Loading...
Sunset Ridge Sidewalk Installation Waiver_720 Sunset RidgeFREUND LAW FIRM, P.C. John D. Freund 1005 Main Street, Suite 200 Dubuque IA 52001 jdfreund@jdfreundlaw.com Telephone: (663) 587 -8050\ Facsimile: (888) 626 -7317 www.jdfreundlaw.co Admitted in Iowa and Wisconsin March 8, 2012 Dubuque City Council Office of City Clerk City Hall 50 W. 13th Street Dubuque, IA 52001 A7/7,d 0,7/„ zy RECEVFD 12 PEAR -8 PH 1: 30 City Clerk's Office Dubuque, IA RE: TIMOTHY AND KELLY SHERMAN / 720 SUNSET RIDGE SIDEWALK INSTALLATION AND WAIVER Dear Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council: We represent Timothy and Kelly Sherman, who reside at 720 Sunset Ridge in Dubuque. On their behalf, we are requesting a waiver of the requirement that they install a sidewalk pursuant to City Code of Ordinances, Section 10 -1 -2. As you may recall, Sunset Ridge was the subject of a major reconstruction project, including the installation and /or upgrading of city street, curb, and sewer, as well as the installation of sidewalks. This matter came before the City Council on August 2, 2010, and between the collaboration of city staff, the residents of Sunset Ridge, and the sharing and listening by and between the taxpayers and the City Council, the reconstruction project was underway and was concluded successfully, in the opinion of the undersigned and the Shermans. The result of that issue, as you may also recall, is that sidewalks were installed/constructed along only the west side of Sunset Ridge. Many opinions were shared during this process, including the merits of sidewalks for promotion of walking. The Shermans do not dispute the usefulness of a sidewalk as part of a larger network of adjoining sidewalks. However, when the Shermans purchased their lot at 720 Sunset Ridge, they were informed by the seller, Tim McNamara, that the City and the neighbors had negotiated a resolution whereby sidewalks would not be required on the east side of the street. Had they realized that the City would require a sidewalk on their lot, then they would have requested a waiver prior to purchasing the lot, which closing occurred on September 22, 2010. We note that this was mere weeks after the council's action on August 2, 2010. The Shermans have been alerted that they are required to install a sidewalk along their property, and their request for a waiver has been denied by the City Engineer. Enclosed for your reference are (1) the written denial and (2) an aerial photograph of our client's lot. Unfortunately, this photograph was taken in 2009 and does not show the improvements to Sunset Ridge, including the sidewalk installation along the west side. For decades, substantially all of the houses along Sunset Ridge had no sidewalks, and that fact is revealed by the enclosed aerial photograph. While we admit that construction and reconstruction projects should generally include the installation of sidewalks, we believe that this particular situation warrants a waiver from the City Council regarding the sidewalk requirements of the City of Dubuque. We also enclose for your reference correspondence from our clients to the City Manager's office, which the City Engineer's denial addressed. We understand the rationale used by the City Engineer, but we ask the City Council to examine some additional data: 1. The reconstruction project voted on in 2010 was a good balance between the sidewalk ordinances and the nature and character of the Sunset Ridge neighborhood, and nothing material has changed regarding that neighborhood since August 2, 2010. 2. After polling twenty -one (21) residents of Sunset Ridge, eighteen (18) returned surveys stating that they either had no opinion (1 response) or that, in their opinions, the sidewalk requirement for 720 Sunset Ridge was not appropriate and that any sidewalk would be mostly unused, aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and a waste of resources (17 responses). Three (3) of the residents did not return a response, and none of the residents reported that installation of a sidewalk at 720 Sunset Ridge was an appropriate requirement. For your reference, we enclose the responses from these neighbors, who were all informed that they might be shared with you. 3. Sunset Ridge is a dead -end street. Only residents of that street and their invitees pass along the street (by vehicle or on foot) with any frequency. While others are certainly welcomed by the residents to walk through, there is no need to have a sidewalk along both sides of the street. The west sidewalk provides sufficient passage through the neighborhood for the number of people utilizing it. In our opinion, sidewalk installation on the east side of the street is an all -or- nothing issue. We do not mean to suggest that you should re -open the issue of having a fully- extended sidewalk along the east side of Sunset Ridge. Rather, there has been no showing of a need for more sidewalk in that neighborhood, and certainly no showing of the need for sidewalk in front of one house only. Unless and until there is a need for the entire east side of the street to have sidewalks, it does not make much sense to have sporadic sections of sidewalk along the east side. We do not believe that granting a waiver to the Shermans would have any precedential value, because these waivers are driven by individual facts, and sometimes it would not be beneficial or logical to grant a waiver. In this case, we believe that there are sufficient grounds for granting this request. We ask that this request for waiver be incorporated within the next available City Council agenda and that the undersigned and /or the Shermans be permitted to speak to you personally about this matter. Thank you for your time and consideration. Best Regards, FREUNI) LAW FIRM, P.C. Enclosures By John D. Freund SET ROG t,a1,0* SUB. OF LOT 1% 9 -9 -2011 Mr. Mike Van Milligan City Manager Dear Mike, My wife and I purchased lot 16 on Sunset Ridge last year. (Now 720 Sunset Ridge) We bought the lot understanding that the street and utilities will be new and we would be assessed for the project. When we bought the lot from Tim McNamara, he said the west side of the street would have sidewalks, and that the east side of the street (our side) did not have to. We were told that the street was pushed a little further to the east side of the street so the west side would have more room for sidewalks. Yesterday, I was talking to Jon Dienst, and he said we may have a problem if we do not put a sidewalk on our side of the street. I made contact with city employees and was made aware of ordinance No. 86 -04, which took affect on May 4th, 2009. My wife and I are asking you to please give us a sidewalk exemption. We do not want the cost associated with or the maintenance of the sidewalk. I understand a couple more residents on Sunset Ridge are also going to or have applied for an exemption from sidewalks on the east side of the street because of additions that require a building permit. Please get back to us soon. We hope to proceed as planned without a sidewalk on the front of our property. Sincerely, Tim Sherman Current Address 1097 Rush Street Dubuque, IA. 52003 Home #563.582.4156 Cell #563.590.3959 Masterpiece on the Mississippi September 28, 2011 Mr. & Mrs. Timothy Sherman 1097 Rush Street Dubuque IA 52003 Re: Public Sidewalk Installation - 720 Sunset Ridge Dear Mr. & Mrs, Sherman, Engineering Department City Hall. 50 W. 13th Street Dubuque, Iowa 52001 563.589.4270 6.63.589.4205 (fax) www ;cityofdubuque.org This letter is to-notify you of the City Code of Ordinances, Chapter 10 -2 -1 that reqiiires installation of public sidewalk whenever a development or redevelopment occurs on a property which abuts a street with curb and gutter. After a discussion with the City Manager regarding your request to waive the sidewalk installation requirement, it was his conclusion that.the walk should be installed. Lot 16 of Sunset Ridge was a vacant lot when the Sunset Ridge Reconstruction Project was initiated and during the project it came to the City's attention that you planned to build a single family residence on this lot. Public water and sanitary sewer were installed as paxt of the reconstruction project for your lot. Sidewalks were installed on the west side of Sunset Ridge as part of the street reconstruction project, but not on the east side at this time. However the east side was graded, obstructions removed from the right -of -way, and walks installed through the driveways for any developments or redevelopments that would initiate the sidewalk installation requirement . Ordinances supporting the sidewalk installation requirement include Ordinance #86 -04, approved and adopted December 20, 2004; Ordinance #25 -09 revised with the effective date of May 4, 2009; and Ordinance #44 -09, approved and adopted on September. 8, 2009. City Council passed the ordinances 7 -0, 6 -1 and 7 -0 respectively. This installation requirement is found in the City Code, Title 10, Chapter 1 -2, As part of the ordinance, exceptions and/or waivers can only be granted in full or partially by the City Manager or City Council. As stated above, public Sidewalk is required, aridhas been requfred since the May 4, 2009.ordinance, "When the owner of any lot or parcel in the city,, that abuts upon any improved public street that has concrete. or stone curb, ha1Lat the owners cost, install to standard qty specifications sidewalk along the fuJi length of the portion. of the lot or parcel abutting the public :et when saidlot or parcel is developed or redeveloped or at. the direction of City COunciL" Over time as other properties on theeast side: of Sunset Ridge make improvements., thatfall into the .conditions as set forthin the.ordinarices, they .alsowilj. be required to install: public sidewalk. With. the efforts to. be:a "sustainable conununity", a continuous -walking network would promote health:, eliminate excess carbon emissions, better conned neighborhood residents and provide a safe route. for pedestrians, :bicyclists, and mobility options for all ages: and abilities:. Your Options at this time. wouId be to comply arid install the Walk with a one- year graceperiod to complete construction: Or to submit your -Waiver request to the City Council yia. the Office of City Clerk, City Ball, 5 0 W. 13th. The regular -Scheduled. council meetings. are the first -and. third. Monday of each month with submittal of documents. to the, Office of City Clerk; City Ha% 50 W. 13th, PubligneylOvva, 52001, on the WedneS.clay prim'. to the scheduled meeting. If there is any other it-derma-U(4110u wish regarding this issue please contact my Office. Gus Psihoyos City Engineer cc: Michael C. Van Milli gen, City Manager Cindy Steinhauser, Asst. City Manager Crenna Brumwell, Asst. City Attorney Rich Russell, Bldg. Services Mgr. Jon. Dienst, P.E., C.E. Ron Turner, R.L.S. Jane Smith, EAII FAJANE SMITH \ Sidewalks\ INSTALL \ Appeals \ 720 Sunset Ridge SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk.for public use on theirproperty at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check one): This is an appropriate requirement by the City of-Dubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement,b -the City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly unused; will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. U4le have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: Dated ,2012. Please sign below: Please sign below: By _ KH, Lol c4 S (,O {4 . By Print Name: IJ1 cc t G J Od Print Name: Print Address: G-15 Swut ld 9 Print Address: -b1/ j, S2063. SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk£or public use oii theirproperty at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check orie): This is an appropriate requirement by the City of Dubuque, and the Sherman should construct the sidewalk as requested. X- This is an inappropriate requirement bythe City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly unused, will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood. and will be a waste of resources. UWe have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: XdR- Dated -3��/ / a , 2012. Please sign below: / Please sign below: By /47 By / W G Print Name: 0 �� / g—Tt� ( ws& r/c.Print Name: a r (J2 r 1.'""2 2' Print Address: aZa 4 fi Print Address: // cC bk1 s..- l- 4 'mac) SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk.for public use otitheir-property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion ()lithe undersigned (please check one): This is an appropriate requirement by the City of Dubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement -by the City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly unused, will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood_ and will be a waste of resources. I NWe have no opinion. ADDITIONAL CCMML-'NTS: Dated r% i /1 ,2012. Pleases -n below: Please sign below: . ♦ By nl Name: ✓ArtA/N�D " Print Name: Print Address: %S-SL /.vf(r air 5e(5 't- .LGr S Print Address: John D. Freund From: Sent: To: Subject: Kennedy Ugkdub @mchsi.comj Sunday, February 12, 2012 12:32 PM jdfreu nd @jdfreundlaw.com Tim & Kelly Sherman sidewalk John, We receive our mail late due to it being forwarded, but I have replied today by mail regarding the Sherman sidewalk matter. I agree that the sidewalk does nothing for the neighborhood and it seems like the City of Dubuque is imposing a financial expense on Sherman rather than being practical in governing our City. I am emailing these comments since the return letter may not reach you by the time you address the City Council on behalf of Mr. & Mrs. Sherman. James G. Kennedy 595 Sunset Ridge Dubuque, IA. SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalkfor public use on their property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check one): This is an appropriate requirement by the City of Dubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. k This is an inappropriate requirement by-lhe City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly.unused, will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. I /We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: ors, (Zgo Of r rni lii' /,» ,p v- SIo6,T I ,,t} / �10732Z���LU >�� Dated 2012. /& &'. I ,g fv�—� 4�'� Please sign below: Please sign below: By � Print Name: �1UJt/ Cre / Print Name: By Print Address: ,LZ,) S1 27? f0 ���� 5 • d ) 5/de tt>�t -(plc , Print Address: SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalkforpublic use on their property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check one): This is an appropriate rogiirement by the City of Dubuque, and the Sherman should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate rcquirement,.bythe City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly. iinused, will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. I/We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: Dated D `i FE i ' , 2012. Please sign below: By e4'74E Print Name: 7174- Print Address: -Oo Y2 /Ot3E 7) it c' cza' )v 57.7 car Please sign below: By 1L �J o� Print Name: M. / t, L F,'e3 /c r Print Address: 790 S 4 3 e <-17 14. 2 003 SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk for public use on their - property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, [A 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check one): This is an appropriate requirement by the City ofDsibuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement by the City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly •unused, will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. IIN e have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: Dated . 2012. Please sign below: By Name: I—• ®asi7)¢-- Print Name: c& r4 /}1 fin% Print Address: 7$ 54,rf' ,4, `1.- -Print Address: 757 65 V,usf '- �r Additional Comments to Survey Regarding Tim and Kelly Sherman Property at 750 Sunset Ridge The need for the construction of a sidewalk of any kind was a significant issue of discussion with city staff in the months during which plans were being drawn for the reconstruction of Sunset Ridge. It was the consensus of the households residing on the street that a sidewalk was not necessary. However, it was the opinion of city legal staff that in order to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act and for the safety of those who might chose to walk on Sunset Ridge that a sidewalk was necessary. Residents retained legal counsel to represent their point of view, and to explore legal issues with city legal staff. While it was not possible to change the city's position completely vis -a -vis the sidewalk, a suitable compromise was reached: (1) a sidewalk would be constructed on the west side of the street with particular care that disruption to existing landscaping be minimized, (2) that considerations be made for those properties with very small distances between the proposed sidewalk and (3) that a narrower than standard road width would be allowed to preserve the country -like ambiance of the neighborhood. With excellent cooperation between city engineering staff, contractors, and homeowners what could have been a contentious project moved along as smoothly as one could have hoped with a positive end result. It is our belief that requiring the Sherman to construct a sidewalk along the front of their handsome new construction is completely contrary to the letter and the spirit of the Sunset Ridge residents' arrangement with the city legal staff, pointless and strange — "a sidewalk from and to nowhere," and would be immensely displeasing in terms of aesthetics for the Sherman's property as well as for our entire neighborhood. We join others in requesting that the requirement that a sidewalk be constructed be amended. SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the Citx of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk for publio use on their-property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (phase check one): This is an appropriate requirctrtent by the City of: Di buque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement .by the City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly - :unused; will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. UWe have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: !.. (/4 1Qn�� �ln1P ii3a1 < in . ,i4-- of A -{PW hw,sPt on 5, e tt oe-+ W;1( QL! -hia.l l,( /du v Ik Confosi,n V.0-14't hazard -(a Dated tr-L. `t' , 2012. PeCte AY;vk Please sign .elow: Print Name: Print Address: K,(% •.. • l S� tier 21fXJ1� Please sign below: By Print Name: Ara jJ —1-11 A I QZ__ Print Address: (010 Jf4 fET Rt ET SURVEY The undersigned is/arc aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalkior pubIid use on their property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check otic): This is an appropriate requirement by the City of,D_ubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement by- the City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly unused; will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. UWe have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: Dated Please sign below: By Print Name: Print Address: , 2012. Please sign below: By a Print Name: Wiz,' Print Address: 7,5 c j ,L, 5L.- I i-p �%t'Bg 0 .Zcv'A SURVEY 'hc undersigned is /arc aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk.forpubIi use On-their property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check one): This is an appropriate requirement by the City of Dubuque, and the Sherman should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement- by-the -City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly-i iriused; will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. 1 /We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: Dated Please sign below: By , 2012. Please sign below: Print Name: _Ge C/,,,.,iPrintName: Print Address: X049 4a-taSc / /66C. -• Print Address: SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk.forpnbhcuse on theirproperty at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (plase check arie): This is an appropriate requirement by the City o f :Dubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement.by the City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostliused, will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. I/We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: t._ L4 _A a. F 5kg -A-n a1,3a sC'Fit`liOw o■• 45 131, (1) 1)c., NVP 047' /-r- A1_c', Arse 'T'iC�Fr ltn c� SFFrvS A 11 F ©,_in 3 Nn ' (�Y 14,'eF-ul l0 1 O- illLL UQ w4 C"a5ac_v `r-co ie4...cs S 4ro o+-+ Dated la 7 Please si By low: �) Print Name: .-(e1.1-e_ v-■ , 2012. Please sign below: By Print Name: Print Address: 0- 5 5 ibe. Print Address: SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk,tor- -public use on'their- property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check oite): This is an appropriate requirement by the City gf-Dubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement.by'the City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly -unused` will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. I/We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: • 3Kt Sre.iP alt w0+( AC Pc-OY i. r\C` %t t o hJ r - • e L&SU.4 - - , Dated 2-3-- , 2012. Please sign below: o n By U uu, \`l t�c$�✓ Print Name: \q Please sigrylelow: By QL•'' Print N Print Address: (s. )(j ) L& (d. r t Print Address:g6 siad$t SURVEY The undersigned is/are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk for public use o`n their property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check oiig): This is an appropriate requirement by the City of.Ditbuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement;by -the City of Dubuque, and in my/our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly:unused, will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. I/We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: 7t1.64 �C� C� I. CLICLC�L2 LGU / /�. 411 J _71.L. gA Dated '—// /02 ,2012. Please sign below: By Print Name: ,jt,tgo h 4. I,C) h I e 1+- Print Address: Please sign below: By Print Name: Print Address: 744.3 SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk for publi use on their property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check one): This is an appropriate requirement by the City of 'Dubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement by the City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly unused, will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood_ and will be a waste of resources. I/We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: Dated 0/ 17. � 2012. Please sign below: Please sign below: By j0. -.(.__ �` DS �c ci By Print Name: 1' u L 1�TPJr Print Name: / `j i' es Let jc Print Address: .S 3 0 J 1S e + icIq Print Address: 2,0 G SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk-for public use on their-property at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check one): • This is an appropriate retnirement by the City e Dubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement.by the-City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostlySinusedd will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. 1/We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: s k - l72.t0 Lt/' _4124-6,4 .MCP C44~ 26, at cc m,4,ddd �q((07t, { Pr �t xlt0 u -apt Dated 9/ i Please sign By Print Name: Ala 7fNPU MAO— , 2012. Please sign below: By %1 Print Name: J c n rs. / /.A Print Address: S60 �uc•:cr QI �t Print Address: .5 t c Saa ar t e) c--, SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalkfor public use on their proterty at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check one): 1 ; ! This is an appropriate requirerent by the City gf:20i buque, and the Sherman should construct the sidewalk as requested. 1f . This is an inappropriate requirementby_t(te -City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion. any sidewalk constructed will be mostly- wuaused ; will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. I/We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: . U /2 Dated 7:-/./4 .9 Please sign .47 By 744 c , 2012. Please sign below: ' // By Print Name: ODG______ Print Name: Print Address: 7S'Y /2 p%r�•, � e, 5-?.rao3 Print Address: jezti zeu:A_e J �i 44.7 (/�7 ar M 2pCr .4/02; -e 6Iv, i�j�✓ SURVEY The undersigned is/are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk.for public use on theirproperty at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check one): This is an appropriate requirement by the City of Dubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. This is an inappropriate requirement by -the City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly.iinused; will be aesthetically ow of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. I /We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: Dated FP 12 l� Please sign Below: By �`t c b Print N. ie al Print Address: jD .')l s 1Se+ '26406 • , 2012. Please sig By to Print Name: SURVEY The undersigned is /are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewalk for public use on theirproperty at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check one): This is an appropriate requirement by the City et Dubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. t� This is an inappropriate requirement,.bythe -City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mostly tinused, will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. I,'Wc have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: Dated " 7 -1� , 2012. Please sign below: By f i/.e �'! By (� -c-L 7 Print Name: f ( 5 K k Print Name: ®'f y c c A L to / Print Address: 5 lift S�Lif e Print Address: SURVEY The undersigned is/are aware that the City of Dubuque has required that Tim Sherman and Kelly Sherman construct a sidewallefor public use ontheirproperty at 720 Sunset Ridge, Dubuque, IA 52003. In the opinion of the undersigned (please check ore): � I This is an appropriate requirement by the City af'Dubuque, and the Shermans should construct the sidewalk as requested. s is an inappropriate rcquirement,by the City of Dubuque, and in my /our opinion, any sidewalk constructed will be mosfly- nused;' will be aesthetically out of place in the neighborhood, and will be a waste of resources. I /We have no opinion. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: r S D LI . CI 3 S �a i �E C, 4-', 1,1tI " >i� ,c\ 0. S e in al a ., t... 1� ;, ;�e �,tc eve I�k,.� b� l ��d c.)af 4)° (4. AL LU.ik rN 1.j CC(CL)J+ r r Dated , 2012. Please sign below: Please siggnn./l low: By l•L By V"1" / Print Name: `t) ice. CL C b,1 , Print Name: / ^ \ /CL Print Address: U6, 1S jt,l� -C- -( ll,t Print Address: i 1-1\ S v' t 1 7 3 S LD