Loading...
Historic Resource Development Program Grant Application . . . , RESOLUTION NO. 25 - 99 RESOLUTION APPROVING THE SUBMISSION OF AN APPLICATION FOR mSTORIC RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM FUNDING TO CONDUCT AN HISTORIC PRESERVATION SURVEY. Whereas, the State Historical Society ofIowa has announced the availability of Historic Resource Development Program (HRDP grant program) funds; and Whereas, the evaluation and survey of properties are eligible activities for HRDP funding; and Whereas, the State Historical Society has advised that an historic preservation survey is necessary for the renewal of a Memorandum of Agreement between the State and City for the purposes of conducting local Section 106 reviews; and Whereas, the City of Dubuque Historic Preservation Commission has reviewed and endorsed the proposed historic survey. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA: Section 1. That the submission of an application for Historic Resource Development Program funds to conduct an historic preservation survey is hereby approved. Section 2. That the Community and Economic Development Director is herby authorized to sign the contract with and submit requests for reimbursements to the State Historical Society of Iowa for Historic Resource Development Program Funds to conduct an historic preservation survey. Section 3. That the City Manager is authorized to utilize budgeted Community Development Block Grant Funds to provide the required local match should the application be approved by the State Historical Society of Iowa. Section 4. That the City of Dubuque agrees to abide by all local, state and federal requirements applicable to the proposed project. Passed, approved and adopted this 18th day of January , 1999 ....... I / ,/ I: )'0/ //"/- :1<::' /" ',/ ;.-<:>t ~i /' . Terrance M. Dugga~..'Mayor ,.:~ . Attest: histpres\survey\hrdp\resoI uti, wpd For Staff Use only: Application # Date Received . STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY OF IOWA REAP/HISTORICAL RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM A PART OF THE RESOURCE ENHANCEMENT AND Pl~DTECTION PROGRAM GRANT APPLICATION FOR JANUARY 15, 1999 (FY20GO GRANTS) Read all instructions in the GraJl1S Manual before completing this applicarion. SECTION I Applicant rity nf n IIhl/CJIJP (319 ) 589-4393 Daytime Phone Number Mailing address Com munitv & Economic Development Department 50 West 13th Street City 0 IJhlJque State Iowa Zip Code 52001 Project Manager rynthirl '\tp;nhaIJspr ( 319 ) 589-4326 Daytime Phone Number E-Mail Address of project manager if available COM DE V @ M W C I* NET . Project Title FAX number of project manager if available 11Q-SRQ-414g Dubu ue Architectural & Historic Context Survey Project Location 50 West 13th Street Street Address Dubuque City Dubuque County Iowa House District # 35 & 36 Iowa Senate District # 18 U.S. Congressional # 2nd Grant Amount Requested (same as item a from budget page) l'OlS3 Cash Match Amount (same as item b from budget page) 950G In-Kind Amount (same as item c from budget page) N/A Total Project Cost (same as item d from budget page) 28258 Check the appropriate category for your application: ~ Historic Preservation Museum _ Documentary Collections 1 Application January 15, 1999 In order for the State of Iowa to reimburse you for the amount that is granted, and to comply with the IRS. regulations on reporting these payments, we must have the following information: Are you/your business an individual or sole proprietor? 0 YES ~ NO If the answer is YES, please provide your Social Security # If your answer is NO, please check the appropriate status: o Business and for-profit corporations o Partnership o Estate or trust o Not-for-profit corporation o State government. ~ Local government (county, city, town, school district, library, hospital, other) o Native American tribe Please provide your Federal Employer Identification # 42-6004596 This form is being used as a substitute for Department of Treasury Form W-9 Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification. Does the applicant own the historic resource? Yes. No X If one or more co-applicants are involved in the project, provide the name of each of the co-applicants, their mailing address, telephone number, and a contact person. Co-applicant N / A Street address City County Zip Telephone number ( ) Contact Person Telephone Number ( ) Co-applicant's status (check one): o Governmental unit or Not-for-profit o Individual o Business or For-profit corporation 2 Application January IS, 1999 . . . SECTION II Review Criteria: SIGNIFICANCE OF THE mSTORICAL RESOURCE AS IT RELA TIS TO THE PROPOSED PROJECT 1. Identify the historical resource in the proposed project. \Vhy is the resource important to state regional or local history? ' This project proposes to conduct a historic context survey throughout Dubuque and a more in-depth architectural survey in a portion of Dubuque's oldest neighborhoods. Dubuque is a community well- known for its historic beauty and, in particular, the Victorian architecture that makes up much of the existing five historic districts. However, there are a great many other influences in Dubuque that have yet to be recorded in detail to the extent that we have recorded the Victorian era influence. From an architectural standpoint, within our community exist building styles that represent the Craftsman, Classical and Colonial Revival eras of architecture among others. The most recent recordation of these styles is included in the 1975 publication, The Heritage of Dubuque. . . an architectural view. However, there is no recent survey information that discusses historic context for Dubuque through 1950 that provides us a link to the influence of architectural styles. Dubuque has been influenced by the manufacturing and industrial movement along the banks of the Mississippi. This resulted in the creation of residential neighborhoods adjacent to these factories. Also significant to these neighborhoods and to the Dubuque community is the predominance of Gem1an heritage in the target survey area. To view the targeted area, one can see the hundreds of two-story wood fran1e homes that fill each neighborhood and provide clues to the influence of these employers upon the growth patt,ems in our community. 3 Application January 15, 1999 Review Criteria: SIGNIFICANCE OR CONTRIBUTION OF THE PROJECT TO E~1IANCE THE PRESERVATION, CONSERVATION OR INTERPRETATION OF IOWA'S IDSTORlCAL RESOURCES 2. Describe your proposed project and how it relates to the historical resource identified in question I? Explain how the proposed project will enhance the preservation, conservation, and/or interpretation of your historical resources. Dubuque, as the oldest city in Iowa, is rich with history. Once the gateway to the west, the location of the city on the banks of the Mississippi River has resulted in significant growth for the city and State over the last 150 years. Adjacency to the river has influenced the growth o[lumber and lead mining industries in Dubuque and is a significant historical contributor to the commercial and residential growth patterns in our community over time. It has been nearly twenty years since a survey was completed. This early survey focused exclusively on Victorian architecture in Dubuque. I t is believed that there exists much in terms of historic context in Dubuque that has yet to be recorded. It is also assumed that over the last twenty years the number of National Register eligible properties in Dubuque has increased. Key factors in identifying the scope of historic contexts for Dubuque will include the progression of commercial and industrial development up to 1950 and the impact on the creation of additional residential structures. Factors that will influence architectural themes will include stylistic developments; works by major architects, craftsmen or developers; use of construction materials and method of construction. This is Part One of the proposed survey and the geographic area will consist of the city limits as identified in maps taken from the 1950's. '. Part Two of this survey will be to inventory, evaluate and provide data entry on those properties located in the residential neighborhood along Washington/Jackson/Elm Streets. During the inventory phase, the consultant will work with the City of Dubuque and property owners to gather data on the neighborhood's 1,033 structures. Included in this data will be information on property ownership, dates of construction, architects or contractors used, physical integrity and other items that relate to the property's significance as a National Register eligible property or district. This infol1nation then will be used for the evaluation phase of the survey. The Washington/Jackson/Elm Street neighborhood was selected based upon a number of factors. Specifically, this area continues to be the area where a higher percentage of Section 106 reviews are conducted for housing rehabilitation. It is anticipated that this trend will continue, as the City of Dubuque Housing Services Department has identified this area as a focal point for the Lead Paint Hazard Reduction Grant. That grant intends to eliminate conditions of lead hazard which may exist in the pre-1970 housing structures within the targeted area. Particular emphasis will be placed upon those structures which are pre-1950, the very structures which may have significant historic value. Therefore, it is vital that information pertaining to the historic and architectural context of this neighborhood be documented so as to support future Section 106 reviews. .~ Application January 15, 1999 . 3. . . Review Criteria: . KNOWLEDGE AND UNDERSTANDING OF ACCEPTED PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS AS THEY RELATE TO THE PROPOSED PROJECT Identify the professional standards, or best practices you will follow and explain how you will apply them in your project. This project will require a professional with expertise in the field of archival survey and documentation. The consultant to be hired must meet the professional qualifications standards as established by the Secretary of the Interior and the SHPO for both history and architectural history, having either a Master's Degree in American History, American Studies or a closely related field, or a Bachelor's Degree plus either two years full-time experience in research and writing or teaching or substantial contribution to the field. In addition, the City's historic preservation staff person, a GIS (Geographic Information System) staff person and, if possible, an intern will be involved in the survey in terms of project management and assisting in the collection of data, research, and/or photography. Requests for proposals will be sent to consultants identified in the approved list provided by the State Historical Society. Project goals will be accomplished by following the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Identification. Specifically: ~ Identification of historic properties is undertaken to the degree required to make decisions about eligibility. ~ Results of identification activities are integrated into the preservation planning process. , ~ Identification activities include explicit procedures for recordkeeping and information distribution. ~ Identification of historic contexts and architectural themes. ~ Evaluation of the significance of historic properties uses established criteria. ~ Evaluation of significance applies the criteria within identified historic contexts and architectural themes. ~ Evaluation results in an inventory of significant properties that is consulted in assigning registration and treatment priorities. ~ Evaluation results are made available to the public. 5 Applicationh January 15, 1999 Review Criteria: DEGREE OF THREAT TO THE RESOURCE 4. "Vhat "ill happen to your identified resource if this project is not funded? As indicated previously, this neighborhood is a target area for the Lead Hazard Reduction Grant progran1 as it is in an area where a higher percentage of housing rehabilitation projects occur. Because little information exists in this neighborhood in terms of architectural significance and historic context, it weakens the City's application of the Secretary of the Interior Standards to individual projects during the Section 106 review process. Often these projects involve significant alteration to the interior and exterior of the structures. Without new information as to the significance of these neighborhoods, we are at a higher risk of losing architectural features, compatible materials, irreversible alterations and other significant elements that assist in identifying the gro\\th of our community. Without documentation of significance to uphold the City's design standards, we are at risk oflosing structures or altering them inappropriately. Review Criteria: DEGREE TO WHICH THE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES OF THE PROJECT ENHANCE THE APPUCANT'S LONG-RANGE PLAN 5. "Vhat are your long-range goals and objectives for your historical resource? How will this project help you meet your goals and objectives? The Dlibuque Comprellensive Pla-n is the community's guide to future development, public policies, and decision making. The approved Comprehensive Plan include a number of long-range goals and objectives that relate to historic preservation in general and this project in particular. They are: 1) Preserve historic and aesthetic character and function of established neighborhoods; 2) Protect and preserve the City's historic buildings, urban pattern and natural environment; 3) Expand the City's use of housing preservation programs whenever appropriate and possible; 4) Safeguard the cultural and historic resources of the community as critical to the quality of life and the attractiveness of Dubuque; 5) Promote the preservation of historic buildings and architectural resources in the community; 6) Educate the conmllmity about the benefits of historic preservation to the community's quality oflife, economic development efforts, tourism and tax base enhancement; 7) Explore, preserve and interpret for present and future generntions, the history of Dubuque and the Mississippi River; and 8) Increase appreciation, education, tcchnical assistance and funding for the community's historical and architectural heritage. This grnnt application proposes to identify historic contexts or themes within the city limits of Dubuque, identify corresponding nrchitectural themes and styles and apply this information to the surveying of a specific residential arca for dctennining National Register eligible properties or districts. Future surveys conducted will be based UpOl thc infonuation obtained regarding historic contexts and architectural themes and follow a similar process involving data collection, survey and site evaluation, use of the Iowa Site Inventory form, photography and incorporation into the City's GIS system. 6 Application January 15, 1999 Review Criteria: DEGREE TO WHICH THE PROJECT SUPPORTS THE ECONOMIC, EDUCATIONAL AND CULTURAL HEALTH OF THE LOCAL AREA, REGION, OR STATE ' . 6. How ,"ill yo~r proposed project affect the economy in your area, attract tourism, and lead to more education and/or appreciation of history? As a river community, Dubuque is a destination point for over one million tourists annually. Every year these tourists are surveyed, and each year they identify historic architecture and historic context as one of the top five reasons to visit Dubuque. By researching our community to discover new historic themes and document architecture influenced by these themes, we will continue to provide new reasons for tourists to return to Iowa and to Dubuque. In addition, using the new survey information we will obtain, we can work with property owners planning to undertake a rehabilitation project and educate them on the significance of their structures and attempt to mitigate any potential loss through a Section 106 review. Working with the Housing Services Department and the historic preservation staff person, we can educate the property owners on alternative methods for addressing rehab projects while meeting the needs of housing and historic preservation. . Review Criteria: DEGREE OF COOPERATION BETIVEEN ORGANIZATIONS OR INDIVIDUALS WITIllN A LOCAL AREA REGION OR THE STATE AS EVIDENCED BY BUT NOT illllTED TO THE NUMBER OF VOLUNTEERS, CASH MATCH, AND IN-Krnn MATCH 7. Ex~lain how other groups and individuals in your community or area will be involved with ~~. ~ This project will be coordinated with several City departments in addition to sharing the information with other historic preservation entities and the general public. Specifically, the historic preservation staff person, the consultant and the intern will work with the Planning Services Department to coordinate incorporation of the information into the City's GIS system and ensure coordination of the project objectives with the previously approved Dubuque Comprehensive Plan. In addition the historic preservation staff person will work in conjunction with Housing Services staff to implement the results of the survey in the Section 106 review process for homeowners undertaking a lead reduction or housing rehabilitation project. Lastly, information obtained will be shared with the City Council, the Historic Preservation Commission, the Dubuque County Historical Society and the Center for Dubuque History to help further the preservation goals of the community. . 7 Application January 15, 1999 Review Criteria: DEGREE TO WHICH THE BUDGET IS REASONABLE. APPROPRIATE TO THE PROJECT, COMPLETE AND MATHEMATICALLY CORRECT 8. Explain to us the workplan and budget for your project. step and the cost . -P~oJecf COmpleilOn Schedule July 1999 Contract signed by Applicant & State; August 1999 September 1999 November 1999 December 1999 Jan. - Mar. 2000 Apr. - June 2000 July - Aug. 2000 Sept. - Oct. 2000 Nov. - Dec. 2000 & Jan. 2001 Feb. 2001 March 2001 April 2001 May 2001 June 2001 8 Application Issue RFP Review proposals & consultant selected Consultant contract signed Phase 1 survey begins - Review resource material and conduct windshield survey of the City (part 1) Survey and on-site evaluation begins with photography in the neighborhood area (part 2) Intensive site survey completed of the neighborhood Literature/Archival research to develop historic and architectural contexts as well as specific information on the neighborhood Property data collection Analysis of data and sites; draft final report Review draft of final report Public presentation Iowa Site Inventory Forms completed Include each step, the order of each Budget $1500 consultant fee, mileage & per diem $7376 consultant field work, mileage & per diem $6900 consultant research $400 telephone/fascimile $250 equipment $500 supplies $100 postage $5355 intern fees $439 consultant time, mileage & perdiem Photography completed and attached to $2000 film and development. . site forms Final report prepared and submitted to City $2500 photocopying and State Public presentation $438 consultant time, mileage & perdiem Identify and prioritize additional survey areas based upon historic and architectural contexts identified in the final report January 15, 1999 s':,~~'oc< ,~ '0 '(:"R"---' '---.. '" ~ ~ " \ i5 " :> z ji .'-... ,.-,\ , \ \ '" " STA Tl I / CITY OF DUBUQUE LOW/AND MODERATE INCOME AREA .I .......... /-.......- :0 ~---.. -\ ...., . ~ r~ \. '\ \ , SECTION III . 9. If this is a facility open to the public, give the schedule of hours open and total number of hours . per year. (page 4 in the manual) Schedule of hours open to the public ----.Ji/14 Hours open per year 10. If the facility is not open to the public as required (see page 4 of manual), describe the plans for increasing accessibility to the public during the next three years, (unless restricted by specific Federal or State Code). N {14 . 11. If funded, how will you use the Technical Advisory Network services in helping you complete your grant project? As previously stated, this project requires a professional with experience in the field of archival survey and documentatio'n. The TAN will be used to help identify potential consultants for the position. In addition, the TAN may be used in an advisory capacity to the City and the hired consultant in meeting the project goals. Specifically, identifying historic contexts and architecturals themes to be used for future survey work. In addition, the TAN may be useful in identifying the procedure to use to incorporate the information into both the City of Dubuque's existing GIS system and integration into the SHPOs electronic filing system. . 10 Application January 15, 1999 USE "VHOLE DOLLAR AMOUNTS FOR ALL FIGURES. DO NOT USE PENNIES!!!! 1. Consultant Services Architectural/Historian Fee r.onc;1l1ti'lnt Ppr Deim Grant Request 13,830 1997 2. Personnel Use GIS/Planninq Intern 3. Contract for Services 4. Supply Expense Film & Development Photo CODving Postaqe Mi<::r (<::oftwi'lrp, ci'lmpri'l) 1,600 5. Equipment Expense (0 rn pllter E ouip m ent Telephone/F ax 6. Travel Expense r. onslllti'lnt Mileage 826 7 . TAN Services 500.00 8. Other Expense COLUMN TOTALS (a) 18.753 BUDGET Cash Match In-Kind Match 5,355 400 2.500 100 500 250 400 (b) 9.505 (c) 17ze total of the first three columns must equal the project total figure. Sub-Total 13.830 1997 5.355 2.000 2,500 100 500 250 400 826 'inn (d) 28.258 USE WHOLE DOLLAR A1MOUNTS FOR ALL FIGURES. DO NOT USE PENNIES!!!!!!!!!!!!! 9 Application January 15, 1999 SECTION IV ASSURANCES . NOTE: PLEASE SIGN THE "ASSURANCES" PAGE IN AN INK OTHER THAN BLACK. SO IT IS EASY TO TELL THE ORIGINAL SIGNATURE FROM THE PHOTOCOPIES. THE APPLICANT HEREBY AGREES AND ACKNOWLEDGES THAT: (1) if awarded funds, the applicant will conduct operations in accordance with Title VI and VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended in the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as amended, which bar discrimination against any employee, applicant, for employment, or any person participating in any sponsored program on the basis of race, creed, color, national origin, religion, sex, age, or physical or mental disability, and require compensation for employment at no less than minimum wage requirements, and will provide safe and sanitary working conditions; (2) if project involves real property, the applicant or co-applicant can prove ownership of the property. (3) the applicant will expend funds solely on the described project and programs; (4) if the proposed project affects a property listed on the National Register of Historic Places, the applicant will consult with the State Historical Society of Iowa, and also will act in accordance with the Secretaty of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings and the Secretary of the Interior I s Standards for Archaeology and Historical Preservation. . (5) If Awarded Funds. Applicant Will Include In All Official Statements. Promotions. Publicity. Advertisin~. Siens. And In Any Printed Document. Audio Visual Production. Or MicrofIlmed Material The Followin~ Credit Line: "Tms PROJECT WAS PARTIALLY SUPPORTED THROUGH FUNDING FROM THE RESOURCE ENHANCEMENT AND PROTECTION (REAP) ACT THROUGH A mSTORICAL RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM (REAP/HRDP) GRANT FROM THE STATE mSTORICAL SOCIETY OF IOWA"; (6) The facts, figures, and information contained in this application, including all attachments, are true and correct; and (7) failure to comply with the administrative rules for this program will result in the penalties outlined in those rules. Signature of Legally Authorized Representative Date .yped Name and Title of Above 11 Application January 15, 1999 . . ~ ...q.~ CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA MEMORANDUM January 13, 1999 TO: The Honorable Mayor and City Council Members FROM: Michael C. Van Milligen, City Manager SUBJECT: Historic Resource Development Program . Community and Economic Development Director Jim Burke is recommending approval of an application to the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) for a Historic Resource Development grant to conduct a historic preservation survey. The Fiscal Year 1999 budget allocated $15,000 of CDBG funds to be used as a match toward funding a historic preservation survey. I concur with the recommendation and respectfully request Mayor and City Council approval. / J Ii/I ;, /ntvizwl k~ /M~ Michael C. Van Milligen MCVM/j Attachment cc: Barry Lindahl, Corporation Counsel Tim Moerman, Assistant City Manager Jim Burke, Community and Economic Development Director . . . . . CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA MEMORANDUM January 7, 1999 To: From: Re: Historic Resource Development Program Grant Application Introduction This memorandum presents for City Council review and approval an application to the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) for a Historic Resource Development grant to conduct a historic preservation survey. Background The City of Dubuque, as a recipient of funding from the Department of Housing and Urban Development is required to perform a Section 106 review for every rehabilitation or construction project receiving federal funds. Specifically, projects that involve Community Development Block Grant or HOME funds are required to have a Section 106 review completed before beginning the project. The purpose of a Section 106 review is to assess the historic and architectural significance of the property being impacted and to recommend any mitigation of the exterior historic features of the property. The City of Dubuque has a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with the SHPO to conduct Section 106 reviews locally versus sending all reviews to SHPO for review and approval. This process can take 30 - 90 days or more depending on the demand for reviews from across the State of Iowa. Currently, these reviews are handled by the a staff person in the Community and Economic Development Department in less than one week. The State is in the process of updating our MOA and we have had some discussion regarding potential changes. The Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) is the federal agency that regulates MOAs between the State and local government. The ACHP has communicated to the Iowa SHPO that our new MOA should include a component that commits the City to conducting historic surveys on a more regular basis. It has been nearly 20 years since the last historic survey was completed in Dubuque. The criteria for National Register Eligibility have changed since that time and the City needs to update its information base with a new survey. The State of Iowa has two grant programs that are potential sources of funding for a portion of the costs of a historic survey. They are the Certified Local Government Grant Program and the Historic Resource Development Grant Program. Both grants require matching funds. Previously an . . . . , " application for a CLG grant was submitted to assist in funding the survey. However, the City will not receive word on whether or not that application will be funded until April 1, 1999, well after the January 15 deadline has expired for application for the use ofHRDP funds. Discussion Attached is an application for a HRDP grant to conduct a preliminary historic preservation survey. The proposed survey is broken into two parts: 1) research on historic contexts and supporting architectural themes throughout the entire community; and, 2) intensive survey of a specific neighborhood applying these historic contexts and architectural themes. The historic themes will include research on the impact of industrial and commercial development upon residential structures from 1830 -1950. By conducting a community-wide assessment of historic contexts, this survey will be used as a foundation to help shape future, required neighborhood surveys. The neighborhood proposed for the intensive portion of the survey is bounded by 14th Street on the south, Central Avenue on the west, 24th Street on the north and Ann Street on the east. A map of this area is attached for your review. This survey area was selected because a higher percentage of Section 106 reviews are received from this area as a result of receiving federal rehabilitation funds from the Housing Services Department. It is anticipated that additional Section 106 reviews will be requested from addresses identified in this area with the implementation of the Lead Paint Hazard Reduction Grant. The total cost for the survey as describe is estimated at $28,258 and includes a budget line item of $500 for TAN (Technical Advisory Network) services. This is a required budget item by the State that makes technical advisors available to potential grantees to assist in the implementation of their proposed project. The sources of funding for this project include $9,505 local CDBG funds and $18,753 HRDP grant funds. The Amended Fiscal Year 1999 Budget has allocated $15,000 of CDBG funds to be used as a match toward funding a historic preservation survey. lfthe grant is awarded, the project will run from July 1999 to June 2001. Recommendation I recommend that the City of Dubuque submit an application for a HRDP grant for the proposed preservation survey. The attached resolution initiates the grant submission. It approves the local match, and stipulates that the City will meet all applicable program requirements. Action Step The requested action is for City Council to adopt the attached resolution. Prepared by: Cynthia M. Steinhauser, Neighborhood Development Specialist histpres\survey\hrdp\hrdpcc. wpd