2. Maintain open space around airports. 3. Preservation of woods, bluffs, hilltops and other scenic areas. 4. Hunting, fishing, hiking and other active uses. Easements allow the land to remain in private ownership, can per- mit continuity of use, retain it on the tax rolls and yet provide conservation or recreation use and value at less cost than out- right acquisition and ownership. Leases, salebacks and leasebacks are other means of providing re- creational and open space opportunities. Such rights may be ac- quired for either a set length of time or in perpetuity depending on the circumstances. C. Regulation: Various forms of municipal regulat,ons can e cant benusedd for conservation, open space and, r- poses. 1. Flood Plain Zoning can assure that valleys, ravines and other drainage areas are not used for unsafe development. This technique is a health, welfare and safety regulation that controls building in areas that are subject to perio- dic flooding. The specifics of different flood plain or- dinances vary but all generally control substantial or in- tensive land uses that would be severely damaged by flood- ing. Agricultural and recreational uses, on the other hand are generally permitted uses. In the case of Dubuque, much of the area outlined as part of the suggested open space network could be secured through the application of flood plain development regulations. 2. The Establishment of Encroachment Lines is another means of preventing development along existing water courses in the path of possible flood run-offs. The use of encroach- ment lines in a recognition of the requirements of exces- sive urban area run-off due to large areas of hard surfac- ed streets, roofs, and other non -porous areas. 3. Agricultural Zoning protects and enables existing agricul- tural uses to continue in operation without encroachment by urban development. Such zoning, if properly applied, also offers direct and permanent protection for the op- eration of part-time farms, large residential estates and various forms of private recreational and institutional uses. L ralP NIF IN! 01!" u!I ■ at • • 4. Cluster Zoning and planned -unit -development provisions can be used to achieve a more attractive and efficient sub -urban development pattern while providing recrea- tion and open space land at the same time. This plan- ning concept usually requires modification of the exist- ing zoning regulations relative to residential develop- ment provided that the average population density and lot coverage in an areas as a whole does not exceed that which is permitted in the residential zoning district in- volved and provided that the surplus land area obtained is designated and maintained as a recreation area either for the exclusive use of a residential cluster or else as a part of the public open space system for the City. The purpose of residential clustering is to create a more desirable living environment, to encourage better land use practices, to achieve more imaginative resi- dential area design and to integrate residential build- ing sites with parks and recreation areas. 5. Incentive Zoning procedures allow the City to extend an incentive to a residential developer by permitting an increased density where two or more smaller parcels are developed for one multi -family garden apartment and ex- tra land is provided as increased open space. Incen- tive zoning is intended for application to existing residential areas where land is already platted in nar- row lots within a multi -family residential zoning dis- trict. - 71 - 72 - 73 IMPLEMENTATION Coordination Primary responsibility for implementing the proposals outlined in this plan is given to the Dubuque Park Board and the Dubuque Playground and Recreation.Commission and their respective staffs. Nearly all of the regular maintenance and replacement projects and improvement to exist- ing facility projects listed in the cost estimate and priority tables are the responsibility of one of these agencies. In addition a number of the new development projects listed will also be undertaken by the Park Board or Recreation Commission. The following multi -agency projects will require the coordination and joint effort of the agencies listed in order to accomplish the project goal 1. General Urban Beautification: a. b. c. d. Park Board Street Department Planning and Zoning Commission Dock Commission 2. Floodwall Development and Maintenance: a. b. c Dock Commission Planning and Zoning Commission U.S. Army Corps of Engineers 3. Indoor Multi -Purpose Facility: a. Recreation Commission b. Planning and Zoning Commission c. Civic and private interests 4. Dubuque Waterfront Improvement: a. b. c. d. e. f. Dock Commission Planning and Zoning Commission Street Department Engineering Department Health Department Civic and private interests 5. City Island Development: a. b. c. Park Board Recreation Commission Planning and Zoning Commission d. Engineering Department e. U. S. Army Corps of Engineers f. Iowa Natural Resources Council 6. Bikeway Development: a. b. c. d. Recreation Commission Planning and Zoning Commission Police Department Engineering Department 7. Five Flags Civic Center: a. Civic and private interests b. City of Dubuque 8. Bluff Conservation and Protection: a. b. c. d. Park Board Planning and Zoning Commission Dubuque County Conservation Board Dubuque County Metropolitan Area Planning 9. Metropolitan Open Space a. b. c. d. e. f. System: Park Board Planning and Zoning Commission Dubuque County Metropolitan Area Planning Dubuque County Conservation Board Iowa Conservation Commission Iowa Natural Resources Council 10. Scenic Drives, Parkways and Trails: a. b. c. d. e. f. g• h. Commission Commission Park Board Planning and Zoning Commission Dubuque County Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Dubuque County Conservation Board Iowa Conservation Commission Iowa Commerce Commission Great River Road (U.S. Government) Civic and private interests 11. Historic Resources Development: a. b. c. d. e. Dubuque County Historical Society Planning and Zoning Commission Iowa State Preservation Program U.S. Government Civic and private interests - 74 Besides the joint efforts needed to carry out the specific projects listed here, general recreation planning coordination will be neces- sary on a continued basis among the following governmental jurisdic- tions and agencies: 1. City of Dubuque a. Park Board b. Playground and Recreation Commission c. Planning and Zoning Commission d. Other agency staffs as needed 2. Dubuque County a. Zoning Commission b. Conservation Board c. Other agency staffs as needed 3. Dubuque County Metropolitan Area Planning Commission 4. Iowa Conservation Commission Updating the Plan In order to keep the plan current and to reflect changes in project priorities, availability of funds or new developments that may occur, the plan will be reviewed on an annual basis. In this way a perman- ent five year recreation facility improvement program can be maintain- ed and sufficiently funded. L L APPENDIX I Detailed Inventory of Existing Local Recreation Facilities BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Park Board - 76 • Ia - Neighborhood Facilities NAME: Cleveland Park LOCATION: End of Cleveland Avenue SIZE (acres): 4.07 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Light FACILITIES: 2 fireplacesil . 2 picnic tables 2 swings 1 piece misc. play equip. .- ill NAME: Jackson Park LOCATION: 15th and Main Streets SIZE (acres): 2.11 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION. Moderate FACILITIES: benches0 1 softball diamond misc. play equipment I NAME: Washington Park LOCATION: 7th and Locust/Bluff Streets SIZE (acres): 1.29 CONDITION: -Gfled UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: benches ,- NAME: Madison Park LOCATION: End of North Main SIZE (acres): 3.75 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Light FACILITIES: 1 swing 1 basketball hoop 2 picnic tables 1 open air shelter 2 piece misc. play equip. NAME: University Park LOCATION: Asbury and Clarke Drive SIZE (acres): 20.00 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATIO\ :-L4ght . FACILITIES: 1 tennis court picnic tables fireplaces - 77 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ia - Neighborhood Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Park Board NAME: Caledonia Playground LOCATION: Caledonia and West 8th SIZE (acres): 0.33 CONDITION: -FaPir- UTILIZATION: Moderate NAME: Frith Playground LOCATION: Queen and Regent SIZE (acres): 0.75 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Jefferson Park LOCATION: Walnut and University SIZE (acres): 0.30 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Moderate NAME: Flatiron (Phoenix) Park LOCATION: Main and Jones SIZE (acres): 0.14 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Light NAME: Grant Park LOCATION: Bluff, Locust and 15th SIZE (acres): 0.15 CONDITION: -Poor UTILIZATID :-'Ei-ght. FACILITIES: 1 basketball hoop benches FACILITIES: none FACILITIES: 1 basketball hoop 1 baseball diamond. blacktop play area misc. play equipment FACILITIES: benches 2 picnic tables FACILITIES: benches- BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Park Board - 78 Ia - Neighborhood Facilities PM! NAME: Oakwood Park LOCATION: North of 32nd Street SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: 4.68 NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: undeveloped FACILITIES: FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: noL No_ • - 79 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ia - Neighborhood Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Recreation Commission NAME: Booth Tennis Courts LOCATION: Booth and Dodge SIZE (acres): 0.75 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 1 tennis court (lighted) NAME: Burden Playground LOCATION: Windsor and Burden SIZE (acres): 2.00 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Moderate FACILITIES: 1 softball diamond 5 pieces misc. play equip. NAME: Falk Playground LOCATION: Ideal Lane and Earl Drive SIZE (acres): 1.00 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Light FACILITIES: misc. play equipment 1 volleyball court ` NAME: Gay Playground LOCATION: Gay and Primrose SIZE (acres): 8.50 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION Moderate FACILITIES: 1 softball diamond 1 ice skating rink 1 archery range 1 warming house 1 badminton court 1 volleyball court - NAME: Peter Cooper Playground LOCATION: Sycamore and l4th Street SIZE (acres): 0.64 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Moderate !=ACILITIES: misc. play equipment - 80 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ia - Neighborhood Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Recreation Commission NAME: Valley High Playground LOCATION: N. Grandview and Cerro Drive. SIZE (acres): 6.01 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Light FACILITIES: 1 storage building • misc. playground equipment II NAME: Waller -Cooper Tot Lot LOCATION: Cooper Place SIZE (acres): 0.50 acres CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Moderate FACILITIES: misc. play equipment I NAME: Hillcrest Tot Lot LOCATION: Hillcrest Road SIZE (acres): 1.50 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Light FACILITIES: misc. play equipment NAME: Hilltop Playground LOCATION: Caledonia and Wilson SIZE (acres}: 1.50 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Light =ACIL1TIES: 1 volleyball court 1 fireplace 2 picnic tables misc. play equipment NAME: Mobile Playground LOCATION: - SIZE (acres): - CONDITION: Good , UTILIZATION: Heavy . FACILITIES:misc. facilities & equip. ■ mt R - 81 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ia - Neighborhood Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Community School District NAME: Audubon School LOCATION: 535 Lincoln SIZE (acres): 2.00 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Moderate FACILITIES: 1 basketball hoop 1 tetherball pole 1 jungle gym NAME: Bryant School LOCATION: 1280 Rush SIZE (acres): 0.86 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 3 basketball hoops 2 jungle gyms 8 tetherball poles 1 softball diamond 2 chinning bars 1 parallel bar NAME: Fulton School LOCATION: 2540 Central SIZE (acres): 0.78 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 3 basketball hoops 1 parallel bar 4 tetherball poles gym 1 softtball field NAME: Irving School LOCATION: 2520 Pennsylvania SIZE (acres): 4.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION Light FACILITIES: 4 basketball hoops 4 tetherball poles 3jungle gyms 1 chinning bar 2 softball diamonds NAME: Jackson School LOCATION: 715 West Locust SIZE (acres): 1.20 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Moderate FACILITIES: 1 basketball hoop 1 tetherball pole 1 softball diamond BUREAU OF OWNERSHIP 1191 OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ia - Neighborhood Facilities OR CONTROL: Dubuque Community School District 11111 NAME: Kennedy School LOCATION: 2135 Woodland Drive SIZE (acres): 2.00 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Lincoln School LOCATION: 1101 West 5th Street SIZE (acres): 1.40 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Marshall School LOCATION: 1450 Rhomberg SIZE (acres): 1.30 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Heavy - 82 4 FACILITIES: 2 basketball hoops • 1 eagles nest 5 tetherball poles 1 chinning bar 2 softball diamonds FACILITIES:1 basketball hoop 1 chinning bar 1 jungle gym 2 tetherball poles 1 softball diamond FACILITIES:2 basketball hoops 3 tetherball poles 1 parallel bar 1 chinning bar NAME: Prescott School LOCATION: 1249 White SIZE (acres): 0.50 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Hoover School LOCATION: 3259 St. Anne Drive SIZE (acres): 8.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION' Moderate FACILITIES:2 basketball hoops 3 tetherball poles 1 slide 1 parallel bar 1 jungle gym FACILITIES:1 softball diamond 1 parallel bar 1 eagles nest 1 sliding pole 1 arched ladder 4 tetherball poles - 83 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ia - Neighborhood Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Community School District NAME: Eisenhower School LOCATION: 3170 Spring Valley Road SIZE (acres): 15.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Moderate NAME: Jefferson Junior High School LOCATION: 1105 Althauser SIZE (acres): 1.83 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Washington Junior High School LOCATION: 51 North Grandview SIZE (acres): 3.60 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Light NAME: Marshall Playground LOCATION: Rhomberg and Whittier SIZE (acres): 2.50 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Moderate NAME: Valentine Playground LOCATION: Valentine Drive SIZE (acres): 4.50 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATIOt: Moderate FACILITIES: 9 swings • 1 chinning bar 1 jungle gym 1 parallel bar 3 basketball hoops 1 softball diamond 4 tetherball poles 1 sliding pole FACILITIES: 4 basketball hoops 1 tennis court 1 football field 1 softball diamond FACILITIES: 1 football field 1 softball diamond FACILITIES: 2 softball diamonds FACILITIES:misc. play equipment softball diamond picnic table fireplace BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: - 84 Ia - Neighborhood Facilities Archdiocese of Dubuque NAME: St. Raphael School LOCATION: 223 Bluff Street SIZE (acres): 1.18 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Light FACILITIES: 2 basketball hoops • play area misc. play equipment NAME: Holy Ghost School LOCATION: 2981 Central Avenue SIZE (acres): 3.70 C0NDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Moderate FACILITIES: 6 basketball hoops 6 tetherball poles NAME: Holy Trinity School LOCATION: 1703 Rhomberg Avenue SIZE (acres): 0.50 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Moderate NAME: Nativity School LOCATION: 1001 Alta Vista SIZE (acres): 1.38 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION : Moderate NAME:Sacred Heart School LOCATION: 2212 Queen Street SIZE (acres): 0.29 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 2 basketball hoops 2 tetherball poles 2 softball diamonds 2 volleyball courts FACILITIES: 2 basketball hoops 1 softball diamond FACILITIES:2 basketball hoops 1 softball diamond NIF n4F- oPL_ it - 85 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ia - Neighborhood Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Archdiocese of Dubuque NAME: St. Anthony's School LOCATION: 2175 Rosedale SIZE (acres): 2.46 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: St. Columbkille's School LOCATION: 1198 Rush SIZE (acres): 3.25 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: St. Joseph's School LOCATION: 2105 St. Joseph Street SIZE (acres): 2.40 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Moderate NAME: St. Mary's School LOCATION: 1600 White SIZE (acres): 0.24 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 2 basketball hoops 1 tetherball pole 2 softball diamonds 2 sliding boards FACILITIES: 1 basketball hoop 1 football field 1 softball diamond FACILITIES: 5 basketball hoops 1 softball diamond 2 tetherball poles 1 jungle gym FACILITIES: 5 basketball hoops 4 swings 2 chinning bars 1 merry-go-round NAME: St. Patrick's School LOCATION: 180 West 15th Street SIZE (acres): 0.38 CONDITION1: Fair UTILIZATION: Heavy . FACILITIES: 2 basketball hoops BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: • - 86 Ia - Neighborhood Facilities Archdiocese of Dubuque NAME: Resurrection School LOCATION: 4300 Asbury Road SIZE (acres): 4.80 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 6 basketball hoops 2 volleyball courts 16 swings 1 slide 2 tetherball poles 6 teeter totters 1 jungle gym 1 softball diamond 1 merry-go-round NAME: Immaculate Conception School, LOCATION: 1001.Davis Avenue NN NN SIZE (acres): CONDITION: - UTILIZATION:,Light FACILITIES: None NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILI7_ATIO� FACILITIES: FACILITIES: - 87 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ia - Neighborhood Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Miscellaneous Religious Institutions NAME: St. Elias Church Playground LOCATION: 1075 Rockdale Road SIZE (acres) : - CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Light FACILITIES: misc. play equipment I NAME: St. Peter's Lutheran Church Play- ground LOCATION: 3200 Asbury Road SIZE (acres): - CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres;: CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Park Board - 88 4 Ib - Community -Wide Facilities NAME: Allison -Henderson Park LOCATION: Between Loras, University at Grandview SIZE (acres): 6.00 `• CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 3 fireplaces • 12 picnic tables . 2 basketball hoops 1 softball diamond 5 misc. play equipment 1 clubhouse (Recreation Commission) NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: . UTILIZATION FACILITIES: . NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: . FACILITIES: A 1 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ib - Community -Wide OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque - 89 Facilities Recreation Commission NAME: Bunker Hill Golf Course LOCATION: Bunker Hill at Fairway Drive SIZE (acres): 105.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Municipal Swimming Pool LOCATION: 1800 Hawthorne SIZE (acres): 1.35 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Petrakis Stadium LOCATION: E. 4th Street & Market Square SIZE (acres): 4.00 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Light NAME: Comiskey Field LOCATION: 2400 Jackson SIZE (acres): 3.50 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: McAleece Recreation Area LOCATION: Kemper at Hawthorne SIZE (acres): 7.50 CONDITIONa: Good UTILIZATIO1,: Heavy FACILITIES: 18-hole golf course • clubhouse maintenance building FACILITIES: swimming pool lockers and change houses FACILITIES: baseball stadium bleachers for 2,000 people toilet facilities and lock- er rooms lighting equipment FACILITIES:.2 baseball diamonds 2-tennis courts 1 ice skating rink 1 clubhouse misc. play equipment FACILITIES: 2 baseball diamonds (ligh- ted) toilet building press booth- 1 concession building 11-4 11H IL IL ILL ELL L[1--L • BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ib - Community -Wide Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Community School District i NAME: Dubuque Senior High School LOCATION: 1800 Clarke Drive SIZE (acres): 19.90 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Moderate NAME: Stephen Hempstead High School LOCATION: 3715 Pennsylvania SIZE (acres): 20.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Moderate NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: 1 football stadium • 1 track 1 archery range 5 tennis courts 1 softball diamond 2 baseball diamonds - FACILITIES: 3 tennis courts 2 softball diamonds 1 baseball diamond 2 football fields 1 track 1 indoor swimming pool FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: - 91 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ib - Community -Wide Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Archdiocese of Dubuque NAME: Wahlert High School LOCATION: 2005 Kane Street SIZE (acres): 12.80 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Moderate FACILITIES: 1 football field 1 track 2 softball diamonds 1 baseball diamond NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION FACILITIES: . NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION. FACILITIES: • NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: • . tACILITIES: BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: 0WNERSf1IP OR CONTROL: Miscellaneous Private - 92 Ib - Community -Wide Facilities and Other NAME: Dubuque Country Club LOCATION: Randall Place SIZE (acres): 140.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION:Heavy NAME: Dubuque Marina LOCATION: Hawthorne and waterfront SIZE (acres): 12.0 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Dubuque Yacht Basin LOCATION: City Island SIZE (acres): 9.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Schmidt Harbor LOCATION: City island SIZE (acres): CONDITION: - UTILIZATION: NAME: Senior Citizen's Centre LOCATION: 1099 Iowa Street SIZE (acres): - CONDITION: Good UTILIZATIO^: Heavy FACILITIES: 18-hole golf course clubhouse tennis courts swimming pool FACILITIES: 250 dock spaces launching ramp and hoist 11 winter storage sales, service, etc. snack bar _ FACILITIES: 130 dock spaces launching ramp and hoist winter storage sales, service, etc. -icesttiro.a401-t, cocktail lounge FACILITIES: under development ti FACILITIES: varied programs and acti- vities N • • - 93 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ib - Community -Wide Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Miscellaneous Private and Other NAME: Creslanes Bowl LOCATION: 255 South Main SIZE (acres): - CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 24 bowling lanes lounge, shop, etc. NAME: Dubuque Bowling Lanes LOCATION: 10291/2 Main Street SIZE (acres): CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Moderate NAME: Fischer Bowling Lanes LOCATION: 880 Locust SIZE (acres): CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Holy Trinity Bowlinq.—L es LOCATION:�1703 Rhomberg SIZE (acres);, -. . CONDITION Fair UTILIZATION: Moderate Moderate FACILITIES: 6 bowling lanes lounge FACILITIES: bowling lanes lounge, shop, etc. FACILITIES: bowling lanes NAME: Riverside Bowl LOCATION: 1869 Hawthorne SIZE (acres: CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 40 bowling lanes 'ballroom, R, . pool tables res-tattrant, lounge, etc. • - 94 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ib - Community -Wide Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Miscellaneous Private and Other NAME: Imperial Lanes LOCATION: Stoneman Road SIZE (acres): 2.5 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Eagle Point Funland LOCATION: 2705 Rhomberg SIZE (acres): 4.50 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION: Moderate NAME: Skate Country LOCATION: Highway 20 (west of City) SIZE (acres): - CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: Dubuque Shooting Society LOCATION: Highway 52 (north of City) SIZE (acres): 24.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 24 bowling lanes lounge, shop, etc. FACILITIES: i-n-daaaLle-s-k at4f1 r i rrk miniature golf 1 go-cart track 1 archery range 1 baseball pitching area FACILITIES: indoor roller skating rink FACILITIES: trapshooting ri� clubhouse;'lounge, 1 i a etc. LI NAME: Dubuque Water Ski Club LOCATION: City Island SIZE (acres): 18.00 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATIO^: Moderate . FACILITIES:clubhouse ' ski -jump boat launching ramp picnic tables toilet building - - 95 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: Ib - Community -Wide Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Miscellaneous Private and Other NAME: Dubuque Flatboat Club LOCATION : City Island S I Z E (acres) : -1-70 CONDITION: Poor UTILIZATION: Moderate FACILITIES: dock space • l au Reiti-rrg-ramp- _pa-cn c-Ftab -es- NAME: Dubuque Conservation Society Park LOCATION: City Island ' ,.,c,,_ %- SIZE (acres) : 20.00 \\,\-_,+ . ( 'J CONDITION: -Fair .�'' UTILIZATION: Moderate-'" vc \ Q FACILITIES: picnic tables fireplaces softball diamond toilet building na-i-sc-play equipment- . - CJ ... - . NAME: Dubuque Boys Club LOCATION: 1299 Locust Street SIZE (acres): - CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: varied programs and facil- ities NAME: YMCA -YWCA LOCATION: Dodge and Booth Streets SIZE (acres): - CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: varied programs and facil- ities NAME: Robert's River Rides LOCATION: Hawthorne at the river SIZE (acres): - CONDITION: - UTILIZATIO� : - 'FACILITIES: 150 passenger excursion boat BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: - 96 Ib- Community -Wide Facilities OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Miscellaneous Private and Other NAME: Clarke College LOCATION: 1550 Clarke Drive SIZE (acres): CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: tennis courts • athletic fields misc. indoor facilities indoor swimming pool NAME: Loras College LOCATION: Loras and Alta Vista SIZE (acres): CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy NAME: University of Dubuque LOCATION: University Avenue SIZE (acres): - CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: tennis courts football stadium track baseball diamond fieldhouse - misc. indoor facilities indoor swimming pool FACILITIES: tennis courts football stadium track baseball diamond fieldhouse misc. indoor facilities indoor swimming pool NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: ':ACILITIES: 1' 1 - 97 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: II - General Outdoor Recreation Areas OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Park Board NAME: Eagle Point Park LOCATION: North end, off Shiras Avenue SIZE (acres): 164.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Very heavy FACILITIES: 115 fireplaces 506 picnic tables 14 picnic shelters 6 toilet buildings 1 bandshell 1 softball diamond 27 pieces play equipment 6 lighted tennis courts 23 swings 2 horseshoe courts 1 fish pond 1 walking path NAME: Louis Murphy Park LOCATION: South end, Grandview Avenue SIZE (acres): 80.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: 59 fireplaces 12 swing sets 200 picnic tables 3 picnic shelters 3 toilet buildings 1 softball diamond 2 horseshoe courts 3 lighted tennis courts 16 pieces misc. playground equipment NAME: Flora Park LOCATION: Pennsylvania and Green SIZE (acres): 35.00 CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Very heavy FACILITIES: 36 fireplaces picnic tables 9 swings 6 sand bores 1 ice skating rink `6 volleyball courts 2 toilet buildings 2 picnic shelters 2 baseball diamonds -3 shuffleboard courts 1 swimming pool and bathhouse 4 lighted horseshoe courts 4 lighted tennis courts 1 multi -purpose building 25 pieces misc. playground equipment NAME: Maus Conservation Park LOCATION: Huff St. off Railroad Avenue SIZE (acres : 8.90 CONDITION: Fair UTILIZATION Moderate FACILITIES: fireplaces picnic tables misc. play equipment - 98 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: II - General Outdoor Recreation Are OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Park Board and Recreation Commission NAME: Franklin D. Roosevelt Park LOCATION: North Cascade Road SIZE (acres): 210.00 CONDITION: - UTILIZATION: - a"e NAME: Veteran's Memorial Park LOCATION: West 32nd St. and Carter Rd. SIZE (acres): CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy 73.00 NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: undeveloped FACILITIES: 4-pieces misc. play equ' 2 softball diamonds 2 rope tows 1 baseball diamond 4 tennis courts 3-picnic tables 1 fireplace 1 toilet building 1 warming house model airplane flying field FACILITIES: - FACILITIES: FACILITIES: - 99 BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: III -Natural Environment Areas OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: U. S. Government NAME: Upper Mississippi River National Wildlife Refuge LOCATION: - SIZE (acres): 1,290 bordering Dubuque County CONDITION : - UTILIZATION: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: various access points, etc for boaters, birdwatchers, fishermen FACILITIES: FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: -FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: I - 100 - 101 Reserved Open Space and BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: VII - Undeveloped Lands OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: Dubuque Park Board i NAME: Twelfth Street Hillside LOCATION: along Twelfth Street SIZE (acres): 0.10 CONDITION : - UTILIZATION: - FACILITIES: none NAME: Montrose Terrace Hillside LOCATION: adjacent to Melrose Terrace SIZE (acres): 0.40 CONDITION: - UTILIZATION: - FACILITIES: none NAME: Eighth Street Hillside LOCATION: along Eighth Street SIZE (acres): 1.70 CONDITION: - UTILIZATION: - FACILITIES: none ; NAME: Grandview Avenue Boulevard LOCATION: along S. Grandview Avenue SIZE (acres)_ - CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: --Hea. y_ FACILITIES: miscellaneous planting and landscaping. NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: i BUREAU OF OUTDOOR RECREATION CLASSIFICATION: OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL: U.S. Government Private and Other Facilities NAME: Lock and Dam #11 LOCATION: Mississippi River at Eagle Point SIZE (acres): - CONDITION: Good UTILIZATION: Heavy FACILITIES: viewpoint lock used by recreational boats NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: . NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres;: CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres;: CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: NAME: LOCATION: SIZE (acres): CONDITION: UTILIZATION: FACILITIES: 7 oriroon -ti 3 9 0 Regional Recreation Inventory a a 11 -Xi 71111 ilt • REGIONAL RECREATION INVENTORY Facilities Boat Access c u: W H .-1 r • b C C ^T p V. 0 U U H H V1 r-i z -H r, •.- U •rf CJ U •ri i 0 County Location Name Control Type yP P.crea e U -r c "� ;-a c m -r- a •� _r r o E. o n --, Land Water Total a u E-i w un L9 u :r. Clayton Marquette Effigy Mounds Federal VI 474 474 x x x National Monument Clayton Mississippi River Upper Mississippi National Wildlife Federal Wide- life 2,948 10,448 13,396 x x x x Refuge Area Clayton Guttenburg Lock & Dam #10 Federal Water 2 2 x x Access. Clayton Guttenburg Guttenburg Nation- al Fish Hatchery Federal Wild- life 1,033 39 1,072 Area Clayton Guttenburg Merritt Forest 'State IV 20 20 x Clayton Elkader Big Spring/Fish Hatchery State Wild- life 67 8 75 x Area Clayton McGregor Pikes Peak Point and State Park State III 870 870 x x x x x Clayton N. Buena- Turkey Mounds State VII 82 82 x Vitsta State Preserve Clayton Clayton Sny., Magill State Water 5- 5 x x x x Acces. Clayton Edgewood Bixby State III 69 69 x x x Clayton Marquette Bloody Run County II 135 135 x x x x r-- T Facilities • REGIONAL RECREATION INVENTORY 0 H U -H a !Camping 1 U) r •r r�3 N 1Loat Access •H VIl •H •H M f -- !Canoeing 1 County Location I Name Control Acreage Type Land Water Total Clayton Garnavillo Buck Creek County III 103 103 x x x x Clayton Elkader Chicken Ridge County III 4 4 x Clayton Clayton Boat Ramp County Water Acces • Clayton Guttenburg French Town Lake County II 11 x x x x x Clayton Elkader Frieden Park County III 1 1 x x x Clayton Monona Gateway Park County III 3 3 x x x 3 Clayton Guttenburg Boat Ramp County II later ccess 1 1 x x x Clayton Strawberry Joy Springs County III 80 80 x x x x x Point Clayton Elkader Lovers Leap County VII 10 10 L Clayton Elkader Osborne Planta- tion County III 60 60 x x x x Clayton Elkader Turkey River Park County Water 2 2 x Acces 3 Delaware Manchester Manchester Nation- al Fish Hatchery Federal Wild- life 25 25 Acces- ' Delaware Strawberry 1,650 1,650 x x x x x - Backbone State State III Point Park Water ^f'SS County 25 26 Delaware Delaware 27 Delaware 2a Delaware 29 Delaware 30 31 32 33 Delaware Delaware Delaware Delaware Location Delhi Manchester Delhi Manchester Greeley Manchester Manchester Dundee Hopkinton Name Silver Lake Bailey's Ford Burtons Wildlife Area Central Park Child's Wildlife Cofins Grove Delaware Township Forrest Dundee Access Dunlap Park T REGIONAL RECREATION INVENTORY Facilities Control State County County County County County County County County. Type II II & later ccess Wild- life Area Wild- life Area Wild- life Area II VII II & dater \ccess water Acces Acreage Land • Water 23 10 22 22 20 Total 39 23 4 10 22 22 20 1 0 H 0 0 •H 0 6 U x x U) G 0 0 0 0 in -H U rH -H •H 6 u) 0 •H r! H w x x x x x x a. -H r0 0 H Historical mftwn r Facilities ;4 ;5 s6 ;7 38 39 0 1 2 3 4 5 REGIONAL RECREATION INVENTORY County Delaware Delaware Delaware Delaware Delaware Delaware Delaware Delaware Delaware Delaware Delaware Jackson Location Greeley Hopkinton Greeley Manchester Greeley Manchester Earlville Delhi Delhi Colesburg Oneida Missippi River Name Fountain Spring Creek Hardscrabble Park Hook Wildlife Are Milo Township Forest Area Oneida Township Park Pin Oak Park Plum Creek Park Silver Lake Park Turtle Creek Ac- cess Twin Bridges Park Oneida Wildlife Area Upper Mississippi National Wildlife Area Control County County County County County County County County County County County Federal Type III III Wildlife Area III II III II III III III Wildlife Area Wildlife Area Acreage Land 176 42 10 100 2 8 29 13 149 20 6 1,322 U U Water Total a 1,400 176 x x 42 10 x 100 x 2 x 8 x 29 x 13 x 149 x 20 x 6 2,722 x x x X r-I H x x N ril U U x x •rl x x x X x x x .r{ 4) P x x x x WAIL MI 'li-a Ailit-ter REGIONAL RECREATION INVENTORY it rj a U J U • 4-3 c H 2' 0 -ri Facilities County Location Name Control Type Acreage Land U 0 U Water Total a tT 0 8 0 U 0' G r♦ •� •H •H +J r, 4-3 U) g H O •H H p L--+ w U U 16 1 18 19 50 5 3 3 3 3 5 7 8 Jackson Jackson Jackson Jackson Jackson Jackson Jackson Jackson Jackson Jackson Jackson Jackson Jackson Bellevue Bellevue Preston Maquoketa Green Island Sabula Bellevue Maquoketa Maquoketa Maquoketa Sabula Bellevue Lock & Dam #12 Pleasant Creek Bellevue State Park Dalton Pond Maquoketa Caves State Park Green Island Sabula Station' Bellevue Station Blackhawk Wild- life Area Horseshoe Pond Jainesville Park Sabula Boat Landing Spruce Creek Ac- cess Federal Federal State State State State State State County County County County County Water Access II Water Access III III IV Wildlife Area Wildlife Area Wildlife Area Wildlife Area II II Water Access II & Water Access 20 510 5 152 1,322 9 19 12 11 8 1 44 1,400 20 x x x x 510 x x x x x 5 x x x 152 x x x 2,722 x x x 9 x x x 19 x x x 12 x 11 x x x 8 x x x x 1 x x x 44 x x x x 8 a) m C U t( t U O r Historical Int. 1 o r _ r __._ r-- r^� 0011111611, Facilities - REGIONAL RECREATION INVENTORY 0 H u Camping 1 x x X x x x x Trails x x x x x x Boat Access x x x x X Fishing x x x x x Hunting ... x Swimming x !Golf Course Canoeing x x x Scenic Parks x historical Int. V Acreage County Location Name Control Type Land Water Total a Jones Anomosa Wapsisinicon State III 248 248 x x State Park Jones Olin Muskrat Slough State Wildlife Area 366 366 Jones Monticello Picture Rocks County Water Access 427 427 x Jones Central ._ .Central Park County II 217 217 x x Junction Jones Hale Junglestown County Water Access 2 2 x Jones Monticello Mon-Mag Dam County III 63 63 x Jo Daviess, Illinois Jo Daviess County Upper Mississippi_ River National Federal Wildlife Area 2,200 Wildlife Area Jo Daviess Illinois Jo Daviess County Apple River Can- you State Park State III 152 152 x x 7 Jo Daviess Galena Galena City VI 5 5 Illinois Jo Daviess Illinois Galena Chestnut Mt. Lodge Private (Open to public) Winter Rec- reation Re- sort 388 . 388 I Grant, Wis..Glen Haven Township Wyalusing State III 1,671 1,671 x x Grant, Wisconsin Potosi Nelson Dewey Memorial State VI 700 700 x x Alma- -ems. Aim 411.0a • AMINIIF ME -ate T.'. .�_.. --AM i C N J. O (t (D rt T1 (D r-•( fi D- 0 0_ 0 -n C .71 (),() 0 3 C r 0 O. 0 (-) N Cu 0 3 0 (D 2 o (n —III c J.. -+1C (DO rt ct (n C cn C (< rt c+ S CL A) (D (/) I--1 t (D 0 0 (D 0 '5 'S < A) 70 n (D (D (D 0 (--)n sv n (n 0 1 - 0 (D (D -O 1n fv O f]) ct CT < 0 C 0 0 (1 .0 = J• rt (D (v (.C] 0 (D v 0 0 (1 (-) 0 0 O -5 r✓ rn .- 1 0 -+h 0 fv uoLgeonP3 0 0 •v 3 J O 0 0 J n -� O -,• m 0 s n(.0 "S V (D J. N S)) n CJ O fv O 0_ 0 0- 1--1 O C7 CJ) .. o O svo n (n C1 (D 0) J. o <(i 0 a a) (n rt 0 -5 (D -h C1 -5 0 V) < 0 -0 Ct C/) (1) O - . 0 C -5 O n 0 CF J• Q C") O 1.0 c-i- 0 n V O 0 a J O "5 • N rF J 23 0 . 0 0 0 f) O -- S -S (/) (p fL rF O 0 fL O 0 0 -h (D fL (+ H (-5 O o 0 ry n C) •• fL O (0 C O O C 0 rF 1< 0 0 0 A) 0 O m 0 (D rt (n O O ct :0 0- 0 O 0 0 5 ...5 %0 (D n -5 0 0) rF O 0 (L O 0 `aoquy uuy 0 0 C C C CT Q C C .0 -v..fl 70.0 O 0) C (D C (D -5 (D < (D .J• fL Cu V fL 0.7- 0 10 C -5 a• 0 C C C C t. 0 Cu 0 V 73 co (D • 0 -5 (D fL (.(. J. �enuuy ZL6t 'pone Ted '£L6T `anbngna 7c 07 (D o n (0 (D 0 s5) rt A) 0 0.. 0 CD C 0 0- C C 0-.0 C • (D (D 0 V J fv {0(a CD0 C 0 CD C1. C CT fv C 0_ C 0 73 0 n (0 0 Cu rt • O n 0 2 2 (n 0 O C) 0 2 2 J. N .J. O `ZL6T uo!_;ea.toad 0 0 0 0 C C C C 0 Q 0 Q C C C C 0.0 70 -0 SD .n CO (1) -0 C C (D C 0 C 0 0 C CT (D n (D 0- (D 0) C (D C -5 "5 CS CL 0 -J A) J • - •• (D O (D A,r+ 55) (D A) N C () 0 0-5 C (D >1 (rt (-' -5 C (J) .J. C)) 0 \ (o o •. • 0 Co 0. 05 C C f1 (O • 3 CDO 0 0 n 0)0 • Q C CZ (D (0 C rt CT .. C c+ 'S C s» 0_ 0_o = IJ- 0 •0 C 0 O N 0 0 (D c+ 0 '-5 --) .. 70 () 0 J. (D -5 -)• 23 rF F--' n -,• (D () (0 -5 2 (fa n 0 V 0 -S C,.) 0) 7 C7 (D .J. • 2 rt (D 0 0 2 .......a, C -5 J. 0 rt o -v C "V ( O �• v A) 0 O C7 n`'( 2 C 0 c J. Q- V 0 J. CP 0 C -0 N .0 10 _C) (a J. C C C 0 CD t (D C- : .. C 0 C-) 2 C C O 3 0 • (D C J. 0 (t) 0- • "'0 rF V) CD 0 -Z 0 C 7� (D N 0 .. 0 ... N Z �) 0 a) (D 5 7c n < 0 v) 5 a -5 0 rt fa, C rt 0 (7- _,.= 73 0 (D and Recreation Commission, Recreation Report, : 1 0 0 A) (n O a 0 rt 0 :' 0 0 —+ J. Q) In : 0 - : • ( (0 (a -(=• Cu • n Q n co J. C al a Cu 0 (D 0 (0 C 0 0 -h 1) c-1- S O CD 0 '0 C C S cr (a O -) o c r C fv .0 O c+ 5 C 0 C1 fL (D o .. 3 o fL 0 -5 ( a 73 05 -5 0 (n Jcj• 0 • n • n iv cr (D (C) O C ()) o Q cF V C �• O (/! 0 C C 0 0' 0V rF Cu 0 0 3 0 C •5 CT 0) c+ 0 -5 CL O -5 c-+ -5 3 O C O (D 5 0 = rF 70 (.-)0 o 0 (n 2 0 0 0 0 -5 O rt J.n (- 8. cf . -5 (D J. (n 0 0 N C ^5 • Cu CT V 0) 0 C n 0- ( [D C (D 1-0 rn(n 0) '••.1 (+ ^S C:) • fL i 0 C < 0- N J - 0 Cl J. CJ (/) rF 1 S3JN32133321 0310313S RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE PLAN DUBUQUE, IOWA (Supplementary Data) October 1973 City of Dubuque Total City Budget 1968-1973 1 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 Total City Budget $10,059,598 $7,285,150 $8,747,038 $9,563,875 $10,100,971 $10,547,634 � t Note: Figures above are from annual City budget reports. Projected City Budget 1974-1978 197.4 1975 1976 1977 1978 Total City Budget $11,941,521 $12,980,433 $14,109,730 $15,337,276 $16,671,619 1 Note: 1974 figure is current as of October 10, 1973, as supplied by the City Manager's budget staff. i Projections are based on simple trends from 1969 to 1973 and do not re- flect extraordinary capital expenditures or other unforseen conditions. k Playground and Recreation Commission I t Total Participation in Programs 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 Total atio 1 Participation n 417,454 445,247 457,963 524,059 487,471 454,539 " - 2 Total Expenditures 1968-1973 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 Total Expenditures $272,729 $253,512 $274,567 $332,996 $320,164 $394,164 % of Total City Budget % of Current Expense 2.7 3.4 4.5 3.2 3.4 4.4 4.6 3.1 3.7 3.9 4.6 Playground and Recreation Commission Projected Program Participation 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 Projected Total Participation 479,993 506,872 535,256 565,230 596,882 Note: Projected figures for 1974-1978 based on an average 5.6% per year increase in program participation as indicated by trends from 1968- 1973. Projected Total Expenditures 1974 1975 1976. 1977 1978 As a % of Total City Budget $382,128 $415,373 $451,511 $490,792 $533,491 On a per -parti- cipant basis $321,595 $339,604 $358,621 $378,704 $399,910 Budget Estimate $428,405 $437,594 Adjusted per Participant Est. $421,595 $439,604 $458,621 $478,704 $499,910 Note: Budget estimate figures are from 1974 Dubuque City budget. Between 1968-1973 total expenditures average 3.2% total City budget. Per participant cost between 1968-1973 averaged .67. Park Board 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 Projected Total Park Attendance 1,247,086 1,273,274 1,300,612 1,327,312 1,355,185 Note: Projections based on average 2.1% per year increase in total attendance as indicated by trends from 1968-1973. Projected Total Expenditures 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 As a % of Total City Budget $382,128 $415,373 $451,511 $490,792 $533,491 On a per -parti- cipant basis $436,481 $445,645 $455,004 $464,559 $474,314 Budget Estimate $458,303 $430,359 Note: Budget estimate figures are from 1974 Dubuque City budget. Between 1968-1973 total expenditures averaged 3.2% of total City budget. Per person cost between 1968-1973 average .35. -ter Park Board Park Attendance 1968-1973 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 Reservations 108,187 111,233 105,727 87,237 96,438 NA Total Attendance 487,748 616,165 755,727 992,237 1,221,483 NA ' Note: In 1971 the reservation system was revised to more accurately estimate the total number of users thus accounting for the lower figure. 4 Park Expenditures 1968-1973 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 Total Expended $188,628 $196,409 $221,065 $412,417 $416,206 $418,713 11 3.9 % of Total 1.8 2.6 2.6 4.3 4.1 City Budget of Current Expense - _ 3.4 3.5 5.6 5.0 4.9 [dote: In 1971 the Park Board undertook massive tree planting programs and other urban beautification work. - 5 General Notes on the Projections 1. All estimates are essentially straightline projections based on trends from 1968-1973. None are adjusted to include an inflation factor, which, if applied, would merely raise all of the figures uniformly and would not affect the relative differences. 2. None of the projections anticipate the impact of major capital im- provements or substantial changes in program areas. It is nearly impossible to forecast the impact on budget and participation of facilities as ice rinks, etc. In most cases, however, such facil- ities are at least partially self-supporting through user fees. Capital costs may be financed in a number of ways which would vary with the specific project. 3. None of the projections anticipate major social or economic change within the population base but available figures indicate that dis- posal income, educational levels, etc. will continue to increase through 1990 (barring unforseen major disasters). While rising in- comes and educational levels are usually associated with greater de- mands for leisure time opportunities, much of the demand will be for commercial recreation activities and personal purchase and use of boats, motorcycles, bicycles, snowmobiles and other recreation ve- hicles. Some examples: a. Bicycle registrations in Dubuque have more than doubled in less than 3 years. There are half as - many bicycles as cars now registered. b. Motorcycle sales and registrations in Dubuque County have doubled between 1970 and 1973. c. Six hundred snowmobiles were registered in Dubu- que County in 1973. d. One thousand new boats were registered between 1972 and 1973. 4. Actual participation in specific recreation programs and use of park facilities will vary from year to year depending on a number of fac- tors including weather, programs and facilities available, local eco- nomic conditions and the like. In some program areas it is possible to project future participation levels with some degree of accuracy. In other program areas it is virtually impossible to forecast demand. 5. In terms of the projects proposed in the Recreation and Open Space Plan only a few specific projects such as the proposed ice rink and addition- al swimming pools would result in substantial increases in participation for these specific activities. User fees would at least partially support the operation of such facilities. Other existing facility improvement pro- jects may or may not have an impact on use of the facility. To attempt to project individual program participation rates and specific facility utili- zation would be nearly impossible except in certain cases where user fees are charged or attendance figures are known.