Loading...
Transit Division FY 2017 Budget PresentationCity of Dubuque SUMMARY: SUGGESTED DISPOSITION: Copyright 2014 Public Hearings # 4. Transit Division FY2017 Budget Presentation ATTACHMENTS: Description Type Transit Division FY17 Recommended Budget Supporting Documentation Transit Division -91- This page intentionally left blank. -92- TRANSIT DIVISION Transit Levy Incr. (Decr.) in Transit Fund Bal. Property Tax Support Percent Increase (Decrease) Personnel - Authorized FTE 1,086,080 896,852 * 896,852 1,172,885 30.8% (406,817) (5,631) 649,380 - 1,086,080 896,852 896,852 1,172,885 276,033 38.33 41.02 41.02 41.02 KI8I:YA *In FY 2016, the Transit Division reconfigured bus routes, modified the summer trolley service and changed to City management for a savings of $374,236. This savings was used to offset the cost of funding the Nightrider Route ($46,913 in FY16), operations of the Intermodal Facility ($29,962), Intercultural Competency training ($3,375), and increasing the General Fund Reserve ($196,212). -93- % Change FY 2014/15 FY 2015/16 FY 2015/16 FY 2016/17 from Adopted Budget Highlights Actual Adopted Amended Recomm'd FY 2015/16 Employee Expense 1,976,261 2,295,950 2,295,950 2,408,357 4.9% Supplies and Services 1,361,333 1,050,704 1,101,339 1,067,919 1.6% Machinery and Equipment 1,916 25,249 25,249 30,798 22_0% Total 3,339,510 3,371,903 3,422,538 3,507,074 4.0% Resources FTA Operating 501,267 1,093,168 1,537,414 1,110,417 1.6% State Operating Assisting 242,876 249,319 249,319 279,748 12.2% Federal Pass-Thru Grant 552,672 507,049 739,305 284,227 -43.9% Medicaid Reimbursement - - 24,000 48,000 0.0% Advertising Fees 50,012 40,000 40,000 40,000 0.0% Mini Bus Passenger Fares 88,113 137,837 137,837 125,569 -8.9% Fixed Route Passenger Fares 234,201 254,671 254,671 222,507 -12.6% Intermodal Ramp Transit Fees - 12,586 12,586 14,017 11.4% Greater Downtown TIF 134,704 134,704 134,704 134,704 0.0% Private Participant/Miscellaneous 42,768 40,086 45,230 75,000 87.1% Total Resources 1,846,613 2,469,420 3,175,066 2,334,189 -5.5% Debt on Jule Improvements Paid with Greater Downtown TIF 304,398 304,912 304,912 333,958 9.5% Debt on Jule Improvements Paid with Local Option Sales Tax - 3,233 3,233 3,160 -2.3% Total Non -Property Tax Debt 304,398 308,145 308,145 337,118 9.4% Transit Levy Incr. (Decr.) in Transit Fund Bal. Property Tax Support Percent Increase (Decrease) Personnel - Authorized FTE 1,086,080 896,852 * 896,852 1,172,885 30.8% (406,817) (5,631) 649,380 - 1,086,080 896,852 896,852 1,172,885 276,033 38.33 41.02 41.02 41.02 KI8I:YA *In FY 2016, the Transit Division reconfigured bus routes, modified the summer trolley service and changed to City management for a savings of $374,236. This savings was used to offset the cost of funding the Nightrider Route ($46,913 in FY16), operations of the Intermodal Facility ($29,962), Intercultural Competency training ($3,375), and increasing the General Fund Reserve ($196,212). -93- INTERMODAL RAMP - 31.5% TRANSIT % Change FY 2014/15 FY 2015/16 FY 2015/16 FY 2016/17 from Adopted Budget Highlights Actual Adopted Amended Recomm'd FY 2015/16 Employee Expense - - 9,126 100.0% Supplies and Services - - 23,839 100.0% Machinery and Equipment - - - 0.0% Total - - 32,965 0.0% Resources Intermodal Kamp Rental - - 14,017 100.0% Total Resources - - - 14,017 0.0% Debt on Intermodal Facility Paid with Greater Downtown TIF 304,398 304,912 304,912 300,712 -1.4% Total Non -Property Tax Debt 304,398 304,912 304,912 300,712 -1.4% Property Tax Support - - - 18,948 18,948 Percent Increase (Decrease) 100.0% Personnel - Authorized FTE - - - 0.50 Improvement Package Summary 1 of 5 This decision package would provide funding for the Express Green 2 and Grey 1 (Midtown) Routes to continue. The three-year Iowa Clean Air Attainment Program (ICAAP) grant that currently funds the Express, Green 2 and Grey 1 Routes will end on Dec 31, 2016, half -way through FY2017. This improvement package includes funding for half of FY2017 ($105,916) and all of FY2018 ($211,832). For FY2017, expenses include 1.74 FTE of part-time driver hours, motor vehicle maintenance and diesel fuel. In preparation for the end of this grant, fares were increased, generating in fixed -route revenue. In FY2016, all routes were evaluated and $100,000 in cost saving cuts to service were completed in preparation for this year's request. These routes are the spine of the complete system redesign completed in January 2014 that allowed for the reduced travel times and extended hours of service to better accommodate commuters traveling to and from work (namely Dubuque Industrial Center West). These routes allowed the system to transform from one with 90 -minute trips to a system that connects people to most destinations in under 30 minutes. If these routes are not funded through the improvement request, the following negative impacts to transit riders will occur: Increased trip lengths: The Express route would be discontinued, increasing trip times from neighborhoods to West -end destinations to 90 minutes and Mid -Town destinations to 60 minutes. Increased wait times: Reduced crosstown service will cause up to 30 minute wait times at transfers. Reduced Ridership: Fixed -Route ridership will fall from to 451,821 to 354,537 as these routes make up 23% of total ridership; Loss of 97,284 Reduced Fare Revenue: Fare revenue would fall from $189,289 to $117,897; Loss of $71,392 Reduced State Funding: State Operating Funding will fall from $279,749 to $215,806; Loss of $63,943 If not funded: Total lost revenue: $135,335 Total lost ridership: 97,284 Loss of this service will have a disproportionately negative impact on low income residents causing reduced access to jobs, medical appointments and schools. A reduction in service of this nature would constitute a substantial reduction of service and require public hearing (2007 Code § 46-76). A required component of an ICAAP application is an authorizing resolution from city council stating "The City also agrees to be responsible for adequately maintaining and operating the routes through maintenance level budgeting (Section 2)". Comprehensive Plan Connections: 'The location and quality of public transit infrastructure, in addition to providing accessibility to all areas of the community are important factors for new and expanding business, industry and residential development' (Comprehensive Plan Goal Summary - Transportation, p5). Providing these routes is essential to "promoting a safe, clean, timely, affordable and comfortable mode of public transportation" and "ensures that service is available for transit dependent people to get to and from work on all shifts and meet the demands of business hours" (Transportation Goals 4.4, 4.8). Maintaining service during the peak commuting hours "promotes appropriate lifestyles and infrastructure changes to reduce causes and impacts of global climate change" (Environmental Quality Goal 2.6). The FY 2017 net cost for six months of the fiscal year is $105,916. The full year net cost in FY 2018 to operate the Express and Midtown routes is $210,870. If these routes are not funded in FY 2018, there will be a loss in revenue of $135,335. Related Cost: $173,583 — Tax Funds - Recurring Recommend — Yes Related Revenue: $ 35,696 — Passenger Fares - Recurring Related Revenue: $ 31,971 — State Aid Operating — Recurring Net Cost: $105,916 Property Tax Impact: +$.0449/+.40% Activity: Transit Administration 2 of 5 This decision package would provide funding to upgrade three part-time Bus Operators to full-time. There are currently two vacant part-time Bus Operator position that were budgeted for health insurance -95- when the City evaluated transit positions in preparation for the Affordable Health Care Act. At that time, 8 healthcare eligible part-time positions and an additional 4 full-time positions were created based on hours worked by employees at the time of the analysis. In the original plan, as the healthcare eligible PT positions were vacated (due to retirement or termination), these positions would remain unfilled and be eliminated during the next budget year. Four of the healthcare eligible PT positions are still filled, while four others have been vacated. Two of those vacancies occurred during FY16. This request to increase the number of full-time positions in the department is based on an evaluation of the advantages of full time employees versus part time employees with regard to training costs, accident costs, and turnover rate. The Jule has 48 part-time drivers and 8 full-time drivers. Part -Time employees have a higher rate of accidents. 100% of at -fault accidents from FY13-16 (to date) involved a part-time driver. Full -Time drivers had zero accidents during the same period. The Part -Time employee turnover rate (25% or 12/48 in FY15) is twice that of full-time drivers (12.5% or 1/8 in FY15). The average training cost per driver is $5,567, for a total training expense of $66,814 annually. The Jule has a set number of hours of service, therefore creating a full-time position does not add more hours or FTE's to the Jule's budget. The additional expenses consist of healthcare, additional holiday hours, vacation days and life insurance. To ensure safe driving habits, compliance with policies, knowledge of the routes and schedules and good customer service, quality employees must be retained. The current civil service list has a large number of qualified, quality candidates who are supporting their families and enjoy and thrive in their positions at The Jule, serving the public in general and specifically our passengers. Much of the public perception and customer service progress that has been made in the past year has come from having these quality drivers on staff and we need to retain those who make our system run better rather than risk losing them. If funded, this improvement package would support many of the City Council priorities including appropriate city staffing levels, financially responsible city government. The cost to consistently train new employees is higher than that of providing full-time benefits to quality existing employees. Related Cost: $54,210 — Tax Funds - Recurring Property Tax Impact: +$.0230/+.21 % Activity: Bus Operations Recommend — No 3 of 5 This decision package would provide funding for armored courier service to pick up fixed route fare boxes. Locked canisters are currently transported to the bank by a Service Worker, once per week. The canisters are unlocked by bank staff and deposited to the City account. The empty canisters are picked up and returned to the garage by the same staff member. The armored courier would complete the transport of the canisters when they have money in them and the service worker would continue to pick up the empty canisters. Related Cost: $1,222 — Tax Funds - Recurring Property Tax Impact: +$.0005/+.00% Activity: Transit Administration go Recommend — Yes 4 of 5 This decision package would provide funding for extended bus service on weekdays. There are two options available to provide extended service. Option A: This request is to provide funding for amended Nightrider service to run 11:30pm Monday -Thursday. The City would apply for an Iowa Clean Air Attainment Program (ICAAP) Grant in Fiscal Year 2017 with the local match required in Fiscal Year 2018. Citizens have responded to multiple community input sessions and surveys, including Budget Input sessions and Inclusive Dubuque surveys and meetings, asking for later evening service on weekdays. To add 5.25 additional hours of service to the Nightrider routes and adjust those to serve the industrial park during end of shift times would cost approximately $171,786. ICAAP would cover 80% of the cost and the 20% local match would be $34,357. This option is supported by the Transit Board. This cost includes running the existing Nightrider routes with minor adjustments to serve the Intermodal and Dubuque Industrial Center with trips to pick up second shift workers from 11 pm-11:30pm. Three years of funding can be applied for on an annual basis and the application can be adjusted each year to reflect service demands and changes based on ridership data and analysis. A survey of citizens and riders is being conducted during winter 2015-2016 to gather additional information about transportation needs after 6pm. If the survey data shows that additional areas need service after 6pm, costs and routes could be reevaluated or additional funds applied for in future years. To apply for ICAAP funds, an authorizing resolution from city council must state that matching funds are available and budgeted for and that the City also agrees to be responsible for adequately maintaining and operating the routes through maintenance level budgeting. Related Cost: $171,786 — Tax Funds - Recurring Recommend — No Related Revenue: $7,044 — Passenger Fares - Recurring Net Cost: $164,742 Property Tax Impact: +$.0699/+.62% Activity: Bus Operations/Mini Bus Operations/Bus Maintenance Option B: This request is to provide funding to extend night service to 9 p.m. on weekdays. The City would apply for an Iowa Clean Air Attainment Program (ICAAP) Grant in Fiscal Year 2017 with the local match required in Fiscal Year 2018. Citizens have responded to multiple community input sessions and surveys, including Budget Input sessions and Inclusive Dubuque surveys and meetings, asking for later evening service on weekdays. Adding three additional hours of service to all routes is estimated to cost $409,779. ICAAP would cover 80% of the cost and the 20% local match would be $81,955. Three years of funding can be applied for on an annual basis and the application can be adjusted each year to reflect service demands and changes based on ridership data and analysis. A survey of citizens and riders is being conducted during winter 2015-2016 to gather additional information about transportation needs after 6 p.m. If the survey data shows that some areas do not need service after 6 p.m., or need service on a limited basis, costs could be reduced. Updated cost -97- estimates and draft routes would be developed prior to the application being submitted in October 2016. To apply for ICAAP funds, an authorizing resolution from city council must state that matching funds are available and budgeted for and that the City also agrees to be responsible for adequately maintaining and operating the routes through maintenance level budgeting. Related Cost: $409,779 — Tax Funds - Recurring Recommend — No Related Revenue: $12,686 — Passenger Fares - Recurring Net Cost: $397,093 Property Tax Impact: +$.1684/+1.50% Activity: Bus Operations/Mini Bus Operations/Bus Maintenance Both Option A and Option B support Comprehensive Plan Connections 'The location and quality of public transit infrastructure, in addition to providing accessibility to all areas of the community are important factors for new and expanding business, industry and residential development' (Comprehensive Plan Goal Summary - Transportation, p5). Providing these routes is essential to "promoting a safe, clean, timely, affordable and comfortable mode of public transportation" and "ensures that service is available for transit dependent people to get to and from work on all shifts and meet the demands of business hours" (Transportation Goals 4.4, 4.8). Maintaining service during the peak commuting hours "promotes appropriate lifestyles and infrastructure changes to reduce causes and impacts of global climate change" (Environmental Quality Goal 2.6). 5 of 5 This decision package would provide funding to provide express service from JFK Circle to Peosta three times per day. The City would apply for an Iowa Clean Air Attainment Program (ICAAP) Grant in Fiscal Year 2017 with the local match required in Fiscal Year 2018. Citizens have responded to multiple community input sessions and surveys and Greater Dubuque Development staff have heard from Peosta businesses that this service is needed. A meeting was held in January 2015 with businesses and North East Iowa Community College staff. This group initially discussed hourly service, but after discussing current shifts, there were large gaps of time where no shifts changed. The group then discussed three to four bus pickups per day with more coordinated shift start and end times at the employer locations and Northeast Iowa Community College. Northeast Iowa Community College, Berry Plastics, Premier Tooling were all willing to arrange schedules/shifts around common bus drop-off times. The Jule is able to provide express service outside of the city limits without being required to provide Minibus service to that entire area as long as the service is provided as an express, limited stop service. A premium fare can also be charged to help support this route. This rate has not yet been determined. Express service to Peosta on weekdays would cost approximately $39,054. The ICAAP grant would cover 80% of the cost and the 20% local match would be $7,810. Jule staff would seek out community partners and businesses to reach the match requirement and for support beyond the grant period. If partners cannot be secured, the grant would not be pursued. Three years of funding can be applied for on an annual basis and the application can be adjusted each year to reflect service demands and changes based on ridership data and analysis. If the route is not successful, or if changes to the pickup times are needed, costs and routes could be reevaluated and additional or reduced funds applied for in future years. To apply for ICAAP funds, an authorizing resolution from city council must state that matching funds are available and budgeted for and that the City also agrees to be responsible for adequately maintaining and operating the routes through maintenance level budgeting. no This improvement request supports Comprehensive Plan Connections "The location and quality of public transit infrastructure, in addition to providing accessibility to all areas of the community are important factors for new and expanding business, industry and residential development" (Comprehensive Plan Goal Summary - Transportation, p5). Providing these routes is essential to "promoting a safe, clean, timely, affordable and comfortable mode of public transportation" and "ensures that service is available for transit dependent people to get to and from work on all shifts and meet the demands of business hours" (Transportation Goals 4.4, 4.8). Maintaining service during the peak commuting hours "promotes appropriate lifestyles and infrastructure changes to reduce causes and impacts of global climate change" (Environmental Quality Goal 2.6). Related Cost: $36,054 — Tax Funds - Recurring Recommend — No Related Revenue: $ 1,200 — Passenger Fares - Recurring Net Cost: $34,854 Property Tax Impact: +$.0148/+.13% Activity: Bus Operations/Mini Bus Operations/Bus Maintenance Significant Line Items at Maintenance Level (Without Recommended Improvement Package) Employee Expense FY 2017 employee expense reflects a 2.5% wage package increase. 2. The Iowa Public Employee Retirement System (IPERS) City contribution remains at 8.93% and the employee contribution remains at 6.18% in FY 2017. 3. The City portion of health insurance expense increased from $1,040 in FY 2016 to $1,325 in FY 2017 per month per contract, resulting is an increase of $34,180 (27.40%). 4. Employee Physicals increased from $5,670 in FY 2016 to $6,484 in FY 2017 based on FY 2015 actual of $6,647. 5. Overtime remains at $17,973 in FY 2017. Overtime actual was $28,053 in FY 2015 and $48,777 in FY 2014. 6. Unemployment Insurance increased from $10,228 in FY 2016 to $16,451 in FY 2016 based on FY 2016 actual. 7. The Express and Midtown route funding from ICAAP ends December 31, 2016. This results in a reduction of -1.74 FTE (-$75,693). Supplies & Services 8. 31.5% of the Intermodal Ramp expense ($32,965) is allocated to the Transit Division and the remaining 68.5% is allocated to the Parking Division. Based on Federal Transit Administration rules, the FY 2017 deficit allocated to Transit of $18,948 cannot reduce the property tax levy provided to run the Transit system and the annual Transit funding from Federal Transit Administration and State Transit Operating Funding cannot be used to support the Intermodal Ramp's operations. Therefore the Federal Transit Administration has agreed that transit will be allocated 31.5% of the revenue and expenses for the Intermodal Ramp which is reflected in the significant line items below. 9. Uniform Purchases decreased from $14,275 in FY 2016 to $13,500 in FY 2017 which represents uniforms for 60 drivers at $225 per driver. 10. Janitorial Supplies increased from $1,084 in FY 2016 to $3,664 in FY 2017 due to moving $2,380 in custodial equipment to this line item. This line item represents bus cleaning supplies. 11. Copying decreased from $3,129 in FY 2016 to $2,309 in FY 2017 based on FY 2015 actual of $1,298, and the addition of the Intermodal Ramp. 12. Legal Notices and Ads increased from $1,636 in FY 2016 to $3,898 in FY 2017 based on FY 2015 actual of $3,898. This line item represents advertising for vacant positions and public notice of meetings and route changes. 13. Property Insurance increased from $7,675 in FY 2016 to $8,076 in FY 2017 based on FY 2016 actual for addition of the Intermodal Ramp. 14. Conferences increased from $5,020 in FY 2016 to $7,680 in FY 2017 due to an every other year Federal Transit Administration training in Kansas City for the Transit Manager ($1,750). These expenses are reimbursable at 80% from the Iowa Department of Transportation and are reflected in Transit reimbursement revenue. 15. Water Utility Expense increased from $1,239 in FY 2016 to $3,033 in FY 2016 based on the addition of the Intermodal Ramp. 16. Gas Utility Expense increased from $20,922 in FY 2016 to $23,425 in FY 2017 based on the addition of the Intermodal Ramp. 17. Electricity Utility Expense increased from $29,138 in FY 2016 to $38,075 in FY 2017 based on the addition of the Intermodal Ramp. 18. Stormwater Utility Expense increased from $0 in FY 2016 to $5,260 in FY 2017 based on FY 2016 year-to-date actual for the Intermodal Facility and Ramp. 19. Property Maintenance increase from $20,783 in FY 2016 to $24,384 in FY 2017 based on the addition of the Intermodal Ramp. 20. Telephone decreased from $7,563 in FY 2016 to $5,819 in FY 2017 based on FY 2016 year-to- date actual. 21. Elevator Maintenance increased from $0 in FY 2016 to $945 in FY 2017 based on the addition of the Intermodal Ramp. 22. Rental of Space decreased from $2,400 in FY 2016 to $0 in FY 2017 based on the City contribution of the Burlington Trailways lease ending in Fiscal Year 2015 when the Intermodal Facility opened. -100- 23. Diesel Fuel decreased from $323,884 in FY 2016 to $318,154 in FY 2017 based on vehicle fuel efficiency rates, miles, and FY15 average fuel cost per gallon and the Express and Midtown routes ending December 31, 2016. 24. Motor Vehicle Maintenance decreased from $234,788 in FY 2016 to $228,216 in FY 2017 based on the Express and Midtown routes ending December 31, 2016. 25. Motor Vehicle Maintenance Accident decreased from $45,000 in FY 2016 to $22,115 in FY 2017 based on FY 2015 actual of $19,615. Added full-time driver positions and a driver trainer have decreased the number of accidents. 26. Software License increased from $66,755 in FY 2016 to $70,924 in FY 2017 due to the addition of a Milestone license for the 26 security cameras at the Intermodal Facility. Machinery & Equipment 27. Equipment replacement items at the maintenance level include ($30,798): Bus Exterior Route Head Signs (12) — Medium Duty Buses $26,400 Radio Equipment $ 1,000 Plexiglas Panels $ 1,000 Shop Equipment $ 500 Camera Equipment $ 1,000 Smart Phones (2) $ 898 Debt Service 28. FY 2017 debt service includes the following ($337,118): $300,712 2012A GO Borrowing Intermodal Facility (Last Year 2031) $3,160 2014B GO Borrowing Roof Improvements (Last Year 2034) $33,246 2017A GO Borrowing Bus Storage and Maintenance Facility (Last Year 2037) The debt service payments for 2012A and 2017A in FY 2017 are paid with Greater Downtown TIF. The debt service payments for 2014B in FY 2017 are paid with local option sales tax. Revenue 29. Revenue projections include: a) Federal operating assistance increased from $1,093,168 in FY 2016 to $1,110,417 in FY 2017 and is based off the FTA assistance projected to be received in FY 2016 which is determined by the number of residents in poverty. Final FTA allocations for FY2017 should be received by March 2016; b) State operating assistance increased from $249,319 in FY 2016 to $279,748 in FY 2017 based on FY 2016 revised. Final State allocations for FY2017 should be received by mid-January 2016. The Fixing America's Surface Transportation (FAST) Act is five-year legislation to improve the Nation's surface infrastructure, including roads, bridges, transit systems, and rail transportation network. FAST Act increases dedicated bus funding by 89% over the life of the bill which provides both stable formula funding and a competitive grant program to address bus and bus facility needs; -101- c) Federal pass-thru grant decreased from $507,049 in FY 2016 to $284,227 in FY 2017. The Nightrider route grant is ending March 2016 and in the FY 2016 adopted budget the City Council approved funding to continue the route. The Midtown Loop and Feeder route grant ending January 2017 and will lose the remaining funding from ICAAP related to the route of $284,227 in FY 2018; d) Mini bus passenger fares decreased from $137,587 in FY 2016 to $125,569 in FY 2017 based on FY 2016 first quarter. There were $1 rate increases in FY 2015 and FY 2016, which have caused passengers to switch from minibus to fixed route because of the cost increase. e) Bus passenger fares decreased from $254,671 in FY 2016 to $222,507 in FY 2017 Fiscal Year 2015 actual passenger fare revenue was $234,201. f) Reimbursements from the Greater Downtown TIF ($134,704) for the downtown parking shuttle remain unchanged. g) Reimbursement from the Iowa Department of Transportation for 80% of transit staff conferences and training (line #12) is included in Federal Pass-Thru ($6,144). These funds are only available on a reimbursement basis, so if conferences are not attended, these funds are not received. h) Intermodal Ramp revenue is allocated 31.5% to the Transit Division, which includes $3,307 in Daily Fees and $10,710 in Monthly Rental. The Intermodal ramp expense allocated to the Transit Division in FY 2017 is $32,965. Based on Federal Transit Administration rules, the FY 2017 deficit of $18,948 cannot reduce the property tax levy provided to run the Transit system and the annual Transit funding from Federal Transit Administration and State Transit Operating Funding cannot be used to support the Intermodal Ramp's operations. Therefore the Federal Transit Administration has agreed that transit will be allocated 31.5% of the revenue and expenses for the Intermodal Ramp. -102- ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION Build and operate a sustainable public transit system that provides safe reliable and efficient transportation options for all persons while supporting the economic growth and environmental goals of the community. SUCCESS IS ABOUT PLANNING, PARTNERSHIPS AND PEOPLE LEADING TO OUTCOMES PEOPLE Jule staff reach out to a diverse set of community members and organizations to provide information and help plan future services. We invest in our staff and our quality of service throughM�o ongoinq safety and drlvertraininq. PLANNING The Jule plans for the future through community surveys, focus groups, contacts with social service agencies, the Transit Advisory Board, and the Metropolitan Planning Organization. PARTNERSHIPS Jule staff work with community organizations and non -profits to help increase access to and awareness of transit services. We do this by developing partnerships to keep information flowing between employers, service providers, program offerings, local college students, and K-12 students, staff and administrators and city staff. -103- ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION Resources 300000 250000 200000 150000 0Mini Bus Passenger Bad Route Greater Donintown Private Participant Medicaid I -� Fees Passenger Fares TIF Reimbursement Resources 1600000 1 40 0000 1200000 1000000 M 800000 600000 ad 000 Z ETA operating State 0 perating Federal Pa,Th ru opposing Fees Proi assistance Grant support The Transit Division Is supported by 41 02 full time equivalent employees, which accounts for 880% of the department expense as seen below. Overall, the departmentsexpenses are expected to Increase by 2 2% In FV 2017 compared to FV 2816. matmenp and equipment FSSaza9 51s>6 106791 SL101,555 suppueraneservisrsledeee Employee ExpenseS;me,a1 So S500,000�y 295,550 51000,000 5150000 •evmn •rvmle •evmss0 5;000,000 52500,000 -104- ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION Administration and Operations Public transportation in the City of Dubuque is delivered through the transit division, The Jule. The Jule manages fixed -route , paratransit and contract services (DuAde and Burlington Trailways) and maintains transit vehicles, bus stops and other capital infrastructure. Management functions include property, vehicle, and equipment management, maintenance and selection, evaluation or routes safety, security, and funding sources, employee hiring, training, payroll and discipline, public relations, marketing, accounting, and submission of grant applications for continued funding as well as compliance with state and federal transportation miss and regulations. The Transit Advisory Board is a 5 member board that advises the city council on executing agreements and grants relating to the transit system operation, the purchase of new equipment and establishing rates and fares. The Administration Activity provides management and maintenance of the accounting and statistical records for the benefit of the Transit Board City Manager, City Council and State and Federal Departments of Transportation (DOT) and Federal Transit Administration (FTA) Reporting statistical information and maintaining compliance with state and federal guidelines including the American's with Disabilities Act (ADA) is essential in addition to collaboration with the Iowa Department of Transportation, Office of Public Transit and Federal Transit Administration for planning, funding and operating and capital assistance. Atlminis[ration antl Operations Funding Summary W 2➢14/15 ARual W 2015/16 Adopted W 2016/17 Recommended Expentll[ures $793,140 $737,000 $747c125 Resources 1 $315,045 1 $373,996 $06992 Administration and Operations PositionSurnmary TranotManag,r Loo Transit Operations supervisor Loo Confidential Account Clark Loo Operations Assistant D50 Marketing Intern D50 Transit Dispatch schedule Loo Transit Dispatch schedule PT Loll service WorkrPF D50 Total FT Equivalent Employees 7.51 -105 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION Performance Measures Administration and Operations -Activity Statement Be Responsive: Provide safe, accessible/convenient, professional transit service in the City of Dubuque for citizens and visitors- connecting people to services, employment, schools and recreation opportunities Q Goal: Financially Responsible & High Performance Organization"' Outcome #1: Communicate Clearly. Provide consistent communication of passenger expectations. Post policies in a consistent format, online, on buses, and in print materials. Each bus is outfitted with one large (11'x1]') sign containing all policies for driver and passenger reference. M RezpKdul. fellow His Rules. Ride Happy. f. NY Your fare w_o.... „. i. M CIM'.. es.._ ses T lie Smoking S. Mfale. fM pen. "'rs'r d. RMwe Ywr volas : no•+i.�� ro v 7. No tori" or erisH" Ii �Vpft 2. WKS! R.ms n......o�,...w�.,ro a..a.a Ia. Sewiw"IMel. _ _ 11.fMllen' 106- ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION Bus Operations Overview The city of Dubuque has grown geographically and the city's fixed -route transit system needed to catchup The award of grant funds to the city for this expansion has provided the opportunity for the transit system to serve more residents and businesses. New routes were developed in 2014 and tweaked in 2015 to serve new areas of the community more efficiently and effectively. Asystem overhaul offering new service areas, more frequent service and quicker connections between downtown and the west end destinations was rolled out in January 2014. Bus operations encompasses seasonal or special services including. • SummerTrolley service is provided from Labor Day through October on Saturdays fork 10am-6pm. Weekday Business Shuttle service connects downtown parking ramps and employer locations during moming and afternoon commute times Nightrider weekend evening service, including MInIBus, operates Friday and Saturday nights fork 6pm-240am during the school year and 11 pm during the summer. Bus Operations includes the following daytime fixed -route services as well as the door to - door MiniBus services that operate from 6 05amf 50pm on weekdays and 8 05am-625pm on Saturdays: P The Jule �T,. Route Map -107- ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION MR 15 -minute nonstop service between the Intermodal Transfer and JFK Circle Transfer provides AM M a quick connection between downtown and west end locations. MA West Service from the JFK Circle Transfer to Pennsylvania Ave, Radford Rd, Chavenelle Rd and the YLOWI UICW NWArtenal to Hempstead High School, Dither Recycling, Radford Court, Innovation Or, Nordstrom, BioLife, and Medical Associates West Service from the JFK Circle Transfer to Kerns, HyVee, Goodwill, Aldi, near Hoover Elementary w' School, Sunset Park, Asbury Rd, Pennsylvania Ave, and Hempstead High School. This route provides afternoon service to Roosevelt Middle and Carver Elementary Schools. L Service from the JFK Circle Transfer along JFK Rd to Kennedy Mall, Mindframe Theater T Highway 20, Walmart, Lowes, Dodge St HyVee, Target, and Shopko. Service from the Internodal Transfer to 32nd St via Jackson Stand returning to the transfer using Saunders St to provide service to neighborhoods East of Central Ave. The bus reconnects with Central Ave near Fulton Elementary School. Service from the Internodal Transfer to the South Locust HyVee, Mervcy Hospital and Medical Associates East Campus. Service between the Delhi Transfer and JFK Circle Transfer while traveling along Asbury Rd, Chaney Rd, Kaufmann Ave, and Kane St nearWahler High School and Mazzuchelli Middle School Service between the Delhi Transfer and JFK Circle Transfer while traveling to Flora Park and Pool, Irving Elementary School, and University of Dubuque. Service from the Internodal Transfer along Windsor Ave to Linwood Cemetery, Mount St Francis, Audubon Elementary School, Prescott Elementary School, and near Jefferson Middle School Service between the Internodal Transfer and the Delhi Transfer while traveling to Medical w' I Associates East, Mercy Hospital, Loras College, and near Lincoln Elementary School. z Service from the Internodal Transfer along Rhomberg Ave to the Point Neighborhood, near m Sutton Pool, Audubon Elementary School ,Eagle 's Grocery Store as well as Kerper Blvd businesses and Schmitt lslandakystique. Service from the Internodal Transfer to Terrace Heights via Jackson St and Peru Rd returning to the transfer using Peru Rd and Central Ave providing service near Fulton Elementary School Service between the Internodal Transfer and Delhi Transfer while traveling to Allison Henderson Park, Clarke University, Senior High School, Our Lady of Guadalupe Elementary School, Jackson Park and near Prescott Elementary School. D Service from the Delhi Transfer via Grandview Ave, Rockdale Rd and returns via Bryan St r providing service to Key West DMV ,Rockdale Rd, South Grandview Ave, Bryant Elementary School and nearTable Mound Elementary School. mService from the Delhi Transfer along North Grandview Ave past Washington Middle School to A all Highway 20 Cedar Cross Rd, and returning to the transfer on Fremont providing service to Warburg Seminary. MR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION uperanons running wmmary FV 2016/17 FTE's FV 2014/15 Actual le 2015/16 Adopted FV 2016/ll Recommended Expenditures $2,432,561 $2,484,256 $2,535,J34 Resources $1,494,564 52,021,230 $2,163,6J2 Bus Operations Position Summary FV 2016/17 FTE's Bus Operator 8.00 Bus Operator PT 23.81 Total FT Equivalent Employees 1 31.81 Highlights of the Past Year • Smart Transit — Using data to optimize routes, reduce costs and increase ridership • SmarterTravel —Research project with IBM to monitornon-bus travel patterns and compare those results with Jule routes for possible adjustments • Opening the Intermodal Transportation Facility in Historic Millwork District Future Initiatives PLUS — Integrate and implement technology into fare payment and tracking Design and build the Bus Storage Facility — reuse of city Superfund site Performance Measures Bus Operations —Activity Statement Provide safe, accessible/convenient, professional transit service in the City of Dubuque for citizens and visitors - connecting people to services, employment, schools and recreation. MGoal: Improved Connectivity 3�� Outcome #1: Connect People to Opportunity. Provide access to transit services so citizens can get to work, school, and recreational opportunities. Transit Access = 5 minute walk to a bus stop 75%of residents live within a 5 minute walk from a bus stop 92% of schools are within a 5 minute walk from a bus stop* *Table Mound and St Columbkille are within a 10 minute walk distance -109- ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION Transit Ridership = +15% in 201 600,000 500,000 440.252 44499] N0000 I N 11) Nil 2012 2013 N14 N15 Outcome #2: Be Responsive. Ask for input and make recommendations that Poll the needs of citizens. rhe Jule conducts a(2nsisurveyat leas! every ovoyeas as well asfocsgmups antl online route andstop request oppoquniieson anongoing bass.rv..o,rod,mra�. F The Jule's rransi Advisory Board meets monthly to evaluate mutes and discuss and pnontae ,across neetls. The mi common ,across request that The Jule receives is for bus routes to operate burl at least spm on weekdays. ..„..... Look for opportunities to provide input on The Jules well madyal, up for transit notifications through the City's Notify -Me system. The. notices and survey links through its Facehook and Twitter accounts. Outcome #3: Improve quality of life. Provide quick travel times so people can apend less time on the bus and more time doing what they choose. JFK Circle to The Jule (2401 Central) 75 min 35 min 40 min The Point to Medial AssochlesWasl 95 min 40 min 55 min Downtown Transterto KohlWHyVee 45 min 25 min 20 min University of Dubuque to walma NLnwas 50 min 25 min 25 min Clarke University to Martel Medical Associates East 45 min 18 min 27 min Jorge College to Kennedy Mall 39 min 25 min 14 min The Point to TargeVHyVaa 85 min 50 min 35 min ltd ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION Or Goal: Economic Prosperity_"'k 'r Outcome #4: Make it Easy. Coordinate with non -profits, colleges, and other city departments to make accessing transit passes and services simple and affordable. The Jule partners with the following organizations and city departments to make access to transit passes easier and more affordable. tmergDUBUQU Ztit Medicaid Enterprise rj Clarke UNIVERSITY NED& 000�__ N-J-Ilzd_l luny A-1.Dr Lt Ur [)PENING DOORS fix �rcr+ i-r`rs; LORAS COLLEGE' City of Dubuque Finance St. Raphael PrOjeCt..oncern Department - manages Cathedral - ►►� Crescent Community bus pass sales at City L HEALTH CENTER Hall *These organizations purchase passes in bulk at a 25% discount and provide them to their clients in need Outcome #5: Be Equitable. Provide the same opportunity for use of public transit services to those with disabilities as to those without. Conduct review of all bus stops, shelters and facilities and before adding new bus stops, evaluate access and infrastructure needs for ADA compliance. SEEM Choose future buses that provide the greatest amount of independence and access for those in our community with mobility impairments. Drive on ramps promote independence and require less maintenance than mechanical lifts. Hfficrest I'm fam I scr1 c e s SrAde .TF ffive ry V j jyc w e,;! tccess2Care O Dubmue COMMUNITY S{M40L3 tmergDUBUQU Ztit Medicaid Enterprise rj Clarke UNIVERSITY NED& 000�__ N-J-Ilzd_l luny A-1.Dr Lt Ur [)PENING DOORS fix �rcr+ i-r`rs; LORAS COLLEGE' City of Dubuque Finance St. Raphael PrOjeCt..oncern Department - manages Cathedral - ►►� Crescent Community bus pass sales at City L HEALTH CENTER Hall *These organizations purchase passes in bulk at a 25% discount and provide them to their clients in need Outcome #5: Be Equitable. Provide the same opportunity for use of public transit services to those with disabilities as to those without. Conduct review of all bus stops, shelters and facilities and before adding new bus stops, evaluate access and infrastructure needs for ADA compliance. SEEM Choose future buses that provide the greatest amount of independence and access for those in our community with mobility impairments. Drive on ramps promote independence and require less maintenance than mechanical lifts. ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION Bus Maintenance Overview The Public Works Mechanics and Service Workers, led bythe Vehicle Maintenance Supervisor conduct all maintenance of transit vehicles. Primary responsibilities are preventative maintenance inspections and major and minor repairs to various vehicle systems, including purchasing and stocking pairs and supplies in accordance with Federal Transit Administration (FTA) and City of Dubuque policies. Service workers also conduct cleaning of fixed -route vehicles and facilities, which include benches, shelters, the bus storage facility and The Jule's three transfer locations at JFK Circle, Delhi, and at the Intermodal Center. The effectiveness of the new Internodal and JFK Transfer facilities, ITS equipment, Smarter Travel Study recommendations and passenger information software rely on buses being in good condition, with few breakdowns and delays in service due to mechanical failure High quality vehicle maintenance and replacement as the fleet reaches the end of its useful life is essential to maintaining the integrity of the transit system. Bus MaiMenai Funding Summary FY 2014/15 FY 2015/16 FY 2016/17 Actual Adopted Recommended Expenditures $113,808 $122,246 $139,788 Resources $37,005 1 $55,518 $69,508 Bus Maintenance Position Summary FY 2016/17 Fres Servrce Worker Cat Servrce Worker PT 0]0 Thal FT Equivalent Employees 1.70 Highlights of the Past Year in Complat 60% of preventative maintenance on vehicles within 10% of the mileage threshold in All vehicles and The Jule's three transfers are covered bysecunty cameras. in New recording systems were inata l le d in all buses to allow for quicker review of on- board security camera footage • Implemaufed a Luz shelter cleaning schedule -112- ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRANSIT DIVISION Future Initiatives Plan for capital replacement of vehicles and focus on ramp entry for improved access for individuals with mobility impairments. Research alternative fuel technologies and conduct cost -benefit analysis Research and seek funding forvehicle replacement Performance Measures Bus Maintenance -Activity Statement Ensure safe, clean and reliable transit service through regular maintenance and inspections of the transitfleet including information technology hardware and software. QGoal: Financially Responsible &High Performance Organizations Outcome 46: Drive and maintain city vehicles like they're our own. Reduce accidents and associated costs through ongoing drivertraining and conduct regular vehicle cleaning and maintenance to extend the life of the fleet STh,c mithSNl The Jule hired a part-time CDL and safety trainer and began Key IHim High ln3¢enng implementing the Smith System (used by UPS, New Lord Hey2larnengmmure MTA) as a training system for its driving staff in July 2014. Key 8 Keep Your Eyes Moving Key Cleave Yourseff An Out This consistent saeyprovides and framework surroundfor the issue of driving safety pmvidesa fizmework for rewarding positive Kew +Make Sure mev See You behavior. Drivers receive annual ing practices ng safety habits Even and postaccident training to help reinforce good driving practices and habit. Even with the expansion of transit service, drivers are driving more miles with fewer accidents. This focus on training and safety has reduced at -fault accidents by 27% (FV14- FV15 The Jule's buses drive city streets a minimum of 12 hours per day. 80lMileage thresholds forpreventative maintenance reflect the constant usage of these vehicles in all weather conditions. Vehicles serviced whim 1of of mileage Light Duty 5,000 miles preventative maintenance threshold mresnold Medium and Heavy �� Duty: e omiles �� preventative maintenance threshold " yt hII !9 (OM 113- Recommended Operating Revenue Budget - Department Total 53 -TRANSIT DIVISION Fund Account Account Title FY14 Actual FY15 Actual FY16 Adopted FY17 Recomm'd 43 - USE OF MONEYAND PROPERTY 0 Revenue Revenue Budget Budget 600 43251 RENTS & CONCESSIONS 0 0 6,000 0 43 - USE OF MONEYAND PROPERTY 0 0 6,000 0 600 44160 FTA OPERATING ASSISTANCE 1,107,768 501,267 1,093,168 1,110,417 44-INTERGOVERMENTAL 1,107,768 501,267 1,093,168 1,110,417 600 45721 STATE -AID OPERATING 229,283 242,876 249,319 279,748 600 45771 FED PASS THRU STATE GRANT 536,758 552,672 507,049 284,227 45 - STATE GRANTS 766,041 795,548 756,368 563,975 605 51305 DAILY FEES 0 0 0 3,307 600 51310 MONTHLY RENTAL 0 0 12,586 0 605 51310 MONTHLY RENTAL 0 0 0 10,710 600 51705 MINI BUS PASSENGER FARES 50,728 87,688 137,587 124,905 600 51710 EAST DBQ PASSENGER FARES 199 420 250 664 600 51715 MINIBUS CONTRACT REVENUE 3 5 0 0 600 51725 PASSENGER FARES 147,971 234,201 254,671 222,507 600 51727 MEDICAID FARES 0 0 0 48,000 600 51730 ADVERTISING FEES 70,734 50,012 40,000 40,000 51 - CHARGES FOR SERVICES 269,635 372,325 445,094 450,093 600 53102 PRIVATE PARTICIPANT 39,767 28,909 34,086 75,000 600 53605 MISCELLANEOUS REVENUE 216 1 0 0 600 53610 INSURANCE CLAIMS 1,022 13,714 0 0 600 53615 DAMAGE CLAIMS 4,929 702 0 0 600 53620 REIMBURSEMENTS -GENERAL 123 (557) 0 0 53 - MISCELLANEOUS 46,057 42,769 34,086 75,000 600 59100 FR GENERAL 968,006 1,220,784 1,227,768 1,307,589 400 59240 FR DOWNTOWN TIF 308,112 304,012 304,912 333,958 400 59350 FR SALES TAX CONSTRUCTION 0 386 3,233 3,160 59 - TRANSFER IN AND INTERNAL 1,276,118 1,525,182 1,535,913 1,644,707 53 - TRANSIT DIVISION TOTAL 3,465,619 3,237,091 3,870,629 3,844,192 -114- Recommended Operating Expenditure Budget - Department Total 53 -TRANSIT DIVISION Fund Account Account Title FY14 Actual FY15 Actual FY16 Adopted FY 17 Recomm'd 600 61020 PART-TIME EMPLOYEES Expense Expense Budget Budget 600 61010 FULL-TIME EMPLOYEES 212,788 281,626 597,633 607,725 600 61020 PART-TIME EMPLOYEES 1,106,504 1,153,029 1,030,885 1,055,852 605 61020 PART-TIME EMPLOYEES 0 0 0 7,173 600 61030 SEASONAL EMPLOYEES 0 4,650 12,848 13,123 600 61050 OVERTIME PAY 48,777 28,053 17,973 17,973 600 61071 HOLIDAY PAY -OVERTIME 4,127 5,517 10,547 10,722 600 61092 VACATION PAYOFF 54 552 0 0 600 61310 IPERS 122,537 130,456 148,917 153,734 605 61310 IPERS 0 0 0 640 600 61320 SOCIAL SECURITY 104,331 111,637 127,755 131,841 605 61320 SOCIAL SECURITY 0 0 0 549 600 61410 HEALTH INSURANCE 134,779 149,940 237,120 271,300 600 61415 WORKMENS' COMPENSATION 98,281 92,095 95,177 111,885 605 61415 WORKMENS' COMPENSATION 0 0 0 473 600 61416 LIFE INSURANCE 229 306 1,197 1,216 600 61417 UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE 5,946 10,058 10,228 16,451 600 61640 SAFETY EQUIPMENT 282 1,652 0 925 605 61640 SAFETY EQUIPMENT 0 0 0 291 600 61645 TOOL ALLOWANCE 238 0 0 0 600 61650 MEAL ALLOWANCE 72 42 0 0 600 61660 EMPLOYEE PHYSICALS 5,670 6,647 5,670 6,484 61 - WAGES AND BENEFITS 1,844,617 1,976,261 2,295,950 2,408,357 600 62010 OFFICE SUPPLIES 1,835 2,639 3,500 3,570 605 62010 OFFICE SUPPLIES 0 0 0 315 600 62011 UNIFORM PURCHASES 3,697 12,485 14,275 13,500 600 62013 UNIFORM MAINTENANCE 1,009 986 1,215 1,215 600 62030 POSTAGE AND SHIPPING 1,056 961 1,109 1,009 605 62030 POSTAGE AND SHIPPING 0 0 0 315 600 62033 HAND TOOLS/EQUIPMENT 0 0 1,000 1,000 600 62034 REPAIR PARTS/SUPPLIES 0 0 500 500 600 62035 COURIER FEES 0 0 0 1,222 600 62060 O/E MAINT CONTRACTS 0 0 497 497 605 62060 O/E MAINT CONTRACTS 0 0 0 157 600 62061 DP EQUIP. MAINT CONTRACTS 5,091 6,374 6,374 7,208 600 62062 JANITORIAL SUPPLIES 1,289 0 1,084 3,664 600 62063 SAFETY RELATED SUPPLIES 0 0 1,000 1,000 600 62090 PRINTING & BINDING 24,273 18,343 28,387 24,741 605 62090 PRINTING & BINDING 0 0 0 866 600 62110 COPYING/REPRODUCTION 3,129 1,298 3,129 1,947 605 62110 COPYING/REPRODUCTION 0 0 0 362 600 62130 LEGAL NOTICES & ADS 1,165 3,898 1,636 3,898 600 62140 PROMOTION 6,334 3,000 12,875 12,875 600 62190 DUES & MEMBERSHIPS 2,916 2,929 3,461 3,530 600 62206 PROPERTY INSURANCE 3,905 4,567 7,675 4,769 -115- Recommended Operating Expenditure Budget - Department Total 53 -TRANSIT DIVISION Fund Account Account Title FY14 Actual FY15 Actual FY16 Adopted FY 17 Recomm'd 600 62207 BOILER INSURANCE Expense Expense Budget Budget 605 62206 PROPERTY INSURANCE 0 0 0 3,307 600 62207 BOILER INSURANCE 79 79 82 79 600 62208 GENERAL LIABILITY INSURAN 38,402 37,283 42,120 39,912 605 62208 GENERAL LIABILITY INSURAN 0 0 0 1,664 600 62310 TRAVEL -CONFERENCES 0 0 5,020 7,680 600 62320 TRAVEL -CITY BUSINESS 0 0 400 400 600 62360 EDUCATION &TRAINING 1,308 1,706 4,800 4,800 600 62411 UTILITY EXP -ELECTRICITY 29,350 26,027 29,138 30,897 605 62411 UTILITY EXP -ELECTRICITY 0 0 0 7,178 600 62412 UTILITY EXP -GAS 21,215 22,155 20,922 22,830 605 62412 UTILITY EXP -GAS 0 0 0 595 600 62415 UTILITY EXPENSE STORMWATR 0 566 0 4,000 605 62415 UTILITY EXPENSE STORMWATR 0 0 0 1,260 600 62416 UTILITY EXP -WATER 0 0 1,239 1,239 605 62416 UTILITY EXP -WATER 0 0 0 1,794 600 62421 TELEPHONE 9,643 1,959 9,063 4,827 605 62421 TELEPHONE 0 0 0 992 600 62424 RADIO/PAGER FEE 0 1,824 5,961 5,962 600 62431 PROPERTY MAINTENANCE 15,844 14,332 20,783 22,267 605 62431 PROPERTY MAINTENANCE 0 0 0 2,117 600 62433 CUSTODIAL SERVICES 2,380 1,473 2,380 0 605 62435 ELEVATOR MAINTENANCE 0 0 0 945 600 62436 RENTAL OF SPACE 0 9,600 2,400 0 600 62511 FUEL, MOTOR VEHICLE 1,316 1,305 1,613 1,692 605 62511 FUEL, MOTOR VEHICLE 0 0 0 47 600 62513 FUEL, DIESEL 364,791 329,111 323,884 318,154 600 62521 MOTOR VEHICLE MAINT. 244,753 273,331 234,788 242,575 600 62522 VEHICLE MAINT., ACCIDENT 10,496 19,615 45,000 22,115 600 62523 OIL & GREASE - TRANSIT 1,531 0 0 0 600 62524 LUB. &ANTIFREEZE -TRANSIT 807 0 1,000 1,000 600 62525 TIRES/TUBES- TRANSIT 47,723 33,094 61,333 62,560 600 62528 MOTOR VEH. MAINT. OUTSOUR 55,842 42,790 36,378 39,468 600 62611 MACH/EQUIP MAINTENANCE 0 2,832 0 0 600 62615 MACH/EQUIP MAINT. OUTSOUR 650 1,759 2,803 2,803 600 62627 CAMERA MAINTENANCE 0 0 1,164 2,106 600 62636 DE-ICING PRODUCTS 0 0 1,000 1,000 605 62636 DE-ICING PRODUCTS 0 0 0 945 600 62663 SOFTWARE LICENSE EXP 26,431 21,975 66,755 70,924 605 62663 SOFTWARE LICENSE EXP 0 0 0 409 600 62664 LICENSE/PERMIT FEES 0 0 75 0 600 62665 FALSE ALARM CHARGES 0 0 3,218 93 605 62665 FALSE ALARM CHARGES 0 0 0 61 600 62666 CREDIT CARD CHARGE 0 0 0 369 605 62666 CREDIT CARD CHARGE 0 0 0 431 -116- Recommended Operating Expenditure Budget - Department Total 53 -TRANSIT DIVISION Fund Account Account Title FY14 Actual FY15 Actual FY16 Adopted FY 17 Recomm'd 600 62671 MISC. OPERATING SUPPLIES Expense Expense Budget Budget 600 62667 INTERNET SERVICES 0 5,265 4,786 4,306 600 62671 MISC. OPERATING SUPPLIES 0 189 0 0 600 62697 LABOR RELATIONS 0 1,100 2,356 1,101 600 62713 LEGAL SERVICES 358 0 0 0 600 62716 CONSULTANT SERVICES 10,348 1,578 9,276 9,276 600 62717 CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECK 0 0 0 10,000 600 62726 AUDIT SERVICES 600 700 750 1,000 605 62726 AUDIT SERVICES 0 0 0 79 600 62731 MISCELLANEOUS SERVICES 2,255 0 0 0 600 62761 PAY TO OTHER AGENCY 477,302 452,203 22,500 22,500 62 - SUPPLIES AND SERVICES 1,419,124 1,361,333 1,050,704 1,067,919 600 71117 TIME CLOCK 0 125 0 0 600 71227 SIGNAGE 30 0 0 26,400 600 71312 VAN/PICKUP/WAG REPL 0 0 22,500 0 600 71314 TRUCK -REPLACEMENT 26,709 0 0 0 600 71410 SHOP EQUIPMENT 599 0 599 500 600 71550 MISCELLANEOUS EQUIPMENT 1,107 0 0 0 600 71610 CUSTODIAL EQUIPMENT 0 0 200 0 600 72410 PAGER/RADIO EQUIPMENT 3,958 573 0 1,000 600 72417 CAMERA RELATED EQUIPMENT 1,164 298 0 1,000 600 72418 TELEPHONE RELATED 0 0 0 898 600 72420 BURGLAR ALARM 0 920 0 0 600 72812 PLEXIGLAS PANELS 0 0 1,950 1,000 71 -EQUIPMENT 33,567 1,916 25,249 30,798 400 74111 PRINCIPAL PAYMENT 205,000 205,000 212,431 229,433 400 74112 INTEREST PAYMENT 103,112 99,398 95,714 107,685 74- DEBT SERVICE 308,112 304,398 308,145 337,118 53 - TRANSIT DIVISION TOTAL 3,605,421 3,643,907 3,680,048 3,844,192 -117- Recommended Expenditure Budget Report by Activity & Funding Sounce 53 -TRANSIT DIVISION SUPPLIES AND SERVICES 0 0 0 23,839 WAGES AND BENEFITS 0 0 0 9,126 INTERMODAL RAMP 0 0 0 32,965 or BUS OPERATIONS -53400 FUNDING SOURCE: TRANSIT Account FY14 Actual Expense FY15 Actual Expense FY16 Adopted Budget FY17 Recomm'd Budget EQUIPMENT TZANSIT ADMIN. -53100 SUPPLIES AND SERVICES FUNDING SOURCE: DEBT SERVICE WAGES AND BENEFITS 980,944 Account FY14 Actual Expense FY15 Actual Expense FY16 Adopted Budget FY17 Recomm'd Budget DEBT SERVICE 308,112 304,398 308,145 337,118 EQUIPMENT 1,560 1,916 24,450 898 SUPPLIES AND SERVICES 517,912 600,444 219,619 209,272 WAGES AND BENEFITS 282 190,781 493,739 537,255 TRANSIT ADMIN. 827,866 1,097,538 1,045,953 1,084,543 958,102 783,145 ILITY -53370 813,660 FUNDING SOURCE: TRANSIT 53600 Account FY14 Actual Expense FY15 Actual Expense FY16 Adopted Budget FY17 Recomm'd Budget SUPPLIES AND SERVICES 0 0 21,959 22,190 WAGES AND BENEFITS 0 0 0 28,972 INTERMODAL FACILITY 0 0 21,959 51,162 58,381 INTERMODAL RAMP -53380 38,633 FUNDING SOURCE: INTERMODAL RAMP TROLLEY OPERATIONS 102,070 Account FY14 Actual Expense FY15 Actual Expense FY16 Adopted Budget FY17 Recomm'd Budget SUPPLIES AND SERVICES 0 0 0 23,839 WAGES AND BENEFITS 0 0 0 9,126 INTERMODAL RAMP 0 0 0 32,965 or BUS OPERATIONS -53400 FUNDING SOURCE: TRANSIT Account FY14 Actual Expense FY15 Actual Expense FY16 Adopted Budget FY17 Recomm'd Budget EQUIPMENT 975 SUPPLIES AND SERVICES 503,795 WAGES AND BENEFITS 980,944 BUS OPERATIONS 1,485,714 0 484,899 1,118,725 1,603,624 0 493,721 1,103,147 1,596,868 28,400 520,533 1,108,383 1,657,316 -118- A MINI BUS OPERATIONS - 53500 FUNDING SOURCE: TRANSIT Account FY14 Actual Expense FY15 Actual Expense FY16 Adopted Budget FY17 Recomm'd Budget EQUIPMENT 0 0 0 1,000 SUPPLIES AND SERVICES 258,325 241,900 290,184 244,783 WAGES AND BENEFITS 699,777 541,245 548,185 567,877 MINI BUS OPERATIONS 958,102 783,145 838,369 813,660 53600 FUNDING SOURCE: TRANSIT Account FY14 Actual Expense FY15 Actual Expense FY16 Adopted Budget FY17 Recomm'd Budget SUPPLIES AND SERVICES 43,689 23,305 16,020 30,560 WAGES AND BENEFITS 58,381 22,487 38,633 34,198 TROLLEY OPERATIONS 102,070 45,792 54,653 64,758 . -53700 - -118- Recommended Expenditure Budget Report by Activity & Funding Sounce 53 -TRANSIT DIVISION FUNDING SOURCE: TRANSIT Account FY14 Actual Expense FY15 Actual Expense FY16 Adopted Budget FY17 Recomm'd Budget EQUIPMENT 31,033 0 799 500 SUPPLIES AND SERVICES 95,402 10,785 9,201 16,742 WAGES AND BENEFITS 105,233 103,023 112,246 122,546 BUS MAINTENANCE 231,668 113,808 122,246 139,788 TRANSIT DIVISION TOTAL $3,605,420.86 $3,643,907.00 $3,680,048.00 $3,844,192.00 -119- CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA DEPARTMENT DETAIL- PERSONNEL COMPLEMENT 53 TRANSIT DIVISION -120- FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2017 FD JC WP -GR JOBCLASS FTE BUDGET FTE BUDGET FTE BUDGET 61010 Full Time Employee Expense 600 7325 GE -41 TRANSIT MANAGER 0.00 0 1.00 95,200 1.00 97,280 600 3000 GE -34 TRANSIT OPERATIONS SUPERVISOR 0.00 0 1.00 72,836 1.00 74,416 600 GE -25 CONFIDENTIAL ACCOUNT CLERK 0.00 0 1.00 36,324 1.00 39,012 600 GD -03 TRANSIT DISPATCHER 1.00 43,467 1.00 44,624 1.00 45,560 600 0637 GD -04 TRANSIT SERVICE WORKER 1.00 47,537 1.00 48,795 1.00 49,820 600 7200 AT -01 BUS OPERATOR 6.00 215,975 8.00 299,854 8.00 301,637 TOTAL FULL TIME EMPLOYEES 8.00 306,979 13.00 597,633 13.00 607,725 61020 Part Time Employee Expense 600 GD -03 TRANSIT DISPATCHER 1.98 81,694 2.01 84,327 2.01 87,053 600 GD -03 OPERATIONS ASSISTANT 0.00 0 0.50 19,357 0.50 19,773 600 7210 AT -02 BUS OPERATOR 27.65 994,254 23.81 873,370 23.81 891,195 600 0637 GD -04 TRANSIT SERVICES WORKER 0.70 31,065 0.70 31,882 0.70 34,874 605 GD -04 LABORER 0.00 0 0.50 21,949 0.50 22,770 TOTAL PART TIME EMPLOYEES 30.33 1,107,014 27.52 1,030,885 27.52 1,055,665 61030 Seasonal Employee Expense 600 NA -38 MARKETING INTERN 0.00 0 0.50 12,848 0.50 13,123 TOTAL SEASONAL EMPLOYEES 0.00 0 0.50 12,848 0.50 13,123 TOTAL TRANSIT DIVISION 38.33 1,413,992 41.02 1,641,366 41.02 1,676,513 -120- CITY OF DUBUQUE, IOWA ACTIVITY PERSONNEL COMPLEMENT SUMMARY Run Date. 01/22/16 FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2017 ACCT FD JC WP -GR POSITION CLASS FTE BUDGET FTE BUDGET FTE BUDGET Transit Admin and Operations -FT NA -48 OPERATIONS ASSISTANT 0.00 0 0.50 19,357 0.50 60053100 61010 600 GE -41 TRANSIT MANAGER 0.00 0 1.00 95,200 1.00 97,280 60053100 61010 600 GE -34 TRANSIT OPERATIONS SUPERVIE 0.00 0 1.00 72,836 1.00 74,416 60053100 61010 600 GE -25 CONFIDENTIAL ACCOUNT CLERK 0.00 0 1.00 36,324 1.00 39,012 60053100 61010 600 GD -03 TRANSIT DISPATCHER 1.00 43,467 1.00 44,624 1.00 45,560 13,123 Intermodal Facility -PT Total 1.00 43,467 4.00 248,984 4.00 256,268 Transit Admin and Operations -PT 60053100 61020 600 NA -48 OPERATIONS ASSISTANT 0.00 0 0.50 19,357 0.50 19,773 60053100 61020 600 GD -03 TRANSIT DISPATCHER 1.98 81,694 2.01 84,327 2.01 87,053 Total 1.98 81,694 2.51 103,684 2.51 106,826 Transit Admin and Operations -Seasonal 60053100 61030 600 NA -38 MARKETING INTERN 0.00 0 0.50 12,848 0.50 13,123 0.00 0 0.50 12,848 0.50 13,123 Intermodal Facility -PT 60053370 61020 600 GD -04 LABORER 0.00 0 0.50 21,949 0.50 22,770 Total 0.00 0 0.50 21,949 0.50 22,770 Bus Operations -FT 60053400 61010 600 7200 AT -01 BUS OPERATOR 4.00 142,798 5.00 187,175 5.00 187,001 Total 4.00 142,798 5.00 187,175 5.00 187,001 Bus Operations -PT 60053400 61020 600 7210 AT -02 BUS OPERATOR 17.55 629,144 15.19 555,878 15.19 567,059 Total 17.55 629,144 15.19 555,878 15.19 567,059 Mini -Bus Operations -FT 60053500 61010 600 AT -03 BUS OPERATOR 2.00 73,176 3.00 112,679 3.00 114,636 Total 2.00 73,176 3.00 112,679 3.00 114,636 Mini -Bus Operations -PT 60053500 61020 600 7210 AT -02 BUS OPERATOR 9.00 325,439 7.91 290,804 7.91 297,096 Total 9.00 325,439 7.91 290,804 7.91 297,096 Trolley Operations -PT 60053600 61020 600 7210 AT -02 BUS OPERATOR -Trolley Route 1.10 39,671 0.71 26,688 0.71 27,040 Total 1.10 39,671 0.71 26,688 0.71 27,040 Bus Maintenance -FT 60053700 61010 600 GD -04 TRANSIT SERVICE WORKER 1.00 47,537 1.00 48,795 1.00 49,820 Total 1.00 47,537 1.00 48,795 1.00 49,820 Bus Maintenance -PT 60053700 61020 600 GD -04 TRANSIT SERVICE WORKER 0.70 31,065 0.70 31,882 0.70 34,874 0.70 31,065 0.70 31,882 0.70 34,874 TOTAL TRANSIT DIVISION 38.33 1,413,992 41.02 1,641,366 41.02 1,676,513 -121- Capital Improvement Projects by Department/ Division TRANSIT DIVISION CIP Capital Improvement Project FY 14 Actual FY 15 Actual FY 16 Adopted FY 17 Recomm'd Number Title Expense Expense Budget Budget 3602446 BUS STORAGE FACILITY 0 0 285,900 1,124,910 3602622 SOIL CONTAMINATION TEST 0 0 25,000 0 6001222 REPLACE MINI BUSES 0 0 0 145,874 6001224 REPLACE FIXED ROUTE BUSES 594,625 104,963 0 0 6001613 TRANSIT ROOF MAINT/REPAIR 18,110 216,440 0 0 6002045 KEYLINE FACILITY IMPROVE 24,948 2,442 0 0 6002235 BUS STOP IMPROVEMENTS 85,198 1,048 5,110 20,000 6002446 BUS STORAGE FACILITY 14,408 40,000 0 4,613,373 6002486 TRANSIT FUEL STATION 19,364 0 0 0 6002621 TRANSIT SECURITY CAMERAS 0 0 36,000 0 TRANSIT DIVISION TOTAL 756,653 364,892 352,010 5, -122- City of Dubuque Recommended Capital Improvement Program Summary Fiscal Year 2017-2021 PROGRAM/DEPT PROJECT DESCRIPTION SOURCE OF FUNDS FY 2017 FY 2018 FY 2019 FY 2020 FY 2021 TOTAL PAGE TRANSIT DIVISION Business Type Vehicle Replacement Sales Tax Fund $ 145,874 $ 446,823 $ 458,886 $ 471,276 $ 608,375 $ 2,131,234 334 (20%),State or Federal Grant Funds Bus Storage and Maintenance State of Good Repair $ 5,738,283 $ 206,240 $ - $ - $ - $ 5,944,523 336 Facility(BSMF) Gmnt,Public Transit Gmnt,DMATS STP Allocation,GO Borrowing(GDTIF),Great er Downtown TIF Bus Stop Improvements Sales Tax Fund (20%) $ 20,000 $ 20,000 $ 20,000 $ 20,000 $ - $ 80,000 338 JFK Circle Transfer Phase 2 Public Transit Grant, $ - $ 401,445 $ - $ - $ - $ 401,445 340 Sales Tax Fund (20%) Total- Transit Division $ 5,904,157 $ 1,074,508 $ 478,886 $ 491,276 $ 608,375 $ 8,557,202 -123- This page intentionally left blank. -124- Transit Budget FY2017 Intermodal Center –Open August 2015 Public Transportation in Dubuque Public Transportation in the City of Dubuque is delivered through the transit division, The Jule The Jule manages fixed-route, paratransit, trolley and contract services (DuRide and Burlington Trailways) and maintains current and plans for future transit vehicles, bus stops, and other capital infrastructure. Three Transfer Locations Intermodal (Downtown), Delhi (Midtown), JFK Circle (West End) 12 Bus Shelter Locations Over 280 Bus Stops 13 Light Duty 12 Medium Duty 4 Heavy Duty 2 Trolleys Daytime Transit Service 15 daily fixed-routes + door-to-door MiniBus service 6:05am-6:50pm weekdays 8:05am-6:25pm Saturdays Evening, Seasonal and Park & Ride Service Weekday Business Shuttle service connects downtown parking ramps and employer locations during morning and afternoon commute times Summer Trolley Service Saturdays Labor Day-October 10am-6pm Nightrider weekend evening service + door-to-door MiniBus service Friday and Saturday Nights 6pm-2:40am during the school year and 6pm-11pm during the summer Who We Are Bus Operators 60 Part-Time 8 Full-Time Dispatchers 6 Part-Time 1 Full-Time Administration/Clerical/Training 1 Full-Time Transit Manager 1 Full-Time Operations Supervisor 1 Part-Time Operations Assistant/Driver Trainer 1 Full-Time Confidential Account Clerk What We Do Connect People to Opportunity Provide Equitable Services Drive and Maintain City Vehicles Like They’re Our Own Improve Quality of Life Make Partnerships Easy Request Input and Respond to Citizen Concerns Communicate Clearly Connect People to Opportunity Provide access to transit services so citizens can get to work, school, and recreational opportunities Transit Access = 5 minute walk 75% of residents live and work with a 5 minute walk 92% or 22 of 24 elementary, middle and high schools are within a 5 minute walk Provide Equitable Services Provide the same opportunity and level of transit services to those with disabilities as to those without. MiniBus and fixed-route service provided 77,133 rides to residents with disabilities and 18,845 to residents over age 65 Plan bus stops and vehicle purchases to increase independence for seniors and residents with disabilities Comply with and work to exceed the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requirements Budget Connection: CIP Bus Stop Improvements $20,000 in FY17 Jule staff will review all bus stops for ADA compliance and prioritize high demand stops for installation of cement pads for wheelchair access pole-mounted seating, solar lighting and bus shelters Budget Connection: CIP Vehicle Replacement $145,874 in FY17 As vehicles are replaced, ramps will be a priority component for both fixed-route and MiniBus vehicles Vehicle maintenance and timely replacement are essential to running high quality public transit service with delays or interruptions due to mechanical failure Drive and Maintain City Vehicles Like They’re Our Own Reduce accidents and associated costs through ongoing driver training and conduct regular vehicle maintenance to extend the life of the fleet. Part-Time CDL and Safety Trainer is instrumental in ensuring drivers are well trained and comfortable before heading out of the road New drivers receive an average of 100 hours of training before transportinfg passengers on their own. Complete preventative maintenance within 10% of FTA established mileage threshold At Fault Accidents: -27% (FY14-FY15) Budget Connection: Bus Storage Facility $5,738,284 in FY17 $4,830,873 in grant funds secured New Bus Storage Facility includes on-site CDL training course and training conference room Reduces deadhead miles to fueling location Replaces existing facility that is too small and outdated for proper vehicle maintenance Reuse of old city garage and brownfield site Improve Quality of Life Provide quick travel times so people can spend less time on the bus and more time doing what they choose Most trip times are under 30 minutes Pre 2014 Travel Time Post 2014 Travel Time Time Savings JFK Circle to The Jule (2401 Central)75 min 35 min 40 min The Point to Medical Associates West 95 min 40 min 55 min Downtown Transfer to Kohls/HyVee 45 min 25 min 20 min University of Dubuque to Walmart/Lowes 50 min 25 min 25 min Clarke University to Mercy/ Medical Associates East 45 min 18 min 27 min Loras College to Kennedy Mall 39 min 25 min 14 min The Point to Target/HyVee 85 min 45 min 40 min Budget Connection: Continuation Funding Express, Grey and Green Lines FY17 Expense (6 months): $105,916 FY18 Expense (12 months): $211,832 The Express route is the spine of the Jule’s reconfigured route system, transporting passengers across town in 15 minutes and serving 32,431 passengers in just the first six months of FY 2016. These routes make up 23% of total ridership. Routes were funded for the maximum 3 years by ICAAP grant program Grant ends midyear FY17 Provides operating funding for Express, Grey and Green Lines Cut $187,118 in annual operating expenses in FY16 in preparation for this request Increased revenue by $126,052 through fare increase effective in FY15 and FY16 Budget Connection: Continuation Funding Express, Grey and Green Lines If these routes are not funded through the improvement request, the following negative impacts will occur: Increased Trip Lengths:Average trip time will return to 60 and 90 minutes Increased Wait Times:Reduced crosstown service will cause up to 30 minute wait times at transfers Reduced Ridership:Fixed-route ridership will decrease by 97,284 rides Reduced Fare Revenue:Fixed-route fare revenue will decrease by $71,392 Reduced State Funding:State Operating Funding will decrease by $63,943 Make Partnerships Easy Coordinate with non-profits, colleges, and other city departments to make accessing transit passes and services simple and affordable Project Pass: 25% discount for non-profits 2,944 passes in FY15 St. Raphael Cathedral City of Dubuque Finance Department – manages bus pass sales at City Hall College Students College students at participating schools ride all routes free with their school ID. Schools pay an annual fee for student access to help fund the Nightrider service. Project Pass: 25% discount for non-profits 2,944 passes in FY15 1,192 1,714 4,032 4,998 3,439 2,841 4,751 825 2,382 3,405 4,653 3,987 2,568 3,242 3,723 3,688 3,706 4,640 1,160 170 952 1,456 2,102 2,125 907 1,611 2,550 3,471 2,953 3,494 738 118 288 293 203 611 888 1,159 1,416 1,526 1870 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 FY16 FY15 FY14 FY13 Budget Connection: Increasing Revenue Medicaid Contracts and College Partnership Partnering with Medicaid providers allows The Jule to bill for the full cost of service and provides low income residents with free rides for medical trips Projected NEW revenue in FY17 = $48,000 Partnering with colleges to fund the Nightrider route and provide free rides for students on evening and daytime routes Projected revenue in FY17 = $75,000 New revenue = $40,914 Armored courier service for weekly fare canister deposits improves security and reduces opportunity for theft Projected cost in FY17 = $1,222 Request Input and Respond to Citizen Concerns Ask for input and make recommendations that reflect the needs of citizens. Online Forms: •Comments •Suggestions •Bus Stop Requests The Jule conducts a transit survey every two years as well as focus groups an online route and stop request opportunities on an ongoing basis The Transit Advisory Board meets monthly to evaluate routes and discuss and prioritize service needs The most common service request is for bus service until 9pm on weekdays. IBM smarter Travel data supports demand for weekday service until 8pm. Staff responded to 279 questions, comments, concerns or compliments fro the public through WebQA in FY15 Communicate Clearly Provide consistent communication pf policies and route information, wear recognizable uniforms and provide quality customer service 15,052 visits 6th most visited page on City website Policies posted online, in route brochures, and in all vehicles for passenger reference Website is updated with new route, schedule and policy information. Communicate weather related route deviations, delays and holiday closures through posters, website, press releases, social media and notify-me alerts 2 daytime dispatchers field 636 calls per day (53 per hour) 563.589.4196 JuleTransit.org JuleTransit Total Ridership Fixed-route, Paratransit (MiniBus) and DuRide service +47% Ridership FY2010-FY2015373,376 397,584 440,252 448,438 478,370 548,769 545,231 - 100,000 200,000 300,000 400,000 500,000 600,000 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 (projected) Annual Ridership Comparison Fixed-route, Paratransit (MiniBus) and DuRide service July 2015-January 2016 37,509 37,384 47,331 52,515 46,551 44,783 48,071 37,438 41,359 47,651 51,542 44,280 45,555 47,908 31,452 36,984 39,525 44,232 41,192 34,552 41,718 31,783 38,681 37,047 43,048 40,219 32,682 38,986 30,000 35,000 40,000 45,000 50,000 55,000 July August September October November December January FY16 FY15 FY14 FY13 Annual Ridership Comparison Fixed-route, Paratransit (MiniBus) and DuRide service July 2015-January 2016 26 9 , 6 5 5 33 , 0 8 6 20 3 , 6 1 4 6, 6 9 2 21 , 1 7 9 4, 8 8 1 16 7 31 5 , 7 3 3 33 , 6 4 8 25 9 , 3 7 5 7, 2 9 9 11 , 5 3 6 3, 6 5 5 22 0 31 4 , 1 4 4 31 , 0 1 5 26 8 , 1 9 8 7, 6 3 2 6, 4 5 6 60 4 23 9 0 50000 100000 150000 200000 250000 300000 350000 Total Ridership Minibus Fixed-Route DuRide Business Shuttle Trolley Government Assistance FY14 FY15 FY16 Ridership by Route Fixed-route, Paratransit (MiniBus) and DuRide service July 2015-January 2016 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000 45,000 Local Tax Support Historical Tax Support for The Jule $1,161,393 $1,078,726 $717,611 $1,044,171 $833,302 $1,080,000 $1,093,064 - 200,000 400,000 600,000 800,000 1,000,000 1,200,000 1,400,000 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16